This article takes advantage of the designation of top tourist cities in China to estimate the impact of quality disclosure on the city tourism economy. According to theories regarding quality disclosure and certification, we develop a tourism promotion hypothesis for the designation, which is then tested with panel data from China’s 284 prefectural-level cities between 2000 and 2015. The difference-in-differences approach shows that gaining the designation increases both domestic and inbound tourism revenues, which is robust to various specifications. Heterogeneity analysis shows that the tourism promotion effect only persists for about three years, decreases over time, is smaller in developed areas, and is less salient for multiple or county-level designations.
AbrateGrazianoCaprielloAntonellaFraquelliGiovanni. 2011. “When Quality Signals Talk: Evidence from the Turin Hotel Industry.” Tourism Management32 (4): 912–21.
2.
AkerlofGeorge A.1970. “The Market for ‘Lemons’: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics84 (3): 488–500.
3.
AlbalateDanielCamposJavierJiménezJuan Luis. 2017. “Tourism and High Speed Rail in Spain: Does the AVE Increase Local Visitors?” Annals of Tourism Research65:71–82.
4.
AlbalateDanielFagedaXavier. 2016. “High Speed Rail and Tourism: Empirical Evidence from Spain.” Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice85:174–85.
5.
AlbanoGian LuigiLizzeriAlessandro. 2001. “Strategic Certification and Provision of Quality.” International Economic Review42 (1): 267–83.
6.
AngristJoshua D.PischkeJörn-Steffen. 2014. Mastering ‘metrics: The Path from Cause to Effect. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
7.
ArnottRichard J.StiglitzJoseph E.1988. “The Basic Analytics of Moral Hazard.” Scandinavian Journal of Economics90 (3): 383–413.
8.
ArrowKenneth J.1963. “Uncertainty and the Welfare Economics of Medical Care.” American Economic Review53 (5): 941–73.
9.
AshenfelterOrley. 1978. “Estimating the Effect of Training Programs on Earnings.” Review of Economics and Statistics60 (1): 47–57.
10.
AuriolEmmanuelleSchilizziSteven G. M.2015. “Quality Signaling through Certification in Developing Countries.” Journal of Development Economics116:105–21.
11.
AutorDavid H.2003. “Outsourcing at Will: The Contribution of Unjust Dismissal Doctrine to the Growth of Employment Outsourcing.” Journal of Labor Economics21 (1): 1–42.
12.
BakaVasiliki. 2016. “The Becoming of User-Generated Reviews: Looking at the Past to Understand the Future of Managing Reputation in the Travel Sector.” Tourism Management53:148–62.
13.
Bar-IsaacHeskiCaruanaGuillermoCuñatVicente. 2007. “Information Gathering Externalities in Product Markets.” EC-07-19. NYU Working Paper. New York: New York University Working Paper.
14.
BeckerBoMilbournTodd. 2011. “How Did Increased Competition Affect Credit Ratings?” Journal of Financial Economics101 (3): 493–514.
15.
BennearLori S.OlmsteadSheila M.2008. “The Impacts of the ‘Right to Know’: Information Disclosure and the Violation of Drinking Water Standards.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management56 (2): 117–30.
16.
BoardOliver. 2009. “Competition and Disclosure.” Journal of Industrial Economics57 (1): 197–213.
17.
BoltonPatrickFreixasXavierShapiroJoel. 2012. “The Credit Ratings Game.” Journal of Finance67 (1): 85–111.
18.
BuckleyRalf. 2004. “The Effects of World Heritage Listing on Tourism to Australian National Parks.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism12 (1): 70–84.
19.
CardDavidKruegerAlan B.1994. “Minimum Wages and Employment: A Case Study of the Fast-Food Industry in New Jersey and Pennsylvania.” American Economic Review84 (4): 772.
CelliniRoberto. 2011. “Is UNESCO Recognition Effective in Fostering Tourism? A Comment on Yang, Lin and Han.” Tourism Management32 (2): 452–54.
22.
ChenZhenhuaHaynesKingsley E.2015. “Impact of High-Speed Rail on International Tourism Demand in China.” Applied Economics Letters22 (1): 57–60.
23.
ClineSarah A.WeilerStephanAydinAyse. 2011. “The Value of a Name: Estimating the Economic Impact of Public Land Designation.” Social Science Journal48 (4): 681–92.
24.
CNTA (China National Tourism Administration). 1998a. Current Management Methods on Designating China’s Top Tourist Cities. Beijing: China National Tourism Administration.
25.
CNTA (China National Tourism Administration). 1998b. “Inspection Criteria for China’s Top Tourist Cities.” Beijing.
26.
CNTA (China National Tourism Administration). 2016. The Yearbook of China Tourism Statistics 2016. Beijing: China Travel and Tourism Press.
27.
CucciaTizianaGuccioCalogeroRizzoIlde. 2016. “The Effects of UNESCO World Heritage List Inscription on Tourism Destinations Performance in Italian Regions.” Economic Modelling53:494–508.
28.
DafnyLeemoreDranoveDavid. 2008. “Do Report Cards Tell Consumers Anything They Don’t Already Know? The Case of Medicare HMOs.” RAND Journal of Economics39 (3): 790–821.
29.
DengTaotaoHuYukunMaMulan. 2019. “Regional Policy and Tourism: A Quasi-natural Experiment.” Annals of Tourism Research74:1–16.
30.
De SimoneElinaCanaleRosaria RitaDi MaioAmedeo. 2019. “Do UNESCO World Heritage Sites Influence International Tourist Arrivals? Evidence from Italian Provincial Data.” Social Indicators Research146:345–59.
31.
DogruTarikBulutUmit. 2018. “Is Tourism an Engine for Economic Recovery? Theory and Empirical Evidence.” Tourism Management67:425–34.
32.
DranoveDavidJinGinger Zhe. 2010. “Quality Disclosure and Certification: Theory and Practice.” Journal of Economic Literature48 (4): 935–63.
33.
DranoveDavidKesslerDanielMcClellanMarkSatterthwaiteMark. 2003. “Is More Information Better? The Effects of ‘Report Cards’ on Health Care Providers.” Journal of Political Economy111 (3): 555–88.
34.
DredgeDianne. 2004. “Development, Economy and Culture: Cultural Heritage Tourism Planning, Liangzhu, China.” Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research9 (4): 405–22.
35.
FreyBruno S.SteinerLasse. 2011. “World Heritage List: Does It Make Sense?” International Journal of Cultural Policy17 (5): 555–73.
36.
GaoYanyanSuWei. 2019. “Is the World Heritage Just a Title for Tourism?” Annals of Tourism Research78:102748.
37.
GaoYanyanSuWeiWangKaini. 2019. “Does High-Speed Rail Boost Tourism Growth? New Evidence from China.” Tourism Management 72 (June): 220–31.
38.
GaoYanyanSuWeiZangLeizhen. 2018. “Quality Accreditation to Tourist Attractions and the Development of Regional Tourism Economy: An Empirical Study from China.” 3404843. SSRN Working Paper Series. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3404843.
39.
Gómez-VegaMafaldaPicazo-TadeoAndrés J.2019. “Ranking World Tourist Destinations with a Composite Indicator of Competitiveness: To Weigh or Not to Weigh?” Tourism Management72:281–91.
40.
GrossmanSanford J.1981. “The Informational Role of Warranties and Private Disclosure about Product Quality.” Journal of Law and Economics24 (3): 461–83.
HastingsJustine S.WeinsteinJeffrey M.2008. “Information, School Choice, and Academic Achievement: Evidence from Two Experiments.” Quarterly Journal of Economics123 (4): 1329–72.
43.
HolzCarsten A.2014. “The Quality of China’s GDP Statistics.” China Economic Review30:309–38.
44.
HuangChia-HuiTsaurJen-RueyYangChih-Hai. 2012. “Does World Heritage List Really Induce More Tourists? Evidence from Macau.” Tourism Management33 (6): 1450–57.
45.
JiangJingxianGretzelUlrikeLawRob. 2014. “Influence of Star Rating and Ownership Structure on Brand Image of Mainland China Hotels.” Journal of China Tourism Research10 (1): 69–94.
46.
JimuraTakamitsu. 2011. “The Impact of World Heritage Site Designation on Local Communities—A Case Study of Ogimachi, Shirakawa-Mura, Japan.” Tourism Management32 (2): 288–96.
47.
JinGinger ZheLeeJungmin. 2014. “Inspection Technology, Detection, and Compliance: Evidence from Florida Restaurant Inspections.” RAND Journal of Economics45 (4): 885–917.
48.
JinGinger ZheLesliePhillip. 2003. “The Effect of Information on Product Quality: Evidence from Restaurant Hygiene Grade Cards.” Quarterly Journal of Economics118 (2): 409–51.
49.
JinGinger ZheSorensenAlan T.2006. “Information and Consumer Choice: The Value of Publicized Health Plan Ratings.” Journal of Health Economics25 (2): 248–75.
50.
JinHehuiQianYingyiWeingastBarry R.2005. “Regional Decentralization and Fiscal Incentives: Federalism, Chinese Style.” Journal of Public Economics89 (9/10): 1719–42.
51.
JohnsonPeter A.SieberRenee E.MagnienNicolasAriwiJoseph. 2012. “Automated Web Harvesting to Collect and Analyse User-Generated Content for Tourism.” Current Issues in Tourism15 (3): 293–99.
52.
JovanovicBoyan. 1982. “Truthful Disclosure of Information.” Bell Journal of Economics13 (36): 44.
53.
KimHyounggonOhChi-OkLeeSangkwonLeeSoojin. 2018. “Assessing the Economic Values of World Heritage Sites and the Effects of Perceived Authenticity on Their Values.” International Journal of Tourism Research20 (1): 126–36.
54.
LeeChien-ChiangChangChun-Ping. 2008. “Tourism Development and Economic Growth: A Closer Look at Panels.” Tourism Management29 (1): 180–92.
55.
LuZhenZhuF.2006. “The Post-Purchase Evaluation of the China’s Star Rated Hotel Service Quality: A Content Analysis of Guest Comments on Third Party Hotel Booking Websites.” Journal of China Tourism Research2 (1/2): 93–103.
MarchioriE.CantoniL.2011. “The Online Reputation Construct: Does It Matter for the Tourism Domain? A Literature Review on Destinations’ Online Reputation.” Information Technology & Tourism13 (3): 139–59.
58.
MarianiMarcello M.GuizzardiAndrea. 2020. “Does Designation as a UNESCO World Heritage Site Influence Tourist Evaluation of a Local Destination?” Journal of Travel Research59 (1): 22–36.
59.
Martin-FuentesEva. 2016. “Are Guests of the Same Opinion as the Hotel Star-Rate Classification System?” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management29:126–34.
60.
MassiddaCarlaEtzoIvan. 2012. “The Determinants of Italian Domestic Tourism: A Panel Data Analysis.” Tourism Management33 (3): 603–10.
61.
MathisJeromeMcAndrewsJamesRochetJean-Charles. 2009. “Rating the Raters: Are Reputation Concerns Powerful Enough to Discipline Rating Agencies?” Journal of Monetary Economics56 (5): 657–74.
62.
MatthewsStevenPostlewaiteAndrew. 1985. “Quality Testing and Disclosure.” RAND Journal of Economics16 (3): 328–40.
63.
MayerMarius. 2014. “Can Nature-Based Tourism Benefits Compensate for the Costs of National Parks? A Study of the Bavarian Forest National Park, Germany.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism22 (4): 561–83.
64.
MayerMariusMüllerMartinWolteringManuelArneggerJuliusJobHubert. 2010. “The Economic Impact of Tourism in Six German National Parks.” Landscape and Urban Planning97 (2): 73–82.
65.
ParkSangwonNicolauJuan L.2015. “Asymmetric Effects of Online Consumer Reviews.” Annals of Tourism Research50:67–83.
66.
PatuelliRobertoMussoniMaurizioCandelaGuido. 2013. “The Effects of World Heritage Sites on Domestic Tourism: A Spatial Interaction Model for Italy.” Journal of Geographical Systems15 (3): 369–402.
67.
PineRayPhillipsPaul. 2005. “Performance Comparisons of Hotels in China.” International Journal of Hospitality Management24 (1): 57–73.
68.
PrendergastCanice. 2007. “The Motivation and Bias of Bureaucrats.” American Economic Review97 (1): 180–96.
69.
ReiniusSandra WallFredmanPeter. 2007. “Protected Areas as Attractions.” Annals of Tourism Research34 (4): 839–54.
70.
SequeiraTiago NevesMaçãs NunesPaulo. 2008. “Does Tourism Influence Economic Growth? A Dynamic Panel Data Approach.” Applied Economics40 (18): 2431–41.
SuYu-WenLinHui-Lin. 2014. “Analysis of International Tourist Arrivals Worldwide: The Role of World Heritage Sites.” Tourism Management40:46–58.
73.
WangZhaoguoYangZhaopingWallGeofferyXuXiaoliangHanFangDuXishihuiLiuQun. 2015. “Is It Better for a Tourist Destination to Be a World Heritage Site? Visitors’ Perspectives on the Inscription of Kanas on the World Heritage List in China.” Journal for Nature Conservation23:19–26.
74.
XiaoMo. 2010. “Is Quality Accreditation Effective? Evidence from the Childcare Market.” International Journal of Industrial Organization28 (6): 708–21.
75.
YangChih-HaiLinHui-LinHanChia-Chun. 2010. “Analysis of International Tourist Arrivals in China: The Role of World Heritage Sites.” Tourism Management31 (6): 827–37.
76.
YangYangXueLanJonesThomas E. 2019. “Tourism-Enhancing Effect of World Heritage Sites: Panacea or Placebo? A Meta-Analysis.” Annals of Tourism Research75:29–41.
77.
YangZhenshanCaiJianming. 2016. “Do Regional Factors Matter? Determinants of Hotel Industry Performance in China.” Tourism Management52:242–53.
78.
Zhan-QingLiuLiuJuanita C. 1993. “Assessment of the Hotel Rating System in China.” Tourism Management14 (6): 440–52.
79.
ZhangTaoZouHeng-fu. 1998. “Fiscal Decentralization, Public Spending, and Economic Growth in China.” Journal of Public Economics67 (2): 221–40.
80.
ZhangXiaobo. 2006. “Fiscal Decentralization and Political Centralization in China: Implications for Growth and Inequality.” Journal of Comparative Economics34 (4): 713–26.
81.
ZhangZiqiongZhangZiliYangYang. 2016. “The Power of Expert Identity: How Website-Recognized Expert Reviews Influence Travelers’ Online Rating Behavior.” Tourism Management55:15–24.
82.
ZhouLi-An. 2007. “Governing China’s Local Officials: An Analysis of Promotion Tournament Model (in Chinese).” Economic Research Journal7:36–50.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
