This article reports the first study ever published of the use of the word soul by a representative sample of members of the Evangelical Theological Society (ETS). All ETS members in New England were sampled. The response rate was 92%. ETS members generally avoid the word soul. Most think that spirit is an adequate replacement. Both terms refer to the inner or subjective person, which is not annihilated when the body dies. Two definitions of soul emerge: (a) the whole person (with the implication that the body is part of the soul), or (b) the inner or subjective person in the natural state (whether saved or unsaved). There is a holistic slant to biblical anthropology; a blurring of boundaries between body, soul, and spirit prior to death. Many theologians say they have not thought about the soul, and that theological anthropology is an underdeveloped and neglected aspect of evangelical theology.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Augustine (1984a). The magnitude of the soul. (J. J. McMahon, Trans.). In The fathers of the church: Saint Augustine (pp. 59–149). Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press.
2.
Augustine (1984b). Immortality of the soul. (L. Schopp, Trans.). In The Fathers of the Church: Saint Augustine, (pp. 15–47). Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press.
3.
BaileyM. (1960). Biblical man and some formulae of Christian teaching. Irish Theological Quarterly, 27, 173–200.
4.
BarrJ. (1993). The garden of Eden and the hope of immortality.Philadelphia: Westminster.
5.
BarthK. (1960). Church dogmatics, (Vol. 3, pt. 4, sec. 54) BromileyG. W., & TorranceT. F. (Eds.). H. Knight, J. K. S. Reid, & R. H. Fuller (Trans.). Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark Publishers.
6.
BartonF. (1990). Heaven, hell and hades: A historical and theological survey of personal eschatology.Lenox, MA: Henceforth.
7.
BerkouwerC. G. (1962). Man: The image of God.Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
8.
BettelheimB. (March 1, 1982). Reflections: Freud and the soul.New Yorker, 52–93.
9.
BettelheimB. (1984). Freud and man's soul.New York: Random House.
10.
BolingerD., & BuckleyW. F.Jr. (1985). Usage and acceptability in language. Second College Edition of the American Heritage Dictionary, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 30–33.
11.
BoydJ. H. (1994a). Affirming the soul: Remarkable conversations between mental health professionals and an ordained minister.Cheshire, CT: Soul Research Institute.
12.
BoydJ. H. (1994b). Soul psychology: How to understand your soul in light of the mental health movement.Cheshire, CT: Soul Research Institute, 336–337, n. 77.
13.
BoydJ. H. (1995). The soul as seen through evangelical eyes, part I: Mental health professionals and ‘the soul.’Journal of Psychology and Theology, 23, 151–160.
14.
BoydJ. H. (in press-a). Losing soul: How and why theologians created the mental health movement,”Calvin Theological Journal.
15.
BoydJ. H. (in press-b). Reclaiming the soul: The search for meaning in a self-centered culture.Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim Press.
16.
BoydJ. H. (in press-c). One's self-concept and biblical theology. Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society.
17.
BrockwayR. W. (1979). Immortality of the soul: An evangelical heresy. Religious Humanism, 13, 14–18.
18.
CavallinH. C. C. (1974). Life after death.Lund, Sweden: Gleerup.
19.
CooperJ. W. (1988). The identity of resurrected persons: Fatal flaws of monistic anthropology. Calvin Theological Journal, 23, 19–36.
20.
CooperJ. W. (1989). Body, soul and life everlasting: Biblical anthropology and the monism-dualism debate.Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
21.
CullmannO. (1958). Immortality of the soul or resurrection of the dead?New York: Macmillan.
22.
CullmannO. (1965). Immortality of the soul or resurrection of the dead: The witness of the New Testament. Immortality and resurrectioned. by K. Stendahl. New York: Macmillan, 9–53.
23.
De VogelC. J. (1977). Reflections on Philipp. 1:23–24. Novum Testamentum, 19, 262–274.
24.
Directory of members (1994). Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society, 37, 285–317.
25.
DohertyW. (1995). Soul searching: Why psychotherapy must promote moral responsibility.New York: Basic Books.
26.
EricksonM. J. (1985). Christian theology.Grand Rapids, MI: Baker.
27.
FisherC. N. (1978). Pain as purgation: The role of pathologizing in the life of the mystic. Pastoral Psychology, 27, 62–70.
28.
FryerN. S. L. (1987). The intermediate state in Paul. Hervormde Teologiese Stud, 43, 448–484.
29.
GoodrickE. W., & KohlenbergerJ. R.III (1990). The NIV exhaustive concordance.Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1546–1547, 1808.
30.
HoekemaA. (1986). Created in the image of God.Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
31.
JaegerW. (1959). The Greek ideas of immortality. Harvard Theological Review, 52, 135–147.
32.
JonesE. (1960). The life and work of Sigmund Freud.New York: Basic Books.
33.
MarkusR. A. (1967). Augustine: Man: Body and soul. Cambridge History of Later Greek and Early Medieval Philosophy, ed. ArmstrongA. H.New York: Cambridge University Press, 357.
34.
MarshallI. H. (1970). Uncomfortable words, VI. ‘Fear Him who can destroy both soul and body in Hell’ (Mt. 10:28 RSV). Expository Times, 81, 276–282.
35.
MoodyD. (1961). The double face of death. Review and Expositor, 58, 348–366.
36.
MooreT. (1992). Care of the soul.New York: Harper Collins.
37.
MooreT. (1994). Soul mates: Honoring the mysteries of love and relationship.New York: Harper Collins.
38.
NeeW. (1986). The spiritual man.New York: Christian Fellowship.
39.
NiebuhrR. (1949). The nature and destiny of man: A Christian interpretation.New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 5–13.
40.
NunbergG. (1985). English and good English. Second college edition of the American heritage dictionary.Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 34–36.
41.
Osei-BonsuJ. (1991). The intermediate state in the New Testament. Scottish Journal of Theology, 44, 169–194.
42.
PeackockH. F. (1976). Translating the word for ‘soul’ in the Old Testament. Bible Translator, 27, 216–219.
43.
PedersenJ. (1926). Israel: Its life and culture.London: Oxford University Press.
44.
RobinsonH. W. (1911). The Christian doctrine of man.Edinburgh, Scotland: Clark.
45.
SchiedermayerD. (1994). Putting the soul back in medicine: Reflections on compassion and ethics.Grand Rapids: Baker Books.
46.
StendahlK. (1984). Immortality is too little and too much. Meanings: The Bible as document and guide.Philadelphia: Fortress.
47.
Van De KempH. (1982). The tension between psychology and theology: An anthropological solution. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 10, 105–112, 205–211.
48.
WhiteH. V. (1961). Immortality and resurrection in recent theology. Encounter, 22, 52–58.
49.
WolfsonH. A. (1958). Immortality and resurrection in the philosophy of the Church Fathers. Immortality and Resurrection, ed. StendahlK.New York: Macmillan.
50.
YoffeE. (April 23, 1995). How the soul is sold: James Hill-man developed a psychoanalytic theory few could understand, until his protégé Thomas Moore translated it for the masses. New York Times Magazine, 44–49.
