In this study, we investigate how dyadic air and rail transport connectivity affects domestic tourist flows among 343 Chinese cities. Using geo-tagged Sina Weibo data to track tourists during China’s National Day Golden Week in 2014, we estimate several gravity models with a negative binomial distribution. The estimation results suggest that air transport connectivity generally has a greater influence than rail transport on dyadic tourist flows, while connectivity provided by ordinary trains (compared to other rail types) is most important in the context of rail transport. Also, we find the effects of transport connectivity and intermodal transport competition to depend on the origin-to-destination distance. Different types of railway trains appear to have distinct effective distance ranges: the effect of high-speed rail trains is strongest at travel distances between 1,800 and 2,000 km, whereas bullet trains’ effect is strongest at distances between 400 and 600 km.
AhrholdtDennis C.GuderganSiegfried P.RingleChristian M.2016. “Enhancing Service Loyalty.” Journal of Travel Research56 (4): 436–50.
2.
AlbalateDanielBelGermàFagedaXavier. 2015. “Competition and Cooperation between High-Speed Rail and Air Transportation Services in Europe.” Journal of Transport Geography42:166–74.
3.
AlbalateDanielFagedaXavier. 2016. “High Speed Rail and Tourism: Empirical Evidence from Spain.” Transportation Research Part A85:174–85.
4.
BazinS.BeckerichC.DelaplaceM.2011. “High Speed Railway, Service Innovations and Urban and Business Tourisms Development.” In Economics and Management of Tourism: Trends and Recent Developments, edited by S. M. and M. A. Lisbon: Collecçao Manuais, Universidade Luisiada Editora.
5.
BiegerThomasWittmerAndreas. 2006. “Air Transport and Tourism—Perspectives and Challenges for Destinations, Airlines and Governments.” Journal of Air Transport Management12 (1): 40–46.
6.
BilotkachVolodymyrFagedaXavierFlores-FillolRicardo. 2010. “Scheduled Service versus Personal Transportation: The Role of Distance.” Regional Science and Urban Economics40 (1): 60–72.
7.
BorodakoKrzysztofRudnickiMichał. 2014. “Transport Accessibility in Business Travel—A Case Study of Central and East European Cities.” International Journal of Tourism Research16 (2): 137–45.
8.
BurgerMartijnvan OortFrankLindersGert-Jan. 2009. “On the Specification of the Gravity Model of Trade: Zeros, Excess Zeros and Zero-Inflated Estimation.” Spatial Economic Analysis4 (2): 167–90.
9.
CaoJingLiuXiaoyue CathyWangYinhaiLiQingquan. 2013. “Accessibility Impacts of China’s High-Speed Rail Network.” Journal of Transport Geography28:12–21.
10.
ChenZhenhuaHaynesKingsley E.2015. “Impact of High-Speed Rail on International Tourism Demand in China.” Applied Economics Letters22 (1): 57–60.
11.
CNTA (China National Tourism Administration). 2014. Tourism Statistical Report of National Day Golden Week, 2014. Beijing: China National Tourism Administration.
12.
DelaplaceMariePagliaraFrancescaPerrinJulieMermetSamuel. 2014. “Can High Speed Rail Foster the Choice of Destination for Tourism Purpose?” Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences111:166–75.
13.
DobruszkesFrédéricDehonCatherineGivoniMoshe. 2014. “Does European High-Speed Rail Affect the Current Level of Air Services? An EU-wide Analysis.” Transportation Research Part A69:461–75.
14.
DormannCarsten FElithJaneBacherSvenBuchmannCarstenCarlGudrunCarréGabrielGarcía MarquézJaime RGruberBerndLafourcadeBrunoLeitãoPedro J. 2013. “Collinearity: A Review of Methods to Deal with It and a Simulation Study Evaluating Their Performance.” Ecography36 (1): 27–46.
15.
DuvalDavid TimothySchiffAaron. 2011. “Effect of Air Services Availability on International Visitors to New Zealand.” Journal of Air Transport Management17 (3): 175–80.
16.
DwyerLarryKimChulwon. 2003. “Destination Competitiveness: Determinants and Indicators.” Current Issues in Tourism6 (5): 369–414.
17.
FourieJohanSantana-GallegoMaría. 2011. “The Impact of Mega-Sport Events on Tourist Arrivals.” Tourism Management32 (6): 1364–70.
18.
FuXiaowenZhangAnmingLeiZheng. 2012. “Will China’s Airline Industry Survive the Entry of High-Speed Rail?” Research in Transportation Economics35 (1): 13–25.
19.
GivoniMosheDobruszkesFrédéric. 2013. “A Review of Ex-Post Evidence for Mode Substitution and Induced Demand Following the Introduction of High-Speed Rail.” Transport Reviews33 (6): 720–42.
20.
HawelkaBartoszSitkoIzabelaBeinatEuroSobolevskyStanislavKazakopoulosPavlosRattiCarlo. 2014. “Geo-located Twitter as Proxy for Global Mobility Patterns.” Cartography and Geographic Information Science41 (3): 260–71.
21.
HongTaoMaTaoHuanTzung-Cheng. 2015. “Network Behavior as Driving Forces for Tourism Flows.” Journal of Business Research68 (1): 146–56.
22.
JiménezJuan LuisBetancorOfelia. 2012. “When Trains Go Faster Than Planes: The Strategic Reaction of Airlines in Spain.” Transport Policy23:34–41.
23.
KádárBálint. 2014. “Measuring Tourist Activities in Cities Using Geotagged Photography.” Tourism Geographies16 (1): 88–104.
24.
KhadarooA. J.SeetanahB.2007a. “Research Note: Does Transport Infrastructure Matter in Overall Tourism Development? Evidence from a Sample of Island Economies.” Tourism Economics13 (4): 675–84.
25.
KhadarooJameelSeetanahBoopen. 2007b. “Transport Infrastructure and Tourism Development.” Annals of Tourism Research34 (4): 1021–32.
26.
KhadarooJameelSeetanahBoopen. 2008. “The Role of Transport Infrastructure in International Tourism Development: A Gravity Model Approach.” Tourism Management29 (5): 831–40.
27.
LiDongYangYang. 2017. “GIS Monitoring of Traveler Flows Based on Big Data.” In Analytics in Smart Tourism Design: Concepts and Methods, edited by XiangZ.FesenmaierD. R.Cham: Springer.
28.
LiXiang. 2016. “Emerging-Market Research: New Bottles AND New Wine?” Journal of Travel Research55 (4): 419–26.
29.
LiuYuSuiZhengweiKangChaoguiGaoYong. 2014. “Uncovering Patterns of Inter-Urban Trip and Spatial Interaction from Social Media Check-In Data.” PLoS One9 (1): e86026.
30.
LongJ. ScottFreeseJeremy. 2006. Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent Variables Using Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.
31.
MarrocuEmanuelaPaciRaffaele. 2013. “Different Tourists to Different Destinations. Evidence from Spatial Interaction Models.” Tourism Management39:71–83.
32.
MartínJuan CarlosNombelaGustavo. 2007. “Microeconomic Impacts of Investments in High Speed Trains in Spain.” The Annals of Regional Science41 (3): 715–33.
33.
MassonSophiePetiotRomain. 2009. “Can the High Speed Rail Reinforce Tourism Attractiveness? The Case of the High Speed Rail between Perpignan (France) and Barcelona (Spain).” Technovation29 (9): 611–17.
34.
McKercherBob. 1998. “The Effect of Market Access on Destination Choice.” Journal of Travel Research37 (1): 39–47.
35.
MorleyCliveRossellóJaumeSantana-GallegoMaria. 2014. “Gravity Models for Tourism Demand: Theory and Use.” Annals of Tourism Research48:1–10.
36.
MukkalaKirsiTervoHannu. 2013. “Air Transportation and Regional Growth: Which Way Does the Causality Run?” Environment and Planning A45 (6): 1508–20.
37.
National Bureau of Statistics of China. 2015. China Statistical Yearbook 2015. Beijing: China Statistics Press.
38.
NerhagenLena. 2003. “Travel Mode Choice: Effects of Previous Experience on Choice Behaviour and Valuation.” Tourism Economics9 (1): 5–30.
39.
NichollsSarahAmelungBasStudentJillian. 2017. “Agent-Based Modeling a Powerful Tool for Tourism Researchers.” Journal of Travel Research56 (1): 3–15.
40.
PagliaraFrancescaLa PietraAndreaGomezJuanVassalloJosé Manuel. 2015. “High Speed Rail and the Tourism Market: Evidence from the Madrid Case Study.” Transport Policy37:187–94.
41.
PagliaraFrancescaVassalloJoséRománConcepción. 2012. “High-Speed Rail versus Air Transportation.” Transportation Research Record2289:10–17.
42.
PanBingYangYang. 2016. “Monitoring and Forecasting Tourist Activities with Big Data.” In Management Science in Hospitality and Tourism, edited by UysalM.SchwartzZ.Sirakaya-TurkE.Waretown, NJ: Apple Academic Press.
43.
PatuelliRobertoMussoniMaurizioCandelaGuido. 2013. “The Effects of World Heritage Sites on Domestic Tourism: A Spatial Interaction Model for Italy.” Journal of Geographical Systems15 (3): 369–402.
44.
PengBoSongHaiyanCrouchGeoffrey I.WittStephen F.2015. “A Meta-analysis of International Tourism Demand Elasticities.” Journal of Travel Research54 (5): 611–33.
45.
PrideauxBruce. 2000. “The Role of the Transport System in Destination Development.” Tourism Management21 (1): 53–63.
46.
PritchardMark P.HavitzMark E.2006. “Destination Appraisal: An Analysis of Critical Incidents.” Annals of Tourism Research33 (1): 25–46.
47.
QinYu. 2016. “China’s Transport Infrastructure Investment: Past, Present, and Future.” Asian Economic Policy Review11 (2): 199–217.
48.
ReyBelénMyroRafael L.GaleraAsun. 2011. “Effect of Low-Cost Airlines on Tourism in Spain. A Dynamic Panel Data Model.” Journal of Air Transport Management17 (3): 163–67.
49.
SchmidheinyKurtBrülhartMarius. 2011. “On the Equivalence of Location Choice Models: Conditional Logit, Nested Logit and Poisson.” Journal of Urban Economics69 (2): 214–22.
50.
SeetanahBoopenKhadarooJameel. 2009. “An Analysis of the Relationship between Transport Capital and Tourism Development in a Dynamic Framework.” Tourism Economics15 (4): 785–802.
51.
SenA.SmithT. E.1995. Gravity Models of Spatial Interaction Behavior. New York: Springer.
52.
ShethJagdish N.2011. “Impact of Emerging Markets on Marketing: Rethinking Existing Perspectives and Practices.” Journal of Marketing75 (4): 166–82.
53.
SmithStephen L. J.XiePhilip Feifan. 2003. “Estimating the Distance Equivalence of the Canada–U.S. Border on U.S.-to-Canada Visitor Flows.” Journal of Travel Research42 (2): 191–94.
54.
StarkieDavid. 2012. “European Airports and Airlines: Evolving Relationships and the Regulatory Implications.” Journal of Air Transport Management21:40–49.
55.
SuMing MingWallGeoffrey. 2009. “The Qinghai–Tibet Railway and Tibetan Tourism: Travelers’ Perspectives.” Tourism Management30 (5): 650–57.
56.
TaniguchiMamoru. 1992. “High Speed Rail in Japan: A Review and Evaluation of the Shinkansen Train.” UCTC No. 103. Berkeley: University of California Transportation Center.
57.
ThraneChrister. 2015. “Examining Tourists’ Long-Distance Transportation Mode Choices Using a Multinomial Logit Regression Model.” Tourism Management Perspectives15:115–21.
van GoeverdenCees D.2009. “Explaining Factors for Train Use in European Long-Distance Travel.” Tourism and Hospitality Planning & Development6 (1): 21–37.
60.
WangDegenQianJiaChenTianZhaoMeifengZhangYun. 2014. “Influence of the High-Speed Rail on the Spatial Pattern of Regional Tourism—Taken Beijing–Shanghai High-Speed Rail of China as Example.” Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research19 (8): 890–912.
61.
WangXinHuangSongshanZouTongqianYanHui. 2012. “Effects of the High Speed Rail Network on China’s Regional Tourism Development.” Tourism Management Perspectives1:34–38.
62.
WuBihuXueLanMorrisonAlastair M.LeungXi Y.2012. “Frame Analysis on Golden Week Policy Reform in China.” Annals of Tourism Research39 (2): 842–62.
63.
WuWenjieWangJianghaoDaiTianshi. 2016. “The Geography of Cultural Ties and Human Mobility: Big Data in Urban Contexts.” Annals of the American Association of Geographers106 (3): 612–30.
64.
YanYork QiZhangHanqin Qiu. 2010. “The Determinants of the 1999 and 2007 Chinese Golden Holiday System: A Content Analysis of Official Documentation.” Tourism Management31 (6): 881–90.
65.
YanYork QiZhangHanqin QiuYeBen Haobin. 2014. “Assessing the Impacts of the High-Speed Train on Tourism Demand in China.” Tourism Economics20 (1): 157–69.
66.
YangChih-HaiLinHui-LinHanChia-Chun. 2010. “Analysis of International Tourist Arrivals in China: The Role of World Heritage Sites.” Tourism Management31 (6): 827–37.
67.
YangYangFikTimothyZhangJie. 2013. “Modeling Sequential Tourist Flows: Where Is the Next Destination?” Annals of Tourism Research43:297–320.
68.
YangYangWongKevin K. F.2012. “A Spatial Econometric Approach to Model Spillover Effects in Tourism Flows.” Journal of Travel Research51 (6): 768–78.
69.
YangYangWongKevin K. F.2013. “Spatial Distribution of Tourist Flows to China’s Cities.” Tourism Geographies15 (2): 338–63.
70.
ZhangQiongYangHangjunWangQiangZhangAnming. 2014. “Market Power and Its Determinants in the Chinese Airline Industry.” Transportation Research Part A64:1–13.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
