Using the “Computers are social actors” paradigm, this study brings the concept of power to human–computer interactions in tourism. Building on theories of social power and deliberate practice, the authors examine psychological effects of expert power of online travel review platforms (influencer) and its interaction effects with the power of users (influenced). Two expert platform attributes are conceptualized: specialization and experience. A significant interaction effect was identified between platform specialization, platform experience, and user power on perceived information-task fit using a 2 × 2 × 2 between-subjects experiment. When users are powerful, specialization affected perceived information-task fit for low-experience platforms; no significant effect was evident for high experience platforms. When users are powerless, specialization did not affect perceived information-task fit, regardless of experience condition. Perceived information-task fit mediated the effect of specialization on intention to use. The findings contribute to power discourses by exploring the workings of expert power.
AlaeiA. R.BeckenS.StanticB.2019. “Sentiment Analysis in Tourism: Capitalizing on Big Data.” Journal of Travel Research58 (2): 175–91.
2.
AndersonC.JohnO. P.KeltnerD.2012. “The Personal Sense of Power.” Journal of Personality80 (2): 313–44.
3.
AyehJ. K.AuN.LawR.2013. ““Do We Believe in TripAdvisor?” Examining Credibility Perceptions and Online Travelers’ Attitude toward Using User-Generated Content.” Journal of Travel Research52 (4): 437–52.
4.
BriñolP.PettyR. E.StavrakiM.2012. “Power Increases the Reliance on First-Impression Thoughts.” Revista de Psicología Social27 (3): 293–303.
5.
BuhalisD.LawR.2008. “Progress in Information Technology and Tourism Management: 20 Years on and 10 Years after the Internet—The State of eTourism Research.” Tourism Management29 (4): 609–23.
6.
BuhrmesterM.KwangT.GoslingS. D.2011. “Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: A New Source of Inexpensive, yet High-Quality, Data?” Perspectives on Psychological Science6 (1): 3–5.
7.
CarnabuciG.BruggemanJ.2009. “Knowledge Specialization, Knowledge Brokerage and the Uneven Growth of Technology Domains.” Social Forces88 (2): 607–41.
8.
CaslerK.BickelL.HackettE.2013. “Separate but Equal? A Comparison of Participants and Data Gathered via Amazon’s MTurk, Social Media, and Face-to-Face Behavioral Testing.” Computers in Human Behavior29 (6): 2156–60.
9.
ChatainO.ZemskyP.2007. “The Horizontal Scope of the Firm: Organizational Tradeoffs vs. Buyer-Supplier Relationships.” Management Science53 (4): 550–65.
10.
ChenL.GillensonM. L.SherrellD. L.2002. “Enticing Online Consumers: An Extended Technology Acceptance Perspective.” Information & Management39 (8): 705–19.
11.
ChoiC.MattilaA. S.2016. “The Effects of Other Customers’ Dress Style on Customers’ Approach Behaviors: The Moderating Role of Sense of Power.” Cornell Hospitality Quarterly57 (2): 211–18.
12.
ChoiS.MattilaA. S.Van HoofH. B.Quadri-FelittiD.2016. “The Role of Power and Incentives in Inducing Fake Reviews in the Tourism Industry.” Journal of Travel Research56 (8): 975–87.
13.
ChoiY.HickersonB.KerstetterD.2018. “Understanding the Sources of Online Travel Information.” Journal of Travel Research57 (1): 116–28.
14.
ChungN.HanH.KooC.2015. “Adoption of Travel Information in User-Generated Content on Social Media: The Moderating Effect of Social Presence.” Behaviour and Information Technology34 (9): 902–19.
DedekeA.2016. “Travel Web-Site Design: Information Task-Fit, Service Quality and Purchase Intention.” Tourism Management54:541–54.
17.
DuboisD.RuckerD. D.GalinskyA. D.2011. “Super Size Me: Product Size as a Signal of Status.” Journal of Consumer Research38 (6): 1047–62.
18.
EricssonK. A.2004. “Deliberate Practice and the Acquisition and Maintenance of Expert Performance in Medicine and Related Domains.” Academic Medicine79 (10): S70–81.
19.
EricssonK. A.KrampeR. T.Tesch-RömerC.1993. “The Role of Deliberate Practice in the Acquisition of Expert Performance.” Psychological Review100 (3): 363–406.
20.
FotisJ.BuhalisD.RossidesN.2012. “Social Media Use and Impact during the Holiday Travel Planning Process.” In Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2012, edited by M.FuchsRicciF.CantoniL., 13–24. Vienna: Springer.
21.
FrenchJ. R. P.RavenB.1959. “The Bases of Social Power.” In Studies of Social Power, edited by D.Cartwright, 150–57. Ann Arbor, MI: Institute for Social Research.
22.
GalinskyA. D.GruenfeldD. H.MageeJ. C.2003. “From Power to Action.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology85 (3): 453–66.
23.
GeorgesenJ. C.HarrisM. J.1998. “Why’s My Boss Always Holding Me Down? A Meta-analysis of Power Effects on Performance Evaluations.” Personality and Social Psychology Review2 (3): 184–95.
24.
GompersP.KovnerA.LernerJ.2009. “Specialization and Success: Evidence from Venture Capital.” Journal of Economics and Management Strategy18 (3): 817–44.
25.
GoodhueD. L.ThompsonR. L.1995. “Task-Technology Fit and Individual Performance.” MIS Quarterly19 (2): 213–36.
26.
HarrisL. C.GoodeM. M.2010. “Online Servicescapes, Trust, and Purchase Intentions.” Journal of Services Marketing24 (3): 230–43.
27.
HaugaardM.2002. Power: A Reader. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
28.
HauserD. J.SchwarzN.2016. “Attentive Turkers: MTurk Participants Perform Better on Online Attention Checks Than Do Subject Pool Participants.” Behavior Research Methods48 (1): 400–7.
29.
HayesA. F.2013. Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach. New York: Guilford.
30.
JacobyJ.TroutmanT.KussA.MazurskyD.1986. “Experience and Expertise in Complex Decision Making.” Advances in Consumer Research13 (1): 469–72.
31.
JaspersonJ. S.CarteT. A.SaundersC. S.ButlerB. S.CroesH. J.ZhengW.2002. “Power and Information Technology Research: A Metatriangulation Review.” MIS Quarterly26 (4): 397–459.
32.
KimY.2018. “Power Moderates the Impact of Desire for Exclusivity on Luxury Experiential Consumption.” Psychology and Marketing35 (4): 283–93.
33.
KohY. J.SundarS. S.2010a. “Effects of Specialization in Computers, Web Sites, and Web Agents on E-commerce Trust.” International Journal of Human-Computer Studies68 (12): 899–912.
34.
KohY. J.SundarS. S.2010b. “Heuristic versus Systematic Processing of Specialist versus Generalist Sources in Online media.” Human Communication Research36 (2): 103–24.
35.
Kurz-MilckeE.GigerenzerG.2004. Experts in Science and Society. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
36.
LeeY. K.ParkJ. H.ChungN.BlakeneyA.2012. “A Unified Perspective on the Factors Influencing Usage Intention toward Mobile Financial Services.” Journal of Business Research65 (11): 1590–99.
37.
LeungD.LawR.van HoofH.BuhalisD.2013. “Social Media in Tourism and Hospitality: A Literature Review.” Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing30 (1/2): 3–22.
38.
LimY. S.YooE. E.2012. “TripAdvisor.com vs. NYCGO.com: Evaluation of Functional Components of Generalist and Specialist Tourism Websites.” In Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2012, edited by M.FuchsRicciF.CantoniL., 120–31. Vienna: Springer.
39.
LiuH.WuL.LiX.2019. “Social Media Envy: How Experience Sharing on Social Networking Sites Drives Millennials’ Aspirational Tourism Consumption.” Journal of Travel Research58 (3): 355–69.
40.
LiuS. Q.MattilaA. S.2017. “Airbnb: Online Targeted Advertising, Sense of Power, and Consumer Decisions.” International Journal of Hospitality Management60:33–41.
41.
LiuX.MehraliyevF.LiuC.SchuckertM.2019. “The Roles of Social Media in Tourists’ Choices of Travel Components.” Tourist Studies. Published online September 3. doi:10.1177/1468797619873107.
42.
LoiaconoE. T.WatsonR. T.GoodhueD. L.2002. “WebQual: A Measure of Website Quality.” Marketing Theory and Applications13 (3): 432–38.
43.
LuiT. W.BartosiakM.PiccoliG.SadhyaV.2018. “Online Review Response Strategy and Its Effects on Competitive Performance.” Tourism Management67:180–90.
44.
Luna-CortésG.López-BonillaJ. M.López-BonillaL. M.2019. “Self-Congruity, Social Value, and the Use of Virtual Social Networks by Generation Y Travelers.” Journal of Travel Research58 (3): 398–410.
45.
MacleodD. V.2010. “Power, Culture and the Production of Heritage.” In Tourism, Power and Culture: Anthropological Insights, edited by D. V.MacleodCarrierJ. G., 64–89. Bristol: Channel View.
46.
MageeJ. C.GalinskyA. D.GruenfeldD. H.2007. “Power, Propensity to Negotiate, and Moving First in Competitive Interactions.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin33 (2): 200–12.
47.
MakarevichA.2018. “Ties of Survival: Specialization, Inter-Firm Ties, and Firm Failure in the US Venture Capital Industry.” Journal of Business Research86 (C): 153–65.
48.
MehraliyevF.ChoiY.KoseogluM. A.2019. “Social Structure of Social Media Research in Tourism and Hospitality.” Tourism Recreation Research44 (4): 451–65.
MunarA. M.JacobsenJ. K. S.2013. “Trust and Involvement in Tourism Social Media and Web-Based Travel Information Sources.” Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism13 (1): 1–19.
51.
MurphyH. C.ChenM. M.2016. “Online Information Sources Used in Hotel Bookings: Examining Relevance and Recall.” Journal of Travel Research55 (4): 523–36.
52.
NassC.MoonY.2000. “Machines and Mindlessness: Social Responses to Computers.” Journal of Social Issues56 (1): 81–103.
53.
NeuhoferB.BuhalisD.LadkinA.2015. “Smart Technologies for Personalized Experiences: A Case Study in the Hospitality Domain.” Electronic Markets25 (3): 243–54.
54.
NgaiE. W. T.TaoS. S. C.MoonK. K. L.2015. “Social Media Research: Theories, Constructs, and Conceptual Frameworks.” International Journal of Information Management35 (1): 33–44.
55.
O’ConnorP.2010. “Managing a Hotel’s Image on TripAdvisor.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management19 (7): 754–72.
56.
PaolacciG.ChandlerJ.IpeirotisP. G.2010. “Running Experiments on Amazon Mechanical Turk.” Judgment and Decision Making5 (5): 411–19.
57.
PhillipsP.BarnesS.ZiganK.ScheggR.2017. “Understanding the Impact of Online Reviews on Hotel Performance: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Travel Research56 (2): 235–49.
58.
PrasadS.2009. “Task Assignments and Incentives: Generalists versus Specialists.” Rand Journal of Economics40 (2): 380–403.
59.
RavenB. H.FrenchJ. R.1958. “Legitimate Power, Coercive Power, and Observability in Social Influence.” Sociometry21 (2): 83–97.
60.
ReevesB.NassC. I.1996. The Media Equation: How People Treat Computers, Television, and New Media Like Real People and Places. Stanford: CSLI.
RuckerD. D.DuboisD.GalinskyA. D.2010. “Generous Paupers and Stingy Princes: Power Drives Consumer Spending on Self versus Others.” Journal of Consumer Research37 (6): 1015–29.
63.
RuckerD. D.GalinskyA. D.DuboisD.2012. “Power and Consumer Behavior: How Power Shapes Who and What Consumers Value.” Journal of Consumer Psychology22 (3): 352–68.
64.
RussellB.1938. A New Social Analysis. London: George Allen & Unwin.
65.
SahY. J.YooB.SundarS. S.2011. “Are Specialist Robots Better Than Generalist Robots?” Paper presented at the International Conference on Human-Robot Interaction, Lausanne, Switzerland, March 6–9.
66.
SawaokaT.HughesB. L.AmbadyN.2015. “Power Heightens Sensitivity to Unfairness against the Self.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin41 (8): 1023–35.
67.
SchuckertM.LiuX. W.LawR.2015. “Hospitality and Tourism Online Reviews: Recent Trends and Future Directions.” Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing32 (5): 608–21.
68.
SmithP. K.TropeY.2006. “You Focus on the Forest When You’re in Charge of the Trees: Power Priming and Abstract Information Processing.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology90 (4): 578–96.
69.
SparksB. A.BrowningV.2011. “The Impact of Online Reviews on Hotel Booking Intentions and Perception of Trust.” Tourism Management32 (6): 1310–23.
70.
SundarS. S.NassC.2001. “Conceptualizing Sources in Online News.” Journal of Communication51 (1): 52–72.
71.
TsaoW. C.HsiehM. T.ShihL. W.LinT. M. Y.2015. “Compliance with eWOM: The Influence of Hotel Reviews on Booking Intention from the Perspective of Consumer Conformity.” International Journal of Hospitality Management46:99–111.
72.
TsengV.SeidmanE.2007. “A Systems Framework for Understanding Social Settings.” American Journal of Community Psychology39 (3/4): 217–28.
73.
UllénF.HambrickD. Z.MosingM. A.2016. “Rethinking Expertise: A Multifactorial Gene–Environment Interaction Model of Expert Performance.” Psychological Bulletin142 (4): 427–46.
74.
WangS.LehtoX.2019. “The Interplay of Travelers’ Psychological Distance, Language Abstraction, and Message Appeal Type in Social Media Advertising.” Journal of Travel Research. Published online October 24. doi:10.1177/0047287519880000.
75.
ZhangL.2015. “Online Reviews: The Impact of Power and Incidental Similarity.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management24 (6): 633–51.
76.
ZhangL.HanksL.2015. “Unearned Preferential Treatment: The Moderating Role of Power.” Cornell Hospitality Quarterly56 (3): 309–19.
77.
ZhangY.FengX.WuY.XiaoJ.2018. “The Dynamics of Online Ratings with Heterogeneous Preferences in Online Review Platform.” Chaos, Solitons and Fractals109:26–30.
78.
ZhangZ. Q.ZhangZ. L.YangY.2016. “The Power of Expert Identity: How Website-Recognized Expert Reviews Influence Travelers’ Online Rating Behavior.” Tourism Management55:15–24.
