The Gini index is probably the most commonly used indicator to measure inequality. For continuous distributions, the Gini index can be computed using several equivalent formulations. However, this is not the case with discrete distributions, where controversy remains regarding the expression to be used to estimate the Gini index. We attempt to bring a better understanding of the underlying problem by regrouping and classifying the most common estimators of the Gini index proposed in both infinite and finite populations, and focusing on the biases. We use Monte Carlo simulation studies to analyse the bias of the various estimators under a wide range of scenarios. Extremely large biases are observed in heavy-tailed distributions with high Gini indices, and bias corrections are recommended in this situation. We propose the use of some (new and traditional) bootstrap-based and jackknife-based strategies to mitigate this bias problem. Results are based on continuous distributions often used in the modelling of income distributions. We describe a simulation-based criterion for deciding when to use bias corrections. Various real data sets are used to illustrate the practical application of the suggested bias corrected procedures.
AnandS.1983. Inequality and Poverty in Malaysia: Measurement and Decomposition. New York: Oxford University Press, The World Bank.
2.
AtkinsonA. B.2017. “Pareto and the Upper Tail of the Income Distribution in the UK: 1799 to the Present.” Economica84(334):129–56.
3.
BakarS. A. A.PathmanathanD.. 2022. “Income Modeling with the Weibull Mixtures.” Communications in Statistics-Theory and Methods51(11): 3612–28.
4.
BergerY. G.2008. “A Note on the Asymptotic Equivalence of Jackknife and Linearization Variance Estimation for the Gini Coefficient.” Journal of Official Statistics24(4):541–55.
5.
BergerY.Gedik Balayİ. 2020. “Confidence Intervals of Gini Coefficient Under Unequal Probability Sampling.” Journal of Official Statistics36(2):237–49.
6.
BergerY. G.MuñozJ. F.. 2015. “On Estimating Quantiles Using Auxiliary Information.” Journal of Official Statistics31(1):101–19.
7.
BergerY. G.SkinnerC. J.. 2005. “A Jackknife Variance Estimator for Unequal Probability Sampling.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B: Statistical Methodology67(1):79–89.
8.
BonaciniL.GalloG.ScicchitanoS.. 2021. “Working from Home and Income Inequality: Risks of a ‘New Normal’ with COVID-19.” Journal of Population Economics34(1):303–60.
9.
BulleN.2016. “A Method of Measuring Inequality Within a Selection Process.” Sociological Methods & Research45(1):69–108.
10.
CampbellC.1980. “A Different View of Finite Population Estimation.” Proceedings of the Survey Research Methods Section, ASA, 1980, 319–24.
11.
CanelasC.GisselquistR. M.. 2019. “Horizontal Inequality and Data Challenges.” Social Indicators Research143(1):157–72.
12.
ClementiF.GallegatiM.. 2005 “Pareto’s Law of Income Distribution: Evidence for Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States.” pp. 3–14 in Econophysics of Wealth Distributions. New Economic Windows, edited by ChatterjeeA.YarlagaddaS.ChakrabartiB. K.. Milano: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/88-470-0389-X_1.
13.
CramerH.1957. Mathematical Methods of Statistics. Princeton: Princeton University Press, Seventh Printing.
14.
DavidsonR.2009. “Reliable Inference for the Gini Index.” Journal of Econometrics150(1):30–40.
15.
DeltasG.2003. “The Small-Sample Bias of the Gini Coefficient: Results and Implications for Empirical Research.” Review of Economics and Statistics85(1):226–34.
16.
DevilleJ. C.1999. “Variance Estimation for Complex Statistics and Estimators: Linearization and Residual Techniques.” Survey Methodology25:193–203.
17.
DorićD.Nikolić-DorićE.JevremovićV.MališićJ.. 2009. “On Measuring Skewness and Kurtosis.” Quality and Quantity43(3):481–93.
18.
EfronB.1990. “More Efficient Bootstrap Computations.” Journal of the American Statistical Association85:79–89.
19.
EfronB.TibshiraniR.. 1993. An Introduction to the Bootstrap. New York, London: Chapman and Hall.
20.
FabriziE.TrivisanoC.. 2016. “Small Area Estimation of the Gini Concentration Coefficient.” Computational Statistics & Data Analysis99:223–34.
21.
GilesD. E.2004. “Calculating a Standard Error for the Gini Coefficient: Some Further Results.” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics66(3):425–33.
22.
GiniC.1912. Variabilità e Mutabilità. Reprinted in Memorie di Metodologica Statistica; Ed. PizettiE. Bologna: Cuppini.
23.
GiorgiG. M.GigliaranoC.. 2017. “The Gini Concentration Index: A Review of the Inference Literature.” Journal of Economic Surveys31(4):1130–48.
24.
GomesE.Vendrell-HerreroF.MellahiK.AngwinD.SousaC. M.. 2018. “Testing the Self-Selection Theory in High Corruption Environments: Evidence from African SMEs.” International Marketing Review35(5): 733–59.
25.
HallP.MaitiT.. 2006. “On Parametric Bootstrap Methods for Small Area Prediction.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B: Statistical Methodology68(2):221–38.
26.
JassoG.1979. “On Gini’s Mean Difference and Gini’s Index of Concentration.” American Sociological Review44(5):867–70.
JiaoJ.HanY.. 2020. “Bias Correction with Jackknife, Bootstrap, and Taylor Series.” IEEE Transactions on Information Theory66(7):4392–418.
29.
LangelM.TilléY.. 2013. “Variance Estimation of the Gini Index: Revisiting a Result Several Times Published.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society176(2):521–40.
30.
LarrazB.2015. “Decomposing the Gini Inequality Index: An Expanded Solution with Survey Data Applied to Analyze Gender Income Inequality.” Sociological Methods & Research44(3):508–33.
31.
LarrazB.PavíaJ. M.Herrera-GómezM.. 2020. “Spatial Aggregation and Resampling Expansion of Big Surveys: An Analysis of Wage Inequality.” Regional Science Policy & Practice13(3):957–81.
32.
LarrazB.PavíaJ. M.VilaL. E.. 2019. “Beyond the Gender Pay Gap.” Convergencia81:1–34.
33.
LorenzM. O.1905. “Methods of Measuring the Concentration of Wealth.” Publications of the American Statistical Association9(70):209–19.
34.
MoranT. P.2006. “Statistical Inference for Measures of Inequality with a Cross-National Bootstrap Application.” Sociological Methods & Research34(3):296–333.
35.
Moya, P.J., J.F. Muñoz, E. Álvarez-Verdejo, and F.J. Blanco-Encomienda. 2023. “Rescaled Bootstrap Conficence Intervals for the Population Variance in the Presence of Outliers or Spikes in the Distribution of a Variable of Interest.” Communications in Statistics-Simmulation and Computation 52(2): 466–81.
36.
MuñozJ. F.Álvarez-VerdejoE.García-FernándezR. M.. 2018. “On Estimating the Poverty Gap and the Poverty Severity Indices with Auxiliary Information.” Sociological Methods & Research47(3):598–625.
OgwangT.2000. “A Convenient Method of Computing the Gini Index and Its Standard Error.” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics62(1):123–9.
39.
OwenA. B.2001. Empirical Likelihood. Boca Raton, Florida: Chapman and Hall/CRC.
40.
PérezC. G.AlaizM. P.. 2011. “Using the Dagum Model to Explain Changes in Personal Income Distribution.” Applied Economics43(28):4377–86.
41.
PfeffermannD.CorreaS.. 2012. “Empirical Bootstrap Bias Correction and Estimation of Prediction Mean Square Error in Small Area Estimation.” Biometrika99(2):457–72.
42.
PikettyT.2015. “About Capital in the Twenty-First Century.” American Economic Review105(5):48–53.
43.
QinY.RaoJ. N. K.WuC.. 2010. “Empirical Likelihood Confidence Intervals for the Gini Measure of Income Inequality.” Economic Modelling27(6):1429–35.
44.
Quatember, A. 2015. Pseudo-Population. A basic Concept in Statistical Surveys. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.
45.
RaoJ. N. K.WuC. F. J.YueK.. 1992. “Some Recent Work on Resampling Methods for Complex Surveys.” Survey Methodology18:209–17.
46.
SalemA. B.MountT. D.. 1974. “A Convenient Descriptive Model of Income Distribution: The Gamma Density.” Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society42(6): 1115–27.
47.
SärndalC. E.SwenssonB.WretmanJ.. 2003. Model Assisted Survey Sampling. New York, NY: Springer Science & Business Media.
48.
SenA.1973. “Poverty, Inequality and Unemployment: Some Conceptual Issues in Measurement.” Economic and Political Weekly 8(31/33): 1457–64.
49.
SzymańskaA.2021. “Reducing Socioeconomic Inequalities in the European Union in the Context of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.” Sustainability13(13):7409.
50.
TridicoP.2018. “The Determinants of Income Inequality in OECD Countries.” Cambridge Journal of Economics42(4):1009–42.
51.
Van OurtiT.ClarkeP.. 2011. “A Simple Correction to Remove the Bias of the Gini Coefficient Due to Grouping.” Review of Economics and Statistics93(3):982–94.
52.
Vendrell-HerreroF.DarkoC. K.GomesE.LehmanD. W.. 2022. “Home-Market Economic Development as a Moderator of the Self-Selection and Learning-by-Exporting Effects.” Journal of International Business Studies 53(7): 1519–1535.
53.
VillarJ. G.RayaJ. M.. 2015. “Use of a Gini Index to Examine Housing Price Heterogeneity: A Quantile Approach.” Journal of Housing Economics29:59–71.
54.
WanG. H.2001. “Changes in Regional Inequality in Rural China: Decomposing the Gini Index by Income Sources.” Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics45(3):361–81.
55.
WangH. Y.ChouW.ShaoY.ChienT. W.. 2020. “Comparison of Ferguson’s and the Gini Coefficient Used for Measuring the Inequality of Data Related to Health Quality of Life Outcomes.” Health and Quality of Life Outcomes18:1–9.
56.
WangD.ZhaoY.GilmoreD. W.. 2016. “Jackknife Empirical Likelihood Confidence Interval for the Gini Index.” Statistics & Probability Letters110:289–95.
57.
WolterK.2007. Introduction to Variance Estimation. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag New York, Inc.
58.
Wu, C., and M. E. Thompson. 2020. Sampling theory and practice. Switzerland, Cham: Springer International Publishing.
59.
YangQ.LiuT.ValdezR.MoonesingheR.KhouryM. J.. 2010. “Improvements in Ability to Detect Undiagnosed Diabetes by Using Information on Family History Among Adults in the United States.” American Journal of Epidemiology171(10):1079–89.
60.
YitzhakiS.1998. “More Than a Dozen Alternative Ways of Spelling Gini.” Research on Economic Inequality8:13–30.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
