Today, communication is a key factor of destination competitiveness. The aim of the present study is to examine the effect of message consistency between different online communication tools on the formation of consumer-based destination brand equity (CBDBE), within two distinct brand positioning strategies (single-destination brand vs. multiple-destination brands). An experimental design is applied to manipulate message consistency (high vs. low) and the type of brand positioning strategy implemented by the destination (single vs. multiple brands). The results demonstrate that when the messages received by the tourist are highly consistent across different channels, branding strategy type exerts no differential effect on CBDBE. By contrast, when the messages present low consistency, a single destination branding strategy generates higher CBDBE than a multiple destination branding strategy. The study makes an original contribution to the literature, showing the interaction between destination branding strategy type and degree of consistency in the messages received by the tourist.
AakerD. A.1991. Managing Brand Equity. New York: Free Press.
2.
AakerD. A.1996. Building Strong Brands. New York: Free Press.
3.
AnantachartS.2004. “Integrated Marketing Communications and Market Planning: Their Implications to Brand Equity Building.” Journal of Promotion Management11 (1): 101–25.
4.
AnholtS.2003. “Branding Places and Nations.” In Brands and Branding, edited by CliftonR.SimmonsJ., 213–26. London: Profile Books.
5.
AnholtS.2004. “Nation-Brands and the Value of Provenance.” In Destination Branding: Creating the Unique Destination Proposition, edited by MorganN.PritchardA.PrideR., 26–39. Boston: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann.
6.
AnholtS., 2007. Competitive Identity: The New Brand Management for Nations, Cities and Regions. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
7.
BakerB.2007. Destination Branding for Small Cities: The Essentials for Successful Place Branding. Portland, OR: Creative Leap Books.
8.
BalakrishnanM. S.2009. “Strategic Branding of Destinations: A Framework.” European Journal of Marketing43 (5/6): 611–29.
9.
BallesterE.Sicilia-PiñeroM., 2009. “Effects of strategic consistency of a message on the consumer.” Cuadernos de Administracion, 22(38): 73–100.
10.
BanyaiM.GloverT. D.2012. “Evaluating Research Methods on Travel Blogs.” Journal of Travel Research51 (3): 267–77.
11.
BelchG. E.BelchM. A.2004. Advertising and Promotion: An Integrated Marketing Communications Perspective, 6th ed.New York: McGraw-Hill.
12.
BianchiC.PikeS.LingsI.2014. “Investigating Attitudes towards Three South American Destinations in an Emerging Long Haul Market Using a Model of Consumer-Based Brand Equity (CBBE).” Tourism Management42:215–23.
13.
BlainC.LevyS. E.RitchieJ. R. B.2005. “Destination Branding: Insights and Practices from Destination Management Organizations.” Journal of Travel Research43:328–38.
14.
BlanksonC.KalafatisS. P.2004. “The Development and Validation of a Scale Measuring Consumer/Customer-Derived Generic Typology of Positioning Strategies.” Journal of Marketing Management20:5–43.
15.
BobrowD. G.NormanD. A.1975. “Some Principles of Memory Schemata.” In Representation and Understanding: Studies in Cognitive Science, edited by BobrowD. G.CollinsA., 131–50. New York: McGraw-Hill.
16.
BooS.BusserJ.BalogluS.2009. “A Model of Customer-Based Brand Equity and Its Application to Multiple Destinations.” Tourism Management30:219–31.
17.
BothaC.CromptonJ. L.KimS.1999. “Developing a Revised Competitive Position for Sun/Lost City, South Africa.” Journal of Travel Research37 (May): 341–52.
18.
CaywoodC.SchultzD. E.WangP.1991. Integrated Marketing Communications: A Survey of National Goods Advertisers. Bloomington, IN: Medill School of Journalism, Northwestern University.
19.
ChaoP.2001. “The Moderating Effects of Country of Assembly, Country of Parts, and Country of Design on Hybrid Product Evaluations.” Journal of Advertising30 (4): 67–81.
20.
ChenJ. S.UysalM.2002. “Market Positioning Analysis: A Hybrid Approach.” Annals of Tourism Research29 (4): 987–1003.
21.
CromptonJ.1992. “Structure of Vacation Destination Choice Sets.” Annals of Tourism Research19 (3): 420–34.
22.
d’AstousA.ChartierF.2000. “A Study of Factors Affecting Consumer Evaluations and Memory of Product Placements in Movies.” Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising22 (2): 31–40.
23.
DaumJ. H.2003. Intangible Assets and Value Creation. Chichester: Wiley.
24.
DavidsonR.MacKinnonJ. G.2006. “The Power of Bootstrap and Asymptotic Tests.” Journal of Econometrics133 (2): 421–41.
25.
Delgado-BallesterE.NavarroA.SiciliaM.2012. “Revitalising Brands through Communication Messages: The Role of Brand Familiarity.” European Journal of Marketing46 (1/2): 31–51.
26.
DooleyG.BowieD.2005. “Place brand architecture: Strategic management of the brand portfolio.” Place Branding1 (4): 402-419.
27.
DroletA.WilliamsP.Lau-GeskL.2007. “Age-Related Differences in Responses to Affective vs. Rational Ads for Hedonic vs. Utilitarian Products.” Marketing Letters18 (4): 211–21.
28.
DuncanT.EverettS. E.1993. “Client Perceptions of Integrated Marketing Communications.” Journal of Advertising Research33 (3): 30–39.
29.
DuncanT.MoriartyS. E.1997. Driving Brand Value: Using Integrated Marketing to Manage Profitable Stakeholder Relationships. New York: McGraw-Hill.
30.
DuncanT. R.MoriartyS. E.1998. “A Communication-Based Marketing Model for Managing Relationships.” Journal of Marketing62 (April): 1–13.
31.
DuncanT. R.MulhernF. eds. 2004. A White Paper on the Status, Scope and Future of IMC (from IMC symposium sponsored by the IMC programs at Northwestern University and the University of Denver). NewYork: McGraw-Hill.
32.
ElliottR.BoshoffC.2008. “The Influence of Business Orientations in Small Tourism Businesses on the Success of Integrated Marketing Communication.” Management Dynamics17 (4): 32–45.
33.
EwingM. T.2009. “Integrated Marketing Communications Measurement and Evaluation.” Journal of Marketing Communications15 (2/3): 103–17.
34.
FanY.2006. “Branding the Nation: What Is Being Branded?” Journal of Vacation Marketing12 (1): 5–14.
35.
FisherR. J.1991. “Durable Differentiation Strategies for Services.” Journal of Services Marketing5 (1): 19–28.
36.
FiskeS. T.TaylorS. E.1991. Social Cognition, 2nd ed.New York: McGraw-Hill.
37.
Frías-JamilenaD. M.Polo-PeñaA. I.Rodríguez MolinaM. A.2017. “The Effect of Value-Creation on Consumer-Based Destination Brand Equity.” Journal of Travel Research56 (8): 1011–31.
38.
GallarzaM. G.GilI.GallarzaH. C.2002. “Destination Image: Toward a Conceptual Framework.” Annals of Tourism Research29 (1): 56–78.
39.
GarcíaJ. A.GómezM.MolinaA.2012. “A Destination Branding Model: An Empirical Analysis Based on Stakeholders.” Tourism Management33:646–61.
40.
GarcíaJ. A.GómezM.MolinaA.2013. “Posicionamiento de marcas-destino: Una aplicación en cinco Structure of vacation destination choice sets regiones españolas [Destination-branding positioning: an application in five Spanish regions].” INNOVAR. Revista de Ciencias Administrativas y Sociales23 (50): 111–27.
41.
GartnerW. C.1989. “Tourism Image: Attribute Measurement of State Tourism Products Using Multidimensional Scaling Techniques.” Journal of Travel Research28 (Fall): 16–20.
42.
GertnerW. C.1996. Tourism Development: Principles, Processes, and Policies. New York: John Wiley.
43.
GrablerK.1997. “Perceptual Mapping and Positioning of Tourist Cities.” In International City Tourism, edited by MazanecJ. A., 101–13. London: Pinter.
44.
GursoyD.McClearyK. W.2004. “An Integrative Model of Tourists’ Information Search Behavior.” Annals of Tourism Research31 (2): 353–73.
45.
HecklerS. E.ChildersT. L.1992. “The Role of Expectancy and Relevancy in Memory for Verbal and Visual Information: What Is Incongruency?” Journal of Consumer Research18 (4): 475–92.
ImH. H.KimS. S.ElliotS.HanH.2012. “Conceptualizing Destination Brand Equity Dimensions from a Consumer-Based Brand Equity Perspective.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing29 (4): 385–403.
48.
INE (Instituto Nacional de Estadistica). 2017. Frontur. Número de turistas según país de residencia [“Number of Tourists by Country of Residence”]. www.ine.es/jaxiT3/Tabla.htm?t=10822&L=0.
49.
Instituto de Turismo de España. 2017. Encuesta de movimientos turísticos en fronteras (Frontur) y Encuesta de gasto turístico (Egatur). Ministerio de Industria, Energía y Turismo [Spanish Border Survey of Inbound Tourism (Frontur) and Spanish Tourist Expenditure Survey (Egatur). Ministry of Industry, Energy and Tourism.].
50.
JosiassenA.LukasB. A.WhitwellG. J.2008. “Country-of-Origin Contingencies: Competing Perspectives on Product Familiarity and Product Involvement.” International Marketing Review25 (4): 423–40.
51.
KellerK. L.1993 “Conceptualizing, Measuring and Managing Customer-Based Brand Equity.” Journal of Marketing57 (1): 1–22.
KellerL. K.2009. “Building Strong Brands in a Modern Marketing Communications Environment.” Journal of Marketing Communications15 (2/3): 139–55.
55.
KeppelG.1991. Design and Analysis: A Researcher’s Handbook. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
56.
KimS. S.ChunaH.PetrickJ. F.2005. “Positioning Analysis of Overseas Golf Tour Destinations by Korean Golf Tourists.” Tourism Management26:905–17.
57.
KirkR. E.1995. Experimental Design: Procedures for the Behavioral Sciences, 3rd ed.Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.
58.
KitchenP. J.2017. “Integrated Marketing Communications: Evolution, Current Status, Future Developments.” European Journal of Marketing51 (3): 394–405.
59.
KliatchkoJ. G.2008. “Revisiting the IMC Construct. A Revised Definition and Four Pillars.” International Journal of Advertising27 (1): 133–60.
60.
CohenJ.1988. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. London: Routledge.
61.
LamT.HsuC. H.2006. “Predicting behavioral intention of choosing a travel destination”. Tourism Management, 27 (4): 589–599.
62.
LascuD. N.ManraiL. A.ManraiA. K.GanA.2018. “A Cluster Analysis of Tourist Attractions in Spain: Natural and Cultural Traits and Implications for Global Tourism.” European Journal of Management and Business Economics27 (3): 218–30.
63.
LeeD. H.ParkC. W.2007. “Conceptualization and Measurement of Multidimensionality of Integrated Marketing Communications.” Journal of Advertising Research47 (3): 222–36.
64.
LeeM.FaberR. J.2007. “Effects of Product Placement in On-line Games on Brand Memory: A Perspective of the Limited-Capacity Model of Attention.” Journal of Advertising36 (4): 75–90.
65.
LópezR.BenllochM. T.2005. From the commercial brand to the territory brand. Revista de Pensament i Análisi5: 87–100.
66.
LowG. S.2000. “Correlates of Integrated Marketing Communi-cations.” Journal of Advertising Research40 (3): 27–39.
67.
LuxtonS.ReidM.MavondoF.2015. “Integrated Marketing Communication Capability and Brand Performance.” Journal of Advertising44 (1): 37–46.
68.
LuxtonS.ReidM.MavondoF.2017. “IMC Capability: Antecedents and Implications for Brand Performance.” European Journal of Marketing51 (3): 421–44.
69.
MacKinnonD. P.2002. “Mediating Variable.” In International Encyclopaedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, edited by SmelserN. J.BaltesP. B., 9503–7. New York: Elsevier.
70.
MadhavaramS.BadrinarayananV.McDonaldR. E.2005. “Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC) and Brand Identity as Critical Components of Brand Equity Strategy: A Conceptual Framework and Research Propositions.” Journal of Advertising34 (4): 69–80.
71.
MalhotraN. K.2010. Marketing Research. An Applied Orientation. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
72.
MandlerJ. M.1982. “Some Uses and Abuses of a Story Grammar.” Discourse Processes5 (3/4): 305–18.
73.
MayoE. J.JarvisL. P.1981. The Psychology of Leisure Travel. Boston: CBI.
74.
McAlexanderJ.BeckerB.KaldenbergD.1993. “Positioning Health Care Services: Yellow Pages Advertising and Dental Practice Performance.” Journal of Health Care Marketing13 (Winter): 54–57.
75.
Melián-GonzálezA.García-FalcónJ. M.2003. “Competitive Potential of Tourism in Destinations.” Annals of Tourism Research30 (3): 720–40.
76.
MihalicT.2000. “Environmental Management of a Tourist Destination: A Factor of Tourism Competitiveness.” Tourism Management21 (1): 65–78.
77.
MoriartyS.SchultzD.2012. “Four Theories of How IMC Works.” Advertising Theory3:491–505.
78.
MorimotoM.TrimbleC.2012. “Consumers’ Use of Blogs as Product Information Sources: From Need-for-Cognition Perspective.” Marketing Management Journal22 (2): 45–60.
79.
MuehlingD. D.StoltmanJ. J.GrossbartS.1990. “The impact of comparative advertising on levels of message involvement”. Journal of Advertising, 19 (4): 41–50.
80.
Muñoz-LeivaF.PorcuL.Del Barrio-GarcíaS.2015. “Discovering Prominent Themes in Integrated Marketing Communication Research from 1991 to 2012: A Co-word Analytic Approach.” International Journal of Advertising34 (4): 678–701.
81.
MykletunR. J.CrottsJ. C.MykletunA.2001. “Positioning an Island Destination in the Peripheral Area of the Baltics: A Flexible Approach to Market Segmentation.” Tourism Management22 (5): 493–500.
82.
NaikP. A.RamanK.2003. Understanding the impact of synergy in multimedia communications”. Journal of Marketing Research, 40(4): 375–388.
83.
NickersonN. P.MoiseyR. N.1999. “Branding a State from Features to Positioning: Making It Simple.” Journal of Vacation Marketing5 (3): 217–26.
84.
Navarro-BailónM. A. (2012). “trategic consistent messages in cross-tool campaigns: effects on brand image and brand attitude”. Journal of Marketing Communications, 18(3): 189–202.
85.
NowakG. J.PhelpsJ.1994. “Conceptualizing the Integrated Marketing Communications’ Phenomenon: An Examination of Its Impact on Advertising Practices and Its Implications for Advertising Research.” Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising16 (1): 49–66.
86.
OppenheimerD. M.MeyvisT.DavidenkoN.2009. “Instructional Manipulation Checks: Detecting Satisficing to Increase Statistical Power.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology45 (4): 867–872.
87.
OsgoodC. E.TannenbaumP. H.1955. “The principle of congruity in the prediction of attitude change”. Psychological Review, 62 (1): 42.
PazS.2005. “Strategic management and city positioning. The City brand as a vector for international projection.”Venezuelan Management Magazine10 (30): 177–195.
90.
PettyR. E.CacioppoJ. T.1986. “The Elaboration Likelihood Model of Persuasion.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology19:123–205.
91.
PeralbaR.2009. “The Strategic Positioning of the Spain Brand”. Madrid: Businessmen’s Circle.
92.
PerdueB. C.SummersJ. O.1986. “Checking the Success of Manipulations in Marketing Experiments.” Journal of Marketing Research23:317–26.
93.
PhelanK.ChenH. T.HaneyM.2013. “‘Like’ and ‘Check-in’: How Hotels Utilize Facebook as an Effective Marketing Tool.” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Technology4 (2): 134–54.
94.
PhelpsJ.JohnsonE.1996. “Entering the Quagmire: Examining the ‘Meaning’ of Integrated Marketing Communications.” Journal of Marketing Communications2 (3): 159–72.
95.
PicktonD.2004. “Assessing Integrated Corporate Communication.” In Handbook of Corporate Communication and Public Relations, Pure and Applied, edited by OliverS. M., 227–41. New York: Routledge.
PikeS.2006. “Destination Decision Sets: A Longitudinal Comparison of Stated Destination Preferences and Actual Travel.” Journal of Vacation Marketing12 (4): 319–28.
98.
PikeS.2012. “Destination Positioning Opportunities Using Personal Values: Elicited through the Repertory Test with Laddering Analysis.” Tourism Management33:100–7.
99.
PikeS.BianchiC.2013. “Destination Brand Equity for Australia: Testing a Model of CBBE in Short-Haul and Long-Haul Markets.” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research20 (10): 1–21.
100.
PikeS.BianchiC.KerrG.PattiC.2010. “Consumer-Based Brand Equity for Australia as a Long-Haul Tourism Destination in an Emerging Market.” International Marketing Review27 (4): 434–49.
101.
PikeS.PageS. J.2014. “Destination Marketing Organizations and Destination Marketing: A Narrative Analysis of the Literature.” Tourism Management41:202–27.
102.
PorcuL.Del Barrio-GarcíaS.KitchenP. J.2012. “How Integrated Marketing Communications (IMC) Works? A Theoretical Review and an Analysis of Its Main Drivers and Effects.” Communication and Society25 (1): 313–48.
103.
PorcuL.Del Barrio-GarcíaS.KitchenP. J.2017. “Measuring Integrated Marketing Communication by Taking a Broad Organisational Approach: The Firm-Wide IMC Scale.” European Journal of Marketing51 (3): 692–718.
104.
PorterM. E.1980. Competitive Strategy. New York: Free Press.
105.
SchmidtT. L.HitchonJ. C.1999. “When Advertising and Public Relations Converge: An Application of Schema Theory to the Persuasive Impact of Alignment Ads.” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly76 (3): 433–55.
106.
SchultzD. E.KimI.KangK.2014. “Integrated Marketing Communication Research.” In The Handbook of International Advertising Research, edited by HongCheng, 457–83. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
107.
SchultzD.E.PattiC.H.2009. “The evolution of IMC: IMC in a customer-driven marketplace”. Journal of Marketing Communications15 (23): 75–84.
108.
SchultzD. E.SchultzH.1998. “Transitioning Marketing Communication into the Twenty-First Century.” Journal of Marketing Communications4:9–26.
109.
ŠerićM.2018. “Content Analysis of the Empirical Research on IMC from 2000 to 2015.” Journal of Marketing Communications24 (7): 647–85.
110.
ŠerićM.2017. “Relationships between Social Web, IMC and Overall Brand Equity: An Empirical Examination from the Cross-Cultural Perspective.” European Journal of Marketing51 (3): 646–67.
111.
ŠerićM.Gil-SauraI.2012. “ICT, IMC, and Brand Equity in High-Quality Hotels of Dalmatia: An Analysis from Guest Perceptions.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management21 (8): 821–51.
112.
ŠerićM.Gil-SauraI.Ozretić-DošenD.2015. “Insights on Integrated Marketing Communications: Implementation and Impact in Hotel Companies.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management27 (5): 958–79.
113.
ŠerićM.Gil-SauraI.Ruiz MolinaM. E.2014. “How Can Integrated Marketing Communications and Advanced Technology Influence the Creation of Customer-Based Brand Equity? Evidence from the Hospitality Industry.” International Journal of Hospitality Management39:144–56.
SawilowskyS.2009. “New Effect Size Rules of Thumb.” Journal of Modern Applied Statistical Methods8 (2): 467–74.
116.
ShadishW. R.CookT. D.CampbellD. T.2002. Experimental and Quasi-experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
117.
SoláR.2007. “Análisis de las Estrategias Publicitarias de las Campañas Turísticas de la Comunidad Valenciana 1989-2006 [Analysis of the Advertising Strategies in the Tourism Campaigns of the Autonomous Community of Valencia].” PhD thesis, Universitat Jaume I, Castellón.
118.
SpeedR.ThompsonP.2000. “Determinants of Sports Sponsorship Response.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science28 (2): 226–38.
119.
SrullT. K.1981. “Person Memory: Some Tests of Associate Storage and Retrieval Models.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory7:440–63.
120.
StangorC.McMillanD.1992. “Memory for expectancy-congruent and expectancy-incongruent information: A review of the social and social developmental literatures”. Psychological Bulletin, 111(1): 42–61.
121.
TasciA. D.2011. “Destination Branding and Positioning.” In Destination Marketing and Management: Theories and Applications, edited by WangY.PizamA., 113–29. Cambridge, MA: CABI.
UysalM.ChenJ.WilliamsD. R.2000. “Increasing State Market Share through a Regional Positioning.” Tourism Management21 (1): 89–96.
126.
VillafañeJ.2005. “The management of business intangibles”. Comunicação e Sociedade8: 101–113.
127.
WalkerM.2010. “Cities as Creative Spaces for Cultural Tourism: A Plea for the Consideration of History.” Pasos: Revista de Turismo y Patrimonio Cultural8 (3): 17–26.
128.
WashburnJ.PlankR.2002. “Measuring brand equity: An evaluation of a consumer-based brand equity scale”. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 17(6): 46–61.
129.
WinerS. R.2009. “New Communications Approaches in Marketing: Issues and Research Directions.” Journal of Interactive Marketing23 (2): 108–17.
130.
WoodsideA. G.SherrellD.1977. “Traveler Evoked, Inept, and Inert Sets of Vacation Destinations.” Journal of Travel Research16:14–18.
WuC. F. J.1986. “Jackknife, Bootstrap and other Resampling Methods in Regression Analysis.” Annals of Statistics14 (4): 1261–95.
133.
XuX.PrattS.2018. “Social Media Influencers as Endorsers to Promote Travel Destinations: An Application of Self-Congruence Theory to the Chinese Generation Y.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing35 (7): 958–72.
134.
YooB.DonthuN.2000. “Developing and Validating a Multidimensional Consumer-Based Brand Equity Scale.” Journal of Business Research52 (1): 1–14.
135.
ZehrerA.SmeralE.HallmannK.2017. “Destination Competitiveness: A Comparison of Subjective and Objective Indicators for Winter Sports Areas.” Journal of Travel Research56 (1): 55–66.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
