Strategies for Modeling a Categorical Variable Allowing Multiple Category Choices

Abstract

This article discusses strategies for modeling a categorical variable when subjects can select any subset of the categories. With c outcome categories, the models relate to a c-dimensional binary response, with each component indicating whether a particular category is chosen. The strategies are the following: (1) Using logit models directly for the marginal distribution of each component; this accounts for dependence among the component responses but does not treat the dependence as an integral part of the model. (2) Using logit models containing subject random effects to generate the dependence among the components; this approach is limited by implying nonnegative associations having a certain exchangeability. (3) Using loglinear modeling; quasi-symmetric ones are useful but are limited to estimation of within-subject effects. Marginal logit models less fully describe the dependence patterns for the data but require fewer assumptions and focus more directly on the effects of greatest substantive interest.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agresti, Alan . 1995. “Logit Models and Related Quasi-Symmetric Loglinear Models for Comparing Responses to Similar Items in a Survey.” Sociological Methods and Research 24:68-95.

Agresti, Alan and I-Ming Liu . 1999. “Marginal Modeling of a Categorical Variable Allowing Arbitrarily Many Category Choices.” Biometrics 55:936-943.

Aitchison, John and S. D. Silvey . 1958. “Maximum-Likelihood Estimation of Parameters Subject to Restraints.” Annals of Mathematical Statistics 29:813-828.

Anderson, Dorothy and Murray Aitkin . 1985. “Variance Components Models With Binary Response: Interviewer Variability.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B 47:203-210.

Coull, Brent A. and Alan Agresti . 2000. “Random Effects Modeling of Multiple Binary Responses Using the Multivariate Binomial Logit-Normal Distribution.” Biometrics 56:73-80.

Haber, Michael . 1985. “Maximum Likelihood Methods for Linear and Log-Linear Models in Categorical Data.” Computational Statistics and Data Analysis 3:1-10.

Lang, Joseph and Alan Agresti . 1994. “Simultaneously Modeling Joint and Marginal Distributions of Multivariate Categorical Responses.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 89:625-632.

Liang, Kung-Yee and Scott L. Zeger . 1986. “Longitudinal Data Analysis Using Generalized Linear Models.” Biometrika 73:13-22.

Lindsay, Bruce , Clifford Clogg , and John Grego . 1991. “Semiparametric Estimation in the Rasch Model and Related Exponential Response Models, Including a Simple Latent Class Model for Item Analysis.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 86:96-107.

10.

Loughin, Thomas M. and Peter N. Scherer . 1998. “Testing for Association in Contingency Tables With Multiple Column Responses.” Biometrics 54:630-637.

11.

Miller, Michael E. , Charles S. Davis , and J. Richard Landis . 1993. “The Analysis of Longitudinal Polytomous Data: Generalized Estimating Equations and Connections With Weighted Least Squares.” Biometrics 49:1033-1044.

12.

Rasch, Georg . 1961. “On General Laws and the Meaning of Measurement in Psychology.” Proceedings of the 4th Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability 4:321-333.

13.

Richert, B. T., M. D. Tokach, R. D. Goodband, and J. L. Nelssen. 1993. “Integrated Swine Systems: `The Animal Component'—Phase 1; The Kansas State University Survey.” KSU Swine Day 1993, 172-76.

14.

Tjur, Tue . 1982. “A Connection Between Rasch's Item Analysis Model and a Multiplicative Poisson Model.” Scandinavian Journal of Statistics 9:23-30.

15.

Zeger, Scott L. , Kung-Yee Liang , and Paul S. Albert . 1988. “Models for Longitudinal Data: A Generalized Estimating Equation Approach.” Biometrics 44:1049-1060.