Sustainable tourism quality control tools (QCTs) are voluntary mechanisms that translate sustainable tourism concepts into practice. While essential to sustainable tourism practice, the most recent depiction of their diversity occurred in the early 2000s and identified just four types and one variability parameter. Reviewing and synthesizing the extant literature, this study identifies 15 types of QCTs, each possessing numerous variations, and seven critical variability parameters. Together these constitute the new “QCT multiverse.” This contemporary perspective on QCT diversity facilitates engagement with sustainable tourism by indicating the more comprehensive array of practices available for destination practitioners and managers.
Álvarez GilM.JimenezJ., BurgosLorenteJ. Céspedes. 2001. “An Analysis of Environmental Management, Organizational Context and Performance of Spanish Hotels.” Omega29:457–71.
2.
AssafG.JosiassenA.CvelbarL. Knežević. 2012. “Does Triple Bottom Line Reporting Improve Hotel Performance?” International Journal of Hospitality Management31:596–600.
3.
AyusoS.2006. “Adoption of Voluntary Environmental Tools for Sustainable Tourism: Analysing the Experience of Spanish Hotels.” Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management13:207–20.
4.
AyusoS.2007. “Comparing Voluntary Policy Instruments for Sustainable Tourism: The Experience of the Spanish Hotel Sector.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism15 (2): 144–59.
5.
BendellJ.FontX.2004. “Which Tourism Rules? Green Standards and GATS.” Annals of Tourism Research31 (1): 139–56.
6.
BestM.ThapaB.2011. “Environmental Management in the Caribbean Accommodations Sector.” Tourism59 (2): 145–68.
7.
BerghoefN.DoddsR.2013. “Determinants of Interest in Eco-Labelling in the Ontario Wine Industry.” Journal of Cleaner Production52:263–71.
8.
BestM.ThapaB.2013. “Motives, Facilitators and Constraints of Environmental Management in the Caribbean Accommodations Sector.” Journal of Cleaner Production52:165–75.
9.
BienA.2006. A Simple User’s Guide to Certification for Sustainable Tourism and Ecotourism, 3rd ed.Washington, DC: Center for Ecotourism and Sustainable Development.
10.
BlackR.2002. “Towards a Model for Tour Guide Certification: An Analysis of the Australian EcoGuide Program.” PhD diss., Monash University.
11.
BlackR.2007. “Professional Certification: A Mechanism to Enhance Ecotour Guide Performance.” In Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism, edited by BlackR.CrabtreeA., 316–35. Wallingford: CABI.
12.
BlackR.CrabtreeA., eds. 2007. Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism. Wallingford: CABI.
13.
BlackR.WeilerB.2005. “Quality Assurance and Regulatory Mechanisms in the Tour Guiding Industry: A Systematic Review.” Journal of Tourism Studies16 (1): 24–37.
14.
BlangyI.Epler WoodM.1993. “Developing and Implementing Ecotourism Guidelines for Wildlands and Neighboring Communities.” In Ecotourism: A Guide for Local Planners, edited by LindbergK.HawkinsD., 32–55. North Bennington: Ecotourism Society.
15.
BohdanowiczP.2006. “Environmental Awareness and Initiatives in the Swedish and Polish Hotel Industries-Survey Results.” Hospitality Management25:662–82.
16.
BohdanowiczP.MartinacI.2007. “Determinants and Benchmarking of Resource Consumption in Hotels—Case Study of Hilton International and Scandic in Europe.” Energy & Buildings39:82–95.
17.
BohdanowiczP.SimanicB.MartinacI.2004. “Environmental Training and Measures at Scandic Hotels, Sweden. Sustainability and Mass Destinations: Challenges and Possibilities.” Business Enterprises for Sustainable Travel Education Network Think Tank IV Conference Proceedings. Esbjerg, Denmark, 30 June – 4 July.
18.
BohdanowiczP.ZientaraP.2008. “Corporate Social Responsibility in Hospitality: Issues and Implications. A Case Study of Scandic.” Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism8 (4): 271–93.
19.
BohdanowiczP.ZientaraP.NovotnaE.2011. “International Hotel Chains and Environmental Protection: An Analysis of Hilton’s We Care! Programme (Europe, 2006-2008).” Journal of Sustainable Tourism19 (7): 797–816.
20.
Bonilla-PriegoM.FontX.Pacheco-OlivaresM. R.2014. “Corporate Sustainability Reporting Index and Baseline Data for the Cruise Industry.” Tourism Management44:149–60.
21.
Bonilla-PriegoM.NajeraJ.FontX.2011. “Environmental Management Decision-Making in Certified Hotels.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism19 (3): 261–81.
22.
BramwellB.HighamJ.LaneB.MillerG.2016. “Twenty-Five Years of Sustainable Tourism and theJournal of Sustainable Tourism: Looking Back and Moving Forward.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism25 (1): 1–9.
23.
BrickerK.2009. “Sustainable Tourism Development in the United States of America: An Intricate Balance from Policy to Practice.” In Tourism Enterprises and Sustainable Development, edited by LeslieD., 64–87. New York: Routledge.
24.
BrickerK.SchultzJ.2011. “Sustainable Tourism in the USA: A Comparative Look at the Global Sustainable Tourism Criteria.” Tourism Recreation Research36 (3): 215–29.
25.
BuckleyR.2002. “Tourism Ecolabels.” Annals of Tourism Research29 (1): 183–208.
26.
BuckleyR.2012. “Sustainability Reporting and Ecocertification In Tourism.” Tourism Recreation Research37 (1): 85–90.
27.
ButlerR.1990. “Alternative Tourism: Pious Hope or Trojan Horse?” Journal of Travel Research28 (3): 40–45.
28.
CarasukR.BeckenS.HugheyK. F.2013. “Exploring Values, Drivers, and Barriers as Antecedents of Implementing Responsible Tourism.” Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research40 (1): 19–36.
29.
CarmodyJ.2013. “Intensive Tour Guide Training in Regional Australia: An Analysis of the Savannah Guides Organisation and Professional Development Schools.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism21 (5): 679–94.
30.
ChanE.2008. “Barriers to EMS in the Hotel Industry.” International Journal of Hospitality Management27 (2): 187–96.
31.
ChanE.2011. “Implementing Environmental Management Systems in Small- and Medium-Sized Hotels: Obstacles.” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research35 (1): 3–23.
32.
ClarkJ.1997. “A Framework of Approaches to Sustainable Tourism.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism5:224–33.
33.
CreswellJ.2007. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing among Five Approaches, 2nd ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
34.
De GrosboisD.2012. “Corporate Social Responsibility Reporting by the Global Hotel Industry: Commitment, Initiatives and Performance.” International Journal of Hospitality Management31:896–905.
35.
De GrosboisD.FennellD.2011. “Carbon Footprint of the Global Hotel Companies: Comparison of Methodologies and Results.” Tourism Recreation Research36 (3): 231–45.
36.
DecropA.1999. “Triangulation in Qualitative Tourism Research.” Tourism Management20 (1): 157–61.
37.
DecropA.2004. “Trustworthiness in Qualitative Tourism Research.” In Qualitative Research in Tourism: Ontologies, Epistemologies and Methodologies, edited by GoodsonPhillimore, 156–69. New York: Routledge.
DiamantisD.WestlakeJ.1997. “Environmental Auditing: An Approach towards Monitoring the Environmental Impacts in Tourism Destinations, With Reference to the Case of Molyvos.” Progress in Tourism and Hospitality Research3 (3): 3–15.
40.
DiefM.FontX.2012. “Determinants of Environmental Management in the Red Sea Hotels: Personal and Organizational Values and Contextual Variables.” Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research36:115–37.
41.
DoddsR.JoppeM.2005. “CSR in the Tourism Industry?” The Status of and Potential for Certification, Codes of Conduct and Guidelines.” IFC/World Bank, Washington.
42.
DoddsR.KuehnelJ.2010. “CSR among Canadian Mass Tour Operators: Good Awareness but Little Action.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management22 (2): 221–44.
43.
DunkR. M.GillespieS. A.MacLeodD.2016. “Participation and Retention in a Green Tourism Certification Scheme.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism24 (12): 1585–603.
ECOTRANS. 2012. Sustainability in Tourism: A Guide through the Label Jungle. Vienna: Naturefriends International.
46.
ECOTRANS. 2016. Sustainability in Tourism: A Guide through the Label Jungle. Vienna: Naturefriends International.
47.
ElkingtonJ.1998. Cannibals with Forks: The Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business. Gabriola Island: New Society.
48.
ErdoganN.BarisE.2007. “Environmental Protection Programs and Conservation Practices of Hotels in Ankara, Turkey.” Tourism Management28:604–14.
49.
ErdoganN.TosunC.2009. “Environmental Performance of Tourism Accommodations in the Protected Areas: Case of the Goreme HIstorical National Park.” International Journal of Hospitality Management28: 406–414.
50.
EsparonM.GyurisE.StoecklN.2014. “Does ECO Certification Deliver Benefits? An Empirical Investigation of Visitors’ Perceptions of the Importance of ECO Certification’s Attributes and of Operators’ Performance.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism22 (1): 148–69.
51.
FarrellB. H.Twining-WardL.2004. “Reconceptualizing Tourism.” Annals of Tourism Research31 (2): 274–95.
52.
FontX.2001. “Regulating the Green Message: The Players in Ecolabelling.” In Tourism Ecolabelling: Certification and Promotion of Sustainable Management, edited by FontX.BuckleyR., 1–17. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
53.
FontX.2002. “Environmental Certification in Tourism and Hospitality: Progress, Process and Prospects.” Tourism Management23 (3): 197–205.
54.
FontX.BuckleyR., eds. 2001. Tourism Ecolabelling: Certification and Promotion of Sustainable Management. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
55.
FontX.Epler WoodM.2007. “Sustainable Tourism Certification Marketing and Its Contribution to SME Market Access.” In Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism, edited by BlackR.CrabtreeA., 147–63. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
56.
FontX.HarrisC.2004. “Rethinking Standards from Green to Sustainable.” Annals of Tourism Research31 (4): 986–1007.
57.
FontX.SallowsM.2002. “Setting Global Sustainability Standards: The Sustainable Tourism Stewardship Council.” Tourism Recreation Research27 (1): 21–32.
58.
FontX.SanabriaR.SkinnerE.2003. “Sustainable Tourism and Ecotourism Certification: Raising Standards and Benefits.” Journal of Ecotourism2:213–18.
59.
FontX.TribeJ.2001. “Promoting Green Tourism: The Future of Environmental Awards.” International Journal of Tourism Research3:9–21.
60.
FontX.WalmsleyA.CogottiS.McCombesL.HäuslerN.2012. “Corporate Social Responsibility: The Disclosure-Performance Gap.” Tourism Management33:1544–53.
61.
González-BenitoJ.González-BenitoO.2006. “A Review of Determinant Factors of Environmental Proactivity.” Business Strategy and the Environment15:87–102.
62.
GraciS.DoddsR.2015. “Certification and Labeling.” In The Routledge Handbook of Tourism and Sustainability, edited by HallM.GosslingS.ScottD., 200–8. New York: Routledge.
HoneyM., ed. 2002. Ecotourism and Certification: Setting Standards in Practice. Washington, DC: Island Press.
70.
HoneyM.2007. “Setting Standards: Certification Programmes for Ecotourism and Sustainable Tourism.” In Ecotourism Conservation in the Americas, edited by StronzaA.DurhamW. H., 234–62. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
71.
HoneyM.RomeA. eds. 2001. Protecting Paradise: Certification Programs for Sustainable Tourism and Ecotourism. Washington, DC: Institute for Policy Studies.
72.
HoneyM.StewartE.2002. “The Evolution of ‘Green’ Standards for Tourism.” In Ecotourism and Certification: Setting Standards in Practice, edited by HoneyM., 33–71. Washington, DC: Island Press.
73.
HoudréH.2008. “Sustainable Hospitality: Sustainable Development in the Hotel Industry.” Cornell Hospitality Report 8.
74.
HunterC.1995. “On the Need to Re-Conceptualise Sustainable Tourism Development.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism3: 155–165.
75.
HunterC.1997. “Sustainable Tourism as an Adaptive Paradigm.” Annals of Tourism Research24:690–707.
JarvisN.WeedenC.SimcockN.2010. “The Benefits and Challenges of Sustainable Tourism Certification: A Case Study of the Green Tourism Business Scheme in the West of England.” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management17:83–93.
78.
JenningsG.2010. Tourism Research, 2nd ed.Milton: John Wiley, and Sons.
79.
LeY.HollenhorstS.HarrisC.McLaughlinW.ShookS.2006. “Environmental Management: A Study of Vietnamese Hotels.” Annals of Tourism Research33 (2): 545–67.
80.
LesarL.WeaverD.GardinerS.2016. “A Decade in the Dark: An Updated Quality Control Framework to Facilitate Customised Sustainable Tourism Practice.” Paper presented at CAUTHE 2016: The Changing Landscape of Tourism and Hospitality: The Impact of Emerging Markets and Emerging Destinations, 148, Sydney, Australia, Feburary.
81.
LincolnY.GubaE.1985. Naturalistic Inquiry. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
82.
MairJ.JagoL.2010. “The Development of a Conceptual Model of Greening in the Business Events Tourism Sector.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism18 (1): 77–94.
83.
MarionJ.ReidS.2007. “Minimising Visitor Impacts to Protected Areas: The Efficacy of Low Impact Education Programmes.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism15 (1): 5–27.
84.
MarkovicJ.PetrovicM.2013. “Sport and Recreation Influence upon Mountain Area and Sustainable Tourism Development.” Journal of Environmental and Tourism Analyses1 (1): 80–89.
85.
MasonP.2007. “Effectiveness of Tourism Codes of Conduct.” In Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism, edited by BlackR.CrabtreeA., 46–64. Cambridge: CABI.
86.
MasonP.MowforthM.1996. “Codes of Conduct in Tourism.” Progress in Tourism and Hospitality Research2:151–67.
87.
McCoolS.ButlerR.BuckleyR.WeaverD.2013. “Is Concept of Sustainability Utopian: Ideally Perfect but Impracticable?” Tourism Recreation Research38 (1): 213–42.
88.
MedinaL.2005. “Ecotourism and Certification: Confronting the Principles and Pragmatics of Socially Responsible Tourism.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism13 (3): 281–95.
89.
MensahI.2006. “Environmental Management Practices among Hotels in the Greater Accra Region.” International Journal of Hospitality Management25 (3): 414–31.
90.
MensahI.2014. “Different Shades of Green: Environmental Management in Hotels in Accra.” International Journal of Tourism Research2: 450–461.
91.
MillarM.BalogluS.2011. “Hotel Guests’ Preferences for Green Guest Room Attributes.” Cornell Hospitality Quarterly52 (3): 302–11.
92.
MycooM.2006. “Sustainable Tourism Using Regulations, Market Mechanisms and Green Certification: A Case Study of Barbados.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism14 (5): 489–511.
93.
NeedhamM.LittleC.2013. “Voluntary Environmental Programs at an Alpine Ski Area: Visitor Perceptions, Attachment, Value Orientations, and Specialization.” Tourism Management35:70–81.
94.
NeumanW.2006. Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, 6th ed.Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
95.
NichollsS.KangS.2012. “Going Green: The Adoption of Environmental Initiatives in Michigan’s Lodging Sector.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism20 (7): 953–74.
96.
OaklandJ.1994. “Total Quality Management.” In Gower Handbook of Quality Management, 2nd ed., edited by LockD., 10–27. Aldershot: Gower.
97.
ParkS.MillarM.2016. “The US Traveler’s Familiarity with and Perceived Credibility of Lodging Ecolabels.” Journal of Vacation Marketing22 (1): 3–12.
98.
ParsonsC.GrantJ.2007. “Green Globe: A Global Environmental Certification Programme for Travel and Tourism.” In Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism, edited by BlackR.CrabtreeA., 81–100. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
99.
RahmanI.ReynoldsD.SvarenS.2012. “How ‘Green’ Are North American Hotels? An Exploration of Low-Cost Adoption Practices.” International Journal of Hospitality Management31:720–27.
100.
RiveraJ.2002. “Assessing a Voluntary Environmental Initiative in the Developing World: The Costa Rican Certification for Sustainable Tourism.” Policy Studies35:333–60.
101.
RiveraJ.De LeonP.2004. “Is Greener Whiter? Voluntary Environmental Performance of Western Ski Areas.” Policy Studies Journal32 (3): 417–37.
102.
SampaioA.ThomasR.FontX.2012. “Why Are Some Engaged and Not Others? Explaining Environmental Engagement among Small Firms in Tourism.” International Journal of Tourism Research14:235–49.
103.
SanabriaR.2002. “Accreditation: Certifying the Certifiers.” In Ecotourism and Certification: Setting Standards in Practice, edited by HoneyM., 325–56. Washington, DC: Island Press.
104.
SarantakosS.1998. Social Research, 1st ed.South Melbourne: Macmillan Education.
105.
SarantakosS.2005. Social Research, 2nd ed.South Melbourne: Palgrave Macmillan.
106.
SasidaharanV.SirakayaE.KerstetterD.2002. “Developing Countries and Tourism Ecolabels.” Tourism Management23:161–74.
107.
SharpleyR.2000. “Tourism and Sustainable Development: Exploring the Theoretical Divide.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism8: g1–19.
SmerecnikK.AndersenP.2011. “The Diffusion of Environmental Sustainability Innovations in North American Hotels and Ski Resorts.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism19 (2): 171–96.
110.
SprouleW.2010. “Content Analysis.” In Social Research Methods, edited by WalterM., 323–49. Australia: Oxford University Press.
StrambachS.SurmeierA.2013. “Knowledge Dynamics in Setting Sustainable Standards in Tourism—The Case of ‘Fair Trade in Tourism South Africa.’” Current Issues in Tourism16 (7/8): 736–52.
115.
Synergy. 2000. Tourism Certification: An Analysis of Green Globe 21 and other Tourism Certification Programmes. London: Synergy.
116.
TinsleyS.2001. Environmental Management Plans Demystified: A Guide to Implementing ISO 14001. New York: Spoon Press.
117.
ToplisS.2000. “Evaluativing the effectiveness of the Australian Tourism Awards in Promoting Ecological Sustainability to the Australian Tourism Industry: A Victorian Perspective.” PhD diss., RMIT University.
118.
ToplisS.2007. “Green and Gold? Awards for Excellence in Australian Tourism: Promoting Quality and Sustainability in the Tourism Industry.” In Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism, edited by BlackR.CrabtreeA., 23–45. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
119.
TothR.2002. “Exploring the Concepts Underlying Certification.” In Ecotourism and Certification: Setting Standards in Practice, edited by HoneyM., 73–101. Washington, DC: Island Press.
UNEP (United Nations Environmental Program). 1995. Environmental Codes of Conduct for Tourism. Paris: UNEP.
125.
VealA.2005. Business Research Methods: A Managerial Approach, 2nd ed.Australia: Longman.
126.
VerecziG.2007. “Sustainability Indicators for Ecotourism Destinations and Operations.” In Quality Assurance and Certification in Ecotourism, edited by BlackR.CrabtreeA., 101–15. Wallingford: CABI.
127.
VideiraN.CorreiaA.AlvesI.RamiresC.SubtilR.MartinsV.2006. “Environmental and Economic Tools to Support Sustainable Golf Tourism: The Algarve Experience, Portugal.” Tourism & Hospitality Research6 (3): 204–17.
128.
WCED (World Commission on Environment and Development). 1987. Our Common Future. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
129.
WeaverD.2001. “Mass Tourism and Alternative Tourism in the Caribbean.” In Tourism and the Less Developed World: Issues and Case Studies, edited by HarrisonD., 161–74. Wallingford, UK: CABI.
130.
WeaverD.2006. Sustainable Tourism: Theory and Practice. Oxford: Elsevier.
131.
WeaverD.2014a. “The Sustainable Development of Tourism: A State-of-the-Art Perspective.” In The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Tourism, edited by LewA.HallM.WilliamsA., 524–33. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell.
132.
WeaverD.2014b. “Asymmetrical Dialectics of Sustainable Tourism: Toward Enlightened Mass Tourism.” Journal of Travel Research53 (2): 131–40.
133.
WeaverD.2017. “Sustainability and Mass Tourism: A Contradiction in Terms?” In Mass Tourism in a Small World, edited by HarrisonD.SharpleyR., 63–74. Cambridge: CABI.
134.
WeaverD.DavidsonM. C.LawtonL.PatiarA.ReidS.JohnstonN.2013. “Awarding Sustainable Asia-Pacific Hotel Practices: Rewarding Innovative Practices or Open Rhetoric?” Tourism Recreation Research38 (1): 15–28.
WeiermairK.1997. “On the Concept and Definition of Quality in Tourism.” In Quality Management in Tourism, edited by KellerP., 549–63. St Gallen: AIEST.
137.
WTTC (World Tourism and Trade Council). 2017. Travel & Tourism Global Economic Impact & Issues 2017. London: WTTC.
138.
Yee HooiT.AmranA.Yen NeeG.2014. “Environmental Management Practices of Hotels in Malaysia: Stakeholder Perspective.” International Journal of Tourism Research16 (6): 586–95.
139.
YuY.LiX.JaiT.2017. “The Impact of Green Experience on Customer Satisfaction: Evidence from TripAdvisor.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management29 (5) 1340–61.
