Status consistency research has been severely criticized for its inability to reconcile certain problems of theory and method As the validity of these criticisms has become evident, researchers have turned from classic research designs to more powerful methods. One popular approach has incorporated typological procedures based on two-factor profiles of status inconsistents. In this paper, a serious fault of the two-factor technique is delineated, and the analysis of differences between types is shown to be without substance. Researchers are provided with a simple procedure for avoiding this pitfall before research is initiated, and elementary combinatorial analysis is utilized to derive a proper procedure. Two research designs, a 2 x 4 and a 3 x 4, receive special attention because of their popularity and complexity, respectively.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abramson, J.H. (1966) "Emotional disorder, status inconsistency and migration ." Milbank Memorial Fund Q.44 (January): 23-48.
2.
Bakan, D. (1967) "The test of significance in psychological research," chapter 1 in On Method: Toward a Reconstruction of Psychological InvestigationSan Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
3.
Bauman, K.E. (1968) "Status inconsistency, satisfactory social interaction, and community satisfaction in an area of rapid growth." Social Forces47 (September): 45-52.
4.
Berry, K.J. and T.W. Martin (1972) "Some methodological dilemmas in status consistency analysis." Rocky Mountain Social Sci. J.9 (October): 83-94.
5.
--- ( 1969) "Status consistency: the validity of reported findings ." Presented to the annual meeting of the Pacific Sociological Association, Seattle.
6.
Blalock, H.M. (1967a) "Tests of status inconsistency theory: a note of caution." Pacific Soc. Rev.10 (Fall): 69-74.
7.
--- (1967b) "Status inconsistency, social mobility, status integration, and structural effects." Amer. Soc. Rev.32 (October): 790-801.
8.
--- (1967c) "Status inconsistency and interaction: some alternative models." Amer. J. of Sociology73 (November): 305-315.
9.
——— (1966) "The identification problem and theory building: the case of status inconsistency." Amer. Soc. Rev.31 (February): 52-61.
10.
Brandmeyer, G. (1965) "Status consistency and political behavior: a replication and extension of research." Soc. Q.6 (Summer): 241-256.
11.
Broom, L. and F.L. Jones (1970) "Status consistency and political preference: the Australian case." Amer. Soc. Rev.35 (December): 989-1001.
12.
Cronbach, L.J. (1958) "Proposals leading to analytic treatment of social perception scores," chapter 23 in R. Tagiuri and L. Petrullo (eds.) Person Perception and Interpersonal Behavior. Stanford : Stanford Univ. Press.
13.
Demerath, N.J. (1965) Social Class in American Protestantism. Chicago: Rand McNally.
14.
--- ( 1962) "Status discrepancy and vertical status: criticisms and suggested remedies." Presented to the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, Washington, D.C.
15.
Fauman, S. (1968) "Status crystallization and interracial attitudes ." Social Forces47 (September): 53-60.
16.
Geschwender, J.A. (1968) "Status inconsistency, social isolation, and individual unrest." Social Forces46 (June): 477-483.
17.
Hunt, L.L. and R.G. Cushing (1970) "Status discrepancy, interpersonal attachment, and right-wing extremism." Social Sci. Q.51 (December): 587-601.
18.
Jackson, E.F. (1962) "Status consistency and symptoms of stress." Amer. Soc. Rev.27 (August): 469-480.
19.
--- and P.J. Burke (1965) "Status and symptoms of stress: additive and interaction effects." Amer. Soc. Rev.30 (August): 556-564.
20.
Lenski, G. (1954) "Status crystallization: a nonvertical dimension of social status." Amer. Soc. Rev.19 (August): 405-413.
21.
Lewis, D. and C.J. Burke (1949) "The use and misuse of the chi-square test." Psych. Bull.46 (November): 433-489.
22.
Mitchell, R.E. (1964) "Methodological notes on a theory of status crystallization ." Public Opinion Q.28 (Summer): 315-325.
23.
Runciman, W.G. and C.R. Bagley (1969) "Status consistency, relative deprivation, and attitudes toward immigrants." Sociology3 (September): 359-375.
Schmitt, D.R. (1965) "An attitudinal correlate of the status congruency of married women." Social Forces44 (December): 190-195.
26.
Selvin, H.C. (1965) "Durkheim's Suicide: further thoughts on a methodological classic." pp. 113-136 in R. A. Nisbet (ed.) Emile Durkheim. Englewood Cliffs, NJ.: Prentice-Hall.
27.
--- ( 1958) "Durkheim's Suicide and problems of empirical research ." Amer. J. of Sociology63 (May): 607-619.
28.
Siegel, S. (1956) Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences . New York: McGraw-Hill.
29.
Wilkinson, D.Y. (1970) "Political assassins and status incongruence: a sociological interpretation." British J. of Sociology21 (December): 400-412.
