Do Christian Counselors Show More Empathy Toward Christian Clients Than Secular Clients? An Examination of the Relations Between Counselors’ Empathy and Counselor–Client Similarity in Christian Commitment

Abstract

This study investigated the association between counselors’ Christian beliefs and their counseling. One hundred fifty-eight participants, including 13 counselors and 145 counselors-in-training who were assessed for levels of Christian commitment, were randomly assigned to view one of two versions of a videotape (i.e., a client with or without Christian commitment) and respond in writing to the client’s problem. Two trained raters (i.e., a licensed counselor and an advanced counseling intern) evaluated counselors’ levels of empathy. Counselors with low and high levels of Christian commitment showed similar levels of empathy for non-Christian and Christian clients, while counselors with moderate levels of Christian commitment showed more empathy for Christian clients. The implications of these findings and directions for future research are discussed.

Keywords

counselor’s Christian commitment counselor’s empathy client’s Christianity counselor–client similarity quasi-experimental design

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

(2017). The Sage encyclopedia of communication research methods. SAGE.

Bassett

R. L.

Sadler

R. D.

Kobischen

E. E.

Skiff

D. M.

Merrill

I. J.

Atwater

B. J.

Livermore

P. W.

(1981). The Shepherd Scale: Separating the sheep from the goats. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 9(4), 335–351. https://doi.org/10.1177/009164718100900406

Batson

C. D.

Sympson

S. C.

Hindman

J. L.

Decruz

Todd

R. M.

Weeks

J. L.

Jennings

Burns

C. T.

(1996). “I’ve been there, too”: Effect on empathy of prior experience with a need. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 22, 474–482. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167296225005

Bellucci

(1980). Effects of communication skill training on the perception and responding of teacher education students. Humanistic Educator, 19(2), 67–75. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2164-6163.1980.tb00124.x

Black

Phillips

(1982). An intervention program for the development of empathy in student teachers. Journal of Psychology, 112(2), 159–168. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223980.1982.9915373

Brammer

L. M.

Abrego

P. J.

Shostrom

E. L.

(1993). Therapeutic counseling and psychotherapy (6th ed.). Prentice Hall.

Butters

R. P.

(2010). A meta-analysis of empathy training programs for client populations [Doctoral dissertation]. https://collections.lib.utah.edu/dl_files/b2/e4/b2e471b0bb9593d957da9065018eee1cd5bce89e.pdf

Capuzzi

Gross

D. R.

(1999). Counseling and psychotherapy (2nd ed.). Prentice Hall.

Carkhuff

R. R.

(1969). Helping and human relations: A primer for lay professional helpers (Vol. 1). Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.

10.

Chung

R. C. Y.

Bemak

(2002). The relationship of culture and empathy in cross-cultural counseling. Journal of Counseling & Development, 80(2), 154–159. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1556-6678.2002.tb00178.x

11.

Clark

A. J.

(2010). Empathy: An integral model in the counseling process. Journal of Counseling & Development, 88(3), 348–356. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1556-6678.2010.tb00032.x

12.

Cohen

(1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Lawrence Erlbaum.

13.

Constantine

M. G.

(2000). Social desirability attitudes, sex, and affective and cognitive empathy as predictors of self-reported multicultural counseling competence. Counseling Psychologist, 28(6), 857–872. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011000000286008

14.

Constantine

M. G.

(2001). Multicultural training, theoretical orientation, empathy, and multicultural case conceptualization ability in counselors. Journal of Mental Health Counseling, 23(4), 357–372.

15.

Crampton

(2011, April 18). Empathy: Why it is important. TIGERS Success Series. https://corevalues.com/team-cultures/empathy-why-it-is-important/

16.

Davis

M. H.

(1983). Measuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 44, 113–126. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.44.1.113

17.

Day

H. I.

Chambers

(1991). Empathy and burnout in rehabilitation counselors. Canadian Journal of Rehabilitation, 5, 33–44.

18.

Downie

M. S.

Robbins

S. B.

(1998). Assessing the qualities of social relationships in clinical and nonclinical individuals. Counseling Psychologist, 26(3), 466–488. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011000098263009

19.

Duan

Hill

C. E.

(1996). The current state of empathy research. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 43(3), 261–274. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0167.43.3.261

20.

Duan

Kivlighan

D. M.

Jr. (2002). Relationships among therapist presession mood, therapist empathy, and session evaluation. Psychotherapy Research, 12(1), 23–37. https://doi.org/10.1080/713869615

21.

Earls

(2015, August 12). Views on divorce studied. Baptist Press. https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/views-on-divorce-studied/

22.

Elliott

Bohart

Watson

Greenberg

(2011). Empathy. Psychotherapy, 48(1), 43–49. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199737208.003.0006

23.

Fairchild

(2021, March 4). Compare major beliefs of 7 Christian denominations. https://www.learnreligions.com/comparing-christian-denominations-beliefs-part-1-700537

24.

Francis

L. J.

Croft

J. S.

Pyke

(2012). Religious diversity, empathy, and God images: Perspectives from the psychology of religion shaping a study among adolescents in the UK. Journal of Beliefs & Values, 33(3), 293–307. https://doi.org/10.1080/13617672.2012.732810

25.

Francis

L. J.

Fearn

Astley

Wilcox

(1999). The relationship between Christian commitment and motivation to study religion at A-level: A preliminary investigation. Journal of Education and Christian Belief, 3(2), 115–122.

26.

Fultz

S. A.

(2002). Clergy referral for counseling problems. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 62(8-B), 3799.

27.

Gallup. (2013). In U.S., four in 10 report attending church in last week. http://news.gallup.com/poll/166613/four-report-attending-church-last-week.aspx

28.

Gallup. (2014). Three-quarters of Americans identify as Christian. https://news.gallup.com/poll/180347/three-quarters-americans-identify-christian.aspx

29.

Gallup. (2018). How many Americans believe in God? https://news.gallup.com/poll/268205/americans-believe-god.aspx

30.

Gantt

E. E.

(2005). “Empathy.” Encyclopedia of human development. SAGE.

31.

Garcia

Bardoshi

Siblo

Steen

Haase

(2013). Enhancing multicultural empathy in the classroom and beyond: A proposed model for training beginner counselors. In Ideas and research you can use: VISTAS 2013. http://www.counseling.org/docs/default-source/vistas/enhancing-multicultural-empathy-in-the-classroom-and-beyond.pdf?sfvrsn=11

32.

Gay

D. A.

Ellison

C. G.

Powers

D. A.

(1996). In search of denominational subcultures: Religious affiliation and” pro-family” issues revisited. Review of Religious Research, 38(1), 3–17.

33.

Gazda

G. M.

Asbury

F. R.

Balzar

F. J.

Childers

W. C.

Haynle

N. A.

Walters

R. P.

(1984). Instructor’s guide to accompany human relations development: A manual for educators (3rd ed.). Allyn & Bacon.

34.

Gazda

G. M.

Asbury

F. R.

Balzar

F. J.

Childers

W. C.

Walters

R. P.

(1984). Human relations development: A manual for educators (3rd ed.). Allyn & Bacon.

35.

George

(2017, March 9). Is suicide an unforgivable sin? Faith and Culture. https://pastorrustygeorge.com/2017/03/09/suicide-unforgivable-sin/

36.

Giordano

A. L.

Prosek

E. A.

Lankford

C. T.

(2014). Predicting empathy: The role of religion and spirituality. Journal of Professional Counseling: Practice, Theory and Research, 41(2), 53–66.

37.

Gladstein

G. A.

(1983). Understanding empathy: Integrating counseling, development, and social psychology perspectives. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 30(4), 467–482. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0167.30.4.467

38.

Glock

C. Y.

Stark

(1965). Is there an American Protestantism? Trans-Action, 3, 8–13.

39.

Goodman

R. A.

(2002). Empathy as the medicine of life. In Breggin

P. R.

Breggin

Bemak

(Eds.), Dimensions of empathic therapy (pp. 51–55). Springer.

40.

Guinee

J. P.

Tracey

T. J. G.

(1997). Effects of religiosity and problem type on counselor description ratings. Journal of Counseling & Development, 76, 65–73.

41.

Gwet

K. L.

(2016). Testing the difference of correlated agreement coefficients for statistical significance. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 76(4), 609–637. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013164415596420

42.

Hafiz

(2017, December 6). 28 percent of Americans believe the Bible is the literal word of God. Religion. https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/06/04/americans-bible-word-of-god_n_5446979.html

43.

Hage

S. M.

Hopson

Siegel

Payton

DeFanti

(2006). Multicultural training in spirituality: An interdisciplinary review. Counseling and Values, 50(3), 217–234. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2161-007X.2006.tb00058.x

44.

Harrow

(1995). Empathy: The spirituality of counseling. Covenant of the Goddess Newsletter (Ostara, 1995). http://proteuscoven.com/counsel/empathy.htm

45.

Hodges

S. D.

Kiel

K. J.

Kramer

A. D. I.

Veach

Villanueva

B. R.

(2010). Giving birth to empathy: The effects of similar experience on empathic accuracy, empathic concern, and perceived empathy. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 36, 398–409. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167209350326

46.

Hogan

(1975). Empathy: A conceptual and psychometric analysis. Counseling Psychologist, 5(2), 14–18. https://doi.org/10.1177/001100007500500204

47.

Holloman

C. R.

Hendrick

H. W.

(1971). Problem solving in different sized groups. Personnel Psychology, 24(3), 489–500.

48.

Holtz

L. H.

(2007). Confessions of an adulterous Christian woman: Lies that got me there; truths that brought me back. Beacon Hill Press.

49.

Hook

J. N.

Davis

D. E.

Owen

Worthington

E. L.

Jr. Utsey

S. O.

(2013). Cultural humility: Measuring openness to culturally diverse clients. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 60, 353–366.

50.

Hope

L. C.

Cook

C. C. H.

(2010). The role of Christian commitment in predicting drug use amongst church affiliated young people. Mental Health, Religion & Culture, 4(2), 109–117. https://doi.org/10.1080/13674670126956

51.

Jenkins

O. B.

(2001, October). Religion as culture. Orville Jenkins Thoughts and Resources. http://orvillejenkins.com/whatisculture/religionascul.html

52.

King

M. B.

Hunt

R. A.

(1975). Measuring the religious variable: National replication. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 14(1), 13–22. https://doi.org/10.2307/1384452

53.

Kocet

M. M.

Herlihy

B. J.

(2014). Addressing value-based conflicts within the counseling relationship: A decision-making model. Journal of Counseling & Development, 92(2), 180–186. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1556-6676.2014.00146.x

54.

Kosmin

B. A.

Keysar

(2009). American Religious Identification Survey (ARIS 2008): Summary report. Trinity College. https://commons.trincoll.edu/aris/files/2011/08/ARIS_Report_2008.pdf

55.

Lewis

K. N.

Epperson

D. L.

(1991). Values, pretherapy information, and informed consent in Christian counseling. Journal of Psychology and Christianity, 10(2), 113–131.

56.

MacFarlane

Anderson

McClintock

A. S.

(2017). Empathy from the client’s perspective: A grounded theory analysis. Psychotherapy Research, 2, 227–238. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2015.1090038

57.

Maciak

A. T.

(2002). A study of empathic ability and spirituality in graduate students under clinical skills training. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 63(3-B), 1567.

58.

Malin

Pos

(2014). The impact of early empathy on alliance building, emotional processing, and outcome during experiential treatment of depression. Psychotherapy Research, 25(4), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2014.901572

59.

Mander

(2004). The selection of candidates for training in psychotherapy and counseling. Psychodynamic Practice: Individuals, Groups and Organizations, 10(2), 161–172. https://doi.org/10.1080/14753630410001686762

60.

Mehnert

Siem

Stürmer

Rohmann

(2018). The impact of client-counselor similarity on acceptance of counseling services for women living with HIV. AIDS Care, 30(4), 461–465.

61.

Miller

M. J.

(1989). A few thoughts on the relationship between counseling techniques and empathy. Journal of Counseling & Development, 67(6), 350–351. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1556-6676.1989.tb02623.x

62.

Miville

M. L.

Carlozzi

A. F.

Gushue

G. V.

Schara

S. L.

Ueda

(2006). Mental health counselor qualities for a diverse clientele: Linking empathy, universal diverse orientation, and emotional intelligence. Journal of Mental Health Counseling, 28(2), 151–165.

63.

Moore

L. A.

(2006, August). Empathy: A clinician’s perspective. The ASHA Leader, 11, 16–35. https://doi:10.1044/leader.FTR5.11102006.16

64.

Moran

Flannelly

K. J.

Weaver

A. J.

Overvold

J. A.

Hess

Wilson

J. C.

(2005). A study of pastoral care, referral, and consultation practices among clergy in four settings in the New York city area. Pastoral Psychology, 53(3), 255–266.

65.

Morrison

Borgen

(2010). How Christian spiritual and religious beliefs help and hinder counselors’ empathy toward clients. Counseling and Values, 55(1), 25–45.

66.

Neukrug

Bayne

Dean-Nganga

Pusateri

(2013). Creative and novel approaches to empathy: A neo-Rogerian perspective. Journal of Mental Health Counseling, 35(1), 29–42.

67.

Ogles

(2017, May). What pastors need to know about mental health, ministry, and liability. christianitytoday.com . https://www.churchlawandtax.com/web/2017/may/what-pastors-need-to-know-about-mental-health-ministry-and-.html

68.

Patterson

L. E.

(1988). The function of automaticity in counselor information processing. Counselor Education and Supervision, 27(3), 195–202. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1556-6978.1988.tb00758.x

69.

Pecnik

J. A.

Epperson

D. L.

(1985). A factor analysis and further validation of the Shepherd Scale. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 13(1), 42–49. https://doi.org/10.1177/009164718501300105

70.

Pope

V. T.

Kline

W. B.

(1999). The personal characteristics of effective counselors: What 10 experts think. Psychological Reports, 84(3), 1339–1344. https://doi.org/10.2466/PR0.84.3.1339-1344

71.

Redfern

Dancey

C. P.

Dryden

(1993). Empathy: Its effect on how counselors are perceived. British Journal of Guidance and Counseling, 21(3), 300–309. https://doi.org/10.1080/03069889308258685

72.

Ridley

C. R.

Lingle

D. W.

(1996). Cultural empathy in multicultural counseling: A multidimensional process model. In Pedersen

P. B.

Draguns

J. G.

Lonner

W. J.

Trimble

J. E.

(Eds.), Counseling across cultures (4th ed., pp. 21–46). SAGE.

73.

Riley

(2008, March 12). Study: Behaviors Americans consider “sinful.” Christian Post. https://www.christianpost.com/news/study-behaviors-americans-consider-sinful.html

74.

Rogers

C. R.

(1957). The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21, 95–103.

75.

Rogers

C. R.

(1959). A theory of therapy, personality, and interpersonal relationships, as developed in the client-centered framework. In Koch

(Ed.), Psychology: A study of a science (Vol. 3, pp. 184–256). McGraw Hill.

76.

Rogers

C. R.

(1961). On becoming a person: A therapist’s view of psychotherapy. Houghton Mifflin.

77.

Rogers

C. R.

(1975). Empathic: An unappreciated way of being. Counseling Psychologist, 5(2), 2–10. https://doi.org/10.1177/001100007500500202

78.

Rubinstein

(2011). Women outnumber men in mental health profession. https://www.goodtherapy.org/blog/more-women-mental-health-professionals/

79.

Saroglou

Delpierre

Dernelle

(2004). Values and religiosity: A meta-analysis of studies using Schwartz’s model. Personality and Individual Differences, 37(4), 721–734.

80.

Smietana

(2014, September 22). Mental illness remains taboo topic for pastors. Baptist Press. https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/mental-illness-remains-taboo-topic-for-pastors/

81.

Strayer

(1987). Affective and cognitive perspectives on empathy. In Eisenberg

Strayer

(Eds.), Empathy and it’s development (pp. 218–244). Cambridge University Press.

82.

Targ

(1999). A curriculum on spirituality, faith, and religion for psychiatry residents. Psychiatric Annals, 29(8), 485–488. https://doi.org/10.3928/0048-5713-19990801-12

83.

Turton

D. W.

(2004). Expectations of counseling: A comparison between evangelical Christians and non-evangelical Christians. Pastoral Psychology, 52, 507–517.

84.

Vieten

Scammell

Pilato

Ammondson

Pargament

Lukoff

(2013). Spiritual and religious competencies for psychologists. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, 5(3), 129–144. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0032699

85.

Walker

D. F.

Gorsuch

R. L.

Tan

S. Y.

(2004). Therapists’ integration of religion and spirituality in counseling: A meta-analysis. Counseling and Values, 49(1), 69–80.