This article presents a new interpretation of Marx's dialectical method. Marx conceived dialectics as a method for constructing a model of society. The way this model is developed is analogous to the way organisms develop according to the German embryologist Karl Ernst von Baer, and, indeed, Marx's theory of capitalism hinges on the same concept of Organisation that is found in teleomechanical biology. The strong analogy between pre-Darwinian biology and Marx's structure of argument shows that the analogy often supposed to exist between Darwin and Marx is not relevant to Marx's theory of capitalism.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Avineri, S.1967. From hoax to dogma. Encounter8:30-32.
2.
Baer, K. E. von.1822. Vorlesung über die Zeugung. Manuscript.
3.
—. 1826. Ueber Entwickelungsgeschichte der Thiere. Königsberg: Bomträger.
4.
—. [1834] 1874. Das allgemeinste Gesetz der Natur in aller Entwickelung. In K. E. von Baer, Reden, vol. 2,15-74. Braunschweig : Vieweg.
5.
—. 1874. Ueber Darwin's Lehre. In K. E. von Baer, Reden, vol. 2, 235-480. Braunschweig: Vieweg.
6.
Ball, T.1979. Darwin and Marx: A reconsideration. Political Theory7:469-83.
7.
Barth, E.M.1970. Enten-eller, de logica van Licht en Donker. Algemeen Nederlands Tijdschrift voor Wijsbegeerte62:217-40. Translated and extended by the author as "Either-or: The logic of light and darkness," manuscript.
8.
—. 1974. The logic of articles in traditional philosophy . Translation from the Dutch by E. M. Barth and T.C. Polts. Dordrecht : Reidel.
9.
—. 1977. The logical paradigm in dialectical philosophy and science . Erkenntnis11:291-322.
10.
Coleman, W.1964. Georges Cuvier: Zoologist. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
11.
Colp, R.1974. The contacts between Karl Marx and Charles Darwin . Journal of the History of Ideas35:329-38.
12.
Cuvier, G.1821. Discours sur les révolutions de la surface de globe . Paris: Dufour.
13.
Darwin, C. [1859] 1964. On the origin of species by means of natural selection. Reprint. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
14.
Feuer, L.S.1978. Marx and Engels as sociobiologists. Survey24 (4): 109-36.
15.
Gerratana, V.1973. Marx and Darwin. New Left Review82:60-82.
16.
Groh, D.1967. Marx, Engels und Darwin. Politische Vierteljahreschrift8:544-59.
17.
Kant, I. [1790] 1977. Kritik der Urteilskraft, edited by W. Weischedel.Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.
18.
Kitcher, P.1985. Darwin's achievement. In Reason and rationality in natural science, edited by N. Rescher,107-47. Lanham, MA: University Press of America.
19.
Lenoir, T.1982. The strategy of life: Teleology and mechanics in nineteenth century German biology. Dordrecht: Reidel.
20.
Lewontin, R.C.1985. Darwin, Mendel and the mind. The New York Review, 10 October.
21.
Loewenstein, J.I. [1970] 1980. Marx against Marxism. Translated from the German by Harry Drost. London: Routledge.
22.
Lucas, E.1964. Marx und Engels' Auseinandersetzung mit Darwin . International Review of Social History9:433-69.
23.
Mayr, E.1985. Darwin's five theories of evolution. In The Darwinian heritage, edited by D. Kohn , 755-72. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
24.
Abridged version published as "What Is Darwinism?" in Toward a new philosophy of biology, 196-214. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1988.
25.
Marx, K. [1867] 1981. Das Kapital: Kritik der politischen Oekonomie, vol. 1. [Capital: A Critique of Political Economy]. Translated by Ben Fowkes. Harmondsworth : Penguin.
26.
—. [1939] 1964. Grundrisse der Kritik der politischen Oekonomie. 2d. Berlin: Dietz. English translations by Nicolaus ( Harmondsworth : Penguin, 1975) and McLellan, Marx's Grundrisse (London : Macmillan, 1980).
27.
Marx, K., and F. Engels. [1956] 1983. Werke. Berlin: Dietz.
28.
Mehring, F.1918. Karl Marx: Geschichte seins Lebens. Leipzig: Barth.
29.
Meikle, S.1985. Essentialism in the thought of Karl Marx. London: Duckworth.
30.
Miller, R.W.1983. Marx in analytic philosophy. Social Science Quarterly64:846-61.
31.
Naccache, B.1980. Marx critique de Darwin. Paris : Vrin.
32.
Raikov, B.E.1968. Karl Ernst Von Baer. Leipzig : Barth.
33.
Russell, E.S. [1916] 1982. Form and function. Reprint. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
34.
Schmidt, A. [1962] 1973. The concept of nature in Marx . Translated from the German by Ben Fowkes. London: New Left Books.
35.
Taylor, A.1989. The significance of Darwinian theory for Marx and Engels . Philosophy of the Social Sciences19:409-23.
