Abstract
This article addresses the way in which the term “holistic” has become the contemporary in word for describing mission and ministry. The philosophical roots of this term are explored and its ideological implications are set out. I propose that this term is not helpful in reflecting the biblical vision of God's concern for all of life and the restoration of all things, and the church s role in bringing God's shalom to all of life. Instead, I propose the term “integral” as a better descriptor for missional activity.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ajula
Deborah
2001
Holism in Development . Monrovia, CA : MARC .
2.
Amaladoss
Michael
1990
Making All Things New . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
3.
Andrews
Dave
1999
Christi-Anarchy: Discovering a Radical Spirituality of Compassion . Oxford, UK : Lion .
4.
Arnold
Clinton E.
1992
Powers of Darkness . Downers Grove, IL : InterVarsity .
5.
Ash
Mitchell G.
1995
Gestalt Psychology in German Culture, 1890–1967: Holism and the Quest far Objectivity . Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press .
6.
Audi
Robert
, ed. 1999
The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy . 2d ed.
Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press .
7.
Banks
R.
1987
All the Business of Life . Sydney, Australia : Albatross .
8.
Bloom
William
, ed. 2000
Holistic Revolution: The Essential Reader . London, UK : Allen Lane, Penguin .
9.
Boff
Leonardo
1986
Ecclesiogenesis: The Base Communities Reinvent the Church . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
10.
Bosch
David
1991
Transforming Mission . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
11.
Bromiley
Geoffrey W.
, ed. 1979
The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia . Vol. 3 . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
12.
Brueggemann
Walter
1978
The Prophetic Imagination . Minneapolis, MN : Fortress .
13.
Brueggemann
Walter
1997
Theology of the Old Testament . Minneapolis, MN : Fortress .
14.
Caruana
Louis
2000
Holism and the Understanding of Science . Aldershot, UK : Ashgate .
15.
Chan
Simon
1998
Spiritual Theology . Downers Grove, IL : InterVarsity .
16.
Chossudovsky
Michael
1998
The Globalisation of Poverty . Sydney, Australia : Pluto .
17.
Cook
Guillermo
, ed. 1994
New Face of the Church in Latin America . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
18.
Craig
Edward
, ed. 1998
Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy . London, UK : Routledge .
19.
Craig
J. M.
1998
Servants among the Poor . Metro Manila, Philippines : OMF Literature .
20.
Croatto
J. Severino
1981
Exodus: A Hermeneutics of Freedom . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
21.
Devitt
Michael
1996
Coming to Our Senses: A Naturalistic Program for Semantic Localism . Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press .
22.
Dorr
Donal
1984
Spirituality and Justice . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
23.
Duncan
Michael
1996
Costly Mission: Following Christ into the Slums . Monrovia, CA : MARC .
24.
Durkheim
Émile
1938
The Rules of Sociological Method . Glencoe, IL : Free Press .
25.
Ellul
Jacques
1989
The Presence of the Kingdom . 2d ed.
Colorado Springs, CO : Helmers & Howard .
26.
Fitzgerald
Allan D.
, ed. 1999
Augustine through the Ages: An Encyclopedia . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
27.
Fodor
Jerry A.
LePore
Ernest
1992
Holism: A Shopper's Guide . Oxford, UK : Blackwell .
28.
Foster
Richard
1980
Celebration of Discipline . London, UK : Hodder & Stoughton .
29.
Gadamer
Hans-Georg
1989
Truth and Method . 2d ed.
London, UK : Sheed & Ward .
30.
Galilea
Segundo
1988
The Way of Living Faith: A Spirituality of Liberation . San Francisco, CA : Harper & Row .
31.
Gibellini
Rosino
, ed. 1994
Paths of African Theology . London, UK : SCM .
32.
Giddens
Anthony
1989
Sociology . Cambridge, UK : Polity .
33.
Gill
A.
1989
Life on the Road . Sydney, Australia : Lancer . Scottdale, PA : Herald Press , 1992.
34.
Gnanakan
Ken R.
1993
Kingdom Concerns . Downers Grove, IL : InterVarsity .
35.
Graham
W. Fred
1971
The Constructive Revolutionary . Richmond, VA : John Knox .
36.
Grant-Thomson
J.
1991
Jodie's Story . Sydney, Australia : Anzea .
37.
Guder
Darrell L.
, ed. 1998
Missional Church . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
38.
Gunton
Colin E.
1997
The Promise of Trinitarian Theology . 2d ed.
Edinburgh, UK : T&T Clark .
39.
Hancock
Graham
1989
Lords of Poverty: The Power, Prestige and Corruption of the International Aid Business . New York : Atlantic Monthly Press .
40.
Hanson
P. D.
1986
The People Called: The Growth of Community in the Bible . San Francisco, CA : Harper & Row .
41.
Hauerwas
Stanley
Willamon
William H.
1989
Resident Aliens . Nashville, TN : Abingdon .
42.
Heidegger
Martin
1962
Being and Time . New York : Harper & Row .
43.
Hennelly
Alfred T.
, ed. 1990
Liberation Theology: A Documentary History . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
44.
Hyson
Leon O.
1989
To Reform the Nation: Theological Foundations of Wesley's Ethics . Grand Rapids, MI : Francis Asbury .
45.
Inwood
Michael
, ed. 1992
A Hegel Dictionary . London, UK : Blackwell .
46.
Paul
John
II
Pope (Karol Wojtyla) 1990
Redemptoris missio: On the Permanent Validity of the Church's Missionary Mandate . Encyclical letter, 7 December. Washington, DC : United States Catholic Conference .
47.
Joy
Martin
1984
Marxism and Totality . Berkeley, CA : University of California Press .
48.
Kaldor
Peter
1995
Mission under the Microscope . Adelaide, Australia : Open Books .
49.
Klaassen
Walter
1981
Anabaptism: Neither Catholic nor Protestant . 2d ed.
Kitchener, ON, Canada : Pandora , 2001.
50.
Knowles
David
1969
Christian Monasticism . New York, NY : McGraw-Hill .
51.
Ladd
George E.
1975
A Theology of the New Testament . London, UK : Lutterworth .
52.
Lévi-Strauss
Claude
1963
Structural Anthropology . Harmondsworth, UK : Penguin .
53.
Lewis
Donald M.
1986
Lighten Their Darkness: The Evangelical Mission to Working-Class London, 1828–1860 . New York : Greenwood .
54.
Linthicum
Robert C.
1991
City of God, City of Satan . Grand Rapids, MI : Zondervan .
55.
Longenecker
Richard N.
1984
New Testament Social Ethics for Today . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
56.
Lua
Theresa Roco
1998
“Developing a Holistic and Contextualized Discipleship Ministry among Filipino Urban Poor Adults in Metro Manila.” Unpublished Ed.D. thesis (summary article with same title in Journal of Asian Missions 2[1] [2000]:43–64).
57.
Maggay
M.
1994
Transforming Society . Oxford, UK : Regnum Lynx .
58.
Magnuson
Norris
1990
Salvation in the Slums: Evangelical Social Work 1865–1920 . Grand Rapids, MI : Baker .
59.
Marsden
George M.
1997
The Outrageous Idea of Christian Scholarship . New York : Oxford University Press .
60.
McAlpine
Thomas H.
1991
Facing the Powers . Monrovia, CA : MARC .
61.
Medina
Belen T.G.
1991
The Filipino Family . Quezon City, Philippines : University of the Philippines Press .
62.
Meyers
Eleanor Scott
, ed. 1992
Envisioning the New City: A Reader on Urban Ministry . Louisville, KY : Westminster/John Knox .
63.
Miranda
Dionisio M.
1993
Buting Pinoy . Manila, Philippines : Divine Word Publications .
64.
Moltmann
Jürgen
1978
The Open Church . London, UK : SCM .
65.
Moltmann
Jürgen
1981
The Trinity and the Kingdom . San Francisco, CA : Harper & Row .
66.
Moltmann
Jürgen
1985
God in Creation . San Francisco, CA : Harper & Row .
67.
Monsma
Stephen V.
1984
Pursuing Justice in a Sinful World . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
68.
Mott
Stephen C.
1982
Biblical Ethics and Social Change . New York : Oxford University Press .
69.
Mouw
Richard J.
1973
Political Evangelism . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
70.
Müller
Karl
1987
Mission Theology: An Introduction . Berlin, Germany : Steyler .
71.
Muzorewa
Gwinyai Henry
1990
An African Theology of Mission . New York : Edwin Mellen .
72.
Newbigin
Lesslie
1994
A Word in Season: Perspectives on Christian World Missions . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
73.
Nicholls
Bruce J.
, ed. 1986
In Word and Deed: Evangelism and Social Responsibility . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
74.
Noll
Mark A.
1994
The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
75.
Nouwen
Henri
1975
Reaching Out: The Three Movements of the Spiritual Life . New York : Doubleday .
76.
O'Gorman
Frances
1992
Charity and Change . Melbourne, Australia : World Vision .
77.
Perkins
John M.
, ed. 1995
Restoring At-Risk Communities . Grand Rapids, MI : Baker .
78.
Phillips
Denis C.
1976
Holistic Thought in Social Sciences . Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press .
79.
Phillips
James M.
Coote
Robert T.
, eds. 1993
Towards the 21st Century in Christian Mission . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
80.
Posterski
Donald
Nelson
Gary
1997
Future Faith Churches . Winfield, BC, Canada : Wood Lake Books .
81.
Prior
David
1992
Creating Community . Colorado Springs, CO : NavPress .
82.
Quebedeaux
Richard
1978
The Worldly Evangelicals . San Francisco, CA : Harper & Row .
83.
Quito
Emerita
1991
The Merging Philosophy of East and West . Manila, Philippines : De La Salle University Press .
84.
Rahner
Karl
1974
The Shape of the Church to Come . London, UK : SPCK .
85.
Ramachandra
Vinoth
1996
The Recovery of Mission . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
86.
Rappaport
Julian
Swift
Carolyn
Hess
Robert
, eds. 1984
Studies in Empowerment: Steps toward Understanding and Action . New York : Haworth .
87.
Rauschenbusch
Walter
1918
A Theology for the Social Gospel . New York : Macmillan .
88.
Remenyi
Joe
1991
Where Credit Is Due . London, UK : IT Publications .
89.
Ringe
Sharon H.
1985
Jesus, Liberation, and the Biblical Jubilee . Philadelphia, PA : Fortress .
90.
Ringma
Charles
1994
Catch the Wind . Sydney, Australia : Albatross .
91.
Ringma
Charles
1995
“Transformation Theology: Some Curriculum Issues.”
Phronesis
2 :77 –91 .
92.
Ringma
Charles
1999
Gadamer's Dialogical Hermeneutic . Heidelberg, Germany : Winter .
93.
Ringma
Charles
2000
Dare to Journey with Henri Nouwen . Colorado Springs, CO : Pinon .
94.
Ringma
Charles
2001
“The Slow March of God.”
Crux
37 (2 ): 31 –38 .
95.
Rowbotham
Michael
2000
Goodbye America: Globalisation. Debt and the Dollar Empire . Sydney, Australia : Envirobook .
96.
Samuel
Vinay
Sugden
Chris
, eds. 1987
The Church in Response to Human Need . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
97.
Scherer
James A.
Bevans
Stephen B.
, eds. 1992a
New Directions in Mission and Evangelization. Vol. I, Basic Statements 1974–1991 . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
98.
Scherer
James A.
1992b
New Directions in Mission and Evangelization. Vol. II, Theological Foundations . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
99.
Senior
Donald
Stuhlmueller
Carroll
1983
The Biblical Foundations of Mission . London, UK : SCM .
100.
Shenk
Wilbert R.
, ed. 1993
The Transfiguration of Mission . Scottdale, PA : Herald Press .
101.
Shorter
Aylward
1988
Toward a Theology of Inculturation . London, UK : Geoffrey Chapman .
102.
Sider
Ronald J.
1990
Rich Christians in an Age of Hunger . London, UK : Hodder & Stoughton .
103.
Sider
Ronald J.
1993
One-Sided Christianity . Grand Rapids, MI : Zondervan .
104.
Smith
Christian
1992
Going to the Root . Scottdale, PA : Herald Press .
105.
Smuts
Jan Christiaan
1926
Holism and Evolution . London, UK : Macmillan .
106.
Snyder
Howard A.
1980
The Radical Wesley and Patterns for Church Renewal . Downers Grove, IL : InterVarsity .
107.
Snyder
Howard A.
1983
Liberating the Church . Downers Grove. IL : InterVarsity .
108.
Spencer
Herbert
1876
Principles of Sociology . New York : D. Appleton .
109.
Stevens
R. Paul
1999
The Abolition of the Laity . Carlisle, UK : Paternoster .
110.
Steward
John
1994
Biblical Holism: Where God, People and Deeds Connect . Melbourne, Australia : World Vision .
111.
Stott
John
, ed. 1975
Christian Mission in the Modern World . Downers Grove, IL : InterVarsity .
112.
Stott
John
, ed. 1984
Issues Facing Christians Today . Basingstoke, UK : Marshalls .
113.
Stott
John
, ed. 1997
Making Christ Known: Historic Mission Documents from the Lausanne Movement, 1974–1989 . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
114.
Sugirtharajah
Rasiah S.
1991
Voices from the Margins . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
115.
Sugirtharajah
Rasiah S.
1999
Vernacular Hermeneutics . Sheffield, UK : Sheffield Academic Press .
116.
Sugirtharajah
Rasiah S.
2001
The Bible and the Third World . Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press .
117.
Thiessen
Gerd
1978
Sociology of Early Palestinian Christianity . Philadelphia, PA : Fortress .
118.
Torres
Sergio
Eagleson
John
, eds. 1982
The Challenge of the Basic Christian Communities . Maryknoll, NY : Orbis Books .
119.
van Gelder
Craig
, ed. 1999
Confident Witness—Changing World . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
120.
Vicedom
Georg F.
1965
The Mission of God: An Introduction to a Theology of Mission . Saint Louis, MO : Concordia .
121.
Webber
Robert E.
1986
The Church in the World . Grand Rapids, MI : Zondervan .
122.
Whitehead
Evelyn Eaton
Whitehead
James D.
1992
Community of Faith: Crafting Christian Communities Today . Mystic, CT : Twenty-Third Publications .
123.
Wink
Walter
1986
Unmasking the Powers . Philadelphia, PA : Fortress .
124.
Wolterstorff
Nicholas
1983
Until Justice and Peace Embrace . Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans .
125.
Woods
Charles Jeffrey
1996
Congregational Megatrends . New York, NY : The Alban Institute .
126.
Wright
Christopher J.H.
1983
Living as the People of God . Downers Grove, IL : InterVarsity .
127.
Yamamori
Tetsunao
, eds. 1995
Serving with the Poor in Asia: Cases in Holistic Ministry . Monrovia, CA : MARC .
128.
Yamamori
Tetsunao
, eds. 1996
Serving with the Poor in Africa: Cases in Holistic Ministry . Monrovia, CA : MARC .
129.
Yoder
John Howard
1972
The Politics of Jesus . Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans. 2d. ed.
Grand Rapids, MI : Eerdmans , 1994.