Using Probabilistic Incentives to Increase Response Rates to Mail-return Highway Intercept Diaries

Abstract

This article reports the results of a field experiment testing the effectiveness of a probabilistic monetary incentive to increase the rate of return of a highway intercept diary used to estimate the economic significance of tourism. The experiment consisted of two groups of travelers using a highway wayside rest just inside a state's borders. The control group was given the mail-return diary-questionnaire, while the experimental group was given the diary-questionnaire and told that they would be entered into a lottery for a $50 U.S. Savings Bond when the diary was returned. The rate of return of the diaries for the experimental group was significantly higher than that of the control group, but no other effects were found.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Armstrong, J S (1975) "Monetary Incentives in Mail Surveys " Public Opinion Quarterly, 39 111-16

Denton, J J , C Tsai , and P Chevrette (1988) " Effects on Survey Responses of Subjects, Incentives and Multiple Mailings " Journal of Experimental Education, 56 77-82

Dillman, D A (1978) Marl and Telephone Survevs The Total Design Method New York

John Wiley & Sons

Fox, R J , M R Crask , and J Kim (1988) "Mail Survey Response Rates A Meta-analysis of Selected Techniques for Inducing Response " Public Opinion Quarterly, 52 467-91

Freund, J E (1988) Modern Elementary Statistics, Englewood Cliffs, NJ

Prentice-Hall

Gray, J , S Hamilton , and J Higgins (1987) Wisconsin Dells Trip Expenditure Diaries Madison Recreation Resources Center , University of Wisconsin

Hansen, R A (1980) "A Self Perception Interpretation of the Effects of Monetary and Nonmonetary Incentives in Mail Survey Respondent Behavior " Journal of Marketing Research , 17 7-83

Heberlein, T A , and R Baumgartner ( 1978) "Factors Affecting Response Rates to Mailed Questionnaires A Quantitative Analysis of the Published Literature " American Sociological Review, 43 447-63

Harris, C C , W J McLaughlin , and E E Krumpe (1988 ) The 1987 Idaho Leisure Travel and Recreation Survey A Statewide Analysis Moscow Department of Wildland Recreation Management, University of Idaho

10.

McDaniel, S , and R W Jackson (1984) "Exploring the Probabilistic Incentive in Mail Survey Research " In 1984 AMA Educator's Proceedings Chicago American Marketing Association, 372-75

11.

McDaniel, S W , and C P Rao (1980) "The Effect of Monetary Inducement on Mailed Questionnaire Response Quality " Journal of Marketing Research, 17 265-68

12.

Moisey, N , and M Yuan (1990) Estimates of Economic Impact of Non-resident Travelers to Montana A Technical Report Research Report 11 Missoula Institute for Tourism and Recreation Research, University of Montana

13.

Nederhof, A J (1983) "The Effects of Material Incentives in Mail Surveys Two Studies " Public Opinion Quarterly, 47. 103-11

14.

Oblinger-McAleb (1980). Old West Region Non-resident Travel and Recreation Survey. Summary Report Denver, CO

Oblinger-McAleb

15.

Perdue, R R (1985) "The 1983 Nebraska Visitor Survey. Achieving a High Response Rate with a Diary Questionnaire " Journal of Travel Research, 24 (Fall) 23-26