The author reacts to Vitz's (1992a, 1992b) two preceding articles. Three major critiques are offered. First, it is suggested that, contrary to Vitz's assumption, not all people live by narrative or story; many are story-less and need help from therapists to construct their stories. Second, although Vitz (1992a) dichotomizes narrative thinking and scientific thinking, it is suggested that such a dichotomy is unrealistic: Both types of thinking are needed in psychotherapy. Third, Vitz seems to be unclear about how faith and Christian processes can be communicated in counseling.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllportG.W. (1968). The person in psychology: Selected essays.Boston: Beacon.
2.
BrunerJ.S. (1986). Actual minds, possible worlds.Cambridge, MA: Howard University Press.
3.
BuckR. (1984). The communication of emotions.New York: Guilford.
4.
CollinsG., with MalonyH.N. (Ed.). (1980). Psychology and theology: Prospects for integration.Nashville: Abingdon.
5.
GerkinC. (1984). The living human document: Re-visioning pastoral counseling in a hermeneutical mode.New York: Abingdon.
6.
HillmanJ. (1983). Healing fiction.Barrytown, NY: Station Hill.
7.
The Holy Bible: Revised Standard Version. (1952). New York: Nelson.
8.
MalonyH.N. (1983). God talk in psychotherapy. In MalonyH.N. (Ed.) Wholeness and holiness: The psychology/theology of mental health (pp. 269–280). Grand Rapids: Baker.
9.
MalonyH.N. (1984, September-October). [Review of The sorcerer's apprentice: A Christian looks at the changing face of psychology]. Theological Students Fellowship Bulletin, p. 39.
10.
MalonyH.N. (1986). Integration musings: Thoughts on being a Christian professional.Pasadena, CA: Integration.
VitzP.C. (1992a). Narratives and counseling, part 1: From analysis of the past to stories about it. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 20, 12–25.
17.
VitzP.C. (1992b). Narratives and counseling, part 2: From stories of the past to stories for the future. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 20, 26–34.
