This article argues that the tradition within the individualism-holism debate of importing arguments from the micro–macro discussion in other disciplines (e.g., philosophy of mind and philosophy of biology) significantly has hampered our understanding of the “individual-social” relationship. While, for example, the “neural-mental” and “atomic-molecular” links represent empirical “gives rise to” relationships, in the social sciences the micro–macro link is a purely analytical “qualifies as” type of relationship. This disanalogy is important, since it has significant implications for the individualism-holism debate: (a) it implies a phenomenally monist social ontology and (b) it disqualifies the notion of social macro causation.
ArcherMargaret S.1995. Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2.
BakerLynne R.2009. “Non-Reductive Materialism.” In The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Mind, edited by BeckermannA.McLaughlinB. P.WalterS., 109-27. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
BouvierAlban. 2011. “Individualism, Collective Agency and the Micro-Macro Relation.” In The Sage Handbook of the Philosophy of Social Sciences, edited by JarvieI. C.Zamora-BonillaJ., 199-216. London: Sage.
4.
ChurchlandPaul M.1985. “Reduction, Qualia, and the Direct Introspection of Brain States.” The Journal of Philosophy82 (1): 8-28.
FodorJerry A.1974. “Special Sciences (Or: The Disunity of Science as a Working Hypothesis).” Synthese28 (2): 97-115.
10.
GreveJens. 2012. “Emergence in Sociology: A Critique of Nonreductive Individualism.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences42 (2): 188-223.
11.
HumphreysPaul. 1997. “How Properties Emerge.” Philosophy of Science64 (1): 1-17.
12.
JeppersonRonaldMeyerJohn W.2011. “Multiple Levels of Analysis and the Limitations of Methodological Individualisms.” Sociological Theory29 (1): 54-73.
13.
KaidesojaTuukka. 2007. “Exploring the Concept of Causal Power in a Critical Realist Tradition.” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour37 (1): 63-87.
14.
KemenyJohn G.OppenheimPaul. 1956. “On Reduction.” Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition7 (1-2): 6-19.
15.
KimJaegwon. 1989. “The Myth of Nonreductive Materialism.” Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association63 (3): 31-47.
16.
KimJaegwon. 1999. “Making Sense of Emergence.” Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition95 (1): 3-36.
17.
KincaidHarold. 1986. “Reduction, Explanation, and Individualism.” Philosophy of Science53 (4): 492-513.
18.
KincaidHarold. 1996. Philosophical Foundations of the Social Sciences: Analyzing Controversies in Social Research. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
19.
KincaidHarold. 2014. “Dead Ends and Live Issues in the Individualism-Holism Debate.” In Rethinking the Individualism-Holism Debate: Essays in the Philosophy of Social Science, edited by ZahleJ.CollinF., 139-52. Cham: Springer.
20.
ListChristianMenziesPeter. 2009. “Nonreductive Physicalism and the Limits of the Exclusion Principle.” The Journal of Philosophy106 (9): 475-502.
21.
ListChristianSpiekermannKai. 2013. “Methodological Individualism and Holism in Political Science: A Reconciliation.” American Political Science Review107 (4): 629-43.
22.
LittleDaniel. 2012. “Explanatory Autonomy and Coleman’s Boat.” Theoria74:137-51.
23.
MitrovicBranko. 2017. “Is Multiple Realizability a Valid Argument Against Methodological Individualism?”Philosophy of the Social Sciences47 (1): 28-43.
24.
MunchRichardSmelserNeil J.1987. “Relating the Micro and Macro.” In The Micro-Macro Link, edited by AlexanderJ. C.GiesenB.MunchR.SmelserN. J., 356-87. Berkeley: University of California Press.
25.
NagelErnest. 1961. The Structure of Science: Problems in the Logic of Scientific Explanation. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
26.
OppenheimPaulPutnamHilary. 1958. “Unity of Science as a Working Hypothesis.” Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science2:3-36.
27.
PutnamHilary. 1975. “The Nature of Mental States.” In Philosophical Papers: Mind, Language and Reality, Vol. 2, edited by PutnamH., 429-40. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
RamströmGustav. Forthcoming. “Coleman’s boat revisited - causal sequences and the micro-macro link.” Sociological Theory.
30.
RitzerGeorge. 2000. Modern Sociological Theory. Boston: McGraw-Hill.
31.
RuizSergioBirbaumerNielsSitaramRanganatha. 2013. “Abnormal Neural Connectivity in Schizophrenia and fMRI-Brain Computer Interface as a Potential Therapeutic Approach.” Frontiers in Psychiatry4:17.
32.
SawyerR. Keith. 2001. “Emergence in Sociology: Contemporary Philosophy of Mind and Some Implications for Sociological Theory.” American Journal of Sociology107 (3): 551-85.
33.
SawyerR. Keith. 2002. “Nonreductive Individualism.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences32 (4): 537-59.
34.
SawyerR. Keith. 2003. “Nonreductive Individualism Part II—Social Causation.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences33 (2): 203-24.
35.
SawyerR. Keith. 2012. “Response to ‘Emergence in Sociology.’”Philosophy of the Social Sciences42 (2): 270-75.
WahlbergTobias H.2014. “Elder-Vass on the Causal Power of Social Structures.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences44 (6): 774-91.
40.
WatkinsJohn W. N.1957. “Historical Explanation in the Social Sciences.” The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science8 (30): 104-17.
41.
WimsattWilliam C.1985. “Forms of Aggregativity.” In Human Nature and Natural Knowledge, edited by DonaganA.PerovichN.WedinM., 259-93. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
42.
WimsattWilliam C.2000. “Emergence as Non-Aggregativity and the Biases of Reductionisms.” Foundations of Science5 (3): 269-97.
43.
ZahleJulie. 2003. “The Individualism-Holism Debate on Intertheoretic Reduction and the Argument from Multiple Realization.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences33 (1): 77-99.
44.
ZahleJulie. 2007. “Holism and Supervenience.” In Philosophy of anthropology and sociology, edited by TurnerS. P.RisjordM. W., 311-41. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
45.
ZahleJulie. 2014. “Holism, Emergence, and the Crucial Distinction.” In Rethinking the Individualism-Holism Debate: Essays in the Philosophy of Social Science, edited by ZahleJ.CollinF., 177-96. Cham: Springer.
46.
ZahleJulieCollinFinn. 2014. “Introduction.” In Rethinking the Individualism-Holism Debate: Essays in the Philosophy of Social Science, edited by ZahleJ.CollinF., 1-14. Cham: Springer.
