Tourists searching for information about destinations on online review sites are concurrently exposed to two different photograph aesthetics, professional (produced by destination managers) and amateur (generated by travelers). While the former is glossy and sharp, the latter is often grainy and overexposed. Although aesthetics are important factors in tourist decision making, the effects of the exposure to both types of photograph aesthetics remain largely unexamined. This research investigates how both types of aesthetics, either singularly or in combination, affect a destination’s visual appeal and tourists’ booking intentions through four controlled experiments (N = 1,282). Our results show that despite the “messy” beauty in amateur aesthetics, photos with professional aesthetics make a depicted destination appear more visually appealing, ultimately driving booking intentions. However, the negative effects of amateur aesthetics are mitigated when (1) viewed by risk-averse tourists, (2) presented alongside positive reviews, and (3) accompanied by a greater number of professional photos.
AlfakhriDemahHarnessDavidNicholsonJohnHarnessTina. 2018. “The Role of Aesthetics and Design in Hotelscape: A Phenomenological Investigation of Cosmopolitan Consumers.” Journal of Business Research85:523–31.
2.
ArgoJennifer J.DahlDarren W.MoralesAndrea C.2008. “Positive Consumer Contagion: Responses to Attractive Others in a Retail Context.” Journal of Marketing Research45 (6): 690–701.
3.
AyehJulian K.AuNormanLawRob. 2013. “‘Do We Believe in TripAdvisor?’ Examining Credibility Perceptions and Online Travelers’ Attitude toward Using User-Generated Content.” Journal of Travel Research52 (4): 437–52.
4.
BazJamilBriysEricBronnenbergBart J.CohenMichèleKastRobertVialaPascaleWathieuLucWeberMartinWertenbrochKlaus. 1999. “Risk Perception in the Short Run and in the Long Run.” Marketing Letters10 (3): 267–83.
BerlyneDaniel E.1971. Aesthetics and Psychobiology. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
7.
BlackT.1999. Doing Quantitative Research in the Social Sciences: An Integrated Approach to Research Design, Measurement and Statistics. London: SAGE.
8.
BoleyB. BynumNickersonNorma PolovitzBosakKeith. 2011. “Measuring Geotourism: Developing and Testing the Geotraveler Tendency Scale (GTS).” Journal of Travel Research50 (5): 567–78.
9.
BreugelmansElsCampoKatiaGijsbrechtsEls. 2007. “Shelf Sequence and Proximity Effects on Online Grocery Choices.” Marketing Letters18 (1/2): 117–33.
10.
BronnerFredde HoogRobert. 2011. “Vacationers and EWOM: Who Posts, and Why, Where, and What?” Journal of Travel Research50 (1): 15–26.
11.
BrookerGeorge. 1984. “An Assessment of an Expanded Measure of Perceived Risk.” ACR North American Advances.
12.
BuhrmesterMichaelKwangTracyGoslingSamuel D.2011. “Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: A New Source of Inexpensive, yet High-Quality, Data?” Perspectives on Psychological Science6 (1): 3–5.
13.
CacioppoJohn T.PettyRichard E.1979. “Effects of Message Repetition and Position on Cognitive Response, Recall, and Persuasion.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology37 (1): 97.
14.
CasalóLuis V.FlaviánCarlosGuinalíuMiguelEkinciYuksel. 2015. “Avoiding the Dark Side of Positive Online Consumer Reviews: Enhancing Reviews’ Usefulness for High Risk-Averse Travelers.” Journal of Business Research68 (9): 1829–35.
15.
ChanTsang-SingCuiGengCuiGeng. 2004. “Consumer Attitudes toward Marketing in a Transitional Economy: A Replication and Extension.” Journal of Consumer Marketing21 (1): 10–26.
16.
ChhabraDeepak. 2005. “Defining Authenticity and Its Determinants: Toward an Authenticity Flow Model.” Journal of Travel Research44 (1): 64–73.
17.
ChoiHyeyoonChoiHwansuk Chris. 2018. “Investigating Tourists’ Fun-Eliciting Process toward Tourism Destination Sites: An Application of Cognitive Appraisal Theory.” Journal of Travel Research58 (5): 732–44.
18.
CollianderJonasMarderBen. 2018. “‘Snap Happy’ Brands: Increasing Publicity Effectiveness through a Snapshot Aesthetic When Marketing a Brand on Instagram.” Computers in Human Behavior78:34–43.
19.
CollianderJonasSöderlundMagnusMarderBen. 2019. “Watching Others Receive Unearned Superior Treatment: Examining the Effects on Tourists Who Receive Less Than Their Peers.” Journal of Travel Research58 (7): 1175–92.
20.
DayanEranBar-HillelMaya. 2011. “Nudge to Nobesity II: Menu Positions Influence Food Orders.” Judgment and Decision Making6 (4): 333–42.
21.
DickingerAstrid. 2011. “The Trustworthiness of Online Channels for Experience-and Goal-Directed Search Tasks.” Journal of Travel Research50 (4): 378–91.
22.
DouglasNick. 2014. “It’s Supposed to Look like Shit: The Internet Ugly Aesthetic.” Journal of Visual Culture13 (3): 314–39.
23.
ErtEyalFleischerAliza. 2016. “Mere Position Effect in Booking Hotels Online.” Journal of Travel Research55 (3): 311–21.
24.
ErzAntoniaMarderBenOsadchayaElena. 2018. “Hashtags: Motivational Drivers, Their Use, and Differences between Influencers and Followers.” Computers in Human Behavior89:48–60.
25.
GregoriNicolasDanieleRobertoAltinayLevent. 2014. “Affiliate Marketing in Tourism: Determinants of Consumer Trust.” Journal of Travel Research53 (2): 196–210.
26.
GuttentagDanielSmithStephenPotwarkaLukeHavitzMark. 2018. “Why Tourists Choose Airbnb: A Motivation-Based Segmentation Study.” Journal of Travel Research57 (3): 342–59.
27.
HaHong-Youl. 2002. “The Effects of Consumer Risk Perception on Pre-Purchase Information in Online Auctions: Brand, Word-of-Mouth, and Customized Information.” Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication8 (1): JCMC813.
28.
HaoJin-XingTangRuiYuYanLiNaoLawRob. 2015. “Visual Appeal of Hotel Websites: An Exploratory Eye Tracking Study on Chinese Generation Y.” In Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism2015, 607–20. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer.
29.
HayesAndrew F.2018. Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach, 2nd ed.New York: Guilford.
30.
HolbrookMorris B.HirschmanElizabeth C.1982. “The Experiential Aspects of Consumption: Consumer Fantasies, Feelings, and Fun.” Journal of Consumer Research9 (2): 132–40.
31.
HortonRaymond L.1976. “The Structure of Perceived Risk: Some Further Progress.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science4 (4): 694–706.
32.
HuYangzhouRitchieJ. R. Brent. 1993. “Measuring Destination Attractiveness: A Contextual Approach.” Journal of Travel Research32 (2): 25–34.
ItoP. K.1980. “7 Robustness of ANOVA and MANOVA Test Procedures.” Handbook of Statistics1:199–236.
35.
KantImmanuel. 2007. Critique of Judgement, edited by WalkerN. and translated by MeredithJ.New York: Oxford University Press.
36.
KaplanRachelKaplanStephenBrownTerry. 1989. “Environmental Preference: A Comparison of Four Domains of Predictors.” Environment and Behavior21 (5): 509–30.
37.
KarlMarion. 2018. “Risk and Uncertainty in Travel Decision-Making: Tourist and Destination Perspective.” Journal of Travel Research57 (1): 129–46.
38.
KashyapRajivBojanicDavid C.2000. “A Structural Analysis of Value, Quality, and Price Perceptions of Business and Leisure Travelers.” Journal of Travel Research39 (1): 45–51.
39.
KimWoo GonMoonYun Ji. 2009. “Customers’ Cognitive, Emotional, and Actionable Response to the Servicescape: A Test of the Moderating Effect of the Restaurant Type.” International Journal of Hospitality Management28 (1): 144–56.
40.
KirillovaKseniaChanJanelle. 2018. “‘What Is Beautiful We Book’: Hotel Visual Appeal and Expected Service Quality.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management30 (3): 1788–807.
41.
KirillovaKseniaFuXiaoxiaoLehtoXinranCaiLiping. 2014. “What Makes a Destination Beautiful? Dimensions of Tourist Aesthetic Judgment.” Tourism Management42:282–93.
42.
LadhariRiadhMichaudMélissa. 2015. “EWOM Effects on Hotel Booking Intentions, Attitudes, Trust, and Website Perceptions.” International Journal of Hospitality Management46:36–45.
43.
LavieTaliaTractinskyNoam. 2004. “Assessing Dimensions of Perceived Visual Aesthetics of Web Sites.” International Journal of Human-Computer Studies60 (3): 269–98.
44.
LawRobQiShanshanBuhalisDimitrios. 2010. “Progress in Tourism Management: A Review of Website Evaluation in Tourism Research.” Tourism Management31 (3): 297–313.
45.
LeeSo YonReynoldsJohnny SueKennonLisa R. 2003. “Bed and Breakfast Industries: Successful Marketing Strategies.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing14 (1): 37–53.
46.
LinPei-JungJonesEleriWestwoodSheena. 2009. “Perceived Risk and Risk-Relievers in Online Travel Purchase Intentions.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management18 (8): 782–810.
47.
LitmanLeibRobinsonJonathanAbberbockTzvi. 2017. “TurkPrime.Com: A Versatile Crowdsourcing Data Acquisition Platform for the Behavioral Sciences.” Behavior Research Methods49 (2): 433–42.
48.
LitvinStephen W.GoldsmithRonald E.PanBing. 2008. “Electronic Word-of-Mouth in Hospitality and Tourism Management.” Tourism Management29 (3): 458–68.
49.
LitvinStephen W.MouriNacef. 2009. “A Comparative Study of the Use of ‘Iconic’ versus ‘Generic’ Advertising Images for Destination Marketing.” Journal of Travel Research48 (2): 152–61.
LogkizidouMariaBottomleyPaulAngellRobEvanschitzkyHeiner. 2019. “Why Museological Merchandise Displays Enhance Luxury Product Evaluations: An Extended Art Infusion Effect.” Journal of Retailing95 (1): 67–82.
52.
LohseGerald L.RosenDennis L.2001. “Signaling Quality and Credibility in Yellow Pages Advertising: The Influence of Color and Graphics on Choice.” Journal of Advertising30 (2): 73–83.
53.
LombardMatthewSnyder-DuchJennifer. 2001. “Interactive Advertising and Presence: A Framework.” Journal of Interactive Advertising1 (2): 56–65.
54.
MaYufengXiangZhengDuQianzhouFanWeiguo. 2018. “Effects of User-Provided Photos on Hotel Review Helpfulness: An Analytical Approach with Deep Leaning.” International Journal of Hospitality Management71:120–31.
55.
MacKayKelly J.CouldwellChristine M.2004. “Using Visitor-Employed Photography to Investigate Destination Image.” Journal of Travel Research42 (4): 390–96.
56.
MacKayKelly J.FesenmaierDaniel R.1997. “Pictorial Element of Destination in Image Formation.” Annals of Tourism Research24 (3): 537–65.
57.
ManningRobertValliereWilliamMinteerBen. 1999. “Values, Ethics, and Attitudes toward National Forest Management: An Empirical Study.” Society & Natural Resources12 (5): 421–36.
58.
MarderBenArcher-BrownChrisCollianderJonasLambertAliette. 2018. “Vacation Posts on Facebook: A Model for Incidental Vicarious Travel Consumption.” Journal of Travel Research58 (6): 1014–33.
59.
MitchellVincent-Wayne. 1992. “Understanding Consumers’ Behaviour: Can Perceived Risk Theory Help?” Management Decision30 (3).
60.
MitchellVincent-WayneMikeGreatorex. 1993. “Risk Perception and Reduction in the Purchase of Consumer Services.” Service Industries Journal13 (4): 179–200.
61.
MitchellVincent-WayneLuizMoutinhoBarbaraR. Lewis. 2003. “Risk Reduction in Purchasing Organisational Professional Services.” Service Industries Journal, 23 (5): 1–19.
62.
MunarAna Maria MaríaJacobsenJens Kr Steen. 2014. “Motivations for Sharing Tourism Experiences through Social Media.” Tourism Management43:46–54.
63.
MurphyJamieHofackerCharlesMizerskiRichard. 2006. “Primacy and Recency Effects on Clicking Behavior.” Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication11 (2): 522–35.
64.
NicholsBill. 2000. “The Work of Culture in the Age of Cybernetic Systems.” In Electronic Media and Technoculture, edited by ThortonJohn Caldwell, 22–46. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
65.
NolanSidney D.Jr.. 1976. “Tourists’ Use and Evaluation of Travel Information Sources: Summary and Conclusions.” Journal of Travel Research14 (3): 6–8.
66.
O’ConnorPeter. 2008. “User-Generated Content and Travel: A Case Study on Tripadvisor. Com.” Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism2008:47–58.
67.
OsbourneHarold. 1968. Aesthetics and Art Theory. London: Longmans, Green & Co.
68.
PanttiMervi. 2013. “Getting Closer? Encounters of the National Media with Global Images.” Journalism Studies14 (2): 201–18.
69.
PaolacciGabrieleChandlerJesseIpeirotisPanagiotis G.2010. “Running Experiments on Amazon Mechanical Turk.” Judgement and Decision Making5 (5).
70.
ParkSangwonNicolauJuan L. 2015. “Asymmetric Effects of Online Consumer Reviews.” Annals of Tourism Research50:67–83.
71.
PetrickJames F.BackmanSheila J.2002. “An Examination of the Determinants of Golf Travelers’ Satisfaction.” Journal of Travel Research40 (3): 252–58.
72.
PhillipsPaul A.2004. “Customer-Oriented Hotel Aesthetics: A Shareholder Value Perspective.” Journal of Retail & Leisure Property3 (4): 365–73.
73.
PhillipsPaulBarnesStuartZiganKrystinScheggRoland. 2017. “Understanding the Impact of Online Reviews on Hotel Performance: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Travel Research56 (2): 235–49.
74.
PittC.ErikssonT.PlanggerK.2019. “Customer Goodwill: How Perceived Competence and Rapport Influence EWOM Diagnosticity of Peer-to-Peer and Professional Access-Based Services.” In Handbook on the Sharing Economy, edited by BelkRussell W.EckhardtGiana M.BardhiFleura. London: Edward Elgar.
75.
PollayRichard W.1986. “The Distorted Mirror: Reflections on the Unintended Consequences of Advertising.” Journal of Marketing50 (2): 18–36.
76.
PreacherKristopher J.HayesAndrew F.2004. “SPSS and SAS Procedures for Estimating Indirect Effects in Simple Mediation Models.” Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers36 (4): 717–31.
77.
RungtusanathamM.WallinCynthiaEckerdStephanie. 2011. “The Vignette in a Scenario-Based Role-Playing Experiment.” Journal of Supply Chain Management47 (3): 9–16.
78.
Salas-OlmedoMaria HenarMoya-GómezBorjaGarcía-PalomaresJuan CarlosGutiérrezJavier. 2018. “Tourists’ Digital Footprint in Cities: Comparing Big Data Sources.” Tourism Management66:13–25.
79.
SalehFaroukRyanChris. 1992. “Client Perceptions of Hotels: A Multi-attribute Approach.” Tourism Management13 (2): 163–68.
80.
SchenkmanBo N.JönssonFredrik U.2000. “Aesthetics and Preferences of Web Pages.” Behaviour & Information Technology19 (5): 367–77.
81.
SchmidtSusanneEisendMartin. 2015. “Advertising Repetition: A Meta-Analysis on Effective Frequency in Advertising.” Journal of Advertising44 (4): 415–28.
82.
ShinYoojinNooneBreffni M.RobsonStephani K. A.2018. “An Exploration of the Effects of Photograph Content, Photograph Source, and Price on Consumers’ Online Travel Booking Intentions.” Journal of Travel Research59 (1): 120–39.
83.
ShulmanJeffrey D.CunhaMarcusJr.Saint ClairJulian K.2015. “Consumer Uncertainty and Purchase Decision Reversals: Theory and Evidence.” Marketing Science34 (4): 590–605.
84.
SimoninBernard L.RuthJulie A.1998. “Is a Company Known by the Company It Keeps? Assessing the Spillover Effects of Brand Alliances on Consumer Brand Attitudes.” Journal of Marketing Research35 (1): 30–42.
85.
SoKevinFungKamWuLaurieXiongLinaKingCeridwyn. 2018. “Brand Management in the Era of Social Media: Social Visibility of Consumption and Customer Brand Identification.” Journal of Travel Research57 (6): 727–42.
86.
StangDavid J.1975. “Effects of ‘Mere Exposure’ on Learning and Affect.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology31 (1): 7.
87.
SunJin. 2014. “How Risky Are Services? An Empirical Investigation on the Antecedents and Consequences of Perceived Risk for Hotel Service.” International Journal of Hospitality Management37:171–79.
TungVincent Wing SunChenPo-JuSchuckertMarkus. 2017. “Managing Customer Citizenship Behaviour: The Moderating Roles of Employee Responsiveness and Organizational Reassurance.” Tourism Management59:23–35.
91.
TuzunkanDemetAlbayrakAsli. 2016. “The Importance of Restaurant Physical Environment for Turkish Customers.” Journal of Tourism Research & Hospitality5 (1).
92.
UlrichRoger S.1983. “Aesthetic and Affective Response to Natural Environment.” In Behavior and the Natural Environment, 85–125. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer.
93.
UrryJ.1995. Consuming Places. London: Routledge.
94.
VotolaNicole L.UnnavaH. Rao. 2006. “Spillover of Negative Information on Brand Alliances.” Journal of Consumer Psychology16 (2): 196–202.
95.
WeerahandiSamaradasa. 1995. “ANOVA under Unequal Error Variances.” Biometrics589–99.
96.
WellmanJ. DouglasDawsonM. S.RoggenbuckJoseph W.1982. “Park Managers’ Predictions of the Motivations of Visitors to Two National Park Service Areas.” Journal of Leisure Research14 (1): 1–15.
97.
YeQiangLawRobGuBinChenWei. 2011. “The Influence of User-Generated Content on Traveler Behavior: An Empirical Investigation on the Effects of E-word-of-mouth to Hotel Online Bookings.” Computers in Human Behavior27 (2): 634–39.
98.
ZhangHongmeiGordonSusanBuhalisDimitriosDingXifen. 2018. “Experience Value Cocreation on Destination Online Platforms.” Journal of Travel Research57 (8): 1093–107.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
