This commentary on Åsa Burman’s Nonideal Social Ontology: The Power View makes a number of critical points about how power and powers are characterized in the book. For example, the idea of negative powers seems metaphysically suspect, leads to grammatical oddities, and could easily be dropped. Burman’s views on the ideal theoretical standard model of social ontology are examined, suggesting a stark difference between what makes a theory “ideal” and “standard.” The claim is put forward that theorists of “nonideal” persuasion may well share most features of the “standard” approach, and this is illustrated with Ásta’s Conferralism.
Ásta. 2018. Categories we Live by: The Construction of Sex, Gender, Race, and Other Social Categories. Oxford University Press.
2.
BarnesBarry. 1988. The Nature of Power. University of Illinois Press.
3.
BrännmarkJohan. 2019. “Institutions, Ideology, and Nonideal Social Ontology.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences49 (2): 137–159.
4.
BurmanÅsa. 2023. Nonideal Social Ontology: The Power View. Oxford University Press.
5.
GilbertMargaret. 2013. Joint Commitment: How We Make the Social World. Oxford University Press.
6.
GualaFrancesco. 2007. “The Philosophy of Social Science: Metaphysical and Empirical.” Philosophy Compass2 (6): 954–980.
7.
HohfeldWesley Newcomb. 1919. “Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied.” In Judicial Reasoning and Other Essays, edited by CookWalter Wheeler. Yale University Press.
8.
JenkinsKatharine. 2023. Ontological Oppression. Oxford University Press.
9.
LaitinenArto.2024. “Reflections on ‘I, You, and We’: A Comment on Zahavi.” Australasian Philosophical Review8 (2): 151–161. doi:10.1080/24740500.2024.2485531
10.
MauSøren. 2023. Mute Compulsion: A Marxist Theory of the Economic Power of Capital. Verso.
11.
MillsCharles W.2005. “‘Ideal Theory’ as Ideology.” Hypatia20 (3): 165–184.
12.
NussbaumMartha. 2011. Creating Capabilities: The Human Development Approach. Harvard University Press.
13.
SearleJohn R.1995. The Construction of Social Reality. Free Press.
14.
SearleJohn R.2010. Making the Social World: The Structure of Human Civilization. Oxford University Press.
15.
SenAmartya. 2009. The Idea of Justice. Harvard University Press.
16.
TuomelaRaimo. 2013. Social Ontology. Oxford University Press.
17.
ZahaviDan.2024. “I, You, and We: Beyond Individualism and Collectivism.” Australasian Philosophical Review8 (2): 111–128. doi:10.1080/24740500.2024.2302443
