Needs Assessment in the Development of a Clergy Consultation Service: A Key Informant Approach

Abstract

A needs assessment was conducted with clergy to assist a counseling center in the development of a clergy consultation service. A total of 66 clergy were surveyed using a questionnaire designed to determine the following: clergy and church demographic characteristics, clergy involvement in counseling activity, referral practices and value placed on collaboration with mental health resources, and receptivity towards consultation with mental health professionals. Clergy revealed they saw the following problems on a frequent basis in their counseling work: marital problems, issues regarding guilt and forgiveness, anger, depression, anxiety, family problems, premarital issues, job related concerns, and parent-teen conflicts. Differences were noted in the counseling technique employed by clergy who had higher education, formal coursework in counseling methods, and had undergone a personal therapy experience. Pastoral counselors and mental health professionals had significantly more value as mental health resources than physicians and other clergy. Clergy also revealed a strong interest in attending seminars relating to stress, marital communication, psychological testing, divorce, depression, working with mental health professionals, anger, delinquency, and sexual problems, with the stipulation that these programs be of minimal cost and time. Suggestions are offered regarding the development and implementation of clergy consultation programs.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bell

R.A.

, Morris

R.R.

, Holzer

C.E.

, & Warheit

G.J.

(1976). The clergy as a mental health resource: Parts I and II. The Journal of Pastoral Care, 30, 103–115.

Bentz

W.K.

(1968). Consensus between role expectations and role behavior among ministers. Community Mental Health Journal, 4, 301–306.

Clemens

M.A.

, Corrodi

R.B.

, & Wasman

(1978). The parish clergy as a mental health resource. Journal of Religion and Health, 17, 227–232.

Clinebell

H.J.

Jr. (1970). The local churches contribution to positive mental health. In Clinebell

H.J.

(Ed.) Community mental health: The role of church and temple (pp. 46–56). Nashville: Abingdon.

Coursey

R.D.

(1977). Introduction: The need history, definition, and limits of program evaluation. In Coursey

R.D.

(Ed.) Program evaluation for mental health: Methods, strategies, participants (pp. 1–8). New York: Grune & Stratton.

Cummings

, & Harrington

(1963). Clergyman as counselor. American Journal of Sociology, 69, 234–243.

Dalton

, & Sandler

I.N.

(1978). Clergy interest in relating to the mental health system: A view from the pulpit. Unpublished manuscript, Arizona State University, Tempe.

Gurin

, Veroff

, & Feld

(1960). Americans view their mental health: A nationwide interview survey. New York: Wiley.

Haugk

K.C.

(1976). Unique contributions of churches and clergy to community mental health. Community Mental Health Journal, 12, 20–28.

10.

Hong

B.A.

, & Wiehe

V.R.

(1974). Referral patterns of clergy. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 2, 291–297.

11.

Hollingshead

A.B.

, & Redlich

F.C.

(1958). Social class and mental illness: A community study. New York: Wiley.

12.

Lee, R. Referral as an act of pastoral care. (1976). The Journal of Pastoral Care, 30, 186–197.

13.

McCann

R.V.

(1962). The churches and mental health. New York: Basic Books.

14.

Morgan

(1982). Needs assessment in churches: A Christian community's need for professional counseling service. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 10, 242–250.

15.

Morrison

B.J.

, & Sundel

(1975). Development of a community assessment strategy for program evaluation in a comprehensive human service delivery system. In Zusman

, & Wurster

C.R.

(Eds.) Program evaluation: Alcohol, drug abuse, and mental health services (pp. 161–174). Boston: Lexington.

16.

Perlmutter

, Yudin

L.W.

, & Heinemann

S.H.

(1974). Awareness of a community mental health center among three “gatekeeper” groups. American Journal of Community Psychology, 2, 23–33.

17.

Piedmont

E.B.

(1968). Referrals and reciprocity: Psychiatrists, general practitioners, and clergymen. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 9, 29–41.

18.

Posavac

E.J.

, & Hartung

B.M.

(1977). An exploration into the reasons people choose a pastoral counselor instead of another type of psychotherapist. The Journal of Pastoral Care, 31, 23–30.

19.

Robinson

, DeMarche

D.F.

, & Wagle

(1960). Community resources in mental health. New York: Basic Books.

20.

Rogers

(1981). Needs assessment with Baptist clergymen. Unpublished manuscript, Rosemead School of Psychology, La Mirada.

21.

Rumberger

D.J.

(1982). Openness to interaction with mental health resources among pastors of clients at the Rosemead Counseling Service. (Doctoral dissertation, Rosemead School of Psychology, Biola University, 1982). Dissertation Abstracts International, 43, 884B.

22.

Smith

M.B.

, & Hobbs

(1966). The community and the community mental health center. American Psychologist, 21, 499–509.

23.

Westburg

G.E.

, & Draper

(1966). Community psychiatry and the clergyman. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.

24.

Winett

R.A.

, Stewart

, & Majors

J.S.

(1978). Prompting techniques to improve the return rate of mailed questionnaires. Journal of Applied Behavioral Analysis, 11, 437.