Swiss Cooperation in the Travel and Tourism Sector: Long-term Relationships and Superior Performance

Abstract

Despite a growing body of research on the interface and relationship between transport and tourism, this research area remains undeveloped. Using Switzerland as a case study, the present study aims to investigate the level of integration between public transport and tourism companies, the enablers of their long-term cooperative relationship and outstanding performance, seen from the perspective of the public transport companies. A mixed methods approach is used to provide greater insights into how these companies cooperate with each other. Our findings suggest that public transport companies adopt different cooperative strategies with different types of partners. They are able to maintain long-term cooperative relationships due to strong cooperation in sales, a long tradition of cooperation, a high degree of involvement in national public organizations, and their central focus on the customer. Type of partner, sales, product design and pricing, and service provision have statistically significant effects on cooperative performance.

Keywords

leisure travel tourism public transport interfirm cooperation Switzerland

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahrholdt

D. C.

Gudergan

S. P.

Ringle

C. M.

2017. “Enhancing Service Loyalty: The Roles of Delight, Satisfaction, and Service Quality.” Journal of Travel Research 56 (4): 436–50.

Albalate

Bel

2010. “Tourism and Urban Public Transport: Holding Demand Pressure under Supply Constraints.” Tourism Management 31 (3): 425–33.

ARE and BfS. 2017. “Swiss Microcensus for Mobility and Transport 2015: Final Report.” Swiss Federal Office of Statistics, Swiss Federal Office of Spatial Development, Neuenburg and Berne.

Azorín

J. M.

Cameron

2010. “The Application of Mixed Methods in Organisational Research: A Literature Review.” Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods 8 (2): 95–105.

Bae

S. Y.

Chick

2016. “An Emerging Korean Youth Culture, Rail-Ro: The Application of Cultural Consensus Analysis to Domestic Rail Travel Experiences.” Current Issues in Tourism 20 (4): 330–68.

Barney

1991. “Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage.” Journal of Management 15:175–90.

Barton

2009. “Technology Transfer in Swiss Tourism.” Paper presented at the Transfer of Technology Forum, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland; November.

Behrens

Pels

2012. “Intermodal Competition in the London-Paris Passenger Market: High-Speed Rail and Air Transport.” Journal of Urban Economics 71 (3): 278–88.

Beritelli

Bieger

Laesser

2014. “The New Frontiers of Destination Management: Applying Variable Geometry as a Function-Based Approach.” Journal of Travel Research 53 (4): 403–17.

10.

Breiding

J. R.

2013. Swiss Made: The Untold Story Behind Switzerland’s Success. London: Profile Books Ltd.

11.

Budeanu

2007. “Sustainable Tourist Behaviour—A Discussion of Opportunities for Change.” International Journal of Consumer Studies 31 (5): 499–508.

12.

Chung

J. Y.

Whang

2011. “The Impact of Low Cost Carriers on Korean Island Tourism.” Journal of Transport Geography 19 (6): 1335–40.

13.

Combs

J. G.

Ketchen

D. J.

1999. “Explaning Interfirm Cooperation and Performance: Toward a Reconciliation of Predictions from the Resource-Based View and Organizational Economics.” Strategic Management Journal 20:867–88.

14.

Creswell

J. W.

Clark

W. L. P.

2011. Designing and Conducting Mixed Methods Research, 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

15.

Currie

Falconer

2014. “Journal of Destination Marketing & Management Maintaining Sustainable Island Destinations in Scotland: The Role of the Transport–Tourism Relationship.” Journal of Destination Marketing & Management 3:162–72.

16.

d’Angella

F. M.

2009. “Tale of Two Cities’ Collaborative Tourism Marketing: Towards a Theory of Destination Stakeholder Assessment.” Tourism Management 30 (3): 429–40.

17.

Das

T. K.

Teng

B.-S.

2000. “A Resource-Based Theory.” Journal of Management 26 (1): 31–61.

18.

Department for Transport. 2018a. “Average Distance Travelled by Purpose and Main Mode: England.” https://assets.publlishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/729506/nts0410.ods (accessed February 12, 2019).

19.

Department for Transport. 2018b. “National Travel Survey England 2017: Main Results.” https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/729521/national-travel-survey-2017.pdf (accessed February 12, 2019).

20.

Desmaris

2014. “The Reform of Passenger Rail in Switzerland: More Performance without Competition.” Research in Transportation Economics 48:290–97.

21.

Dev

C. S.

Klein

Fisher

R. A.

1996. “A Market-Based Approach for Partner Selection in Marketing Alliances.” Journal of Travel Research 35 (1): 11–17.

22.

Dierickx

Cool

1989. “Asset Stock Accumulation and Sustainability of Competitive Advantage.” Management Science 35 (12): 1504–13.

23.

Dobruszkes

2011. “High-Speed Rail and Air Transport Competition in Western Europe: A Supply-Oriented Perspective.” Transport Policy 18 (6): 870–79.

24.

Duschek

Sydow

2002. “Resource-oriented approaches to strategic management: Two perspectives on corporate cooperation.” Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Studium 31:426–31.

25.

Dussauge

Garrette

Mitchell

2000. “Learning from Competing Partners: Outcomes and Durations of Scale and Link Alliances in Europe, North America and Asia.” Strategic Management Journal 21 (2): 99–126.

26.

Dyer

1997. “Effective Interfirm Collaboration: How Firms Minimize Transaction Costs and Maximize Transaction Value.” Strategic Management Journal 18 (7): 535–56.

27.

Dyer

Singh

1998. “The Relational View: Cooperative Strategy and Sources of Interorganzational Competitive Advantage.” Academy of Management Journal 23 (4): 660–79.

28.

Ettema

Schwanen

2012. “A Relational Approach to Analysing Leisure Travel.” Journal of Transport Geography 24:173–81.

29.

Evans

2001. “Collaborative Strategy: An Analysis of the Changing World of International Airline Alliances.” Tourism Management 22 (3): 229–43.

30.

Gibson

C. B.

2017. “Elaboration, Generalization, Triangulation, and Interpretation.” Organizational Research Methods 20 (2): 193–223.

31.

Gilbert

Wong

R. K. C.

2003. “Passenger Expectations and Airline Services: A Hong Kong Based Study.” Tourism Management 24 (5): 519–32.

32.

Gössling

2013. “National Emissions from Tourism: An Overlooked Policy Challenge?” Energy Policy 59:433–42.

33.

Grandori

Soda

1995. “Interfirm Networks: Antecedents, Mechanisms and Forms.” Organization Studies 16 (2): 183–214.

34.

Gronau

Kagermeier

2007. “Key Factors for Successful Leisure and Tourism Public Transport Provision.” Journal of Transport Geography 15 (2): 127–35.

35.

Gronau

2017. “Encouraging Behavioural Change towards Sustainable Tourism: A German Approach to Free Public Transport for Tourists.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism 25 (2): 265–75.

36.

Gross

2009. “Competition and Cooperation in Local Public Transport: Realistic Scenario or Just a Fantasy?” Transformations in Business and Economics 8 (1): 86–100.

37.

Gulati

Singh

1998. “The Architecture of Cooperation: Managing Coordination Costs and Appropriation Concerns in Strategic Alliances.” Administrative Science Quarterly 43 (4): 781–814.

38.

Gyr

2010. “The History of Tourism: Structures on the Path to Modernity.” European History Online (EGO). http://ieg-ego.eu/en/threads/europe-on-the-road/the-history-of-tourism/ueli-gyr-the-history-of-tourism (assessed October 20, 2018).

39.

Hagedoorn

Schakenraad

J. O. S.

1994. “The Effect of Strategic Technology Alliances on Company Performance.” Strategic Management Journal 15 (4): 291–309.

40.

Hall

D. H.

1999. “Conceptualising Tourism Transport: Inequality and Externality Issues.” Journal of Transport Geography 7 (3): 181–88.

41.

Hall

2010. “Equal Access for All? Regulative Mechanisms, Inequality and Tourism Mobility.” In Tourism and Inequality: Problems and Prospects, edited by Cole

Stroma

Morgan

Nigel

, 34–48. Wallingford, UK: CABI.

42.

Halsall

D. A.

2001. “Railway Heritage and the Tourist Gaze: Stoomtram Hoorn-Medemblik.” Journal of Transport Geography 9 (2): 151–60.

43.

Heinze

G. W.

Kill

H. H.

1997. Leisure and Mobility: New Solutions for Leisure Travel. Hannover: Akad. für Raumforschung und Landesplanung.

44.

Hill

Shaw

R. N.

1995. “Co-Marketing Tourism Internationally: Bases for Strategic Alliances.” Journal of Travel Research 34 (1): 25–32.

45.

Hitt

M. A.

Dacin

M. T.

Levitas

Arregle

J.-L.

Borza

2000. “Partner Selection in Emerging and Developed Market Contexts: Resource-Based and Organizational Learning Perspectives.” Academy of Management Journal 43 (3): 449–67.

46.

Hyde

K. F.

Laesser

2009. “A Structural Theory of the Vacation.” Tourism Management 30 (2): 240–48.

47.

Jansen

Perian

Beckmann

K. J.

2002. “Aktivitätenmuster und Raum-Zeit-Verhalten in der Freizeit.” Aachen: Institut für Stadtbauwesen und Stadtverkehr RWTH Aachen, Stadt Region Land, Heft 73.

48.

Johann

2014. “The Relationship Building Strategy with Partners in Tourism Market.” European Journal of Tourism, Hospitality and Recreation 95–105.

49.

Kale

Dyer

J. H.

Singh

2002. “Alliance Capability, Stock Market Response, and Long-Term Alliance Success: The Role of the Alliance Function.” Strategic Management Journal 23 (8): 747–67.

50.

Khadaroo

Seetanah

2007. “Transport Infrastructure and Tourism Development.” Annals of Tourism Research 34 (4): 1021–32.

51.

Laesser

1999. “Implementing Destination Structures: Experiences with Swiss Cases.” Turizam 47 (3): 185–280.

52.

Lamb

Davidson

1997. “Tourism and Transportation in Ontario, Canada.” In Practising Responsible Tourism: International Case Studies in Tourism Planning, Policy and Development, edited by Harrison

Lynn C.

Husbands

Winston

, 261–76. Chichester, UK: Wiley.

53.

Lavie

2006. “The Competitive Advantage of Interconnected Firms: An Extension of the Resource-Based View.” Academy of Management 31 (3): 638–58.

54.

Le-Klähn

D. T.

Gerike

Hall

C. M.

2014. “Visitor Users vs. Non-users of Public Transport: The Case of Munich, Germany.” Journal of Destination Marketing and Management 3 (3): 152–61.

55.

Leiper

1990. Tourism Systems: An Interdisciplinary Perspective. Palmerston North, NZ: Department of Management Systems, Business Studies Faculty, Massey University.

56.

Lohmann

Duval

D. T.

2014. “Destination Morphology: A New Framework to Understand Tourism–Transport Issues?” Journal of Destination Marketing & Management 3:133–36.

57.

Lumsdon

Page

2004. “Progress in Transport and Tourism Research: Reformulating the Transport-Tourism Interface and Future Research Agendas.” In Tourism and Transport: Issues and Agenda for the New Millennium, edited by Lumsdon

Les

Stephen Page, 1–27. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

58.

Mahrous

A. A.

Hassan

S. S.

2017. “Achieving Superior Customer Experience: An Investigation of Multichannel Choices in the Travel and Tourism Industry of an Emerging Market.” Journal of Travel Research 56 (8): 1049–64.

59.

March

Wilkinson

Ian

. 2009. “Conceptual Tools for Evaluating Tourism Partnerships.” Tourism Management 30 (3): 455–62.

60.

Michel

J. G.

Hambrick

D. C.

1992. “Diversification Posture and Top Management Team Characteristics.” Academy of Management Journal 35:9–37.

61.

Molina-Azorin

J. F.

Bergh

D. D.

Corley

K. G.

Ketchen

D. J.

2017. “Mixed Methods in the Organizational Sciences.” Organizational Research Methods 20 (2): 179–92.

62.

Nash

2008. “Passenger Railway Reform in the Last 20 Years: European Experience Reconsidered.” Research in Transportation Economics 22:61–70.

63.

Ohnmacht

Götz

Schad

2009. “Leisure Mobility Styles in Swiss Conurbations: Construction and Empirical Analysis.” Transportation 36 (2): 243–65.

64.

Page

2009. Transport and Tourism: Global Perspectives, 3rd ed. Harlow, UK: Pearson Prentice Hall.

65.

Parkhe

1993. “Strategic Alliance Structuring: A Game Theoretic and Transaction Cost Examination of Interfirm Cooperation.” Academy of Management Journal 36 (4): 794–829.

66.

Perch-Nielsen

Sesartic

Stucki

2010. “The Greenhouse Gas Intensity of the Tourism Sector: The Case of Switzerland.” Environmental Science & Policy 13:131–40.

67.

Petersen

2016. “Watching the Swiss: A Network Approach to Rural and Exurban Public Transport.” Transport Policy 52:175–85.

68.

Rey

Myro

R. L.

Galera

2011. “Effect of Low-Cost Airlines on Tourism in Spain: A Dynamic Panel Data Model.” Journal of Air Transport Management 17 (3): 163–67.

69.

Rhonden

Lumsdon

2006. “A Conceptual Classification of the Transport-Tourist Experience.” Paper presented at: The European Transport Conference (ETC), Strasbourg.

70.

Rosenfeld

S. A.

1996. “Does Cooperation Enhance Competitiveness? Assessing the Impacts of Inter-firm Collaboration.” Research Policy 25:247–63.

71.

Sarkar

M. B.

Echambadi

Harrisor

J. S.

2001. “Alliance Entrepreneurship and Firm Market Performance.” Strategic Management Journal 22 (6/7): 701–11.

72.

Sarma

2003. “Towards Positioning a Tourist Destination: A Study of Northeast India.” Asean Journal on Hospitality and Tourism 2 (2): 104–19.

73.

Saxton

1997. “The Effects of Partner and Relationship Characteristics on Alliance Outcomes.” Academy of Management Journal 40 (2): 443–61.

74.

Schiefelbusch

Jain

Schäfer

Müller

2007. “Transport and Tourism: Roadmap to Integrated Planning Developing and Assessing Integrated Travel Chains.” Journal of Transport Geography 15 (2): 94–103.

75.

Schlich

Schönfelder

Hanson

Axhausen

K. W.

2002. “Leisure Travel in a Historical Perspective: Changes in the Structures of Time and Space Use.” Arbeitsbericht Verkehrsund Raumplanung 107.

76.

Schreiner

Kale

Corsten

2009. “What Really Is Alliance Management Capability and How Does It Impact Alliance Outcomes and Success?” Strategic Management Journal 30 (13): 1395–419.

77.

Schweizer Bundesrat. 2009. Verordnung über die Abgeltung des Regionalen Personenverkehrs—ARPV [Ordinance on the Charging of Regional Passenger Traffic]. https://www.admin.ch/opc/de/official-compilation/2009/6061.pdf (accessed November 15, 2018).

78.

Schweizer Tourismus-Verband. 2017. “Schweizer Tourismus in Zahlen 2016: Struktur- Und Branchendaten.”

79.

SECO. 2016. “Umsetzungsprogramm der Tourismuspolitik 2016-2019 (Implementation Program of Tourism Policy).” Staatssekretariat für Wirtschaft.

80.

Seetaram

2016. “Special Focus. Economics of Tourism and Transport: Introduction.” Tourism Economics 22 (2): 203–6.

81.

Seppälä-Esser

Airey

Szivas

2009. “The Dependence of Tourism SMEs on NTOs.” Journal of Travel Research 48 (2): 177–90.

82.

Siegrist

Aufdereggen

Lintzmeyer

Spiess

2016. “Chapter 13: The Economic Potential of Regional Nature Pakrs in Switzerland: A Case Study of the Planned Regional Nature Parks in the Canton of Bern.” In Protected Areas and Regional Development in Europe: Towards a New Model for the 21st Century, edited by Mose

Ingo

, 213–30. London: Routledge.

83.

Stuart

T. E.

2000. “Interorganizational Alliances and the Performance of Firms: A Study of Growth and Innovation Rates in a High-Technology Industry.” Strategic Management Journal 21:791–811.

84.

M. M.

Wall

2009. “The Qinghai-Tibet Railway and Tibetan Tourism: Travelers’ Perspectives.” Tourism Management 30 (5): 650–57.

85.

Swiss Federal Council. 2017. Tourism Strategy of the Swiss Confederation. Bern: Swiss Federal Council.

86.

Thompson

Schofield

2007. “An Investigation of the Relationship between Public Transport Performance and Destination Satisfaction.” Journal of Transport Geography 15 (2): 136–44.

87.

Thorgren

Wincent

Boter

2012. “Small Firms in Multipartner R&D Alliances: Gaining Benefits by Acquiescing.” Journal of Engineering and Technology Management 29 (4): 453–67.

88.

Tissot

2004. “A Travers Les Alpes. Le Montreux-Oberland Bernois ou la Construction d’un Système Touristique, 1900-1970.” Geschichte der Alpen 9:227–44.

89.

Tissot

2006. “Développement des Transports et Tourisme: Quelles Relations?” Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Geschichte 56 (1): 31–37.

90.

Topolšek

Mrnjavac

Kovačić

2014. “Integration of Travel Agencies with Transport Providers.” Tourism Management Perspectives 9:14–23.

91.

UNWTO and UNEP (United Nations World Tourism Organization and United Nations Environment Programme). 2008. “Climate Change and Tourism—Responding to Global Challenges.” Madrid. https://sdt.unwto.org/sites/all/files/docpdf/climate2008.pdf (accessed March 4, 2019).

92.

von Arx

Thao

V. T.

Wegelin

Maarfield

Frölicher

2018. “Research in Transportation Economics The Development of International Passenger Rail Services from 2007 to 2016 : The Case of Switzerland.” Research in Transportation Economics 69:326–36.

93.

VöV (Verband öffentlicher Verkehr). 2013. Direct Service Manual on Public Transport Practices. Berne: Swiss Association of Public Transport (SAPT).

94.

VöV (Verband öffentlicher Verkehr). 2017. Facts and Figures: Swiss Public Transport 2016/2017.

95.

WTTC. 2018. “Economic Impact of Travel & Tourism 2018: Switzerland.” London. https://www.wttc.org/-/media/files/reports/economic-impact-research/countries-2018/switzerland2018.pdf%22%5Ct%22_blank%22%5Ct%22_blank (accessed November 14, 2018).

96.

Yang

Zhang

2012. “Effects of High-Speed Rail and Air Transport Competition on Prices, Profits and Welfare.” Transportation Research Part B: Methodological 46 (10): 1322–33.

97.

Zach

2012. “Partners and Innovation in American Destination Marketing Organizations.” Journal of Travel Research 51 (4): 412–25.

98.

Zentralbahn. 2017. “Geschäftsbericht 2016 (Annual Report).” https://www.zentralbahn.ch/sites/default/files/180323_Zentralbahn_GB_2017_Endversion%20%28klein%29.pdf (accessed October 24, 2018).

99.

Zhang

Song

Huang

G. Q.

2009. “Tourism Supply Chain Management: A New Research Agenda.” Tourism Management 30 (3): 345–58.