A “holy war” is being fought within comparative historical sociology between deductivists and inductivists over the scope of general theory. The issues include broad versus narrow scope conditions, explicit versus contingent theorizing, and theory testing versus theory building. The irony of the conflict is that each side makes ample use of the other's product, despite condemning its progenitor. The authors offer a hierarchical approach to qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) as a method for linking deductive and inductive approaches, and link QCA to game theory as a way to design more dynamic comparative studies. The authors illustrate this method through a split labor market analysis of interracial conflict and cooperation in nine U.S. labor organizing drives.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abbott, Andrew
. 1992. “From Causes to Events: Notes on Narrative Positivism.”Sociological Methods & Research20:428-455.
2.
Amenta, Edwin
, Bruce G. Carruthers, and Yvonne Zylan. 1992. “A Hero for the Aged? The Townsend Movement, the Political Mediation Model, and U.S. Old-Age Policy, 1934-1950.”American Journal of Sociology98:308-339.
3.
Bonacich, Edna
. 1972. “A Theory of Ethnic Antagonism: The Split Labor Market.”American Sociological Review37:547-559.
4.
Bonacich, Edna
. 1975. “Abolition, the Extension of Slavery, and the Position of Free Blacks: A Study of Split Labor Markets in the United States, 1830-1863.”American Journal of Sociology81:601-628.
5.
Bonacich, Edna
. 1976. “Advanced Capitalism and Black/White Race Relations in the United States: A Split Labor Market Interpretation.”American Sociological Review41:34-51.
6.
Bonacich, Edna
. 1979. “The Past, Present, and Future of Split Labor Market Theory.”Research in Race and Ethnic Relations1:17-64.
7.
Boswell, Terry E.1986. “A Split Labor Market Interpretation of Discrimination Against Chinese Immigrants, 1850-1882.”American Sociological Review51:352-371.
8.
Boswell, Terry, Cliff Brown, John Brueggemann, and Ralph Peters. 1998. “Racial Competition and Class Solidarity.” Unpublished manuscript, Emory University.
9.
Boswell, Terry
, and David Jorjani. 1988. “Uneven Development and the Origins of Split Labor Market Discrimination: A Comparison of Black, Chinese, and Mexican Immigrant Minorities in the United States.” Pp. 169-185 in Racism, Sexism, and the World System, edited by J. Smith, J. Collins, T. K. Hopkins, and A. Muhammad. New York: Greenwood Press.
10.
Brown, Cliff, and Terry Boswell. 1995a. “Modeling Racially Split Labor Markets: Theoretical Adaptations and Technical Modifications for Heckathorn's Sequential Decision Model.” Unpublished Manuscript, University of New Hampshire.
11.
Brown, Cliff
, and Terry Boswell. 1995b. “Strikebreaking or Solidarity in the Great Steel Strike of 1919: A Split Labor Market, Game-Theoretic, and QCA Analysis.”American Journal of Sociology100:1479-1519.
12.
Brueggemann, John. 1994. “Realizing Solidarity: Comparative Historical Analysis of Inter-Racial Labor Organizing in the Coal, Steel, and Auto Industries, 1927-41.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Emory University.
13.
Brueggemann, John
, and Terry Boswell. 1998. “Realizing Solidarity: Sources of Interracial Unionism During the Great Depression.”Work and Occupations25:436-482.
14.
Griffin, Larry
. 1992. “Temporality, Events, and Explanation in Historical Sociology.”Sociological Methods & Research20:403-427.
15.
Griffin, Larry
. 1993. “Narrative, Event Structure Analysis, and Causal Interpretation in Historical Sociology.”American Journal of Sociology98:1094-1133.
16.
Heckathorn, Douglas
. 1990. “Collective Sanctions and Compliance Norms: A Formal Theory of Group Mediated Social Control.”American Sociological Review55:366-384.
17.
Heckathorn, Douglas
. 1991. “Collective Sanctions and Group Heterogeneity: Cohesion and Polarization in Normative Systems.”Advances in Group Processes9:41-63.
18.
Hicks, Alexander
. 1994. “Qualitative Comparative Analysis and Analytical Induction: The Case of the Emergence of the Social Security State.”Sociological Methods & Research23:86-113.
19.
Hicks, Alexander
, Joya Misra, and Tang Nah Ng. 1995. “The Programmatic Emergence of the Social Security State.”American Sociological Review60:329-349.
20.
Isaac, Larry W.
, and Larry J. Griffin. 1989. “Ahistoricism in Time-Series Analyses of Historical Processes.”American Sociological Review54:873-890.
21.
Kiser, Edgar
, and Michael Hechter. 1991. “The Role of General Theory in Comparative-Historical Sociology.”American Journal of Sociology97:1-30.
22.
Kiser, Edgar
, and Michael Hechter. 1998. “The Debate on Historical Sociology: Rational Choice Theory and Its Critics.”American Journal of Sociology104:785-816.
23.
Lieberson, Stanley
. 1991. “Small N's and Big Conclusions: An Examination of the Reasoning in Comparative Studies Based on a Small Number of Cases.”Social Forces70:307-320.
Olson, Mancur
. 1965. The Logic of Collective Action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
26.
Peters, Ralph. 1994. “Social Perpetuity Over Social Transformation: The Failure of Bi-Racial Textile Unionization in the Postwar South.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Emory University.
27.
Quadagno, Jill
, and Stan J. Knapp. 1992. “Have Historical Sociologists Forsaken Theory?”Sociological Methods & Research20:481-507.
28.
Ragin, Charles C.
1987. The Comparative Method. Berkeley: University of California Press.
29.
Ragin, Charles C.
, Susan E. Mayer, and Kriss A. Drass. 1984. “Assessing Discrimination: A Boolean Approach.”American Sociological Review49:221-234.
30.
Reich, Michael
. 1981. Racial Inequality: A Political-Economic Analysis. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
31.
Sewell, William
. 1996. “Three Temporalities: Toward Eventful Sociology.” Pp. 245-280 in The Historic Turn in the Human Sciences, edited by Terrance J. McDonald. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
32.
Siu, Paul C. P.1952. “The Sojourner.”American Journal of Sociology58:34-44.
33.
Skocpol, Theda
. 1979. States and Social Revolutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
34.
Somers, Margaret R.1998. “ `We're No Angels': Realism, Rational Choice, and Relationality in Social Science.”American Journal of Sociology104:722-784.
35.
Stinchcombe, Arthur
. 1993. Discussion comments at the 88th Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, August, Miami.
36.
Wallace, Michael
, Beth A. Rubin, and Brian T. Smith. 1988. “American Labor Law: Its Impact on Working Class Militancy, 1901-1980.”Social Science History12:1-29.
37.
Wickham-Crowley, Timothy P.
1992. Guerrillas and Revolution in Latin America: A Comparative Study of Insurgents and Regimes Since 1956. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
38.
Wilson, William J.
1978. The Declining Significance of Race. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
