Two classes of argument, logical and moral, are usually offered for the general assumption that racism is inherently irrational. The logical arguments involve accusations concerning stereotyping (category mistakes and empirical errors resulting from overgeneralization) as well as inconsistencies between attitudes and behavior and inconsistencies in beliefs. Moral arguments claim that racism fails as means to well-defined ends, or that racist acts achieve ends other than moral ones. Based on a rationality-neutral definition of racism, it is argued in this article that none of these arguments establish exhaustively that racism is inherently irrational. Ways are suggested to proceed in condemning racism(s) as morally and socially unacceptable, independent of the irrationality claim.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abelson, R.P.1976. Social psychology's rational man. In Rationality and the social sciences, edited by S. I. Benn and G. Mortimore.London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
2.
Adorno, T.W., E. Frenkel-Breunswik, D. Levinson, and R. Sanford.1950. The authoritarian personality. New York: Harper & Row.
3.
Allport, G.1954. The nature of prejudice. Boston: Beacon.
4.
Appiah, A.1989. Racisms. In Anatomy of racism, edited by D. T. Goldberg.Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press.
5.
Aristotle.1946. Collected works of Aristotle, edited by R. P. McKeon.New York: Random House.
6.
Baier, K.1978. Merit and race. Philosophia8:121-51.
7.
—. 1984. Rationality, reason and the good. In Morality, reason and truth, edited by D. Copp and D. Zimmerman.Totowa, NJ : Rowman & Alanheld.
8.
Banton, M.1983. Categorical and statistical discrimination. Ethnic and Racial Studies6:269-83.
9.
—. 1987. United States racial ideology as collective representation . Ethnic and Racial Studies10:466-68.
10.
Barker, M.1981. The new racism. London: Junction Books.
11.
Becker, G.1957. The economics of discrimination. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
12.
Boggs, J.1970. Racism and the class struggle. New York: Monthly Review Press.
13.
Boston, T.1988. Race, class and conservativism. Boston : Allen & Unwin.
14.
Boxill, B.1984. Blacks and social justice. Totowa, NJ: Rowman & Alanheld.
15.
Brandt, G., and D. Muir.1986. Schooling, morality and race. Journal of Moral Education15:58-67.
16.
Campbell, D.1967. Stereotypes and the perception of group differences. American Psychology22:823-35.
17.
Cavell, S.1976. The claim of reason. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
18.
Cell, J.1982. The highest stage of white supremacy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
19.
Coetzee, J.M.1986. Tales of Afrikaners. Sunday Times Magazine , 9 March.
20.
Cohen, C.1979. Why racial preference is illegal and immoral. Commentary67(June): 40-51.
21.
Cohen, S.1988. A hard act to follow: The Immigration Act of 1988. Warwick: Centre for Research in Ethnic Relations.
22.
Cox, O.C.1948. Caste, class and race. New York: Modem Reader.
23.
Dummett, A.1986. Race, culture and moral education. Journal of Moral Education15:10-15.
24.
Dummett, A., and M. Dummett.1982. The role of government in Britain's racial crisis. In Race in Britain, edited by C. Husband.London: Open University Press.
25.
Fishman, J.1956. Examination of the process and functions of social stereotyping . Journal of Social Psychology43:27-64.
26.
Foot, P.1978. Are moral considerations overriding? In Virtues and vices. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
27.
Foucault, M.1977. Two lectures. In Power/Knowledge, edited by Colin Gordon.New York: Pantheon.
28.
—. 1978. The history of sexuality, volume I. New York: Random House.
29.
Gabriel, J., and G. Ben-Tovim.1977. Marxism and the concept of racism. Economy and Society7:118-42.
30.
Gates, H.L., Jr.1989. Critical remarks. In Anatomy of racism , edited by D. T. Goldberg.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
31.
Gilroy, P.1987. There ain't no black in the Union Jack. London: Hutchinson.
32.
Godelier, M.1972. Rationality and irrationality in economics. New York: Monthly Review Press.
33.
Goldberg, D.T.1986a. Reading the signs: the force of language. Philosophical Forum, Double Issue on Apartheid18:71-93.
34.
—. 1986b. A grim dilemma about racist referring expressions. Metaphilosophy17:224-29.
35.
—. 1987. Raking the field of the discourse of racism. Journal of Black Studies18:58-71.
36.
—. 1989a. The social formation of racist discourse. In Anatomy of racism, edited by D. T. Goldberg.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
37.
—. 1989b. Racist discourse and the language of class. In Race and class as patterns of twentieth century exploitation, edited by A. Zegeye, J. Maxted, and L. Harris.London: Hans Zell (Butterworth).
38.
—. 1990. Polluting the body politic: Racist discourse and urban location. In Racism and the postmodern city, edited by M. Keith and M. Cross.London: Unwin & Hyman.
39.
—, ed. 1989c. Anatomy of racism. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
40.
Gould, S.J.1981. The mismeasure of man. New York: Norton.
41.
Greenberg, S.1987. Legitimating the illegitimate. Berkeley : University of California Press.
42.
Hare, R.M.1980. Prediction and moral appraisal. In Midwest Studies in Philosophy III, edited by P. French , T. Uehling, and H. Wettstein.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
43.
Harris, L., ed. 1983. Philosophy born of struggle. Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt .
44.
Innes, D.1984. Anglo American and the rise of modern South Africa. New York: Monthly Review Press.
45.
Jarvie, I.C., and Agassi, J.1970. The problem of the rationality of magic. In Rationality, edited by Bryan Wilson.Oxford: Blackwell.
46.
Jencks, C.1983. Thomas Sowell vs. special treatment for blacks. New York Review of Books30, 4 March.
47.
Jones, M.1985. Education and racism. Journal of Philosophy of Education19:223-34.
48.
Jones, R.A.1982. Perceiving the other. In In the eye of the beholder, edited by A. G. Miller.New York: Praeger.
49.
Jordan, W.1968. White over black. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
50.
Kamin, L.1974. The science and politics of IQ. Potomac, MD: Erlbaum.
51.
Keith, A.1928. The evolution of the human species. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Society58:305-21.
52.
Kelman, S.1981. Cost-benefit analysis: An ethical critique. Regulation, January-February.
53.
Lewontin, R., L. Kamin, and S. Rose.1984. Not in our genes. New York: Pantheon.
54.
Liska, A., ed. 1975. The consistency controversy. New York: Wiley.
55.
Miles, R.1989. Racism. London: Routledge.
56.
Mill, J.S.1859. On liberty. Various editions.
57.
Miller, A.G.1982. In the eye of the beholder. New York : Praeger.
58.
Miller, R.1984. Analyzing Marx. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
59.
—. 1987. Fact and method. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
60.
Newcomb, T., and W. Charters.1950. Social psychology. New York: Dryden.
61.
Prager, J.1972. White racial privilege and social change: An examination of theories of racism. Berkeley Journal of Sociology17:117-50.
62.
—. 1987a. American political culture and the shifting meaning of race. Ethnic and Racial Studies10:62-81.
63.
—. 1987b. The meaning of difference: A response to Michael Banton . Ethnic and Racial Studies10:469-72.
64.
Putnam, C.1961. Race and reason. Washington, DC: Public Affairs Press.
65.
Rawls, J.1951. Outline of a decision procedure for ethics. Philosophical Review60:171-92.
66.
—. 1971. A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press.
67.
Reich, M.1971. The economics of racism. In Problems in political economy, edited by D. Gordon.2d ed. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
68.
—. 1981. Racial inequality. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
69.
Scanlon, T.M.1984. Contractualism and utilitarianism. In Utilitarianism and beyond, edited by A. Sen and B. Williams.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
70.
Singer, M.1978. Some thoughts on race and racism. Philosophia8:163-85.
71.
Singer, P.1978. Is racial discrimination arbitrary? Philosophia8:187-203.
72.
Sowell, T.1975. Race and economics. New York: McKay.
73.
Stepan, N.L.1982. The idea of race in science. London : Macmillan.
74.
—. 1989. Race and gender: The role of analogy in science. In Anatomy of racism, edited by D. T. Goldberg.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
75.
Stepan, N.L., and S. Gilman.1988. Appropriating the idioms of science: Strategies of resistance to biological determinism. Unpublished manuscript.
76.
Stephan, W., and D. Rosenfield.1982. Racial and ethnic stereotypes. In In the eye of the beholder, edited by A. G. Miller.New York: Praeger .
77.
Tajfel, H.1973. The roots of prejudice: Cognitive aspects. In Psychology and race, edited by P. Watson.Chicago: Aldine.
78.
Thurow, L.1969. Poverty and discrimination. Washington, DC: Brookings Institute.
79.
Urbach, P.1974. Progress and degeneration in the IQ debate (1. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science25:99-135.
80.
van den Berghe, P.1981. The ethnic phenomenon. New York: Elsevier.
81.
Wasserstrom, R.1979. On racism and sexism. In Today's moral problems. New York: Macmillan.
