Social scientists have frequently sought to understand the distinct effects of age, period, and cohort, but disaggregation of the three dimensions is difficult because cohort = period − age. We argue that this technical difficulty reflects a disconnection between how the cohort effect is conceptualized and how it is modeled in the traditional age-period-cohort framework. We propose a new method, called the age-period-cohort-interaction (APC-I) model, that is qualitatively different from previous methods in that it represents Ryder’s theoretical account about the conditions under which cohort differentiation may arise. This APC-I model does not require problematic statistical assumptions and the interpretation is straightforward. It quantifies inter-cohort deviations from the age and period main effects and also permits hypothesis testing about intra-cohort life-course dynamics. We demonstrate how this new model can be used to examine age, period, and cohort patterns in women’s labor force participation.
AbbottAndrew. 2005. “The Historicality of Individuals.” Social Science History29(1):1–13.
2.
AaronsonStephanieCajnerTomazFallickBruceGalbis-ReigFelixSmithChristopherWascherWilliam. 2014. “Labor Force Participation: Recent Developments and Future Prospects.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity2:197–275.
AlwinDuane F.McCammonRyan J.. 2003. “Generations, Cohorts, and Social Change.” Pp. 23–49 in Handbook of the Life Course, Handbooks of Sociology and Social Research, edited by MortimerJ. T.ShanahanM. J.. Boston, MA: Springer.
5.
BalleerAlmutGomez-SalvadorRamonTurunenJarkko. 2014. “Labour Force Participation across Europe: A Cohort-based Analysis.” Empirical Economics46:1385–415.
6.
BeckettMegan. 2000. “Converging Health Inequalities in Later Life—An Artifact of Mortality Selection?” Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:106–19.
7.
BorellaErikaGhislettaPaoloRibaupierreAnik de. 2011. “Age Differences in Text Processing: The Role of Working Memory, Inhibition, and Processing Speed.” The Journals of Gerontology. Series B, Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences66:311–20.
8.
BousheyHeather. 2005. Are Women Opting Out? Debunking the Myth, 2005–36. Washington, DC: Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR).
9.
ChauvelLouisSchröderMartin. 2015. “The Impact of Cohort Membership on Disposable Incomes in West Germany, France, and the United States.” European Sociological Review31:298–311.
10.
ChavesMark. 1989. “Secularization and Religious Revival: Evidence from U.S. Church Attendance Rates, 1972–1986.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion28:464–77.
11.
ChengSiwei. 2016. “The Accumulation of (Dis)Advantage: The Intersection of Gender and Race in the Long-term Wage Effect of Marriage.” American Sociological Review81:29–56.
12.
ChengSiweiTamboriniChristopher R.KimChangHwanSakamotoArthur. 2019. “Educational Variations in Cohort Trends in the Black-White Earnings Gap Among Men: Evidence From Administrative Earnings Data.” Demography.
13.
ClaytonD.SchifflersE.. 1987. “Models for Temporal Variation in Cancer Rates. II: Age-period-cohort Models.” Statistics in Medicine6:469–81.
14.
CloggClifford C.1982. “Cohort Analysis of Recent Trends in Labor Force Participation.” Demography19:459–79.
15.
ColeStephen. 1979. “Age and Scientific Performance.” American Journal of Sociology84:958–77.
16.
ConnellyRachel. 1992. “The Effect of Child Care Costs on Married Women’s Labor Force Participation.” The Review of Economics and Statistics74:83–90.
17.
DanneferDale. 1987. “Aging as Intracohort Differentiation: Accentuation, the Matthew Effect, and the Life Course.” Sociological Forum2:211–36.
18.
DanneferDale. 2003. “Cumulative Advantage/Disadvantage and the Life Course: Cross-fertilizing Age and Social Science Theory.” The Journals of Gerontology: Series B58:S327–37.
19.
DiPreteThomas A.EirichGregory M.. 2006. “Cumulative Advantage as a Mechanism for Inequality: A Review of Theoretical and Empirical Developments.” Annual Review of Sociology32:271–97.
20.
DugganMarkImbermanScott A.. 2009. “Why Are the Disability Rolls Skyrocketing? The Contribution of Population Characteristics, Economic Conditions, and Program Generosity.” Pp. 337-79 in Health at Older Ages: The Causes and Consequences of Declining Disability among the Elderly, edited by DavidCutlerDavidWise. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
21.
DupreMatthew E.2007. “Educational Differences in Age-related Patterns of Disease: Reconsidering the Cumulative Disadvantage and Age-as-leveler Hypotheses.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior48:1–15.
22.
ElderGlen H.Jr. 1975. “Age Differentiation and the Life Course.” Annual Review of Sociology1:165–90.
23.
ErcegChristopher J.LevinAndrew T.. 2014. “Labor Force Participation and Monetary Policy in the Wake of the Great Recession.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking46:3–49.
24.
EuwalsRobKnoefMarikevan VuurenDaniel. 2011. “The Trend in Female Labour Force Participation: What Can Be Expected for the Future?” Empirical Economics40:729–53.
25.
FarkasG.1977. “Cohort, Age, and Period Effects upon the Employment of White Females: Evidence for 1957–1968.” Demography14:33–42.
26.
FarréLídiaVellaFrancis. 2013. “The Intergenerational Transmission of Gender Role Attitudes and Its Implications for Female Labour Force Participation.” Economica80:219–47.
27.
FernándezRaquel. 2013. “Cultural Change as Learning: The Evolution of Female Labor Force Participation over a Century.” American Economic Review103:472–500.
28.
FerraroKenneth F.FarmerMelissa M.. 1996. “Double Jeopardy, Aging as Leveler, or Persistent Health Inequality? A Longitudinal Analysis of White and Black Americans.” The Journals of Gerontology: Series B51B:S319–28.
29.
FerraroKenneth F.Kelley-MooreJessica A.. 2003. “Cumulative Disadvantage and Health: Long-term Consequences of Obesity?” American Sociological Review68:707–29.
30.
FienbergStephen E.2013. “Cohort Analysis’ Unholy Quest: A Discussion.” Demography50:1981–84.
31.
FienbergStephen E.MasonWilliam M.. 1979. “Identification and Estimation of Age-period-cohort Models in the Analysis of Discrete Archival Data.” Sociological Methodology10:1–67.
32.
FienbergStephen E.MasonWilliam M.. 1985. “Specification and Implementation of Age, Period and Cohort Models.” Pp. 45–88 in Cohort Analysis in Social Research. New York, NY: Springer.
33.
FischerClaude S.HoutMichael. 2006. Century of Difference: How America Changed in the Last One Hundred Years. Russell Sage Foundation.
34.
FirebaughGlennHarleyBrian. 1991. “Trends in U.S. Church Attendance: Secularization and Revival, or Merely Lifecycle Effects?” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion30:487–500.
35.
FloodSarahKingMariamRugglesStevenWarrenJohn Robert. 2017. Integrated Public Use Microdata Series, Current Population Survey: Version 5.0. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.
36.
FortinNicole M.2015. “Gender Role Attitudes and Women’s Labor Market Participation: Opting-out, AIDS, and the Persistent Appeal of Housewifery.” Annals of Economics and Statistics117/118:379–401.
37.
FosseEthanWinshipChristopher. 2019a. “Analyzing Age-Period-Cohort Data: A Review and Critique.” Annual Review of Sociology45(1):467–92.
38.
FosseEthanWinshipChristopher. 2019b. “Bounding Analyses of Age-Period-Cohort Effects.” Demography56(5):1975–2004.
39.
GlennNorval D.1976. “Cohort Analysts’ Futile Quest: Statistical Attempts to Separate Age, Period and Cohort Effects.” American Sociological Review41:900–04.
40.
GlennNorval D.1989. “A Flawed Approach to Solving the Identification Problem in the Estimation of Mobility Effect Models: A Comment on Brody and McRae.” Social Forces67:789–95.
41.
GlennNorval D.2005. Cohort Analysis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
42.
GoldinClaudia. 2006. “The Quiet Revolution That Transformed Women’s Employment, Education, and Family.” The American Economic Review96:1–21.
43.
GoldinClaudiaKatzLawrence F.. 2018. Women Working Longer. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
44.
GoldinClaudiaMitchellJoshua. 2017. “The New Life Cycle of Women’s Employment: Disappearing Humps, Sagging Middles, Expanding Tops.” Journal of Economic Perspectives31:161–82.
45.
GreenbergB. G.WrightJohn J.ShepsCecil G.. 1950. “A Technique for Analyzing Some Factors Affecting the Incidence of Syphilis.” Journal of the American Statistical Association45:373–99.
46.
GrotenhuisManfred tePelzerBenLuoLiyingSchmidt-CatranAlexander W.. 2016. “The Intrinsic Estimator, Alternative Estimates, and Predictions of Mortality Trends: A Comment on Masters, Hummer, Powers, Beck, Lin, and Finch.” Demography53:1245–52.
47.
HardingDavid J.JencksChristopher. 2003. “Changing Attitudes toward Premarital Sex: Cohort, Period, and Aging Effects.” The Public Opinion Quarterly67(2):211-26.
48.
HeckmanJamesRobbRichard. 1985. “Using Longitudinal Data to Estimate Age, Period and Cohort Effects in Earnings Equations.” Pp. 137–50 in Cohort Analysis in Social Research, edited by MasonW. M.FienbergS. E.. New York: Springer.
49.
HopeKeith. 1975. “Models of Status Inconsistency and Social Mobility Effects.” American Sociological Review40(3):322–43.
50.
HobcraftJohnMenkenJanePrestonSamuel. 1982. “Age, Period, and Cohort Effects in Demography: A Review.” Population Index48:4–43.
51.
HoffmanSaul D.2009. “The Changing Impact of Marriage and Children on Women’s Labor Force Participation.” Monthly Labor Review132:3–14.
52.
HolfordTheodore R.1983. “The Estimation of Age, Period and Cohort Effects for Vital Rates.” Biometrics39:311–24.
53.
HollisterMatissa N.SmithKristin E.. 2014. “Unmasking the Conflicting Trends in Job Tenure by Gender in the United States, 1983–2008.” American Sociological Review79:159–81.
54.
HouleJason N.MartinMolly A.. 2011. “Does Intergenerational Mobility Shape Psychological Distress? Sorokin Revisited.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility29(2):193–203.
55.
HuiZhengChengSiwei. Forthcoming. “A Simulation Study of the Role of Cohort Forces in Mortality Patterns.” Biodemography and Social Biology.
56.
JaccardJamesTurrisiRobert. 2003. Interaction Effects in Multiple Regression. SAGE.
57.
KennedySheelaRugglesSteven. 2014. “Breaking Up Is Hard to Count: The Rise of Divorce in the United States, 1980–2010.” Demography51:587–98.
58.
KeyesKatherine M.UtzRebecca L.RobinsonWhitneyLiGuohua. 2010. “What Is a Cohort Effect? Comparison of Three Statistical Methods for Modeling Cohort Effects in Obesity Prevalence in the United States, 1971–2006.” Social Science & Medicine70:1100–08.
59.
KuhnThomas S.1996. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
60.
KupperLawrence L.JanisJoseph M.KarmousAzzaGreenbergBernard G.. 1985. “Statistical Age-period-cohort Analysis: A Review and Critique.” Journal of Chronic Diseases38:811–30.
61.
KupperLawrence L.JanisJoseph M.SalamaIbrahim A.YoshizawaCarl N.GreenbergBernard G.WinsboroughH. H.. 1983. “Age-period-cohort Analysis: An Illustration of the Problems in Assessing Interaction in One Observation per Cell Data.” Communications in Statistics—Theory and Methods12:201–17.
62.
LeeJin Young. 2014. “The Plateau in U.S. Women’s Labor Force Participation: A Cohort Analysis.” Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society53:46–71.
63.
LuoLiying. 2013. “Paradigm Shift in Age-period-cohort Analysis: A Response to Yang and Land, O’Brien, Held and Riebler, and Fienberg.” Demography50:1985–88.
64.
LuoLiyingHodgesJames S.. 2016. “Block Constraints in Age–Period–Cohort Models with Unequal-width Intervals.” Sociological Methods & Research45:700–26.
65.
LuoLiyingHodgesJames S.. Forthcoming. “Constraints in Random Effects Age-period-cohort Models.” Sociological Methodology.
66.
LuoLiyingHodgesJames S.WinshipChristopherPowersDaniel. 2016. “The Sensitivity of the Intrinsic Estimator to Coding Schemes: Comment on Yang, Schulhofer-Wohl, Fu, and Land.” American Journal of Sociology122:930–61.
67.
LynchJohnSmithGeorge DaveyHarperSamHillemeierMarianne. 2004. “Is Income Inequality a Determinant of Population Health? Part 2. U.S. National and Regional Trends in Income Inequality and Age- and Cause-specific Mortality.” The Milbank Quarterly82:355–400.
68.
MacunovichDiane J.2012. “Relative Cohort Size, Relative Income, and Married Women’s Labor Force Participation: United States, 1968–2010.” Population and Development Review38:631–48.
69.
MasonKaren OppenheimMasonWilliam M.WinsboroughH. H.PooleW. Kenneth. 1973. “Some Methodological Issues in Cohort Analysis of Archival Data.” American Sociological Review38(2):242–58.
70.
MertonRobert K.1968. “The Matthew Effect in Science: The Reward and Communication Systems of Science are Considered.” Science159:56–63.
71.
O’BrienRobert M.2000. “Age Period Cohort Characteristic Models.” Social Science Research29(1):123–39.
O’BrienRobert M.2013. “Comment of Liying Luo’s Article, ‘Assessing Validity and Application Scope of the Intrinsic Estimator Approach to the Age-period-cohort Problem.’” Demography50:1973–75; discussion 1985–88.
74.
O’BrienRobert M.HudsonKennethStockardJean. 2008. “A Mixed Model Estimation of Age, Period, and Cohort Effects.” Sociological Methods & Research36:402–28.
75.
O’RandAngela M.1996. “The Precious and the Precocious: Understanding Cumulative Disadvantage and Cumulative Advantage Over the Life Course.” The Gerontologist36:230–38.
76.
PampelFred C.HunterLori M.. 2012. “Cohort Change, Diffusion, and Support for Environmental Spending in the United States.” American Journal of Sociology118:420–48.
77.
PengXizhe. 1987. “Demographic Consequences of the Great Leap Forward in China’s Provinces.” Population and Development Review13:639–70.
78.
RobertsonChrisBoylePeter. 1986. “Age, Period and Cohort Models: The Use of Individual Records.” Statistics in Medicine5:527–38.
79.
RodgersWillard L.1982. “Estimable Functions of Age, Period, and Cohort Effects.” American Sociological Review47:774–87.
80.
RyderNorman B.1965. “The Cohort as a Concept in the Study of Social Change.” American Sociological Review30:843–61.
81.
SobelMichael E.1981. “Diagonal Mobility Models: A Substantively Motivated Class of Designs for the Analysis of Mobility Effects.” American Sociological Review46(6):893–906.
82.
SobelMichael E.1985. “Social Mobility and Fertility Revisited: Some New Models for the Analysis of the Mobility Effects Hypothesis.” American Sociological Review50(5):699–712.
83.
SarmaSisiraDevlinRose AnneThindAmardeepChuMan-Kee. 2012. “Canadian Family Physicians’ Decision to Collaborate: Age, Period and Cohort Effects.” Social Science & Medicine (1982)75:1811–19.
84.
SchaieK. Warner. 1965. “A General Model for the Study of Developmental Problems.” Psychological Bulletin64:92–107.
85.
SchefféHenry. 1999. The Analysis of Variance. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons.
86.
SmithTom W.1990. “Liberal and Conservative Trends in the United States Since World War II.” The Public Opinion Quarterly54:479–507.
87.
TukeyJohn W.1949. “One Degree of Freedom for Non-Additivity.” Biometrics5(3):232–42.
88.
TreasJudith. 1987. “The Effect of Women’s Labor Force Participation on the Distribution of Income in the United States.” Annual Review of Sociology13:259–88.
89.
WilsonJames A.GoveWalter R.. 1999. “The Age-period-cohort Conundrum and Verbal Ability: Empirical Relationships and Their Interpretation: Reply to Glenn and to Alwin and McCammon.” American Sociological Review64:287–302.
90.
WinshipChristopherHardingDavid J.. 2008. “A Mechanism-based Approach to the Identification of Age–Period–Cohort Models.” Sociological Methods & Research36:362–401.
91.
YangYangLandKenneth C.. 2016. Age-Period-Cohort Analysis: New Models, Methods, and Empirical Applications. Chapman and Hall/CRC.
92.
YangYangWohlSam SchulhoferFuWenjiang J.LandKenneth C.2008. “The Intrinsic Estimator for Age-Period-Cohort Analysis: What It Is and How to Use It.” American Journal of Sociology113(6):1697–1736.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
