The developments in citizenship in India that took place in 2019–2020 witnessed intervention from women belonging to minority communities who have emerged as forebears of resistance to the authoritarian-masculine imposition of citizenship as religious exclusion in the form of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA), 2019. The article revisits the women protests against the Act through the lens of ‘acts of citizenship’. The Shaheen Bagh protests, as these are called popularly, have been studied mainly as Muslim women exhibiting their defiance against a draconian law adversely affecting them. I argue that these protests can be interpreted as acts of citizenship where women spearheaded demonstrations against the Indian state to withhold their rights of citizenship as ‘activist citizens’, asserting the constitutional value of respecting diversity and democratic citizenship, thereby demonstrating ‘constitutional patriotism’. The article contributes to the ongoing debate on gendered citizenship in India providing an alternative approach, moving away from the popular binaries of ‘cultural diversity’ and ‘cultural nationalism’.
Apoorvanand. (2021, January15). India’s ‘love jihad’ laws: Another attempt to subjugate Muslims. Aljazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2021/1/15/indias-love-jihad-laws-another-attempt-to-subjugate-muslims
2.
ArendtH. (1998). The human condition (2nd ed.). University of Chicago Press.
3.
BalibarE. (2002). Politics and the other (JonesC., SwensonJ. & TurnerC., Trans.). Verso Books.
4.
BergsonH. (1977). The two sources of morality and religion (AudraR. A. & BreretonC., Trans.). University of Notre Dame Press.
5.
BermeoN. (2016). On democratic backsliding. Journal of Democracy, 27(1), 15–19.
6.
BhawsarK. (2020, December11). Lessons from anti-CAA protests. The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/lessons-from-anti-caa-protests-7101411/
7.
BonnerK. (2008). Arendt’s citizenship and citizen participation in disappearing Dublin. In IsinEngin F. & NielsonGreg M. (Eds.), Acts of citizenship. Zed Books.
8.
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC). (2019, December11). Citizenship Amendment Bill: India’s new ‘anti-Muslim’ law explained. BBC News. Retrieved June1, 2020, from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-50670393
9.
ButaliaU. (1993). Community, state and gender––on women’s agency during Partition. Economic & Political Weekly, 28(17), 12–24.
10.
ButlerJ. (1997). Excitable speech: A politics of the performative. Routledge.
11.
ButlerJ., & AthanasiouA. (2013). Dispossession: The performative in the political. Polity Press.
12.
ButlerJ., GambettiZ., & SabsayL. (2016). Vulnerability in resistance. Duke University Press.
13.
ChakravartiU. (1992). Whatever happened to the Vedic dasi? Orientalism, nationalism and the script for the past. In SangariK. & VaidS. (Eds.), Recasting women: Essays in colonial history. Kali for Women.
14.
ChistiS. (2021, July1). The relevance of a documentary on Gandhi’s non-violence today. The Wire. https://thewire.in/film/mahatma-gandhi-documentary-ramesh-sharma-ahimsa
15.
DasV. (1997). Critical events: An anthropological perspective of contemporary India. Oxford University Press.
16.
DattaA. B. (2021). Nation and its ‘other’ women: Muslim subjectivity and gendered agency in Delhi. Contemporary South Asia, 44(2), 380–397.
17.
DattaP. K. (2020, November4). Ordinary Indians are standing up for inter-faith love as it lives in our cultural memory: We have always been both. The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/tanishq-ad-controversy-inter-faith-love-inter-caste-mariage-6930295/
18.
FanonF. (1963). Wretched of the earth. Grove Press.
19.
FoucaultM. (2007). What is critique? In FoucaultM. & LotringerS. (Eds.), The politics of truth. Semiotext(e).
20.
GuptaC. (2009). Hindu women, Muslim men: Love jihad and conversions. Economic & Political Weekly, 44(51), 13–15.
21.
HabermasJ. (1992). Citizenship and national identity: Some reflections on the future of Europe,Praxis International, 12(1), 1–19.
22.
HildebrandtP. (2019). An elephant in the room/on the balcony: Performing the ‘welcome city’ Hamburg. In HildebrandtP., EvartK., PetersS., SchaubM., WilderK. & ZiemarG. (Eds.), Performing citizenship: Bodies, agencies, limitations. Palgrave Macmillan.
23.
HuntingtonS. (1991). Democracy’s third wave. Journal of Democracy, 2(2), 12–34.
24.
IsinE. (2019). Doing rights with things: The art of becoming citizens. In HildebrandtP., EvartK., PetersS., SchaubM., WilderK. & ZiemarG. (Eds.), Performing citizenship: Bodies, agencies, limitations. Palgrave Macmillan.
IsinE. F., & NielsonG. M. (2008). Acts of citizenship. Zed Books.
27.
IsinE. F. (2008). Theorizing acts of citizenship. In IsinE. F. & NielsonGreg M. (Eds.), Acts of citizenship. Zed Books.
28.
JayalN. G. (2013). Citizenship and its discontent. Harvard University Press.
29.
KesavanR. (2020, January31). When bullets are aimed at the Constitution, who’s the patriot and who’s the traitor?The Wire. https://thewire.in/politics/anti-caa-protests-constitutional-patriotism
30.
KidwaiA. (1974). In freedom’s shade. Penguin Books.
31.
KymlickaW. (1995). Multicultural citizenship: A liberal theory of minority rights. Oxford University Press.
32.
MackertJ., & TurnerB. S. (2017). Transformation of citizenship: Struggle, resistance and violence (Vol. 3). Routledge.
33.
MalikA., ShivajiM., & VergheseA. (2019, December31). In India, thousands are protesting the new citizenship law. Here are 4 things to know. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/12/31/india-thousands-are-protesting-new-citizenship-law-here-are-things-know/
34.
MansfieldH. C. (2010). Tocqueville: A very short introduction. Oxford University Press.
35.
MathaiM. P. (2012). The defining features of Gandhian non-violence. Innovación Educativa, 12(60), 77–85. http://www.scielo.org.mx/pdf/ie/v12n60/v12n60a6.pdf
36.
MayhallL. E. N. (2003). The militant suffrage movement: Citizenship and resistance in Britain, 1860-1930. Oxford University Press.
37.
McThomasM. (2016). Performing citizenship: Undocumented migrants in the United States. Routledge.
38.
MenonN. (1998). State, gender, community: Citizenship in contemporary India. Economic & Political Weekly. 33(5). https://www.epw.in/journal/1998/5/review-political-economy-review-issues-specials/state-gender-community-citizenship
39.
MenonN. (2012). Seeing like a feminist. Penguin Books.
40.
MenonR., & BhasinK. (1993). Recovery, rupture and resistance: Indian state and abduction of women during Partition. Economic & Political Weekly, 28(17), WS2–WS11.
41.
MullerJ. W. (2009). Seven ways to misunderstand constitutional patriotism. Notezie de Politeia, XXV(96), 20–24.
42.
MulveyL. (1975). Visual pleasure and narrative cinema. Screen, 16(3), 6–8.
43.
MustafaS. (2020). Shaheen Bagh and the idea of India. Speaking Tiger Publications.
44.
PadmanabhanC. (2020, January26). Flag this extraordinary moment—A symbol of power has become a totem of resistance. The Wire. https://thewire.in/rights/flag-this-extraordinary-moment-a-symbol-of-power-has-become-a-totem-of-resistance
45.
PandeyN. (2021, March23). BJP leaves CAA out of its Assam manifesto, 2 days after promising it in Bengal. The Print. https://theprint.in/politics/bjp-leaves-caa-out-of-its-assam-manifesto-2-days-after-promising-it-in-bengal/626848/
46.
ParthasarathyD. (2020, June26). Citizenship (Amendment) Act: The pitfalls of homogenising identities in resistance narratives. Economic & Political Weekly Engage, 55(25). https://www.epw.in/engage/article/citizenship-amendment-act-pitfalls-homogenising-identities-resistance-narratives
47.
Press Trust of India. (2021, March23). BJP’s stand on CAA varies from state to state, claims Assam Congress. The Deccan Herald. https://www.deccanherald.com/national/national-politics/bjps-stand-on-caa-varies-from-state-to-state-claims-assam-congress-965569.html
48.
ProkhovnikR. (1998). Public and private citizenship: From gender invisibility to feminist inclusiveness. Feminist Review, 60(84), 104.
49.
RajanR. S. (2003). The scandal of the state: Women, law and citizenship in postcolonial India. Duke University Press.
50.
RathoreA., & NandyA. (2020, February4). Hate is hot in India. Colder ideas like constitutional patriotism must work harder to win. The Print. https://theprint.in/pageturner/excerpt/hate-is-hot-in-india-colder-ideas-like-constitutional-patriotism-must-work-harder/359421/
51.
ReganH., GuptaS., & KhanO. (2019, December17). India passes the controversial citizenship bill that excludes Muslims. CNN. https://edition.cnn.com/2019/12/11/asia/india-citizenship-amendment-bill-intl-hnk/index.html
52.
ReinachA. (1983). The a priori foundations of civil law. Aletheia, 3, 1–142.
53.
RoyA. (2010). Mapping citizenship in India. Oxford University Press.
54.
SenguptaP. (2018). Language as identity in colonial India: Policies and politics. Palgrave Macmillan.
55.
SetalvadT. (2020, November13). The love jihad spectre: It has now crept into judicial discourse, to the detriment of a woman’s freedom and autonomy. The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/love-jihad-women-freedom-the-love-jihad-spectre-7049722/
56.
ShamsadM. R. (2020, November16). It is not for the law to decide on any other matter concerning marriage of two adults. The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/love-jihad-india-court-consent-7052733/
57.
ShaniO. (2017). How India became democratic: Citizenship and the making of universal franchise. Cambridge University Press.
58.
ShuklaA. (2020, January27). The BJP has done immense damage to India, but also led to some unexpected miracles. The Wire. https://thewire.in/rights/bjp-anti-caa-protests-women
59.
SingerP. (2008). Citizenship without acts? With Tocqueville in America. In IsinE. F. & NielsonG. (Eds.), Acts of citizenship. Zed Books.
60.
StiksI. (2017). Occupying citizenship: Protest, critique, emancipation. In MackertJ. & TurnerB. S. (Eds.), Transformation of citizenship: Struggle, resistance and violence (Vol. 3). Routledge.
TullyJ. (2014). On global citizenship: James Tully in dialogue. London: Bloomsbury.
63.
Van GunsterenH. R. (1998). A theory of citizenship: Organising plurality in contemporary democracies. Routledge.
64.
ViswanathS. (2020, June10). An activist’s dilemma: What is ahimsa in the age of state-sponsored murder?Scroll. inhttps://scroll.in/article/964257/an-activists-dilemma-what-is-ahimsa-in-the-age-of-state-sponsored-murder
65.
VogelU. (1996). Marriage and the boundaries of citizenship. In van SteenbergenB. (Ed.), The conditions of citizenship. SAGE Publications.
66.
WalzerM. (1960, Fall). The idea of resistance. Dissent. https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/the-idea-of-resistance-michael-walzer-1960
67.
WaseemM. (2002). Causes of democratic downslide. Economic & Political Weekly, 37(44–45), 4532–4538.
68.
WhiteM. (2008). Can an act of citizenship be creative? In IsinE. F. & NielsonG. M. (Eds.), Acts of citizenship. Zed Books.
69.
Yuval-DavisN. (2008). Gender and nation. SAGE Publications.
ZiviK. (2005). Making rights claim: An introduction. Department of Political Science, University of Southern California. https://clp.usc.edu/centers/clhc/archives/workshops/documents/Zivi.pdf
