According to the article, Neurath's reflexive epistemology—expressed by the metaphor of the ship in need of reconstruction on the open sea—represents a philosophical alternative to the classical and contemporary forms of scientific realism and ethical cognitivism, including Popper's falsificationism. Against Quine's reductive interpretation of Neurath's boat argument as the basis for a 'naturalized epistemology,' the article maintains that the metaphor suggests the idea of an insuperable situation of linguistic and conceptual circularity. This prevents any attempt at self-foundation in scientific knowledge, as well as in ethics and politics, and rules out any 'constructive philosophy' aiming to break circularity in pursuit of some methodological beginning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Arrow, K.J.1963. Social choice and individual values.New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
2.
Bloor, D.1976. Knowledge and social imagery.London: Routledge, Chapman, & Hall.
3.
Cherniak, C.1986. Minimal rationality.Cambridge : MIT Press.
4.
Duhem, P.1954. La théorie physique: Son objet et sa structure.Paris: Marcel Rivière, 1914; Eng. tr. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
5.
Frank, P.1931. Das Kausalgesetz und seine Grenzen.Wien: Springer.
6.
—. 1950. Modern science and its philosophy.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
7.
Haller, R.1982a. New light on the Vienna CircleThe Monist65, no. 1.
8.
—. 1982b. Das Neurath-Prinzip: Grundlagen und Folgerungen. In Arbeiterbildung in der Zwischenkriegszeit, edited by F. Stadler. Wien and München: Löcker Verlag .
9.
Hegselmann, R.1979. Otto Neurath: Empiristischer Aufklärer und Sozialreformer. In O. Neurath, Wissenschaftliche Weltauffassung, Sozialismus und logischer empirismus, Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
10.
Laudan, L.1984. The pseudo-science of science? In Scientific rationality: The sociological turn, edited by J. R. Brown. Dordrecht and Boston: D. Reidel.
11.
Lorenzen, P.1968. Methodisches Denken. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Eng. tr. in Constructive philosophy, Amherst : University of Massachusetts Press, 1987.
12.
Neurath, O.1912. Das Problem des Lustmaximums. Jahrbuch der Philosophischen Gesellschaft an der Universität zu Wien 1912. Now also in O. Neurath, Gesammelte philosophische und methodologische Schriften, edited by R. Haller and H. Rutte. Wien: Hölder-Pichler-Tempsky , 1981.
13.
—. 1913. Die Verirrten des Cartesius und das Auxiliarmotiv. Jahrbuch der Philosophischen Gesellschaft an der Universitat zu Wien 1913. Eng. tr. in [Otto Neurath] Philosophical papers , 1913-1946, edited by R. S. Cohen and M. Neurath. Dordrecht and Boston: D. Reidel, 1982. [Hereafter referred to as PP].
14.
—. 1921. Anti-Spengler. München: Callwey Eng. tr. in O. Neurath, Empiricism and sociology , edited by M. Neurath and R. S. Cohen. Dordrecht and Boston : D. Reidel, 1973.
15.
—. 1930-31. Wege der wissenschaftlichen WeltauffassungErkenntnis1. Eng. tr. in PP.
16.
—. 1931a. PhysikalismusScientia50. Eng. tr. in PP.
17.
—. 1931b. Empirische Soziologie.Wien : Springer. Eng. tr. in O. Neurath,
18.
Empiricism and sociology, 405, 408-409.
19.
—. 1931c. Soziologie im PhysikalismusErkenntnis2. Eng. tr. in PP.
20.
—. 1932-33. ProtokollsatzeErkenntnis3. Eng. tr. in PP.
21.
—. 1934. Radikaler physikalismus und "Wirkliche Welt."Erkenntnis4. Eng. tr. in PP.
22.
—. 1935a. Einheit der Wissenschaft als AufgabeErkenntnis5. Eng. tr. in PP.
23.
—. 1935b. Pseudorationalismus der FalsifikationErkenntnis5. Eng. tr. in PP.
24.
—. 1936a. Le développement du Cercle de Vienne et l'avenir de l'empirisme logique.Paris: Hermann & Cie.
25.
—. 1936b. Einzelwissenschaften, Einheitswissenschaft, PseudorationalismusActualités Scientifiques et Industrielles , no. 388. Eng. tr. in PP.
26.
—. 1936c. L'encyclopédie comme "modèle."Revue de Synthèse12, no. 2. Eng. tr. in PP.
27.
—. 1936d. Physikalismus und erkenntnisforschung ITheoria2. Eng. tr. in PP.
28.
—. 1936e. Soziologische prognosenErkenntnis6.
29.
—. 1937. Prognosen und terminologie in physik, biologie, soziologieActualités Scientifique et Industrielles , no. 533.
30.
Now also in O Neurath, Gesammelte philosophische und methodologische schriften , edited by R. Haller and H. Rutte. Wien: Hölder-Pichler-Tempsky, 1981.
31.
—. 1937-38. Zu den Vortragen von Black, Kokoszynska, WilliamsErkenntnis7. Eng. tr. in PP.
32.
—. 1944. Foundations of the social sciences, Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
33.
—. 1946. Prediction and inductionAnalisi1, no. 3. Now also in PP.
34.
Neurath, O. and Lauwerys. J.A.1945. Plato's republic and German educationJournal of Education77, no. 910.
35.
Popper, K.R.1935. Logik der forschung.Wien: Springer.
36.
Eng. tr. The logic of scientific discovery.London : Hutchinson, 1968.
37.
—. 1960. The poverty of historicism.London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
38.
—. 1970. Normal science and its dangers. In Criticism and the growth of knowledge, edited by I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
39.
—. 1974. Replies to my critics. In The philosophy of Karl Popper , edited by P. A. Schilpp. La Salle, IL: Open Court.
40.
Prigogine, I., and I Stengers.1979. La Nouvelle alliance. Métamorphose de la science.Paris: Gallimard . Eng. tr. Boulder and London: Shambhala, 1984.
41.
Quine, W.V.O.1966. The ways of paradox and other essays.New York: Random House.
42.
—. 1969. Epistemology naturalized. In W. V O. Quine, Ontological relativity and other essays.New York: Columbia University Press.
43.
—. 1980a. Identity, ostension, and hypostasis. In W. V. O. Quine, From a logical point of view.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
44.
—. 1980b. Two dogmas of empiricism. In W. V O. Quine, From a logical point of view.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
45.
Romanos, G.D.1983. Quine and analytic philosophy.Cambridge: MIT Press.
46.
Sen, A.K.1970. The impossibility of a Paretian liberalJournal of Political Economy78 .
