Macroeconomic traditions disagree on the policies needed for the economy to properly function and how to assess them. In this paper, we contend that these disagreements originate from the social ontological commitments of a theory. The ontology of money underlines these disagreements between Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) and mainstream economics. First, we assess MMT’s ontology of money. Next, we identify MMT’s normative commitments and classify MMT’s ontology as a taxonomic definition with thick concepts. Finally, we offer reasons why MMT's ontology of money leads to rivalries with other economic traditions. We argue disagreements on policy are expected, given the ontological differences elaborated.
AlexandrovaAnna. 2018. “Can the Science of Well-Being Be Objective?” British Journal for the Philosophy of Science69 (2): 421-45.
2.
ArmstrongPhilSiddiquiKalim. 2019. “The Case for the Ontology of Money as Credit: Money as Bearer or Basis of ‘Value.” Real-World Economics Review90: 98-118.
3.
BellStephanie. 2000. “Do Taxes and Bonds Finance Government Spending?” Journal of Economic Issues34 (3): 603-20.
4.
CesarattoSergio. 2016. “The State Spends First: Logic, Facts, Fictions, Open Questions.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics39 (1): 44-71.
5.
DuffieDarrell. 1990. “Money in General Equilibrium Theory.” In Handbook of Monetary Economics, edited by FriedmanBenjamin M.HahnFrank H., Vol. 1, 81-100. Amsterdam: North Holland.
6.
EdwardsSebastian.2019. “Modern Monetary Theory: Cautionary Tales from Latin America.” Cato Journal39 (3): 529‐61.
7.
EpsteinBrian. 2013. “Social Objects without Intentions.” In Institutions, Emotions, and Group Agents: Contributions to Social Ontology, edited by Konzelmann ZivAnitaBernhard SchmidHans, 53-68. Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Springer.
8.
EpsteinBrian. 2016. “A Framework for Social Ontology.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences46 (2): 147-67.
9.
GraeberDavid. 2011 (2014). Debt: The First 5,000 Years. Updated and expanded ed.New York: Melville House.
10.
HodgsonGeoffrey M.2019. “Taxonomic Definitions in Social Science, with Firms, Markets and Institutions as Case Studies.” Journal of Institutional Economics15 (2): 207–33.
11.
InnesA. Mitchell. 1913. “What Is Money?” Banking Law Journal30: 377-408.
12.
InnesA. Michell. 1914. “The Credit Theory of Money.” Banking Law Journal31: 151-68.
13.
JuniperJamesSharpeTimothy P.WattsMartin J.. 2014–15. “Modern Monetary Theory: Contributions and Critics.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics37 (2): 281-307.
14.
KeltonStephanie. 2021. The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People’s Economy. New York: PublicAffairs.
15.
KiyotakiNobuhiroWrightRandall. 1993. “A Search-Theoretic Approach to Monetary Economics.” American Economic Review83 (1): 63‐77.
16.
KotilainenKonsta. 2022. “A Cosmopolitan Reading of Modern Monetary Theory.” Global Society36 (1): 89-112.
17.
LawsonTony. 2019a. “Money’s Relation to Debt: Some Problems with MMT’s Conception of Money.” Real-World Economics Review89: 109-28.
18.
LawsonTony. 2019b. The Nature of Social Reality: Issues in Social Ontology. London: Routledge.
19.
LawsonTony. 2022. “Two Conceptions of the Nature of Money: Clarifying Differences Between MMT and Money Theories Sponsored by Social Positioning Theory.” Real-World Economics Review101: 2-19.
20.
LernerAbba P.1943. “Functional Finance and the Federal Debt.” Social Research10 (1): 38-51.
21.
LernerAbba P.1947. “Money as a Creature of the State.” American Economic Review37 (2): 312-17.
22.
LiuXinhuaWrayL. Randall. 2016. “A Sovereign Currency Approach to China’s Policy Options.” Chinese Economy49 (3): 173-98.
23.
LudwigDavid.2016. “Ontological Choices and the Value-Free Ideal.” Erkenntnis81: 1253-72.
24.
MankiwN. Gregory. 2020. “A Skeptic’s Guide to Modern Monetary Theory.” AEA Papers and Proceedings110: 141-44.
25.
MehrlingPerry. 2000. “Modern Money: Fiat or Credit?” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics22 (3): 397-406.
SardoniC.WrayL. R.. 2007. “Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates and Currency Sovereignty.” Working Paper, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection 489. Levy Economics Institute.
31.
SearleJohn R. 1995. The Construction of Social Reality. New York: Free Press.
32.
SemenovaAlla. 2007. “The Origin of Money: Enhancing the Chartalist Perspective.” Working Paper, Center for Full Employment and Price Stability Research Archive 55. Center for Full Employment and Price Stability.
33.
SmithAdam. 1776 (1991). The Wealth of Nations. New York: Prometheus Books.
34.
SmithinJohn. 2016. “Endogenous Money, Fiscal Policy, Interest Rates and the Exchange Rate Regime: A Comment on Palley, Tymoigne and Wray.” Review of Political Economy28 (1): 64-78.
35.
TchernevaPavlina R.2016. “Money, Power, and Monetary Regimes.” Working Paper, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection 861. Levy Economics Institute.
36.
TchernevaPavlina R.2020. The Case for a Job Guarantee. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
37.
TymoigneEric. 2021. “Seven Replies to the Critiques of Modern Money Theory.” Working Paper, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection 996. Levy Economics Institute.
38.
TymoigneEricWrayL. Randall. 2013. “Modern Money Theory 101: A Reply to Critics.” Working Paper, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection 778. Levy Economics Institute.
39.
WrayL. Randall. 2000a. “Modern Money.” In What Is Money? edited by SmithinJohn N., 42-66. London: Routledge.
40.
WrayL. Randall. 2000b. “Money and Inflation.” Working Paper, Center for Full Employment and Price Stability Research Archive 12. Center for Full Employment and Price Stability.
41.
WrayL. Randall. 2011. “Understanding Modern Money: How a Sovereign Currency Works.” In New Approaches to Monetary Theory: Interdisciplinary Perspectives, edited by GanssmannHeiner, 158-70. London: Routledge.
42.
WrayL. Randall.2012 (2015). Modern Money Theory: A Primer on Macroeconomics for Sovereign Monetary Systems. 2nd ed.Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
43.
WrayL. Randall. 2014. “From the State Theory of Money to Modern Money Theory: An Alternative to Economic Orthodoxy.” Working Paper, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection 792. Levy Economics Institute.
44.
WrayL. Randall. 2020a. “Sovereign Currency and Non-Sovereign Budgets: The Modern Money Theory Approach.” Public Budgeting & Finance40 (3): 26-48.
45.
WrayL. Randall. 2020b. “The ‘Kansas City’ Approach to Modern Money Theory.” Working Paper, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection 961. Levy Economics Institute.
46.
WrayL. Randall. 2022. Making Money Work for Us: How MMT Can Save America. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
