Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2015-7
Performance evaluation of direct saline stool microscopy,Formol ether concentration and Kato Katz diagnostic methods for intestinal parasitosis in the absence of gold standard methods
The parasite load within the sample and the amount of sample taken during examination greatly compromise the sensitivity of direct saline stool microscopy.
Methods
A cross-sectional study was conducted in March 2011 in Bahir Dar city among 778 fresh single stool samples to evaluate the performance of direct saline (DS), Kato Katz (KK) and Formol ether concentration (FEC) methods against the ‘Gold’ standard.
Result
Among 778 stool samples from school age children, the highest prevalence of intestinal parasites was recorded by FEC (55.1%). The sensitivity of DS, FEC and KK were 61.1%, 92.3% and 58.7%, respectively.
Conclusion
FEC is more sensitive than DS and KK. Hence, use of the latter is preferred.
World Health Organization. Control of Tropical Diseases, Geneva: WHO, 1998.
2.
FaustECAntoniJSOdomV. A critical study of clinical laboratory technicians for the diagnosis of protozoan cycts and helminth eggs in feces. Am J Trop Med1938; 18: 169–183.
3.
ShimelisABerhanuEGirmayMZelalemATechalewS. Intestinal parasitic infections in relation to HIV/AIDS status, diarrhea and CD4 T-cell count. BMC Infectious Diseases2009; 9: 155–155.
4.
KnoppSRinaldiLKhamisISStothardJRRollinsonDMaurelliMP. A single FLOTAC is more sensitive than triplicate Kato-Katz for the diagnosis of low-intensity soil-transmitted helminth infections. T Roy Soc Trop Med Hyg2009; 103: 347–354.
5.
TarafderMRCarabinHJosephLBalolongEOlvedaRMcGarveyST. Estimating the sensitivity and specificity of Kato-Katz stool examination technique for detection of hookworms, Ascaris lumbricoides and Trichuris trichiura infections in humans in the absence of a ‘gold’ standard. Int J Parasitol2010; 40: 399–404.
6.
LeveckeBWildeNDVandenhouteEVercruysseJ. Field validity and feasibility of four techniques for the detection of Trichuris in Simians: a model for monitoring drug efficacy in public health. PLoS Neg Trop Dis2009; 3: e366–e366.
7.
RitchieLS. An ether sedimentation technique for routine stool examination. Bull US Army Med Dep1948; 8: 326–326.
8.
McmillanAMcneillageGJC. Comparison of the sensitivity of microscopy and culture in the laboratory diagnosis of intestinal protozoal infection. Clin Pathol1984; 37: 809–811.
9.
SantosFLucianoNCerqueiraEJLSoaresNM. Comparison of the thick smear and Kato-Katz techniques for diagnosis of intestinal helminth infections. Revista da Sociedade Brasileira de Med Trop2005; 38: 196–198.
10.
Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia. Population Census Commission: Summary and statistical Report of the 2007 Population and Housing Census: Population size by age and sex, Addis Ababa: Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, 2008.
11.
DendukuriNRahmeEBélislePJosephL. Bayesian sample size determination for prevalence and diagnostic test studies in the absence of a gold standard test. Biometrics2004; 60: 388–397.
12.
TungtroncherAChiworapornCPraewanichRRadomyosPBiotanoJJ. The potential usefulness of modified Kato thick smear technique in the detection of intestinal sarcocystosis during field survey. Asian J Trop Med Public Health2007; 38: 232–238.
13.
World Health Organization Expert Committee. Prevention and control of schistosomiasis and soil-transmitted helminthiasis, World Health Organization Technical Report Series 912, Geneva: WHO, 2002.
14.
MogesFBelyhunYTirunehMKebedeYMuluAKassuA. Comparison of formol-acetone concentration method with that of the direct iodine preparation and formol-ether concentration methods for examination of stool parasites. Ethiopian J Health Dev2010; 24: 148–151.
15.
TayeS. Comparison of Kato-Katz and Formol-Ether concentration methods for the diagnosis of intestinal helminthic infections among school children of Wonji Shoa town, Eastern Ethiopia: A school based cross-sectional study. American Journal of Health2014; 2: 271–274.
16.
EndrisMTekesteZLemmaWKassuA. Comparison of the Kato-Katz, Wet Mount, and Formol-Ether concentration diagnostic techniques for intestinal helminth infections in Ethiopia. ISRN Parasitology2013; 2013: 5–5.
17.
SheyinZBigwanEIGaladimaM. Comparison of Formol-ether, direct smear and nigrosine methylene blue for the diagnosis of human intestinal parasites. J Microbiol Res Rev2013; 1: 30–34.
18.
GoodmanDHajiHJBickleQD. A comparison of methods for detecting the eggs of ascaris, trichuris, and hookworm in infant stool, and the epidemiology of infection in zanzibari infants. Am J Trop Med Hyg2007; 76: 725–731.
19.
ParaemeshwarappaKDChandrakanthCUnilB. The prevalence of intestinal parasitic infections and the evaluation of different concentration techniques of the stool examination. J Clin Diagn Res2012; 6: 1188–1191.
