The criteria used respectively by mental health professionals and legal professionals in child custody assessments are reviewed. The review concentrates on case precedents and the psychological literature in an attempt to delineate the major criteria on which custody decisions are based. Differences in assumptions between the two groups of professionals are highlighted.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BagarozziD.JurichA.JacksonA. (1983). Marital and family therapy: New perspectives in theory, research and practice. New York: Human Sciences Press.
2.
BatesF. (1976). The changing position of the mother in custody cases: Some comparative developments. Family Law, 6, 125–128.
3.
BillerW.B. (1970). Father absence and the personality development of the male child. Developmental Psychology, 2(2), 181–201.
4.
BittermanC.M. (1968). The multimarriage family. Journal of Social Casework, 49, 218–221.
5.
BlumenthalM.D. (1967). Mental health among divorced. Archives of Psychiatry, 16, 603–608.
6.
BobergP.Q.R. (1977). The law of persons and the family, Cape Town: Juta and Company Limited.
7.
BowermanC.E.IrishD.P. (1962). Some relationships of stepchildren to their parents. Marriage and Family Living, 24, 113–121.
8.
BowlbyJ. (1951). Maternal care and mental health. Geneva: World Health Organization.
9.
BowlbyJ. (1969). Attachment and loss. Vol. 1, Attachment. London: Hogarth.
10.
BromleyP.M. (1976). Family Law (5th ed.) London: Butterworths and Company.
11.
BuxtonM. (1981). Oedipal difficulties and custody change. Case Analysis, 1(4), 297–317.
12.
ChasinR.GrunebaumH. (1982). A model for evaluation in child custody disputes. In KaslowF.W. (Ed.), The international book of family therapy, New York: Brunner/Mazel.
13.
CohenL.J. (1974). The operational definition of human attachment. Psychological Bulletin, 81, 107–217.
14.
CollettaN.D. (1979). The impact of divorce: Father absence or poverty. Journal of Divorce, 3, 27–36.
15.
DerdeynA.P. (1975). Child custody consultation. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 45, 791–801.
16.
DerdeynA.P. (1977). Children in divorce. Journal of Pediatrics, 60, 20–27.
17.
ErculeD.GoldenbergN.SchlesingerB. (1979). Children in one-parent families: Some implications. In SchlesingerB. (Ed.). One in ten: The single parent in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Faculty of Education, Guidance Centre.
18.
FineS. (1980). Children in divorce, custody and access situations: The contribution of the mental health professional. Journal of Clinical Psychology and Psychiatry and Applied Disciplines, 21(4), 353–361.
19.
FinlayH.A.GoldS. (1971). The paramount interests of the child in law and psychiatry. Australian Law Journal, 45, 82–94.
20.
FultonJ.A. (1979). Parental reports of children's post-divorce adjustment. Journal of Social Issues, 35(4), 126–139.
21.
GlickP.C. (1979). Children of divorced parents in demographic perspective. Journal of Social Issues, 35, 4.
22.
GoldsteinJ. (1972). Finding the least detrimental alternative: The problem for the law of child placement. Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, 27, 626–641.
23.
GoldsteinJ. (1977). Medical care for the child at risk: On State supervision of parental autonomy. Yale Law Journal, 86, 645–651.
24.
GoldsteinJ.FreudA.SolnitA.J. (1980). Beyond the best interests of the child, London: Burnett Books Limited.
25.
HahloH.R. (1985). The South African law of husband and wife (5th ed.) Cape Town: Juta and Company Limited.
26.
HenningJ.S.OldhamJ.T. (1977). Children of divorce: Legal and psychological crises. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 6(2), 55–59.
27.
HessR.D.CamaraK.A. (1979). Post-divorce family relationships as mediating factors in the consequences of divorce in children. Journal of Social Issues, 35(4), 79–96.
28.
HetheringtonE.M. (1972). Effects of father-absence on personality development in adolescent daughters. Developmental Psychology, 7(2), 313–326.
29.
HetheringtonE.M.CoxM.CoxR. (May, 1978). Family interaction and social, emotional and cognitive development of children following divorce. Paper presented at the Symposium on the Family: Setting Priorities, Washington D.C.
30.
HodgesF.W.BuschsbaumH.K.TierneyC.W. (1983). Parent — child relationships and adjustment in preschool children in divorced and intact families. Journal of Divorce, 7(2), 43–58.
31.
JacksonA.M.WarnerN.S.HorbeinR.NelsonN.FortescueE. (1980). Beyond the best interests of the child revisited: An approach to custody evaluations. Journal of Divorce, 3(3), 207–222.
32.
KahnE. (1967). The rules of precedent applied in South African courts. South African Law Journal, 84, 52–58.
33.
KalterN. (1977). Children of divorce in an out-patient psychiatric population. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 47, 40–51.
34.
KingM. (1974). Maternal love — fact or myth?Family Law, 4, 61–64.
35.
KopfK.E. (1970). Family variables and school adjustment of 8th grade father absent boys. The Family Coordinator, 19, 145–150.
36.
KriesbergL. (1970). Mothers in poverty: A study of fatherless families. Chicago: Aldine.
37.
KurdekL.A.BliskD. (1983). Dimensions and correlates of mothers' divorce experiences. Journal of Divorce, 6(4), 1–24.
38.
LambiaseE.E.A.CumesJ.W. (1987). Child custody decisions: How legal and mental health professionals view the concept of ‘best interests of the child’. South African Journal of Psychology, 17(4), 127–130.
39.
MarsdenD. (1969). Mothers alone: Poverty and the fatherless family. London: Allen Lane the Penguin Press.
40.
McDermottJ.F. (1968). Parental divorce in early childhood. American Journal of Psychiatry, 124, 1424–1432.
41.
McDermottJ.F. (1970). Divorce and its psychiatric sequelae in children. Archives of General Psychiatry, 23, 421–427.
42.
MusettoA.P. (1978). Child custody and visitatio: The role of the clinician in relation to the family. Family Therapy. 5(2), 143–150.
43.
MusettoA.P. (1981). Standards for deciding contested custody. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 10(1), 51–55.
44.
NortonA.J.GlickP.C. (1976). Marital instability: Past, present and future. Journal of Social Issues, 32, 5–20.
45.
PearlinL.I.JohnsonJ.S. (1977). Marital status, life strains and depression. American Sociological Review, 42, 704–715.
46.
PearlinJ.MunsonP.ThoenniesN. (1983). Children's rights and child custody proceedings. Journal of Divorce, 7(2), 1–21.
47.
PettM.G. (1982). Correlates of children's social adjustment following divorce. Journal of Divorce, 5(4), 25–37.
48.
RosenR. (1977). Children of divorce: What they feel about access and other aspects of the divorce experience. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 6, 24–27.
49.
RosenR.AbramovitzA. (1975). Disputed custody: Suggested guidelines for drawing up of recommendations for legal practice and court proceedings. South African Journal of Psychology, 5, 74–80.
50.
RosenbergB.G.Sutton-SmithB. (1971). Sex-role identity and sibling composition. Journal of Genetic Psychology, 118, 29–32.
51.
RutterM. (1971). Parent — child separation: Psychological effects on children. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 12, 233–260.
RutterM. (1980). Maternal deprivation, 1972–1978: New findings, new concepts, new approaches. In ChessS.ThomasA. (Eds.). Annual progress in child psychiatry and child development, 1980. New York: Brunner/Mazel, 44–81.
54.
RutterM.CoxA.TuplingC.BergerM.YuleW. (1975). Attachment and adjustment in 2 geographical areas, I: The prevalence of psychiatric disorders. British Journal of Psychiatry, 126, 493–509.
55.
SantrockJ.W. (1970). Paternal absence, sex typing and identification. Developmental Psychology, 2(2), 264–272.
56.
SantrockJ.W. (1977). The effects of father absence on sex-typed behaviours in male children: Reason for absence and age of onset of absence. Journal of Genetic Psychology, 130, 3–10.
57.
SantrockJ.W.WarshakR.A. (1979). Father custody and social development in boys and girls. Journal of Social Issues, 35(4), 112–125.
58.
SchaefferH.R.EmersonP.E. (1964). The development of social attachments in infance. Monograph for the Society for Research in Child Development, 29 (3, Serial Number 94).
59.
SiegalD.M.HurleyS. (1977). The role of the child's preferences in custody proceedings. Family Law Quarterly, 11(1), 22–28.
60.
SornarajahM. (1973). Parental custody: The recent trends. South African Law Journal, 90, 131–149.
61.
SpiroE. (1976). The interests of the child and the conflict of laws. In BatesF. (Ed.). The child and the law, (Vol. II.), New York: Oceana Publications Inc. Dobbs Ferry.
62.
SpiroE. (1971). Law of parent and child (3rd edition with 1979 supplement), Cape Town: Juta and Company Limited.
63.
SpiroE. (1983). Custody and guardianship ‘stante matrimonio’ and on dissolution of marriage. Acta Juridica, 109–124.
64.
StackC.B. (1976). Who owns this child? Divorce and child custody decisions in middle-class families. Social Problems, 23(4), 505–515.
65.
TessmanL.M. (1978). Children of parting parents, New York: Aronson.
66.
ThiesM. (1977). Beyond divorce: The impact of remarriage on children, Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 6(2), 59–61.
67.
TizzardB. (1977). Adoption: A second chance, London: Open Books.
68.
TizzardB.HodgesJ. (1978). The effects of early institutional rearing on the development of eight-year-old children. Journal of Clinical Psychology and Psychiatry, 19, 99–118.
69.
TrengroveJ.J. (1983). Figures supplied by Mr Justice Trengrove in a message to FAMSA National Council.
70.
TrombettaD. (1982). Custody evaluation and custody mediation: A comparison of two dispute interventions. Journal of Divorce, 6(1–2), 65–76.
71.
VessJ.D.SchwebelA.I.MorelandJ. (1983). The effects of early parental divorce on the sex-role development of college students. Journal of Divorce, 7(1), 83–95.
72.
WallersteinJ.S. (1983). Children of divorce: The psychological tasks of the child. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 53, 230–243.
73.
WallersteinJ.S.KellyJ.B. (1980a). Surviving the breakup. New York: Basic Books.
74.
WallersteinJ.S.KellyJ.B. (1980b). California's children of divorce. Psychology Today, 13(8), 67–76.
75.
WestD.J.FarringtonD.P. (1973). Who becomes delinquent?London: Heineman Educational.
76.
WestD.J.FarringtonD.P. (1977). The delinquent way of life, London: Heineman Educational.
77.
WinstonM.P.ForsherT. (1971). Nonsupport of legitimate children by affluent fathers: A case of poverty and welfare dependence. New York: Rand Corporation.
