Piaget,Vygotsky,and the Cultural Development of the Notions of Possibility and Necessity: An Experimental Study among Rural South African Learners

Abstract

I employ the theories of Vygotsky and Piaget in analysing the modes of experimental task performance in order to elaborate on the role that cultural content plays in the development and functioning of the notions of possibility and necessity. I challenge the notion of cognitive lag that has hitherto pervaded explanations of the development of subjects from non-industrialised, diverse socio-cultural settings. A Piagetian experimental task, comprising half circles of contrasting colours, is used in the investigation. One of these half circles, covered with tinfoil, is assumed to be either red or green in colour but not knowable in advance, and it is used as a basis for hypothesising about the possible colour values of circles that could be made from combining this half with the uncovered one. Eighty Venda-speaking learners, 20 learners from each of four grades (Grades 1, 3, 5, and 7), with ages ranging from an average 6.5 years in Grade 1 to 12.5 years in Grade 7, participated in the study. The results reveal that learners, although functioning at the operational level of thinking, employ both concrete-functional and formal-abstract and conceptual modes of thinking at the same time. Thus the concept of possibility is conceptualised as constituting both its concrete, functional form (involving a conception of the possible as the possible-real) and its formal, conceptual form (involving the conception of the possible as a hypothetical state of affairs, disembedded from its concrete context of problem manifestation and involving holding two or more cognitive categories constant during problem solving).

Keywords

necessity Piaget possibility socio-cultural Venda Vygotsky

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arievich

I. M.

Stetsenko

(2000). The quality of cultural tools and cognitive development: Galperin's perspective and its implications. Human Development, 43, 69–92.

Buck-Morss

(1975). Socio-economic bias in Piaget's theory and its implications for cross-cultural studies. Human Development, 18, 35–49.

Craig

(1985). Mothers and children: An analysis of change. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Natal, Durban.

Craig

Miller

(1984). Mother-child interaction. In Edwards

S. D.

(Ed.), Development and enrichment strategies for disadvantaged children (pp. 14–27). KwaDlangezwa: University of Zululand.

Dasen

P. R.

Heron

(1992). Cross-cultural tests of Piaget's theory. In Smith

, (Ed.), Jean Piaget: Critical assessment (pp. 64–110). London: Routledge.

Hedegaard

(1990). How instruction influences children's concepts of evolution. Mind, Culture and Activity, 3, 11–24.

Hedegaard

(1996). The zone of proximal development as basis for instruction. In Daniels

(Ed.), An introduction to Vygotsky (pp. 171–196). London: Routledge.

Hedegaard

(2002). Learning and child development: A cultural-historical study. Aarhus. Aarhus University Press.

Kamin

L. J.

(2006). African IQ and mental retardation. South African Journal of Psychology, 36, 1–9.

10.

Levert

Jansen

(2001). A Lurian-Piagetian approach to assessment of historically disadvantaged black scholars in English medium schools. South African Journal of Psychology, 31, 21–31.

11.

Luria

A. R.

(1976). Cognitive development: Its cultural and social foundations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

12.

Luria

A. R.

(1979). The making of mind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

13.

Macdonald

C. A.

(1987). Le Bonniec's epistemic modality: Cross-cultural replications. Pretoria: Human Sciences Research Council.

14.

Moll

(1994). School was far away: The formal perceptions, classifications and syllogistic reasoning of Kokwane Ndlovu. Perspectives in Education, 15, 189–217.

15.

Muthivhi

A. E.

(2008a). A socio-cultural case study of the schooling system in Venda, South Africa. Unpublished doctoral thesis, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg.

16.

Muthivhi

(2008b). Language policy, classroom practice and concept learning in a Grade One Tshivenda classroom. Southern African Review of Education, 14, 23–35.

17.

Muthivhi

A. E.

(2009). A dialogue between Piaget and Vygotsky on the developmental acquisition of the notions of necessity and possibility: A South African case study. Journal of Educational Studies, 8, 68–90.

18.

Muthivhi

A. E.

Broom

(2008). Continuities across schooling transition: A case of classroom practices among teachers in Venda, South Africa. Journal of Educational Studies, 7, 87–104.

19.

Piaget

(1964). Development and learning. In Ripple

Rockcastle

(Eds), Piaget rediscovered (pp. 7–20). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University.

20.

Piaget

(1966). Needs and significance of cross-cultural studies in genetic psychology. International Journal of Psychology, 1, 3–13.

21.

Piaget

(1968). Six psychological studies. London: Harvester Press.

22.

Piaget

(1970). Genetic epistemology. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

23.

Piaget

(2002). The theory of stages in cognitive development. In Gallager

J. M.

Reid

D. K.

(Eds), The learning theory of Piaget and Inhelder (pp. 12–37). Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.

24.

Piaget

(2001). The stages of intellectual development of the child. In Gauvain

Cole

(Eds), Readings on the development of children (pp. 9–28). New York, NY: W.H. Freeman.

25.

Le Bonniec

Pieraut P. G.

(1980). The development of modal reasoning: Genesis of necessity and possibility notions. New York, NY: Academic Press.

26.

Tulviste

(1991). The cultural-historical development of verbal thinking. New York, NY: Nova Science Publishers.

27.

Van Vlaenderen

(1999). Problem solving: A process of reaching common understanding and consensus. South African Journal of Psychology, 29, 166–177.

28.

Vygotsky

L. S.

(1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

29.

Vygotsky

L. S.

(1981). The genesis of higher mental functions. In Wertsch

J. V.

(Ed.), The concept of activity in Soviet psychology (pp. 144–188). New York, NY: Sharpe.

30.

Vygotsky

L. S.

(1986). Thought and language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

31.

Vygotsky

L. S.

(1987). The collected works of L. S. Vygotsky. Volume I: Problems of general psychology. New York, NY: Plenum Press.

32.

Wertsch

J. V.

(1984). The zone of proximal development: Some conceptual issues. In Rogoff

Wertsch

J. V.

(Eds), Children's learning in the zone of proximal development. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.