It is a testimony to the enduring importance of Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions that, 30 years on, its doctrines of normal science and paradigm, incommensurability and revolution continue to challenge metascien tists and stimulate vigorous debate. Critique has mainly come from philosophers and historians; by and large, interested sociologists have embraced Kuhn. Un justifiably so, this article argues, bringing to light a serious difficulty or "anom aly" in his account of the social side of science. Contrary to what he claims, scientific knowledge is not the achievement of organic communities. It is con structed in "trans-epistemic arenas" by diverse participants, laypeople, and specialists. Accepting "community" is a flawed concept in the sociology of science, and in appreciating the major role Kuhn assigned it, the Kuhnian system looks less robust than it did before.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
A word up your nose1993. The Economist , 7 August, 16.
2.
Bames, B., and D. Edge, eds. 1982. Science in context.Milton Keynes, MA: Open University Press .
3.
Ben-David, J.1991. Scientific growthBerkeley: University of California Press.
4.
Bitz, A., A. McAlpine, and R Whitley, eds. 1975. Production, flow and use of information in research laboratories in different sciences.London: British Library Report Series.
5.
Chubin, D.1976. The conceptualization of scientific specialtiesSociological Quarterly17:448-76.
6.
Collins, H.1974. The TEA set: Tacit knowledge and scientific networksScience Studies4:165-86. Reprinted as "Tacit knowledge and scientific networks," in B. Barnes and D. Edge, Science in context (Milton Keynes, MA: Open University Press,1982), 44-64.
7.
Crane, D.1969. Social structure in a group of scientists: A test of the "invisible college" hypothesisAmerican Sociological Review34:335-52.
8.
Edge, D.1979. Quantitative measures of communication in scienceHistory of Science17:102-34.
9.
Fleck, L. [1935] 1979. Genesis and development of a scientific fact Reprint, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
10.
Garfield, E.1964a. The use of citation data in writing the history of sciencePhiladelphia: Institute of Scientific Information.
11.
-. 1964b. Science citation indexPhiladelphia : Institute for Scientific Information.
12.
-. 1979. Citation indexing-Its theory and application in science, technology, and humanitiesNew York: John Wiley
13.
Garvey, W., and B. Griffith.1971. Scientific communicationAmerican Psychologist26:349-62.
14.
Gutting, G., ed. 1980. Paradigms and revolutions.Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
15.
-. 1980. Introduction. In Paradigms and revolutions , edited by G. Gutting, 1-22. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
16.
Hagstrom, W.1965. The scientific communityCarbondale : Southern Illinois University Press.
17.
Hoyningen-Huene, P.1993. Reconstructing scientific revolutions , translated by A. Levine. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
18.
Kessler, M.1965. Comparison of the results of bibliographic coupling and "analytic subject indexing."American Documentation16:223-33.
19.
Knorr-Cetina, K.1981. The manufacture of knowledgeOxford, UK: Pergamon.
20.
-. 1982. Scientific communities or transepistemic arenas of research?Social Studies of Science12:101-30.
21.
-. 1983. New developments in science studies: The ethnographic challengeCanadian Journal of Sociology8:153-77.
22.
Kuhn, T. [1957] 1959. The Copernican revolution Reprint, New York: Vintage.
23.
-. 1962. The structure of scientific revolutionsChicago: University of Chicago Press.
24.
-. 1963. The function of dogma in scientific research In Scientific change, edited by A. Crombie. London : Heinemann.
25.
-. 1970a. The structure of scientific revolutions2ded. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
26.
-. 1970b. Logic of discovery or psychology of research? In Criticism and the growth of knowledge, edited by I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
27.
-. 1977. The essential tensionChicago: University of Chicago Press.
28.
MacIntyre, A.1980. Epistemological crises, dramatic narrative, and the philosophy of science In Paradigms and revolutions , edited by G. Gutting. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press.
29.
Masterman, M.1970. The nature of a paradigm In Criticism and the growth of knowledge, edited by I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
30.
McAlpine, A., et al.1975. The investigation of patterns of social and mtellectual organisation in the sciences In The production, flow and use of information, edited by A. Bitz, A. McAlpine, and R. Whitley London: British Library Report Series.
31.
Menzel, H.1966. Scientific communication: Five themes from social science researchAmerican Psychologist21:999-1004.
32.
Merton, R.1973. The sociology of scienceChicago : University of Chicago Press.
33.
Mulkay, M., G. Gilbert, and S. Woolgar.1975. Problem areas and research networks in scienceSociology9:187-203.
34.
Musgrave, A. [1971] 1980. Kuhn's second thoughts In Paradigms and revolutions, edited by G. Gutting, 39-53. Reprint, Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press.
35.
Polanyi, M. [1942] 1951. Self-government of science In The logic of liberty, edited by M. Polyani, 49-67. Reprint, Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
36.
-. 1962. The republic of scienceMinerva1:54-73.
37.
Price, D.1963. Little science, big scienceNew York : Columbia University Press.
38.
-. 1965. Networks of scientific papersScience149:510-15.
39.
Price, D., and D. Beaver.1966. Collaboration in an invisible collegeAmerican Psychologist21:1011-18.
40.
Shapere, [1964] D.1980. The structure of scientific revolutions In Paradigms and revolutions, edited by G. Gutting, 27-38. Reprint, Notre Dame: Notre Dame University.
41.
Swanson, D.1966. Scientific journals and information services of the futureAmerican Psychologist21:1005-1010.
42.
Whitley, R.1975. Summary report of the study In Production, flow and use of information in research laboratories in different sciences , edited by A. Bitz, A. McAlpine, and R. Whitley. London: British Library Report Series.
43.
-. 1978. Types of science, organizational strategies and patterns of work in research laboratories in different scientific fieldsSocial Science Information17:427-47.
44.
Whitley, R.1983. From the sociology of scientific communities to the study of scientists' negotiations and beyondSocial Science Information22:681-720.
