Abstract
Weighted explanations , whereby some causes are deemed more important than others, are ubiquitous in historical studies. Drawing from influential recent work on causation, I develop a definition of causal-explanatory strength. This makes clear exactly which aspects of explanatory weighting are subjective and which objective. It also sheds new light on several traditional issues, showing for instance that: underlying causes need not be more important than proximate ones; several different causes can each be responsible for most of an effect; small causes need not be less important than big ones; and non-additive interactive effects between causes present no particular difficulty.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Achinstein, P.
1983 . The nature of explanation , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
2.
Carr, E.H.
1962 . What is history?
Alfred Knopf : New York .
3.
Lewis, D.
1973 . Causation . Journal of Philosophy
70 :556 -67 .
4.
Martin, R.
1989 . The past within us . Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
5.
Northcott, R.
2005 a. Comparing apples with oranges . Analysis
65 (1 ): 12 -18 .
6.
———. 2005 b. Pearson's wrong turning: against statistical measures of causal efficacy . Philosophy of Science
72 (5 ): 900 -12 .
7.
———. 2006 . Causal efficacy and the analysis of variance . Biology and Philosophy
21 (2 ): 253 -76 .
8.
———. (forthcoming). Apportioning explanatory responsibility .
9.
Pearl, J.
2000 . Causality . New York : Cambridge University Press .
10.
Przeworski, A.
, and
M. Wallerstein.
1988 . Structural dependence of the state on capital . American Political Science Review
82 (1 ): 11 -29 .
11.
Sober, E.
1988 . Apportioning causal responsibility . Journal of Philosophy
85 :303 -18 .
12.
Sober, E.
,
E.O. Wright
, and
A. Levine.
1992 . Causal asymmetries . In Reconstructing Marxism , 129 -75 . London and New York: Verso .
13.
Spirtes, P.
,
C. Glymour
, and
R. Scheines.
2000 . Causation, prediction, and search
2 nd ed. Cambridge, MA : MIT Press .
14.
Turner, S.
1986 . The Search for a methodology of social science . Dordrecht : Reidel .
15.
———. 2007 . Causation in history . In The Blackwell guide to the philosophy of history , edited by
Avi Tucker
. Oxford : Blackwell .
16.
Van Fraassen, B.
1980 . The scientific image . Oxford : Oxford University Press .
17.
Woodward, J.
2003 . Making things happen: A theory of causal explanation . New York : Oxford University Press .