Directiveness and Authoritarianism: Some Research Findings and a Critical Reappraisal

Abstract

Afrikaans

Resulting from a cogent critique of the F scale as a measure of personality, Ray (1976) has proposed his ‘directiveness’ scale as a behaviourally valid measure of authoritarian personality. Research using this scale has suggested that authoritarian personality and the endorsement of authoritarian attitudes or ideology may be quite unrelated. This was supported by the present study which found no relationship between directiveness and either intolerant and negative attitudes towards homosexuals or an F scale measure of authoritarian attitudes. The conceptualizations of authoritarianism of Ray and Adorno et al. (1950) were then briefly reviewed and it was suggested that they appear to be quite distinct. It was therefore concluded that research using Ray's directiveness scale does not invalidate the theory of the authoritarian personality and that the development of a behaviourally valid measure of authoritarian personality as conceptualized by Adorno et al. remains a major research priority.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adorno

T.W.

Frenkel-Brunswik

Levinson

Sanford

The Authoritarian Personality. New York: Harper, 1950

Corbett

Troiden

Dodder

Tolerance as a correlate of experience with stigma: The case of the homosexual. J. Homosex., 1977, 3, 3–13

Fromm

Fear of Freedom. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1942

Heaven

P.C.L.

Authoritarianism, prejudice and alienation among Afrikaners. J. Soc. Psychol., 1980, 110, 39–42

Heaven

P.C.L.

Correlates of authoritarian personality. S. Afr. J. Psychol., 1981, 11, 85–86

Heaven

P.C.L.

Measuring authoritarianism by behaviour inventory among Afrikaners. S. Afr. J. Psychol., 1982, 12, 88–89

Heaven

P.C.L.

Rajab

Authoritarianism and patriotism: A study among Afrikaners and Indians in South Africa. In Heaven

P.C.L.

(Ed.), Authoritarianism: South African Studies. Bloemfontein: De Villiers, 1980

Heaven

P.C.L.

Ray

J.J.

Non-authoritarian Afrikaners. In Heaven

P.C.L.

(Ed.), Authoritarianism: South African Studies. Bloemfontein: De Villiers, 1980

McClintock

Personality syndromes and attitude change. J. Pers., 1958, 26, 479–493

10.

Morin

Garfinkle

Male homophobia. J. Soc. issues, 1978, 34, 29–47

11.

Mynhardt

J.C.

Prejudice among Afrikaans- and English-speaking South African students. J. Soc. Psychol., 1980, 110, 9–17

12.

Orpen

The effect of cultural factors on the relationship between prejudice and personality. J. Psychol., 1971, 78, 73–79

13.

Ray

J.J.

Do authoritarians hold authoritarian attitudes?

Hum. Relat., 1976, 29, 307–325

14.

Ray

J.J.

The authoritarian as measured by a personality scale: Solid citizen or misfit?

J. Clin. Psychol., 1979a, 35, 744–745

15.

Ray

J.J.

A short balanced F scale. J. Soc. Psychol., 1979b, 109, 309–310

16.

Ray

J.J.

Authoritarianism in California 30 years later — with some cross-cultural comparisons. J. Soc. Psychol., 1980a, 111, 9–17

17.

Ray

J.J.

Authoritarian tolerance. J. Soc. Psychol., 1980b, 111, 303–304

18.

Ray

J.J.

Achievement motivation as an explanation of authoritarian behaviour: Data from Australia, South Africa, California, England and Scotland. In Heaven

P.C.L.

(Ed.), Authoritarianism: South African Studies. Bloemfontein: De Villiers, 1980c

19.

Ray

J.J.

Do authoritarian attitudes or authoritarian personalities reflect mental illness?

S. Afr. J. Psychol., 1981a, 11, 153–157

20.

Ray

J.J.

Authoritarianism, dominance and assertiveness. J. Pers. Assess., 1981b, 45, 390–397

21.

Titus

H.E.

F scale validity considered against peer nomination criteria. Psychol. Rec., 1968, 18, 395–403

22.

Titus

H.E.

Hollander

E.P.

The California F scale in psychological research: 1950–1955. Psychol. Bull., 1957, 54, 47–64