This research investigates the impact of different degrees of price dispersion on travelers’ hotel choice. More specifically, within an online travel agency (OTA) context, we examine the effect of wide (vs. narrow) price dispersion on hotel preference. In addition, we suggest two boundary conditions for this effect: salience of external regular price and perception of destination uncertainty. Across multiple studies, our results show that travelers prefer a hotel option featuring wide price dominance dispersion. Additionally, both the presence of an external regular price and the level of uncertainty associated with the hotel destination act as moderating influences. This work represents an emerging direction in the online price dispersion literature, namely, exploring the consequences of online price dispersion. In practice, by understanding the influence of price dispersion on consumer choice, OTAs can develop more effective pricing strategies in partnership with their hotel room suppliers.
AbrateG.VigliaG. 2016. “Strategic and Tactical Price Decisions in Hotel Revenue Management.” Tourism Management55:123–32.
2.
AinscoughT. L.2005. “The Effect of Brand, Agent and Price on Consumer Evaluation of Travel Services.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing19 (1): 39–48.
3.
AlbaJ.LynchJ.WeitzB.JaniszewskiC.LutzR.SawyerA.WoodS. 1997. “Interactive Home Shopping: Consumer, Retailer, and Manufacturer Incentives to Participate in Electronic Marketplaces.” Journal of Marketing61 (3): 38–53.
4.
AlbaJ.MelaC. F.ShimpT. A.UrbanyJ. E. 1999. “The Effect of Discount Frequency and Depth of Consumer Price Judgments.” Journal of Consumer Research26 (2): 99–114.
5.
AncaraniF.ShankarV. 2004. “Price Levels and Price Dispersion within and across Multiple Retailer Types: Further Evidence and Extension.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science32 (2): 176–87.
6.
AssafA. G.OhH.TsionasM. G. 2016. “Unobserved Heterogeneity in Hospitality and Tourism Research.” Journal of Travel Research55 (6): 774–88.
BayeM. R.MorganJ. 2001. “Information Gatekeepers on the Internet and the Competitiveness of Homogeneous Product Markets.” American Economic Review91 (3): 454–74.
9.
BayeM. R.MorganJ.ScholtenP. 2004. “Price Dispersion in the Small and in the Large: Evidence from an Internet Price Comparison Site.” Journal of Industrial Economics52 (4): 463–96.
10.
BaylisK.PerloffJ. M. 2002. “Price Dispersion on the Internet: Good Firms and Bad Firms.” Review of Industrial Organization21 (3): 305–24.
11.
BennettM. M.LaiC. W. K. 2005. “The Impact of the Internet on Travel Agencies in Taiwan.” Tourism and Hospitality Research6 (1): 8–23.
12.
BernoulliD.1738. “Exposition of a New Theory on the Measurement of Risk.” Econometrica22 (1954): 23–6.
13.
BiswasA.BlairE. A. 1991. “Contextual Effects of Reference Price in Retail Advertisements.” Journal of Marketing55 (3): 1–12.
14.
BiswasD.2004. “Economics of Information in the Web Economy: Towards a New Theory?” Journal of Business Research57 (7): 724–33.
15.
BiswasD.BurmanB. 2009. “The Effects of Product Digitalization and Price Dispersion on Search Intentions in Offline versus Online Settings: The Mediating Effects of Perceived Risks.” Journal of Product & Brand Management18 (7): 477–86.
16.
BoltonL. E.KehH. T.AlbaJ. W. 2010. “How Do Price Fairness Perceptions Differ across Culture?” Journal of Marketing Research47 (3): 564–76.
17.
BoltonL. E.WarlopL.AlbaJ. W. 2003. “Consumer Perceptions of Price (Un) Fairness.” Journal of Consumer Research29 (4): 474–91.
18.
BornemannT.HomburgC. 2011. “Psychological Distance and the Dual Role of Price.” Journal of Consumer Research38 (3): 490–504.
19.
BrewerP.ChristodoulidouN.RothenbergerM. 2005. “Thoughts on the Evolution of Rooms Inventory.” Journal for Hospitality Financial and Technology Professionals11:22–24.
20.
BrownJ. R.GoolsbeeA. 2002. “Does the Internet Make Markets More Competitive? Evidence from the Life Insurance Industry.” Journal of Political Economy110 (3): 481–507.
21.
BrunoH. A.CheH.DuttaS. 2012. “Role of Reference Price on Price and Quantity: Insights from Business-to-Business Markets.” Journal of Marketing Research49 (5): 640–54.
22.
BrynjolfssonE.SmithM. D. 2000. “Frictionless Commerce? A Comparison of Internet and Conventional Retailers.” Management Science46 (4): 563–85.
23.
ChangS.ChangC.SuW. 2015. “Quality or Sacrifice? The Influence of Decision Task and Product Characteristics on the Dual Role of Price.” Psychological Reports: Employment Psychology & Marketing117 (1): 72–88.
24.
ChenE. Y. I.BeiL. 2005. “The Effects of Price Dispersion and Suggested List Price on Consumers’ Internal Reference Price.” Consumer Interests Annual51:160–70.
25.
ChenH. S.YuanJ. 2016. “A Journey to Save on Travel Expenses: The Intentional Buying Process of Consumers on Opaque-Selling Websites.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management25 (7): 820–40.
26.
ChenP.HittL. M. 2003. Understanding Price Dispersion in Internet-Enabled Markets. Working Paper, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA.
27.
ChoiC.MattilaA. S. 2018. “The Effects of Internal and External Reference Prices on Travelers’ Price Evaluations.” Journal of Travel Research57 (8): 1068–77.
28.
ChristodoulidouN.BrewerP.FeinsteinA. H.BaiB. 2007. “Electronic Channels of Distribution: Challenges and Solutions for Hotel Operators.” Hospitality Review25 (2): 92–100.
29.
ChristodoulidouN.ConnollyD. J.BrewerP. 2010. “An Examination of the Transactional Relationship between Online Travel Agencies, Travel Meta Sites, and Suppliers.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management22 (7): 1048–62.
30.
ChuaB.LeeS.GohB.HanH. 2015. “Impacts of Cruise Service Quality and Price on Vacationers’ Cruise Experience: Moderating Role of Price Sensitivity.” International Journal of Hospitality Management44:131–45.
31.
ClayK.KrishnanR.WolffE.FernandesD. 2002. “Retail Strategies on the Web: Price and Non–Price Competition in the Online Book Industry.” Journal of Industrial Economics50 (3): 351–67.
32.
ClemonsE. K.HannI.HittL. M. “Price Dispersion and Differentiation in Online Travel: An Empirical Investigation.” Management Science48 (4): 534–49.
33.
DolanR. J.MoonY. 2000. “Pricing and Market Making on the Internet.” Journal of Interactive Marketing14 (2): 56–73.
34.
EricksonG. M.JohanssonJ. K. 1985. “The Role of Price in Multi-attribute Product Evaluation.” Journal of Consumer Research12 (2): 195–99.
35.
GarbarinoE.MaxwellS. 2010. “Consumer Response to Norm-Breaking Pricing Events in E-commerce.” Journal of Business Research63 (9/10): 1066–72.
36.
GerardiK. S.ShapiroA. 2009. “Does Competition Reduce Price Dispersion? New Evidence from the Airline Industry.” Journal of Political Economy117 (1): 1–37.
37.
GrewalD.RoggeveenA.Lindsey-MullikinJ. 2014. “The Contingent Effect of Semantic Price Cues.” Journal of Retailing90 (2): 198–205.
38.
HayesA. F.MontoyaA. K.RockwoodN. J. 2017. “The Analysis of Mechanisms and Their Contingencies: PROCESS versus Structural Equation Modeling.” Australasian Marketing Journal25 (1): 76–81.
39.
HillK. M.FombelleP. W.SirianniN. J. 2016. “Shopping under the Influence of Curiosity: How Retailers Use Mystery to Drive Purchase Motivations.” Journal of Business Research69 (3): 1028–34.
40.
HinterhuberA.2015. “Violations of Rational Choice Principles in Pricing Decisions.” Industrial Marketing Management47:65–74.
41.
HuangJ.ChangC.ChenC. Y. 2005. “Perceived Fairness of Pricing on the Internet.” Journal of Economic Psychology26 (3): 343–61.
42.
HuberJ.PayneJ. W.PutoC.1982. “Adding Asymmetrically Dominated Alternatives: Violations of Regularity and the Similarity Hypothesis.” Journal of Consumer Research9 (1): 90–98.
43.
HuberJ.PutoC. 1983. “Market Boundaries and Product Choice: Illustrating Attraction and Substitution Effects.” Journal of Consumer Research10 (1): 31–44.
44.
HungW.ShangJ.WangF. 2010. “Pricing Determinants in the Hotel Industry: Quantile Regression Analysis.” International Journal of Hospitality Management29 (3): 378–84.
45.
HwangE.KimJ.LeeJ. C.KimS. 2018. “To Do or to Have, Now or Later, in Travel: Consumption Order Preference of Material and Experiential Travel Activities.” Journal of Travel Research. Published online September 5.
46.
JacobsonR.ObermillerC. 1990. “The Formation of Expected Future Price: A Reference Price for Forward-Looking Consumers.” Journal of Consumer Research16 (4): 420–32.
47.
JiangP.2002. “A Model of Price Search Behavior in Electronic Marketplace.” Internet Research12 (2): 181–90.
48.
JinL.HeY.ZhangY. 2013. “How Power States Influence Consumers’ Perceptions of Price Unfairness.” Journal of Consumer Research40 (5): 818–33.
49.
JosiamB. M.HobsonJ. S. P. 1995. “Consumer Choice in Context: The Decoy Effect in Travel and Tourism.” Journal of Travel Research34 (1): 45–50.
50.
KahnemanD.TverskyA. 1979. “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decisions under Risk.” Econometrica47:263–91.
51.
KalyanaramG.LittleJ. D. C. 1994. “An Empirical Analysis of Latitude of Price Acceptance in Consumer Package Goods.” Journal of Consumer Research21 (3): 408–18.
52.
KannanP. K.KopalleP. K. 2001. “Dynamic Pricing on the Internet: Importance and Implications for Consumer Behavior.” International Journal of Electronic Commerce5 (3): 63–83.
KimD.JangS. S. 2013. “Price Placebo Effect in Hedonic Consumption.” International Journal of Hospitality Management35:306–15.
55.
KimJ.HwangE.PhillipsM.JangS.KimJ.SpenceM. T.ParkJ. 2018. “Mediation Analysis Revisited: Practical Suggestions for Addressing Common Deficiencies.” Australasian Marketing Journal26 (1): 59–64.
56.
KimJ.KimP. B.KimJ. 2017. “Different or Similar Choices: The Effect of Decision Framing on Variety Seeking in Travel Bundle Packages.” Journal of Travel Research57 (1): 99–115.
57.
KimJ.KimS.LeeJ.KimP. B.CuiY. 2019. “Influence of Choice Architecture on the Preference for a Pro-Environmental Hotel.” Journal of Travel Research. Published online April15.
58.
KimS. Y.KimJ. U.ParkS. C. 2017. “The Effects of Perceived Value, Website Trust and Hotel Trust on Online Hotel Booking Intention.” Sustainability9 (12): 1–14.
59.
KimW. G.ChoM.KimD.ShinG. 2014. “The Effect of Price Dispersion on Hotel Performance.” Tourism Economics20 (6): 1159–79.
60.
KrachtJ.WangY. 2010. “Examining the Tourism Distribution Channel: Evolution and Transformation.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management22 (5): 736–57.
61.
KrishnaA.BrieschR.LehmannD. R.YuanH. 2002. “A Meta-analysis of the Impact of Price Presentation on Perceived Savings.” Journal of Retailing78 (2): 101–18.
62.
KrishnanB. C.DuttaS.JhaS. 2013. “Effectiveness of Exaggerated Advertised Reference Prices: The Role of Decision Time Pressure.” Journal of Retailing89 (1): 105–13.
63.
KuesterS.FeurerS.SchuhmacherM. C.ReinartzD. 2015. “Comparing the Incomparable? How Consumers Judge the Price Fairness of New Products.” International Journal of Research in Marketing32 (3): 272–83.
64.
KungM.MonroeK. B.CoxJ. L. 2002. “Pricing on the Internet.” Journal of Product & Brand Management11 (5): 274–88.
65.
LeeC. H.CranageD. A. 2010. “Customer Uncertainty Dimensions and Online Information Search in the Context of Hotel Booking Channel.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management19 (5): 397–420.
66.
LichtensteinD. R.2005. “Price Perceptions, Merchant Incentives, and Consumer Welfare.” Journal of Product & Brand Management14 (6): 357–61.
67.
LockyerT.2005. “The Perceived Importance of Price as One Hotel Selection Dimension.” Tourism Management26 (4): 529–37.
68.
MaserB.WeiermairK. 1998. “Travel Decision-Making: From the Vantage Point of Perceived Risk and Information Preferences.” Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing7 (4): 107–18.
69.
MattilaA. S.O’NeillJ. W. 2003. “Relationships between Hotel Room Pricing, Occupancy, and Guest Satisfaction: A Longitudinal Case of a Midscale Hotel in the United States.” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research27 (3): 328–41.
70.
MazumdarT.RajS. P.SinhaI. 2005. “Reference Price Research: Review and Propositions.” Journal of Marketing69 (4): 84–102.
71.
MittelmanM.AndradeE. B.ChattopadhyayA.BrendlC. M. 2014. “The Offer Framing Effect: Choosing Single versus Bundled Offerings Affects Variety Seeking.” Journal of Consumer Research41 (4): 953–64.
72.
MontgomeryH.1983. “Decision Rules and the Search for a Dominance Structure: Towards a Process Model of Decision Making.” In Advances in Psychology, 14: 343–369. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
73.
MoralesA.AmirO.LeeL. 2017. “Keeping It Real in Experimental Research—Understanding When, Where, and How to Enhance Realism and Measure Consumer Behavior.” Journal of Consumer Research44 (2): 465–76.
74.
MoreauC. P.LehmannD. R.MarkmanA. B. 2001. “Entrenched Knowledge Structures and Consumer Response to New Products.” Journal of Marketing Research38 (1): 14–29.
75.
MurrayK. B.1991. “A Test of Service Marketing Theory: Consumer Information Acquisition Activities.” Journal of Marketing55 (1): 10–25.
76.
NooneB. M.MattilaA. S. 2009. “Hotel Revenue Management and the Internet: The Effect of Price Presentation Strategies on Customers’ Willingness to Book.” International Journal of Hospitality Management28 (2): 272–79.
77.
OhH.1999. “Service Quality, Customer Satisfaction, and Customer Value: A Holistic Perspective.” International Journal of Hospitality Management18 (1): 67–82.
78.
PanX.RatchfordB. T.ShankarV. 2002. “Can Price Dispersion in Online Markets Be Explained by Differences in E-tailer Service Quality?” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science30 (4): 433–45.
79.
PanX.RatchfordB. T.ShankarV. 2004. “Price Dispersion on the Internet: A Review and Directions for Future Research.” Journal of Interactive Marketing18 (4): 116–35.
80.
ParkJ.KimJ. 2005. “The Effects of Decoys on Preference Shifts: The Role of Attractiveness and Providing Justification.” Journal of Consumer Psychology15 (2): 94–107.
81.
PettiboneJ. C.WedellD. H. 2000. “Examining Models of Nondominated Decoy Effects across Judgment and Choice.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes81 (2): 300–28.
82.
PreacherK. J.HayesA. F. 2008. “Asymptotic and Resampling Strategies for Assessing and Comparing Indirect Effects in Multiple Mediator Models.” Behavior Research Methods40 (3): 879–91.
83.
RatchfordB. T.PanX.ShankarV. 2003. “On the Efficiency of Internet Markets for Consumer Goods.” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing22 (1): 4–16.
84.
SalopS.StiglitzJ. 1977. “Bargains and Ripoffs: A Model of Monopolistically Competitive Price Dispersion.” Review of Economic Studies44 (3): 493–510.
85.
SalopS.StiglitzJ. E. 1982. “The Theory of Sales: A Simple Model of Equilibrium Price Dispersion with Identical Agents.” American Economic Review72 (5): 1121–30.
86.
SenguptaA.WigginsS. N. 2014. “Airline Pricing, Price Dispersion, and Ticket Characteristics on and off the Internet.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy6 (1): 272–307.
87.
SimonsonI.1989. “Choice Based on Reasons: The Case of Attraction and Compromise Effects.” Journal of Consumer Research16 (2): 158–74.
88.
SmithM. D.2001. “The Law of One Price? Price Dispersion and Parallel Pricing in Internet Markets.” Working Paper, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA.
89.
SohC.MarkusM. L.GohK. H. 2006. “Electronic Marketplaces and Price Transparency: Strategy, Information Technology, and Success.” MIS Quarterly30 (3): 705–23.
90.
StanglB.InversiniA.ScheggR. 2016. “Hotels’ Dependency on Online Intermediaries and Their Chosen Distribution Channel Portfolios: Three Country Insights.” International Journal of Hospitality Management52:87–96.
91.
SuterT. A.BurtonS. 1996. “Believability and Consumer Perceptions of Implausible Reference Prices in Retail Advertisements.” Psychology & Marketing13 (1): 37–54.
92.
TseA. C. B.2003. “Disintermediation of Travel Agents in the Hotel Industry.” International Journal of Hospitality Management22 (4): 453–60.
93.
TverskyA.ShafirE. 1992. “Choice under Conflict: The Dynamics of Deferred Decision.” Psychological Science3 (6): 358–61.
94.
UrbanyJ. E.BeardenW. O.WeilbakerD. C. 1988. “The Effect of Plausible and Exaggerated Reference Prices on Consumer Perceptions and Price Search.” Journal of Consumer Research15 (1): 95–110.
95.
UrbanyJ. E.DicksonP. R.WilkieW. L. 1989. “Buyer Uncertainty and Information Search.” Journal of Consumer Research16 (2): 208–15.
96.
VarianH. R.2000. “Buying, Sharing and Renting Information Goods.” Journal of Industrial Economics48 (4): 473–88.
97.
VölcknerF.2008. “The Dual Role of Price: Decomposing Consumers’ Reactions to Price.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science36 (3): 359–77.
98.
VossG. B.ParasuramanA.GrewalD. 1998. “The Roles of Price, Performance, and Expectations in Determining Satisfaction in Service Exchanges.” Journal of Marketing62 (4): 46–61.
99.
WangD.NicolauJ. L. 2017. “Price Determinants of Sharing Economy Based Accommodation Rental: A Study of Listings from 33 Cities on Airbnb.com.” International Journal of Hospitality Management62:120–31.
100.
WuK.VassilevaJ.NoorianZ.ZhaoY. 2015. “How Do You Feel When You See a List of Prices? The Interplay among Price Dispersion, Perceived Risk and Initial Trust in Chinese C2C Market.” Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services25:36–46.
101.
XingX.YangZ.TangF. 2006. “A Comparison of Time-Varying Online Price and Price Dispersion between Multichannel and Dotcom DVD Retailers.” Journal of Interactive Marketing20 (2): 3–20.
102.
ZeithamlV. A.1981. “How Consumer Evaluation Processes Differ between Goods and Services.” In Marketing of Services, edited by DonnellyJ.GeorgeW., 186–190. Chicago: American Marketing Association.
103.
ZhuangH.LeszczycP. T. P.LinY. 2018. “Why Is Price Dispersion Higher Online Than Offline? The Impact of Retailer Type and Shopping Risk on Price Dispersion.” Journal of Retailing94 (2): 136–53.
