Obtaining reliable and timely estimates of migration flows is critical for advancing the migration theory and guiding policy decisions, but it remains a challenge. Digital data provide granular information on time and space, but do not draw from representative samples of the population, leading to biased estimates. We propose a method for combining digital data and official statistics by using the official statistics to model the spatial and temporal dependence structure of the biases of digital data. We use simulations to demonstrate the validity of the model, then empirically illustrate our approach by combining geo-located Twitter data with data from the American Community Survey (ACS) to estimate state-level out-migration probabilities in the United States. We show that our model, which combines unbiased and biased data, produces predictions that are more accurate than predictions based solely on unbiased data. Our approach demonstrates how digital data can be used to complement, rather than replace, official statistics.
AlexanderMonicaPolimisKivanZagheniEmilio. 2020. “Combining Social Media and Survey Data to Nowcast Migrant Stocks in the United States.” Population Research and Policy Review41:1-28.
BellMartinBlakeMarcusBoylePaulDuke-WilliamsOliverReesPhilipStillwellJohnHugoGraeme. 2002. “Cross-national Comparison of Internal Migration: Issues and Measures.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society)165:435-64.
4.
BijakJakubBryantJohn. 2016. “Bayesian Demography 250 Years After Bayes.” Population studies70:1-19.
5.
BlumenstockJoshua E. 2012. “Inferring Patterns of Internal Migration From Mobile Phone Call Records: Evidence From Rwanda.” Information Technology for Development18:107-25.
6.
ClarkGordon L. 1983. Interregional Migration National Policy and Social Justice. Totowa NJ: Rowman and Allanheld.
7.
ClarkWilliam AVDeurlooMarinus CDielemanFrans M. 2000. “Housing Consumption and Residential Crowding in US Housing Markets.” Journal of Urban Affairs22:49-63.
8.
DeWaardJackHauerMathewFussellElizabethCurtisKatherine JWhitakerStephan DMcConnellKathrynPriceKobieEgan-RobertsonDavidSotoMichaelCastroCatalina Anampa. 2021. “User Beware: Concerning Findings From the Post 2011–2012 US Internal Revenue Service Migration Data.” Population Research and Policy Review41:1-12.
9.
FayR. E.HerriotR. A.1979. “Estimates of Income for Small Places: An Application of James–Stein Procedure to Census Data.” Journal of the American Statistical Association74:269-77.
10.
FiorioLeeAbelGuyCaiJixuanZagheniEmilioWeberIngmarVinuéGuillermo. 2017. “Using Twitter Data to Estimate the Relationship between Short-term MObility and Long-term Migration.” Pp. 103-10. in Proceedings of the 2017 ACM on Web Science Conference. ACM.
11.
FiorioLeeZagheniEmilioAbelGuyHillJohnathanPestreGabrielLetouzéEmmanuelCaiJixuan. 2021. “Analyzing the Effect of Time in Migration Measurement Using Georeferenced Digital Trace Data.” Demography58:51-74.
12.
MichaelGreenwood. 1981. Migration and Economic Growth in the United States. New York: Academic Press.
13.
HawelkaBartoszSitkoIzabelaBeinatEuroSobolevskyStanislavKazakopoulosPavlosRattiCarlo. 2014. “Geo-located Twitter As Proxy for Global Mobility Patterns.” Cartography and Geographic Information Science41:260-71.
14.
JurdakRajaZhaoKunLiuJiajunAbouJaoudeMauriceCameronMarkNewthDavid. 2015. “Understanding Human Mobility From Twitter.” PloS one10:e0131469.
15.
Knorr-HeldL. 2000. “Bayesian Modelling of Inseparable Space-time Variation in Disease Risk.” Statistics in Medicine19:2555-67.
16.
LaiShengjiezu Erbach-SchoenbergElisabethPezzuloCarlaRuktanonchaiNick WSorichettaAlessandroSteeleJessicaLiTraceyDooleyClaire ATatemAndrew J. 2019. “Exploring the Use of Mobile Phone Data for National Migration Statistics.” Palgrave Communications5:1-10.
17.
LeszczenskyLarsWolbringTobias. 2019. “How to Deal with Reverse Causality Using Panel Data? Recommendations for Researchers Based on a Simulation Study.” Sociological Methods & Research51:837-865.
18.
LindgrenFinnRueHåvard. 2015. “Bayesian Spatial Modelling with R-INLA.” Journal of Statistical Software63:1-25.
19.
MalikMominLambaHemankNakosConstantinePfefferJürgen. 2015. “Population Bias in Geotagged Tweets.” Pp. 18-27 in ICWSM Workshop on Standards and Practices in Large-Scale Social Media Research.
20.
MasseyDouglas SArangoJoaquinHugoGraemeKouaouciAliPellegrinoAdelaTaylorJ. Edward. 1993. “Theories of International Migration: A Review and Appraisal.” Population and development review19:431-66.
21.
MercerLaina DWakefieldJonPantazisAthenaLutambiAngelina MMasanjaHonoratiClarkSamuel. 2015. “Space-Time Smoothing of Complex Survey Data: Small Area Estimation for Child Mortality.” The annals of applied statistics9:1889-905.
22.
MisloveAlanLehmannSuneAhnYong-YeolOnnelaJukka-PekkaRosenquistJ. Niels. 2011. “Understanding the Demographics of Twitter users.” in Fifth International AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media.
23.
MolloyRavenSmithChristopher LWozniakAbigail. 2011. “Internal Migration in the United States.” Journal of Economic perspectives25:173-96.
24.
MolloyRavenSmithChristopher LWozniakAbigail. 2017. “Job Changing and the Decline in Long-distance Migration in the United States.” Demography54:631-53.
25.
MoragaPaula. 2019. Geospatial Health Data: Modeling and Visualization with R-INLA and Shiny. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
26.
MorettiEnrico. 2013. “Real Wage Inequality.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics5:65-103.
27.
MuthénBengtAsparouhovTihomir. 2018. “Recent Methods for the Study of Measurement Invariance With Many Groups: Alignment and Random Effects.” Sociological Methods & Research47:637-64.
28.
PokhriyalNeetiJacquesDamien Christophe. 2017. “Combining Disparate Data Sources for Improved Poverty Prediction and Mapping.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences114:E9783-92.
29.
RaymerJamesWiśniowskiArkadiuszForsterJonathan JSmithPeter W. F.BijakJakub. 2013. “Integrated Modeling of European Migration.” Journal of the American Statistical Association108:801-19.
30.
RieblerAndreaSørbyeSigrunn HSimpsonDanielRueHåvard. 2016. “An Intuitive Bayesian Spatial Model for Disease Mapping that Accounts for Scaling.” Statistical Methods in Medical Research25:1145-65.
31.
RueH.HeldL.. 2005. Gaussian Markov Random Fields: Theory and Application. Boca Raton: Chapman and Hall/CRC Press.
32.
SimpsonDanielRueHåvardRieblerAndreaMartinsThiago GSørbyeSigrunn Het al. 2017. “Penalising Model Component Complexity: A Principled, Practical Approach to Constructing Priors.” Statistical Science32:1-28.
33.
SteigerEnricoWesterholtRenéReschBerndZipfAlexander. 2015. “Twitter As An Indicator for Whereabouts of People? Correlating Twitter with UK Census Data.” Computers, Environment and Urban Systems54:255-65.
WakefieldJonFuglstadGeir-ArneRieblerAndreaGodwinJessicaWilsonKatieClarkSamuel J. 2019. “Estimating Under Five Mortality in Space and Time in a Developing World Context.” Statistical Methods in Medical Research28:2614-34.
36.
WesolowskiAmyStresmanGillianEagleNathanStevensonJenniferOwagaChrispinMarubeElizabethBousemaTeunDrakeleyChristopherCoxJonathanBuckeeCaroline O. 2014. “Quantifying Travel Behavior for Infectious Disease Research: A Comparison of Data From Surveys and Mobile Phones.” Scientific reports4:1-7.
37.
WillekensFransMasseyDouglasRaymerJamesBeaucheminCris. 2016. “International Migration Under the Microscope.” Science352:897-9.
38.
ZagheniEmilioGarimellaVenkata Rama KiranWeberIngmarStateBogdan. 2014. “Inferring International and Internal Migration Patterns from Twitter Data.” Pp. 439-44 in Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on World Wide Web, WWW ’14 Companion, New York, NY, USA: ACM.
39.
ZagheniEmilioWeberIngmar. 2012. “You are where you E-mail: using E-mail Data to Estimate International Migration Rates.” Pp. 348-51 in Proceedings of the 4th Annual ACM Web Science Conference. ACM.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
