The COVID-19 pandemic has had a devastating effect on many industries around the world including tourism and policy makers are interested in mapping out what the recovery path will look like. We propose a novel statistical methodology for generating scenario-based probabilistic forecasts based on a large survey of 443 tourism experts and stakeholders. The scenarios map out pessimistic, most-likely and optimistic paths to recovery. Taking advantage of the natural aggregation structure of tourism data due to geographic locations and purposes of travel, we propose combining forecast reconciliation and forecast combinations implemented to historical data to generate robust COVID-free counterfactual forecasts, to contrast against. Our empirical application focuses on Australia, analyzing international arrivals and domestic flows. Both sectors have been severely affected by travel restrictions in the form of international and interstate border closures and regional lockdowns. The two sets of forecasts, allow policy makers to map out the road to recovery and also estimate the expected effect of the pandemic.
Airports Council International (ACI) Europe. 2020. “Impact of COVID-19 on European Airport Passenger Traffic.” Technical Report, Airports Council International. https://www.aci-europe.org/airport-traffic-covid-19.
2.
ArmstrongJ. S.2006. “How to Make Better Forecasts and Decisions: Avoid Face-to-Face Meetings.” Foresight: The International Journal of Applied Forecasting5: 3–15.
3.
ArmstrongJ. S.2008. “Methods to Elicit Forecasts From Groups: Delphi and Prediction Markets Compared.” SSRN1153124.
4.
ArvanM.FahimniaB.ReisiM.SiemsenE.2019. “Integrating Human Judgement Into Quantitative Forecasting Methods: A Review.” Omega86: 237–52.
5.
AthanasopoulosG.AhmedR. A.HyndmanR. J.2009. “Hierarchical Forecasts for Australian Domestic Tourism.” International Journal of Forecasting25: 146–66.
6.
BarrowD. K.KourentzesN.2016. “Distributions of Forecasting Errors of Forecast Combinations: Implications for Inventory Management.” International Journal of Production Economics177: 24–33. doi:10.1016/j.ijpe.2016.03.017.
7.
BatesJ. M.GrangerC. W. J.1969. “The Combination of Forecasts.” Operational Research20 (4): 451–68.
8.
BauschT.GartnerW. C.OrtanderlF.2021. “How to Avoid a COVID-19 Research Paper Tsunami? A Tourism System Approach.” Journal of Travel Research60: 467–85.
9.
ClaeskensG.MagnusJ. R.VasnevA. L.WangW.2016. “The Forecast Combination Puzzle: A Simple Theoretical Explanation.” International Journal of Forecasting32 (3): 754–62. doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2015.12.005.
10.
CookM. P.2006. “Visual Representations in Science Education: The Influence of Prior Knowledge and Cognitive Load Theory on Instructional Design Principles.” Bioscience Education90 (6): 1073–91.
11.
DavisF. D.LohseG. L.KottemannJ. E.1994. “Harmful Effects of Seemingly Helpful Information on Forecasts of Stock Earnings.” Journal of Economic Psychology15 (2): 253–67.
12.
EdmundsonR. H.1990. “Decomposition; A Strategy for Judgemental Forecasting.” Journal of Forecasting9 (4): 305–14.
13.
FildesR.GoodwinP.LawrenceM.NikolopoulosK.2009. “Effective Forecasting and Judgmental Adjustments: An Empirical Evaluation and Strategies for Improvement in Supply-Chain Planning.” International Journal of Forecasting25 (1): 3–23.
14.
FildesR.GoodwinP.ÖnkalD.2019. “Use and Misuse of Information in Supply Chain Forecasting of Promotion Effects.” International Journal of Forecasting35 (1): 144–56.
15.
ForsythP.GuiomardC.NiemeierH. M.2020. “Covid-19, the Collapse in Passenger Demand and Airport Charges.” Journal of Air Transport Management89: 101932.
16.
FotiadisA.PolyzosS.HuanT. T. C.2021. “The Good, The Bad and The Ugly on COVID-19 Tourism Recovery.” Annals of Tourism Research87: 103117. doi:10.1016/j.annals.2020.103117.
17.
GoodwinP.GönülS.ÖnkalD.KocabıyıkoğluA.GöğüşC. I.2019. “Contrast Effects in Judgmental Forecasting When Assessing the Implications of Worst and Best Case Scenarios.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making32 (5): 536–49.
18.
GoodwinP.WrightG.1993. “Improving Judgmental Time Series Forecasting: A Review of the Guidance Provided by Research.” International Journal of Forecasting9 (2): 147–61.
19.
GraefeA.ArmstrongJ. S.2011. “Comparing Face-to-Face Meetings, Nominal Groups, Delphi and Prediction Markets on an Estimation Task.” International Journal of Forecasting27 (1): 183–95.
20.
GursoyD.ChiC. G.2020. “Effects of COVID-19 Pandemic on Hospitality Industry: Review of the Current Situations and a Research Agenda.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management29 (5): 527–9.
21.
HyndmanR. J.AhmedR. A.AthanasopoulosG.ShangH. L.2011. “Optimal Combination Forecasts for Hierarchical Time Series.” Computational Statistics & Data Analysis55 (9): 2579–89. doi:10.1016/j.csda.2011.03.006.
JonesM. C.1993. “Simple Boundary Correction for Kernel Density Estimation.” Statistics and Computing3 (3): 135–46.
24.
JørgensenM.SjøbergD. I.2003. “An Effort Prediction Interval Approach Based on the Empirical Distribution of Previous Estimation Accuracy.” Information and Software Technology45 (3): 123–36.
25.
KahnemanD.LovalloD.1993. “Timid Choices and Bold Forecasts: A Cognitive Perspective on Risk Taking.” Management Science39 (1): 17–31.
26.
KaukoK.PalmroosP.2014. “The Delphi Method in Forecasting Financial Markets— An Experimental Study.” International Journal of Forecasting30 (2): 313–27.
27.
KourentzesN.AthanasopoulosG.2019. “Cross-Temporal Coherent Forecasts for Australian Tourism.” Annals of Tourism Research75: 393–409. doi:10.1016/j.annals.2019.02.001.
28.
KourentzesN.BarrowD.PetropoulosF.2019. “Another Look at Forecast Selection and Combination: Evidence From Forecast Pooling.” International Journal of Production Economics209: 226–35. doi:10.1016/j.ijpe.2018.05.019.
29.
KourentzesN.SaaymanA.Jean-PierreP.ProvenzanoD.SahliM.SeetaramN.VoloS.2021. “Visitor Arrivals Forecasts Amid COVID-19: A Perspective From the Africa Team.” Annals of Tourism Research88: 103197.
30.
LawrenceM.GoodwinP.O’ConnorM.ÖnkalD.2006. “Judgmental Forecasting: A Review of Progress Over the Last 25years.” International Journal of Forecasting22 (3): 493–518.
31.
LiG.WuD. C.ZhouM.LiuA.2019. “The Combination of Interval Forecasts in Tourism.” Annals of Tourism Research75 (August 2018): 363–78. doi:10.1016/j.annals.2019.01.010.
32.
LinV. S.GoodwinP.SongH.2014. “Accuracy and Bias of Experts’ Adjusted Forecasts.” Annals of Tourism Research48: 156–74.
33.
LinV. S.SongH.2015. “A Review of Delphi Forecasting Research in Tourism.” Current Issues in Tourism18 (12): 1099–131.
34.
LiuA.ViciL.RamosV.GiannoniS.BlakeA.2021. “Visitor Arrivals Forecasts Amid COVID-19: A Perspective From the EUROPE Team.” Annals of Tourism Research88: 103182.
35.
MacGregorD. G.2001. “Decomposition for Judgmental Forecasting and Estimation.” In Principles of Forecasting, edited by ArmstrongJ. S. 107–23. Boston, MA: Springer.
36.
MakridakisS.SpiliotisE.AssimakopoulosV.2020. “The M4 Competition: 100,000 time Series and 61 Forecasting Methods.” International Journal of Forecasting36 (1): 54–74. doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2019.04.014.
37.
ManeenopS.KotcharinS.2020. “The Impacts of COVID-19 on the Global Airline Industry: An Event Study Approach.” Journal of Air Transport Management89: 101920.
38.
MilesJ.2008. “A Primer on Prediction Markets.” Foresight: The International Journal of Applied Forecasting9: 33–5.
39.
MillerK. M.HofstetterR.KrohmerH.ZhangZ. J.2011. “How Should Consumers’ Willingness to Pay Be Measured? An Empirical Comparison of State-of-the-Art Approaches.” Journal of Marketing Research48 (1): 172–84.
40.
Montero-MansoP.AthanasopoulosG.HyndmanR. J.TalagalaT. S.2020. “FFORMA: Feature-Based Forecast Model Averaging.” International Journal of Forecasting36 (1): 86–92. doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2019.02.011
O’LearyD. E.2017. “Crowd Performance in Prediction of the World Cup 2014.” European Journal of Operational Research260 (2): 715–24.
46.
PanagiotelisA.AthanasopoulosG.GamakumaraP.HyndmanR. J.2021. “Forecast Reconciliation: A Geometric View With New Insights on Bias Correction.” International Journal of Forecasting37 (1): 343–59. doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2020.06.004.
47.
PereraH. N.HurleyJ.FahimniaB.ReisiM.2019. “The Human Factor in Supply Chain Forecasting: A Systematic Review.” European Journal of Operational Research274 (2): 574–600.
48.
PetropoulosF.FildesR.GoodwinP.2016. “Do ‘Big Losses’ in Judgmental Adjustments to Statistical Forecasts Affect Experts’ Behaviour?”European Journal of Operational Research249 (3): 842–52.
49.
PetropoulosF.KourentzesN.NikolopoulosK.SiemsenE.2018. “Judgmental Selection of Forecasting Models.” Journal of Operations Management60: 34–46.
50.
PetropoulosF.SvetunkovI.2020. “A Simple Combination of Univariate Models.” International Journal of Forecasting36 (1): 110–5. doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2019.01.006.
51.
QiuR. T. R.WuD. C.DropsyV.PetitS.PrattS.OheY.2021. “Visitor Arrivals Forecasts Amid COVID-19: A Perspective From the Asia and Pacific Team.” Annals of Tourism Research88: 103155. doi:10.1016/j.annals.2021.103155.
52.
R Core Team. 2020. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. https://www.R-project.org/.
RonisD. L.YatesJ. F.1987. “Components of Probability Judgment Accuracy: Individual Consistency and Effects of Subject Matter and Assessment Method.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes40 (2): 193–218.
55.
RoweG.2007. “A Guide to Delphi.” Foresight: The International Journal of Applied Forecasting8: 11–6.
56.
SchoemakerP. J.2004. “Forecasting and Scenario Planning: The Challenges of Uncertainty and Complexity.” In Blackwell Handbook of Judgment and Decision Making, edited by KoehlerD. J.HarveyN., 274–96. Malden, MA: Wiley Online Library.
57.
SchoemakerP. J.TetlockP. E.2016. “Superforecasting: How to Upgrade Your Company’s Judgment.” Harvard Business Review94 (5): 73–8.
58.
ShenS.LiG.SongH.2008. “An Assessment of Combining Tourism Demand Forecasts over Different Time Horizons.” Journal of Travel Research47 (2): 197–207.
59.
ShenS.LiG.SongH.2011. “Combination Forecasts of International Tourism Demand.” Annals of Tourism Research38 (1): 72–89. doi:10.1016/j.annals.2010.05.003.
60.
SmithJ.WallisK. F.2009. “A Simple Explanation of the Forecast Combination Puzzle.” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics71 (3): 331–55.
61.
SongH.GaoB. Z.LinV. S.2013. “Combining Statistical and Judgmental Forecasts via a Web-Based Tourism Demand Forecasting System.” International Journal of Forecasting29 (2): 295–310.
62.
SongH.QiuR. T.ParkJ.2019. “A Review of Research on Tourism Demand Forecasting.” Annals of Tourism Research75: 338–62.
63.
SongH.WittS. F.WongK. F.WuD. C.2009. “An Empirical Study of Forecast Combination in Tourism.” Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research33 (1): 3–29.
64.
SurowieckiJ.2004. “The Wisdom of the Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter That the Few.” London, GB: Abacus.
65.
TetlockP. E.2017. Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know?Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
TziralisG.TatsiopoulosI.2007. “Prediction Markets: An Extended Literature Review.” The Journal of Prediction Markets1 (1): 75–91.
68.
UNWTO. 2020. “UNWTO World Tourism Barometer and Statistical Annex, January 2020.” UNWTO World Tourism Barometer18 (1): 1–48.
69.
WebbyR.O’ConnorM.EdmundsonB.2005. “Forecasting Support Systems for the Incorporation of Event Information: An Empirical Investigation.” International Journal of Forecasting21 (3): 411–23.
70.
WickramasuriyaS. L.AthanasopoulosG.HyndmanR. J.2019. “Optimal Forecast Reconciliation for Hierarchical and Grouped Time Series Through Trace Minimization.” Journal of the American Statistical Association114 (526): 804–19.
71.
WongK. K. F.SongH.WittS. F.WuD. C.2007. “Tourism Forecasting: To Combine or Not to Combine?”Tourism Management28: 1068–78.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
