The “Triangle That Moves the Mountain” and Thai Alcohol Policy Development: Four Case Studies

Abstract

The “Triangle that Moves the Mountain” is a conceptualized strategy initiated as a social tool for solving difficult social problems, by simultaneously strengthening capacity in three interrelated sectors: (1) creation of knowledge; (2) social movement; and (3) political involvement. The concept has been claimed as the basis of many successes in various Thai policy arenas.

This article describes the strategy implications of four alcohol policy development case studies. The first case is the establishment process for the Thai Health Promotion Foundation and its contribution to the alcohol policy area. The second and third cases are two phases in the development of alcohol promotion regulation. The last case reviews the movement against the approval of an alcohol company listing on the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The case studies show that capacity strengthening in three sectors, based on this concept, benefited Thai alcohol policy development.

Keywords

Alcohol alcohol policy Triangle that Moves the Mountain Thailand

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Babor

T. F.

(2002). Linking science to policy. The role of international collaborative research. Alcohol Research and Health, 26, 66–74.

Bangkok Today Newspaper. (2005). Stop alcohol ad. October 1, 2005 [in Thai].

Boonphinon

(1997). A review of foreign legislation on health promotion foundation. Nonthaburi: Health Research System Institute. [in Thai].

Bowornwathana

(1997). Thailand: Bureaucracy under coalition governments. Civil Service Systems in Comparative Perspective. Bloomington, IN: School of Public and Environmental Affairs, Indiana University.

Bunnag

(2006). Council of State urged to review stance on ban. Bangkok Post Newspaper. November 27, 2006.

Center for Alcohol Studies. (2005). Alcohol and stock market. Bangkok: Center for Alcohol Studies [in Thai].

Center for Alcohol Studies. (2006). Revised data on alcohol consumption rank. Bangkok: Center for Alcohol Studies [in Thai].

Center for Alcohol Studies. (n.d.). History of CAS. Bangkok: Center for Alcohol Studies [in Thai].

Chinmaneevong

(2006). 30,000 to lose jobs. Bankok Post Newspaper.

10.

Food Act B.E. 252. (1979). (enacted May 5, 1979). [in Thai].

11.

Futrakul

(2006). Analysis: The first bill on the alcohol Beverage Control in Thailand. Disease Control Journal, 32, 149–261 [in Thai].

12.

Grailit

(2006). Statement of the Lawyer Council of Thailand on Alcohol Advertising Regulation November 28, 2006. Bangkok: Lawyer Council of Thailand, [in Thai].

13.

Health System Reform Office. (2003). Health and alcohol. Matichon Newspaper. July 2. 2003 [in Thai].

14.

Kajorntham

, & Sornphaisarn

(2204). Effectiveness of alcohol consumption control measures. Bangkok: National Health Foundation.

15.

Khao-sod Newspaper. (2003). 300,000 new drinkers this year. July 22, 2003 [in Thai].

16.

Khao-sod Newspaper. (2005). Support for Chang beer listing. February 18, 2005 [in Thai].

17.

Khao-sod Newspaper. (2006a). Concealed alcohol promotion on TV. January 30, 2006 [in Thai].

18.

Khao-sod Newspaper. (2006b). Continue protesting against Chang beer listing. January 7. 2006 [in Thai].

19.

Khao-sod Newspaper. (2006c). PM against alcohol ad ban. February 7, 2006 [in Thai].

20.

Khao-sod Newspaper. (2006d). Senator blames PM on freezing alcohol ad ban. February 8, 2006 [in Thai].

21.

Krungthep Thurakit Newspaper. (2003a). Jaturon proposes four measures on road accidents. July 3, 2003 [in Thai].

22.

Krungthep Thurakit Newspaper. (2003b). 30 alcohol producers lobby the cabinet. July 8, 2003 [in Thai].

23.

Krungthep Thurakit Newspaper. (2005). Alcohol promotion. September 7, 2005 [in Thai].

24.

Krungthep Thurakit Newspaper. (2006). Research says ads ban is useless. March 29, 2006 [in Thai].

25.

Mäkelä

, & Viikari

(1977). Notes on Alcohol and the State. Acta Sociologica, 20, 155–178.

26.

Matichon Newspaper. (2003a). Daytime alcohol ads ban. June 20, 2003 [in Thai].

27.

Matichon Newspaper. (2003b). Dr. Hathai accepted invitation to be alcohol watchdog. August 2, 2003 [in Thai].

28.

Matichon Newspaper. (2003c). Establishing Alcohol Consumption Control Committee. July 22, 2003 [in Thai].

29.

Matichon Newspaper. (2003d). Reschedule the decision on alcohol ad ban. July 22, 2003 [in Thai].

30.

Matichon Newspaper. (2005a). 50,000 against Chang beer listing. July 19, 2005 [in Thai].

31.

Matichon Newspaper. (2005b). PM floats over Chang beer listing saga. March 24, 2005 [in Thai].

32.

Matichon Newspaper. (2005c). Postpone decision on Chang beer listing. August 11, 2005 [in Thai].

33.

Matichon Newspaper. (2006a). Alcohol industry warns government. January 18, 2006 [in Thai].

34.

Matichon Newspaper. (2006b). Study says ads ban cannot make drinkers quit. September 19, 2006 [in Thai].

35.

Matichon Newspaper. (2006c). ThaiBev wants dual listing. June 5, 2006 [in Thai].

36.

Matichon Sudsubda Newspaper. (2006). Conclusion of the Chang beer saga: Thais are loser. January 20, 2006 [in Thai].

37.

Nation Newspaper. (2006). Ad ban wins praise from many sectors. October 23, 2006.

38.

Nikomborirak

(2002). Marketing behavior survey to support fair marketing competition. Bangkok: Thailand Development Research Institute [in Thai].

39.

Österberg

, & Karlsson

(2001). Alcohol policies in the ECAS countries, 1950–2000. In Norström

(Ed.), Alcohol in Postwar Europe: Consumption, drinking patterns, consequences and policy responses in 15 European countries. Stockholm: National Institute of Public Health, European Commission.

40.

Partanen

, & Montonen

(1988). Alcohol and the mass media. Euro Reports and Studies 108. Copenhagen: World Health Organization regional Office for Europe.

41.

Phoojadgarn Newspaper. (2003). Dr. Prakit warns alcohol industry to stop lobbying. July 10, 2003 [in Thai].

42.

Phoojadgarn Newspaper. (2006a). Alcohol ad affects youth. September 19, 2006 [in Thai].

43.

Phoojadgarn Newspaper. (2006b). Chang beer to Singapore. January 4, 2006 [in Thai].

44.

Phoojadgarn Newspaper. (2006c). Phra Payom supports alcohol ad ban. October 13, 2006 [in Thai].

45.

Phoojadgarn Newspaper. (2006d). Total ban aborted? PM urges Pinit to reconsider. February 10, 2006 [in Thai].

46.

Phoojadgarn Online Newspaper. (2005). Elephant keepers support Chang beer listing. September 7, 2005 [in Thai].

47.

Phoojadgarn Online Newspaper. (2006). Poor quality research saying that advertising ban won't affect drinking. September 19, 2006 [in Thai].

48.

Posttoday Newspaper. (2003). Monks attack at alcohol industry. July 21, 2003 [in Thai].

49.

Posttoday Newspaper. (2004). Alcohol industry warned. October 10, 2004 [in Thai].

50.

Prachachat Thurakit Newspaper. (2005a). Chang beer listing stalled. March 24, 2005 [in Thai].

51.

Prachachat Thurakit Newspaper. (2005b). Chang beer listing on the cross road, consultant to lobby committee. March 21, 2005 [in Thai].

52.

Prachachat Thurakit Newspaper. (2005c). Word by word: Thapana Siriwathanaphakdee and next step of Chang beer. February 28, 2005 [in Thai].

53.

Prachachat Thurakit Newspaper. (2006). Chang beer effect, Thai or Singapore. January 16, 2006 [in Thai].

54.

Room

(1999). The idea of alcohol policy. Nordic Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 16 (English supplement), 7–20.

55.

Room

Jernigan

Carlini-Marlatt

Gureje

Mäkëla

Marshall

(2002). Alcohol in Developing Societies: A Public Health Approach. Helsinki: Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies and the World Health Organization.

56.

Saffer

(1991). Alcohol advertising bans and alcohol abuse: An international perspective. Journal of Health Economics, 10, 65–79.

57.

Saiyood

(2003). Where is Jaturon. Krungthep Thurakit Newspaper.? July 24, 2003 [in Thai].

58.

Securities and Exchange Commission. (2000). Announcement of SEC on approval of listing process in Stock Exchange Thailand (12/2543). Bangkok: Securities and Exchange Commission [in Thai].

59.

Shitanon

(2003). Are you government or alcohol seller? Matichon Newspaper. July 7, 2003 [in Thai].

60.

Siwaraksa

(2005). The birth of the ThaiHealth Fund. Bangkok: Thai Health Promotion Foundation.

61.

Srimuang

(2005). Statement on alcohol industry listing in SEC. Bangkok: StopDrink Network, [in Thai].

62.

StopDrink Network. (n.d.). StopDrink Network partners. Retrieved October 21, 2006, from http://www.stopdrink.com/index.php?content=links. Bangkok: Stopdrink Network [in Thai].

63.

Supawongse

Buasai

, & Thanapathara

(1999). The Evolution of the tobacco consumption control in Thailand. Nonthaburi: Ministry of Public Health [in Thai].

64.

Thai Health Promotion Foundation. (2006). ThaiHealth Master Plan for the fiscal year 2006–2008, Bangkok: Thai Health Promotion Foundation.

65.

Thai Health Promotion Foundation. (n.d.-a). Alcohol Consumption Control Program. Retrieved October 15, 2005, from http://www.thaihealth.or.th/en/content.php?n=Alcohol, Bangkok: Thai Health Promotion Foundation.

66.

Thai Health Promotion Foundation (n.d.-b). Health Promotion Foundation Act, B.E. 254. (2001). Bangkok: Thai Health Promotion Foundation [in Thai].

67.

Thai Health Promotion Foundation & StopDrink Network. (2003). Youth and alcoholic beverages advertisement. Factsheet for alcohol refraining. Bangkok: Thai Health Promotion Foundation [in Thai].

68.

ThaiPR.net. (2006). Launch of the Federation on Alcohol Control of Thailand (13 October 2006). Retrieved October 23, 2006 from http://www.thailand4.com/news/2006-10-13/1559-launch-of-the-federation-on-alcohol-control-of. Bangkok: ThaiPR.net [in Thai].

69.

Thaipost Newspaper. (2006). Cabinet agrees with new alcohol law. January 25, 2006 [in Thai].

70.

Thairath Newspaper. (2006). People support free health insurance and alcohol ad ban. October 15, 2006 [in Thai].

71.

Thamarangsi

(2005). A Position Paper for Thailand on agenda 13.14: Public health problems caused by harmful use of alcohol in the 58th World Health Assembly (a report), Nonthaburi: International Health Policy Program.

72.

Thamarangsi

(2006). Why we drink so much. Journal of Health Science, 15, 335–346 [in Thai].

73.

Thansetthakij Newspaper. (2003). Alcohol industry alliance puts pressure to cabinet. July 6, 2003 [in Thai].

74.

Thansetthakij Newspaper. (2004). 3 groups to lobby Deputy PM on advertising regulation. January 18, 2004 [in Thai].

75.

The Council of the State. (2006). Official Record of the Council of the State: Consideration on the legitimacy of the alcohol advertising regulation-December 29, 2006 [in Thai].

76.

Wasi

(2000). “Triangle that moves the mountain” and health systems reform movement in Thailand. Human Resources for Health Development Journal, 4, 106–110.

77.

Wasi

(2005a). Examples of knowledge management by the concept “triangle that moves the mountain.” Bangkok: Knowledge Management Institute [in Thai].

78.

Wasi

(2005b). Thai tobacco control movement: The next step. Bangkok: Siam Sewana Network [in Thai].

79.

Wibulpolprasert

(Ed.). (2005). Thailand Health Profile 2001–2004. Nonthaburi: Bureau of Policy and Strategy, Ministry of Public Health.

80.

World Health Organization. (n.d.). Adult Per Capita Consumption. Retrieved November 28, 2005 from www3.who.int/whosis/alcohol/alcohol_apc_data. World Health Organization.