Reydon and Scholz raise doubts about the Darwinian status of organizational ecology by arguing that Darwinian principles are not applicable to organizational populations. Although their critique of organizational ecology’s typological essentialism is correct, they go on to reject the Darwinian status of organizational populations. This paper claims that the replicator-interactor distinction raised in modern philosophy of biology but overlooked for discussion by Reydon and Scholz provides a way forward. It is possible to conceptualize evolving Darwinian populations providing that the inheritance mechanism is appropriately specified. By this approach, adaptation and selection are no longer dichotomized, and the evolutionary significance of knowledge transmission is highlighted.
AldrichH. E.HodgsonG. M.HullD. L.KnudsenT.MokyrJ.VanbergV., 2008. “In Defence of Generalized Darwinism.” Journal of Evolutionary Economics18:577-96.
3.
AriewA.2008. “Population Thinking.” In Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Biology, edited by RuseM., 64-86. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
AungerR. ed. 2000. Darwinizing Culture: The Status of Memetics as a Science. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
5.
BagehotW.1872. Physics and Politics, or Thoughts on the Application of the Principles of “Natural Selection” and “Inheritance” to Political Society. London: King.
6.
BaumJ. A. C. ed., 2002. The Blackwell Companion to Organizations. Oxford: Blackwell.
7.
BaumJ. A. C.SinghJ. V., eds. 1994a. Evolutionary Dynamics of Organizations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
8.
BaumJ. A. C.SinghJ. V.1994b. “Organizational Hierarchies and Evolutionary Processes.” In Evolutionary Dynamics of Organizations, edited by BaumJ. A. C.SinghJ. V.New York: Oxford University Press.
9.
BeckerM. C. ed., 2008. Handbook of Organizational Routines. Cheltenham, England: Elgar
10.
BoydR.RichersonP. J.1985. Culture and the Evolutionary Process. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
11.
BrandonR. N.1990. Adaptation and Environment. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
12.
BrandonR. N.1998. “The Levels of Selection: A Hierarchy of Interactors.” In The Philosophy of Biology, edited by HullD. L.RuseM., 176-97. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
13.
BrudererE.SinghJ. V.1996. “Organizational Evolution, Learning and Selection: A Genetic-Algorithm-Based Model.” Academy of Management Journal39:1322-49.
14.
BurgelmanR. A.1991. “Intraorganizational Ecology of Strategy Making and Organizational Adaptation: Theory and Field Research.” Organization Science2, no. 3: 39-62.
15.
CampbellD. T.1965. “Variation and Selective Retention in Sociocultural Evolution.” In Social Change in Developing Areas: A Reinterpretation of Evolutionary Theory, edited by Barringer. 19-49. Cambridge: Schenkman Press.
16.
CarrollG. R.HannanM. T.2000. The Demography of corporations and industries. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
17.
CordesC.2006. “Darwinism in Economics: From Analogy to Continuity.” Journal of Evolutionary Economics16, no. 5: 529-35.
18.
DarwinC.1859. On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life. Vol. 2. London: Murray.
19.
DarwinC.1871. The Descent of Man. London: Murray.
20.
DarwinC.1874. The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. New York: Burt.
21.
DawkinsR.1983. “Universal Darwinism.” In Evolution from Molecules to Men, edited by BendallD. S., 403-25. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22.
DawkinsR.1986. The Blind Watchmaker. Harlow, England: Longman.
23.
DennettD.1995. Darwin’s Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life. London: Allen.
24.
DollimoreD. E.2006. Darwinian Evolutionary Ideas in Business Economics and Organization Studies. PhD diss., University of Hertfordshire.
25.
DobrevS. D.van WitteloostuijnA.BaumJ. A. C.2006. “Introduction: Ecology versus Strategy or Strategy and Ecology?” In Advances in Strategic Management: Ecology and Strategy, edited by BaumJoel A.C.DobrevStanislav D.WitteloostuijnArjen Van, 23:1-26. Bingley, England: Emerald Group.
26.
EllisL.1996. “A Discipline in Peril: Sociology’s Future Hinges on Curing Its Biophobia.” American Sociologist27:21-41.
27.
GannettL.2003. “Making populations: Bounding genes in space and time.” Philosophy of Science70:989–1001.
28.
Godfrey-SmithP.2000. “The Replicator in Retrospect.” Biology and Philosophy15:405-23.
Godfrey-SmithP.2009. Darwinian Populations and Natural Selection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
31.
HannanM. T.2005. “Ecologies of Organizations: Diversity and Identity.” Journal of Economic Perspectives19, no. 1: 51-70.
32.
HannanM. T.FreemanJ.1977. “The Population Ecology of Organizations.” American Journal of Sociology82:929-64.
33.
HannanM. T.FreemanJ.1989. Organizational Ecology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
34.
HodgsonG. M.2001. “Is Social Evolution Lamarckian or Darwinian?” In Darwinism and Evolutionary Economics, edited by LaurentJohnNightingaleJohn, 87-118. Cheltenham, England: Elgar.
35.
HodgsonG. M.2002. “Darwinism in Economics: From Analogy to Ontology.” Journal of Evolutionary Economics12, no. 3: 259-82.
36.
HodgsonG. M.2004. “Social Darwinism in Anglophone Academic Journals: A Contribution to the History of the Term.” Journal of Historical Sociology17:428-63.
37.
HodgsonG. M.KnudsenT.2004. “The Firm as an Interactor: Firms as Vehicles for Habits and Routines.” Journal of Evolutionary Economics14:281-307.
38.
HodgsonG. M.KnudsenT.2006a. “The Nature and Units of Social Selection.” Journal of Evolutionary Economics16:477-89.
39.
HodgsonG. M.KnudsenT.2006b. “Why We Need a Generalized Darwinism: And Why Generalized Darwinism Is Not Enough.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization61:1-19.
40.
HodgsonG. M.KnudsenT.2008. “In Search of General Evolutionary Principles: Why Darwinism Is Too Important to Be Left to the Biologists.” Journal of Bioeconomics10:51-69.
41.
HodgsonG. M.KnudsenT.2010. Darwin’s Conjecture: In Search for General Principles of Social and Economic Evolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
42.
HodgsonG. M.KnudsenT.2012. “Underqualified-Maximal Generality in Darwinian Explanation: A Response to Matt Gers.” Biology and Philosophy27:607-14.
43.
HullD. L.1978. “A Matter of Individuality.” Philosophy of Science. 45:335-60.
44.
HullD. L.1980. “Individuality and Selection.” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics11:311-32.
45.
HullD. L.1981. “The Units of Evolution: A Metaphysical Essay.” In The Philosophy of Evolution, edited by JensenU. J.HarréR., 23-44. Brighton, England: Harvester Press.
46.
HullD. L.1982. “The Naked Meme.” In Learning, Development and Culture: Essays in Evolutionary Epistemology, edited by PlotkinHenry. C., 273-327. New York: Wiley.
47.
HullD. L.1988. Science as a Process: An Evolutionary Account of the Social and Conceptual Development of Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
48.
HullD. L.1990. “Ernst Mayr on the Philosophy of Biology: A Review Essay.” Journal of Historical Methods23, no. 1: 42-45.
49.
HullD. L.2000. “Taking Memetics Seriously: Memetics Will Be What We Make It.” In Darwinizing Culture: The Status of Memetics as a Science, edited by AungerR., 43-68. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
50.
HullD. L.2001. Science and Selection: Essays on Biological Evolution and the Philosophy of Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51.
HullD. L.LanghamR. E.GlennS. S.2001. “A General Account of Selection: Biology, Immunology and Behavior.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences24, no. 3: 511-73.
52.
JablonkaE.ZimanJ.2000. “Evolutionary Models for Technological Change.” In Technological Innovation as an Evolutionary Process, edited by ZimanJ. M., 27-40. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
53.
KlepperSteven. 2002. “The Capabilities of New Firms and the Evolution of the US Automobile.” Industry Industrial and Corporate Change11:645-66.
54.
KnudsenT.2001. “Nesting Lamarckism within Darwinian Explanations: Necessity in Economics and Possibility in Biology?” In Darwinism and Evolutionary Economics, edited by LaurentJ.NightingaleJ., 121-59. Cheltenham, England: Elgar.
55.
KnudsenT.2004. “General Selection Theory and Economic Evolution: The Price Equation and the Genotype/Phenotype Distinction.” Journal of Economic Methodology11, no. 2: 147-73.
56.
LaurentJ.NightingaleJ., eds. 2001. Darwinism and Evolutionary Economics. Cheltenham, England: Elgar.
57.
LemosJ.2009. “In Defense of Organizational Evolution: A Reply to Reydon and Scholz.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences39:463-74.
58.
LevinthalD. A.1991. “Organizational Adaptation and Environmental Selection: Interrelated Processes of Change.” Organization Science2:140-45.
59.
LevittB.MarchJ. G.1988. “Organizational Learning.” In Annual Review of Sociology, edited by ScottW. R., 319-40. Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
60.
LewontinR. C.1970. “The Units of Selection.” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics1:1-18.
61.
MayrE.1959. “Typological versus Population Thinking.” In Evolution and Anthropology: A Centennial Appraisal, 409-12. Washington, DC: Anthropological Society of Washington.
62.
MayrE.1976. Evolution and the Diversity of Life: Selected Essays. Cambridge, MA: Belknap.
MayrE.1982. The Growth of Biological Thought: Diversity, Evolution, and Inheritance. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
65.
MayrE.1988. Toward a New Philosophy of Biology: Observations of an Evolutionist. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
66.
McKelveyB.1982. Organizational Systematics: Taxonomy, Evolution, Classification. Berkeley: University of California Press.
67.
MetcalfeJ. S.1987. “Evolution and Economic Change.” Paper read at Technology and Economic Progress: Proceedings of Section F (Economics) of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, Belfast.
68.
MetcalfeJ. S.1998. Evolutionary Economics and Creative Destruction. London: Routledge.
69.
MetcalfeJ. S. 2004. Book Review: Technological Innovation as an Evolutionary Process (2001), edited by JohnZiman. Evolutionary Theories in the Social Sciences Website. Retreived from http://www.etss.net/index.php/weblog/booksandreviewsfull/105/
70.
MinerA. S.1991. “Organizational Evolution and the Social Ecology of Jobs.” American Sociological Review56:772-85.
71.
NelsonR. R.WinterS. G.1982. An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
72.
OkashaS., 2006. Evolution and the Levels of Selection. Oxford: Oxford University Press
73.
PriceG. R.1995. “The Nature of Selection.” Journal of Theoretical Biology175:389-96.
74.
ReydonT. A. C.ScholzM.2009. “Why Organizational Ecology Is Not a Darwinian Research Program.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences39:408-39.
75.
RitchieD. G.1896. “Social Evolution.” International Journal of Ethics6:165-81.
76.
RitchieD. G. 1889. Darwinism and Politics. 1st ed. London: Swan Sonnernschein.
77.
ScholzM.ReydonT. A. C.2010. “Organizational Ecology: No Darwinian Evolution after All. A Rejoinder to Lemos.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences40:504-12.
78.
SoberE. ed. 2006. Conceptual Issues in Evolutionary Biology. 3rd ed.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
79.
SperberD.2000. “An Objection to the Memetic Approach to Culture.” In Darwinizing Culture: The Status of Memetics as a Science, edited by RobertAunger, 162–73. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
80.
SteeleE. J.LindleyR. A.BlandenR. V.DaviesP.1998. Lamarck’s Signature: How Retrogenes Are Changing Darwin’s Natural Selection Paradigm. New York: Perseus.
81.
SterelnyK.SmithK. C.DickisonM.1996. “The Extended Replicator.” Biology and Philosophy11:377-403.
82.
StinchcombeA. L.1965. “Social Structure and Organizations.” In Handbook of Organizations, edited by MarchJ. G., 153-93. Chicago: Rand McNally.
83.
StoelhorstJ. W.2008. “The Explanatory Logic and Ontological Commitments of Generalized Darwinism.” Journal of Economic Methodology15:343-63.
84.
ToulminS.1972. Human Understanding. London: Oxford University Press.
85.
VeblenT. B.1898. “Why Is Economics Not an Evolutionary Science?”Quarterly Journal of Economics12:373-97.
86.
VromenJ.2001. “The Human Agent in Evolutionary Economics.” In Darwinism and Evolutionary Economics, edited by LaurentJ.NightingaleJ., 184-208. Cheltenham, England: Elgar.
87.
VromenJ.2004. “Conjectural Revisionary Economic Ontology: Outline of an Ambitious Research Agenda for Evolutionary Economics.” Journal of Economic Methodology11:213-47.
88.
WilsonD. S.2002. Darwin’s Cathedral: Religion and the Nature of Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
89.
WinterS. G.1987. “Natural Selection and Evolution.” In The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, edited by EatwellJ.MilgateM.NewmanP., 3:614-17. London: McMillan.
90.
WittU.2004. “On the Proper Interpretations of ‘Evolution’ in Economics and Its Implications for Production Theory.” Journal of Economic Methodology11, no. 2: 125-46.
91.
WittU.2008. “What Is Specific about Evolutionary Economics?”Journal of Evolutionary Economics18:547-75.
92.
ZimanJ. M.2002. “Selectionist Reasoning as a Tool of Thought.” In The Evolution of Cultural Entities, edited by WheelerM.ZimanJ.BodenM. A., 1-8. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
