The Gandhi–Ambedkar debate on caste is an integral part of discourses on social justice and the historiography of India. Recent events such as Arundhati Roy’s The Doctor and the Saint and the subsequent responses have revived interest in the debate and elicited a need to re-examine it. This article has three main aims. First, it seeks to systematically review, compile, and synthesise the literature and viewpoints on the debate. In doing so, the article comments and expands on the existing Gandhi–Ambedkar debate, including the prospect of reconciliation between them. Second, the authors contend that the young Ambedkar shared similarities with Gandhi in thought and action before the 1930s and that their understudied first meeting in 1931 could have played a crucial role in changing Ambedkar’s attitude towards Gandhi. Lastly, it reviews a neglected dimension of the debate, that of reconciliation, and reiterates the need to pursue it.
AhmedA. K. (2023). Pathways to a better India: Dr. BR Ambedkar’s and Mahatma Gandhi’s Philosophical Ideals. Lokāyata, 14(2), 111–119.
2.
AloysiusG. (1998). Nationalism without a nation in India. Oxford.
3.
AmbedkarB. R. (1936). Annihilation of caste: Speech prepared for the annual conference of the Jat-Pat-Todak Mandal of Lahore, but not delivered. BR Kadrekar.
4.
AmbedkarB. R. (1979). Castes in India. In Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar: Writings and speeches (Vol. 1, pp. 1)–22). Dr. Ambedkar Foundation.
5.
AmbedkarB. R. (1991). What Congress and Gandhi have done to the untouchables. In MoonV. (Ed.), Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar: Writings and speeches (Vol. 9, pp. 1)–297). Education Department, Government of Maharashtra.
6.
AmbedkarB. R. (2002). Outside the fold. In RodriguesV. (Ed.), The essential writings of BR Ambedkar (p. 318). Oxford.
7.
AmbedkarB. R. (2014). Waiting for a visa. In MoonV. (Ed.), Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar writings and speeches (Vol. 12, pp. 663)–693). Dr. Ambedkar Foundation.
8.
AmbedkarB. R., AnandS., & RoyA. (Eds.). (2014). Annihilation of caste: The annotated critical edition. Verso.
9.
AmbedkarB. R., & MoonV. (1979). Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar: Writings and speeches (Vol 1). Dr. Ambedkar Foundation.
10.
AmbedkarS., & KhanN. (2022). Babasaheb: My life with Dr Ambedkar. Penguin.
11.
BaruaA. (2019). Revisiting the Gandhi–Ambedkar debates over ‘caste’: The multiple resonances of varņa. Journal of Human Values, 25(1), 25–40.
12.
BiswasS. (2018). Gandhi, Ambedkar and British policy on the communal award. Studies in People’s History, 5(1), 48–64.
13.
BiswasS. (2021). Gandhi and Ambedkar against untouchability: A reappraisal. South Asia Research, 41(2), 259–278.
14.
Cháirez-GarzaJ. F. (2018). ‘Bound hand and foot and handed over to the caste Hindus’: Ambedkar, untouchability and the politics of Partition. The Indian Economic & Social History Review, 55(1), 1–28.
15.
GaikwadS. (1998). Ambedkar and Indian nationalism. Economic & Political Weekly (hereafter EPW), 33(10), 515–518.
16.
GandhiM. (1964a). Draft constitution of the ashram. In the collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (hereafter CWMG)XIII (pp. 91–98). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India.
17.
GandhiM. (1964b). Speech on ‘Ashram vows’ at Y. M. C. A., Madras. In CWMG XIII (pp. 225–235).
18.
GandhiM. (1964c). Caste must go and the sin of untouchability. Navajivan Publishing House.
19.
GandhiM. (1966). The crime of Chauri Chaura. In CWMG XXII (pp. 415–421). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
20.
GandhiM. (1972). Letter to Hanumanprasad Poddar. In CWMG LVIII (pp. 353–355). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
21.
GandhiM. (1976a). Dr. Ambedkar’s indictment-I. In CWMG LXIII (pp. 134–136). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
22.
GandhiM. (1976b). Dr. Ambedkar’s indictment-II. In CWMG LXIII (pp. 153–155). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
23.
GandhiM. (1978). To the readers. In CWMG LXXIII (pp. 44–46). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
24.
GandhiM. (1979a). Letter to B. R. Ambedkar. In CWMG LXXVIII (p. 13). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
25.
GandhiM. (1979b). Village swaraj. In CWMG LXXVI (pp. 308–309). Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, GOI.
26.
GandhiM. K. (2021). Village industries: Prabhat Prakashan.
27.
GandhiM. K., & BrownJ. M. (2008). The essential writings. Oxford.
28.
GandhiR. (2008). Gandhi: The man, his people, and the empire. University of California Press.
29.
GandhiR. (2015a). Independence and social justice: The Ambedkar–Gandhi debate. EPW, 50(15), 35–44.
30.
GandhiR. (2015b). Response to Arundhati Roy. EPW, 50(30), 83–85.
31.
GoreM. S. (1993). The social context of an ideology: Ambedkar’s political and social thought. Sage Publications Pvt Limited.
32.
GuhaR. (2010). Gandhi’s Ambedkar. In SinghA. & MohapatraS. (Eds), Indian political thought: A reader. Routledge.
33.
GuruG. (2017). Ethics in Ambedkar’s critique of Gandhi. EPW, 52(15), 95–100.
34.
IyerR. N. (1973). The moral and political thought of Mahatma Gandhi. OUP.
35.
JaffrelotC. (2005). Dr. Ambedkar and untouchability: Fighting the Indian caste system. Columbia University Press.
36.
JodhkaS. S. (2002). Nation and village: Images of rural India in Gandhi, Nehru and Ambedkar. EPW, 37(32), 3343–3353.
37.
KhundrakpamP., & SarmahJ. K. (2021). Revisiting a theory of justice through Gandhi. Gandhi Marg Quarterly, 43(3), 281–300.
38.
KolgeN. (2014). The politician: A response to Arundhati Roy’s The doctor and the saint. Gandhi Marg Quarterly, 36(1), 145–164.
39.
KolgeN. (2016). Was Gandhi a racist? His writings in South Africa. EPW, 51(5), 88–93.
40.
KolgeN. (2017). Was Gandhi a ‘champion of the caste system’?EPW, 52(13), 42–50.
41.
KolgeN. (2018a). Was there a strategy in Gandhi’s approach to fight against the caste system? InGandhi against caste. Oxford University Press.
42.
KolgeN. (2018b). Gandhi’s evolving strategy to abolish the caste system: Part, II. In Gandhi against caste. Oxford University Press.
43.
KomaleshaH. S. (2015). Reconciling Gandhi with Ambedkar. EPW, 50(34), 75–76.
44.
LelyveldJ. (2011). Great soul. Vintage.
45.
OmvedtG. (1994). Dalits and the democratic revolution: Dr Ambedkar and the dalit movement in colonial India. Sage Publications.
46.
PalshikarS. (1996). Gandhi–Ambedkar interface: … When shall the twain meet?EPW, 31(31), 2070–2072.
47.
PanthamT. (2009). Against untouchability: The discourses of Gandhi and Ambedkar. In GuruG. (Ed.), Humiliation: Claims and context (pp. 179–208). Oxford University Press.
48.
PuriB. (2022). The Ambedkar–Gandhi debate. Springer.
49.
RaoA. (1997). Arguing against inclusion. EPW, 32(8), 427–428.
50.
RoyA. (2014). The doctor and the saint. In AnandS. (Ed.), Annihilation of caste: The annotated critical edition (pp. 12–85).
51.
RoyA. (2015). All the world’s a half-built dam. EPW, 50(25), 165–173.
52.
RoyR. (2005). Gandhi, Ambedkar and the untouchables. Gandhi Marg Quarterly, 26(4), 389–412.
53.
SarkarS. (1997). Writing social history. Oxford.
54.
SinghA. (2014). Gandhi and Ambedkar: Irreconcilable differences?International Journal of Hindu Studies, 18(3), 413–449.
55.
TillyC. (1985). Retrieving European lives. In ZunzO. (Ed.), Reliving the past: The worlds of social history (pp. 11–52). UONC Press.
