This study investigates the effect of regional trade agreements (RTAs)—including preferential and free trade agreements, customs unions, and common markets—on bilateral tourism flows. We explore these effects using a panel gravity data set of 163 destination countries, 171 source countries, and 13,589 country-pairs from 1995 to 2015. This is the first large cross-country study to undertake such an integrated analysis using the gravity framework. Results show that all types of RTAs have a positive and significant effect on bilateral tourism flows. The overall indicator of RTAs that captures the combined effect of all types of RTAs on bilateral tourism flows is also positive and significant, on average, as well as when different regions are separately evaluated. These findings underscore the importance of strong economic integration in fostering international tourism flows. Policies aimed at improving a country’s economic integration with other countries can help promote international tourism flows.
AdamsonF. B.2006. “Crossing Borders: International Migration and ‘National Security.’”International Security31 (1): 165–99.
2.
AndersonJ. E.YotovY. V.2016. “Terms of Trade and Global Efficiency Effects of Free Trade Agreements, 1990–2002.” Journal of International Economics99:279–98.
3.
BaierS. L.YotovY. V.ZylkinT.2019. “On the Widely Differing Effects of Free Trade Agreements: Lessons from Twenty Years of Trade Integration.” Journal of International Economics116:206–26.
4.
BeckenS.MahonR.RennieH. G.ShakeelaA. (2014). The tourism disaster vulnerability framework: An application to tourism in small island destinations. Natural Hazards71 (1): 955–972.
5.
BarbieriK.1996. “Economic Interdependence: A Path to Peace or a Source of ‘Interstate Conflict’?”Journal of Peace Research33 (1): 29–49.
6.
BlascoD.GuiaJ.PratsL.2014. “Emergence of Governance in Cross-Border Destinations.” Annals of Tourism Research49:159–73.
BrandiC.SchwabJ.BergerA.MorinJ.2020. “Do Environmental Provisions in Trade Agreements Make Exports from Developing Countries Greener?” World Development129:104899.
9.
BütheT.MilnerH. V.2008. “The Politics of Foreign Direct Investment into Developing Countries: Increasing FDI through ‘International Trade Agreements’?”American Journal of Political Science52 (4): 741–62.
10.
ButlerR. W.MaoB.1996. “Conceptual and Theoretical Implications of Tourism between Partitioned States.” Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research1 (1): 25–34.
11.
CaliendoL.ParroF.2015. “Estimates of the Trade and Welfare Effects of NAFTA.” Review of Economic Studies82 (1): 1–44.
12.
CarrèreC.2006. “Revisiting the Effects of Regional Trade Agreements on Trade Flows with Proper Specification of the Gravity Model.” European Economic Review50 (2): 223–47.
13.
ChangS.-C.LaiF.2011. “Intra-Continental and Intercontinental Service Trade in the Travel and ‘Tourism Industry.’” Tourism Economics17 (5): 963–82.
14.
ChiangM.-H.2019. “China–ASEAN Economic Relations after Establishment of Free Trade Area.” Pacific Review32 (3): 267–90.
15.
ChungM. G.HerzbergerA.FrankK. A.LiuJ.2020. “International Tourism Dynamics in a Globalized World: A Social Network Analysis Approach.” Journal of Travel Research59 (3): 387–403.
16.
CzaikaM.NeumayerE.2020. “On the Negative Impact of Time Zone Differences on International Tourism.” Current Issues in Tourism23 (10): 1181–85.
De HolanP. M.PhillipsN.1997. “Sun, Sand, and Hard Currency.” Annals of Tourism Research24 (4): 777–95.
19.
De SoyresF. M. M. R.MaireJ. L. Y.SubletG.2019. “An Empirical Investigation of Trade Diversion and Global Value Chains.” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper, vol. 9089.
20.
De VitaG.2014. “The Long-Run Impact of Exchange Rate Regimes on International Tourism Flows.” Tourism Management45:226–33.
21.
DiGiuseppeM.KleinbergK. B.2019. “Economics, Security, and Individual-Level Preferences for Trade Agreements.” International Interactions45 (2): 289–315.
22.
DropsyV.MontetC.PoirineB.2020. “Tourism, Insularity, and Remoteness: A Gravity-Based Approach.” Tourism Economics26 (5): 792–808.
23.
DwyerL.ForsythP.SpurrR.Van HoT.2006. “Economic Effects of the World Tourism Crisis on Australia.” Tourism Economics12 (2): 171–86.
FereidouniH. G.Al-mulaliU.2014. Current Issues in Tourism17 (2): 105–13.
26.
FreundC.OrnelasE.2010. “Regional Trade Agreements.” Annual Review of Economics2 (1): 139–166.
27.
GhaliaT.FidrmucJ.SamargandiN.SohagK.2019. “Institutional Quality, Political Risk and Tourism.” Tourism Management Perspectives32:100576.
28.
GholipourH. F.Al-mulaliU.MohammedA. H.2014. “Foreign Investments in Real Estate, Economic Growth and Property Prices: Evidence from OECD Countries.” Journal of Economic Policy Reform17 (1): 33–45.
29.
Gil-ParejaS.Llorca-ViveroR.Martínez-SerranoJ. A.2007. “The Effect of EMU on Tourism.” Review of International Economics15 (2): 302–12.
30.
GoldbergP. K.2019. “The Future of Trade: Policy Can Play a Role in Shaping the Future of the Ailing Multilateral Trade System.” Finance & Development56 (2).
31.
Gómez-HerreraE.2013. “Comparing Alternative Methods to Estimate Gravity Models of Bilateral Trade.” Empirical Economics44 (3): 1087–111.
32.
GreenawayD.MilnerC.2002. “Regionalism and ‘Gravity.’” Scottish Journal of Political Economy49 (5): 574–85.
33.
Hafner-BurtonE. M.2005. “Trading Human Rights: How Preferential Trade Agreements Influence Government Repression.” International Organization59 (3): 593–629.
34.
HarbG.BassilC.2020. “Gravity Analysis of Tourism Flows and the ‘Multilateral Resistance to Tourism.’”Current Issues in Tourism23 (6): 666–78.
35.
HeadK.MayerT.2014. “Gravity Equations: Workhorse, Toolkit, and Cookbook.” In Handbook of International Economics, 4th ed., chap. 3, edited by GopinathG.HelpmanE.RogoffK., 131–95. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier.
36.
HeadK.MayerT.RiesJ.2010. “The Erosion of Colonial Trade Linkages after Independence.” Journal of International Economics81 (1): 1–14.
37.
HjalagerA.-M.2007. “Stages in the Economic Globalization of Tourism.” Annals of Tourism Research34 (2): 437–57.
38.
IMF (International Monetary Fund). 2016. World Economic Outlook, October 2016. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
39.
KhalidU.OkaforL. E.AzizN.2020. “Armed Conflict, Military Expenditure and International Tourism.” Tourism Economics26 (4): 555–77.
40.
KhalidU.OkaforL. E.BurzynskaK.2021. “Does the Size of the Tourism sector Influence the Economic Policy Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic?”Current Issues in Tourism1–20.
41.
KhalidU.OkaforL. E.SanusiO. I.2021. “Exploring Diverse Sources of Linguistic Influence on International Tourism Flows.” Journal of Travel Research. Published online February 5. doi:10.1177/0047287520988909.
42.
KhalidU.OkaforL. E.ShafiullahM.2020. “The Effects of Economic and Financial Crises on International Tourist Flows: A Cross-Country Analysis.” Journal of Travel Research59 (2): 315–34.
43.
KhanH.TohR. S.ChuaL.2005. “Tourism and Trade: Cointegration and Granger Causality Tests.” Journal of Travel Research44 (2): 171–76.
44.
KimS. S.PrideauxB.TimothyD.2016. “Factors Affecting Bilateral Chinese and Japanese Travel.” Annals of Tourism Research61:80–95.
45.
KulendranN.WilsonK.2000. “Is There a Relationship between International Trade and International Travel?” Applied Economics32 (8): 1001–9.
46.
KumarM.PrasharS.JanaR.2019. “Does International Tourism Spur International Trade and Output? Evidence from Wavelet Analysis.” Tourism Economics25 (1): 22–33.
47.
LordeT.LiG.AireyD.2016. “Modeling Caribbean Tourism Demand: An Augmented Gravity Approach.” Journal of Travel Research55 (7): 946–56.
48.
ManosuthiN.LeeJ.-S.HanH.2020. “Impact of Distance on the Arrivals, Behaviours and Attitudes of International Tourists in Hong Kong: A Longitudinal Approach.” Tourism Management78:103963.
49.
MartinP.MayerT.ThoenigM.2012. “The Geography of Conflicts and Regional Trade Agreements.” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics4 (4): 1–35.
50.
MartinsL. F.GanY.Ferreira-LopesA.2017. “An Empirical Analysis of the Influence of Macroeconomic Determinants on World Tourism Demand.” Tourism Management61:248–60.
51.
McKercherB.DecostaP. L. E.2007. “Research Report: The Lingering Effect of Colonialism on Tourist Movements.” Tourism Economics13 (3): 453–74.
52.
MedvedevD.2012. “Beyond Trade: The Impact of Preferential Trade Agreements on FDI Inflows.” World Development40 (1): 49–61.
53.
MorleyC.RossellóJ.Santana-GallegoM.2014. “Gravity Models for Tourism Demand: Theory and Use.” Annals of Tourism Research48:1–10.
54.
NaipaulS.WangY.OkumusF.2009. “Regional Destination Marketing: A Collaborative Approach.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing26 (5/6): 462–81.
55.
NesaduraiH. E. S.2013. “Malaysia’s Conflict with the Philippines and Indonesia over Labour Migration: Economic Security, Interdependence and Conflict Trajectories.” Pacific Review26 (1): 89–113.
56.
OkaforL. E.2020. “Export Market Destinations, Imported Intermediates, and Productivity: Firm-Level Evidence from Ghana.” International Trade Journal1–28.
57.
OkaforL. E.AdeolaO.FolarinO.2021a. “Natural Disasters, Geography, and International Tourism.” In Economic Effects of Natural Disasters, edited by ChaiechiT., 55–76. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
58.
OkaforL. E.AdeolaO.FolarinO.2021b. “Natural Disasters, Trade Openness and International Tourism: The Role of Income Levels across Countries.” Tourism Recreation Research. Published online March 8. doi:10.1080/02508281.2021.1891740.
59.
OkaforL. E.KhalidU.2021. “Regaining International Tourism Attractiveness after an Armed Conflict: The Role of Security Spending.” Current Issues in Tourism24 (3): 385–402.
60.
OkaforL. E.KhalidU.AdeolaO.2021. “The Effect of Regional Trade Agreements on International Tourist Flows in the Middle East and Africa.” In New Frontiers in Hospitality and Tourism Management in Africa, edited by NgoasongMichael ZAdeolaOgechiKimbuAlbert NHinsonRobert E 245–62. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
61.
OkaforL. E.KhalidU.BurzynskaK.2021. “The Effect of Migration on International Tourism Flows: The Role of Linguistic Networks and Common Languages.” Journal of Travel Research. Published online April 27. doi:10.1177/00472875211008250.
62.
OkaforL. E.KhalidU.ThenT.2018. “Common Unofficial Language, Development and International Tourism.” Tourism Management67:127–38.
63.
OkaforL. E.TeoW. L.2019. “2018 WTO Trade Policy Review of Malaysia.” World Economy42 (12): 3447–63.
64.
OnganS.GocerI.2020. “The Causal Relationships between International Trade and International Tourism in NAFTA Countries: Applications of Time and Frequency Domain Approaches.” International Trade Journal34 (3): 319–38.
65.
ParamatiS. R.AlamM. S.LauC. K. M.2018. “The Effect of Tourism Investment on Tourism Development and CO2 Emissions: Empirical Evidence from the EU Nations.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism26 (9): 1587–607.
66.
PengB.SongH.CrouchG. I.WittS. F.2015. “A Meta-analysis of International Tourism Demand Elasticities.” Journal of Travel Research54 (5): 611–33.
67.
PetersonT. M.2015. “Insiders versus Outsiders: Preferential Trade Agreements, Trade Distortions, and Militarized Conflict.” Journal of Conflict Resolution59 (4): 698–727.
68.
PineR.McKercherB.2004. “The Impact of SARS on Hong Kong’s Tourism Industry.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management16 (2): 139–43.
ProkkolaE.-K.2010. “Borders in Tourism: The Transformation of the Swedish–Finnish Border Landscape.” Current Issues in Tourism13 (3): 223–38.
71.
RodríguezC.BustilloR.2010. “Modelling Foreign Real Estate Investment: The Spanish Case.” Journal of Real Estate Finance & Economics41 (3): 354–67.
72.
RomalisJ.2007. “NAFTA’s and CUSFTA’s Impact on International Trade.” Review of Economics & Statistics89 (3): 416–35.
73.
SaaymanA.FiginiP.CassellaS.2016. “The Influence of Formal Trade Agreements and Informal Economic Cooperation on International Tourism Flows.” Tourism Economics22 (6): 1274–300.
Santana-GallegoM.Ledesma-RodríguezF.Pérez-RodríguezJ. V.2011. “Tourism and Trade in OECD Countries. A Dynamic Heterogeneous Panel Data Analysis.” Empirical Economics41 (2): 533–54.
76.
Santana-GallegoM.Ledesma-RodríguezF.Pérez-RodríguezJ.2016a. “The Euro Effect: Tourism Creation, Tourism Diversion and Tourism Potential within the European Union.” European Union Politics17 (1): 46–68.
77.
Santana-GallegoM.Ledesma-RodríguezF. J.Pérez-RodríguezJ. V.2016b. “International Trade and Tourism Flows: an Extension of the Gravity Model.” Economic Modelling52:1026–33.
78.
Santana-GallegoM.Ledesma-RodríguezF. J.Pérez-RodríguezJ. V.Cortés-JiménezI.2010. “Does a Common Currency Promote Countries’ Growth via Trade and Tourism?”. World Economy33 (12): 1811–35.
79.
ShafiullahMuhammadOkaforLuke EmekaKhalidUsman. 2019. “Determinants of International Tourism Demand: Evidence from Australian States and Territories.”Tourism Economics25 (2): 274–96.
80.
SongH.LiG.CaoZ.2018. “Tourism and Economic Globalization: an Emerging Research Agenda.” Journal of Travel Research57 (8): 999–1011.
81.
SönmezS. F.1998. “Tourism, Terrorism, and Political Instability.” Annals of Tourism Research25 (2): 416–56.
82.
TangS.SelvanathanE. A.SelvanathanS.2007. “The Relationship between Foreign Direct Investment and Tourism: Empirical Evidence from China.” Tourism Economics13 (1): 25–39.
83.
TosunC.TimothyD. J.ParpairisA.MacdonaldD.2005. “Cross-Border Cooperation in Tourism Marketing Growth Strategies.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing18 (1): 5–23.
84.
VučetićA.2008. “Impact of Tourism Policy on Development of Selective Tourism.” Selective Tourism3:4–17.
85.
Waqas-AwanA.Rosselló-NadalJ.Santana-GallegoM.2020. “New Insights into the Role of Personal Income on International Tourism.” Journal of Travel Research60 (4): 799–809.
86.
WebsterC.TimothyD. J.2006. “Travelling to the ‘Other Side’: the Occupied Zone and Greek Cypriot Views of Crossing the Green Line.” Tourism Geographies8 (2): 162–81.
87.
World Bank. 2019. World Bank Development Indicators. Washington, DC: Worls Bank.
XuL.WangS.LiJ.TangL.ShaoY.2019. “Modelling International Tourism Flows to China: A Panel Data Analysis with the Gravity Model.” Tourism Economics25 (7): 1047–69.
91.
YangY.LiuH.LiX.2019. “The World Is Flatter? Examining the Relationship between Cultural Distance and International Tourist Flows.” Journal of Travel Research58 (2): 224–40.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
