Popper Revisited,or What Is Wrong With Conspiracy Theories?

Abstract

Conpiracy theories are widely deemed to be superstitious. Yet history appears to be littered with conspiracies successful and otherwise. (For this reason, "cock-up" theories cannot in general replace conspiracy theories, since in many cases the cock-ups are simply failed conspiracies.) Why then is it silly to suppose that historical events are sometimes due to conspiracy? The only argument available to this author is drawn from the work of the late Sir Karl Popper, who criticizes what he calls "the conspiracy theory of society" in The Open Society and elsewhere. His critique of the conspiracy theory is indeed sound, but it is a theory no sane person maintains. Moreover, its falsehood is compatible with the prevalence of conspiracies. Nor do his arguments create any presumption against conspiracy theories of this or that. Thus the belief that it is superstitious to posit conspiracies is itself a superstition. The article concludes with some speculations as to why this superstition is so widely believed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Collingwood, R.G. 1946. The idea of history. Oxford : Oxford University Press.

Conquest, Robert. 1986. The harvest of sorrow. London : Hutchinson. [paperback edition ( 1988), London: Arrow Books]

—. 1992. The party in the dock. Times Literary Supplement, 11 June 1992.

Dray, W. 1980. Perspectives on history. London and Henley: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Feyerabend, R.K. 1975. Popper's objective knowledge. Inquiry 17. [reprinted in Feyerabend 1981, pp. 168-201]

—. 1981. Philosophical papers, vol. 2: Problems of empiricism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Fried, Richard M. 1990. Nightmare in red: The McCarthy era in perspective . New York: Oxford University Press.

Gibbon, Edward. n.d. Decline and fall of the Roman Empire, vol. 2. New York: Modern Library (Random House).

Goldman, Alvin. 1992. In defence of simulation theory. Mind and Language 7, nos. 1&2:102-119.

10.

Hervey, Lord John. 1952. Lord Hervey's memoirs, edited by Romney Sedgwick . London: William Kimber.

11.

Hill, B.W. 1989. Sir Robert Walpole. London: Hamish Hamilton.

12.

Hitchens, Christopher. 1988. Prepared for the worst. London : Hogarth.

13.

Lakatos, Imre. 1971. The history of science and its rational reconstructions . [reprinted in Lakatos 1978, pp. 102-138]

14.

—. 1974. Popper on demarcation and induction. In The Philosophy of Karl Popper, edited by P A. Schilpp. La Salle, IL: Open Court. [reprinted in Lakatos 1978]

15.

—. 1978. The methodology of scientific research programmes: Philosophical papers, vol. 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

16.

Lewis, C.S. 1965. Screwtape proposes a toast. London : Fontana.

17.

Macauley, Lord Thomas. 1898. History of England, 5 vols. London: Longmann's Green .

18.

Orwell, George. 1970. The collected essays, journalism and letters of George Orwell, vol. 3. Harmondsworth , England: Penguin.

19.

Pipes, Richard. 1992. Seventy-five years on: The Great October Revolution as a clandestine coup d'etat. Times Literary Supplement 11 June 1992.

20.

Popper, Sir Karl R 1948. Prediction and prophecy. 10th International Congress of Philosophy. [reprinted in Popper 1972a; all references are to this reprint]

21.

—. 1949. Towards a rational theory of tradition. The Rationalist Annual. [reprinted in Popper 1972a; all references are to this reprint]

22.

—. 1957. The poverty of historicism. London and Henley: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

23.

—. 1966. The open society and its enemies, vol. 2: The high tide of prophecy: Hegel, Marx and the aftermath , 5th edition. London and Henley: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

24.

—. 1972a. Conjectures and refutations, 4th edition. London and Henley: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

25.

—. 1972b. Objective knowledge: An evolutionary approach . Oxford: Oxford University Press .

26.

Procopius of Caesarea. 1961. Secret history, translated by R. T. Atwater. Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press.

27.

Schilpp, P A. , ed. 1974. The philosophy of Karl Popper. La Salle, IL: Open Court.

28.

Thompson, E.P. 1982. Zero option. London: Merlin.

29.

—. 1985. The heavy dancers. New York : Pantheon.

30.

Turnbull, M. 1988. The spycatcher trial. London : Heinemann. [references made to the paperback edition, 1989]

31.

van der Zee, H. , and B. van der Zee. 1988. Revolution in the family. Harmondsworth, England: Penguin.

32.

White, Theodore H. 1975. Breach of faith : The fall of Richard Nixon. New York: Reader's Digest.