In this article, we unveil determinants of guest satisfaction with urban hotel locations and disclose what types of locations are preferred by guests. Using data from 8,185 online reviews of 220 Los Angeles hotels checked in during a 1-year period, we apply a mixed-effect ordered logit model to investigate factors determining location evaluation scores. We classify all location-related factors into three categories: accessibility to points of interest, transport convenience, and surrounding environment. Our results suggest that a property’s accessibility to attractions, airports, universities and public transportation, as well as green spaces, bodies of water, and local businesses are significant determinants. Free parking and airport shuttle bus service could mitigate disadvantages related to inferior airport accessibility. Moreover, we underscore different hotel location satisfaction effects across travelers’ experiences and types of travel described in the online reviews. Lastly, different types of travelers demonstrate heterogeneous location preferences related to different tourist attractions.
AlKahtaniSaad Jubran H.XiaJianhongVeenendaalandBertCaulfieldCraigHughesMichael. 2015. “Building a Conceptual Framework for Determining Individual Differences of Accessibility to Tourist Attractions.” Tourism Management Perspectives16:28–42.
3.
AntipovaAnzhelika. 2015. “Black, White, Male, and Female Concentrated Employment: The Effect of Spatial and Aspatial Labor Factors.” Cities42 (Part B):160–70.
4.
ArañaJorge E.LeónCarmelo J.2013. “Correcting for Scale Perception Bias in Tourist Satisfaction Surveys.” Journal of Travel Research52 (6): 772–88.
5.
ArbelAvnerPizamAbraham. 1977. “Some Determinants of Urban Hotel Location: The Tourists’ Inclinations.” Journal of Travel Research15 (3): 18–22.
6.
BéginStéphane. 2000. “The Geography of a Tourist Business: Hotel Distribution and Urban Development in Xiamen, China.” Tourism Geographies2 (4): 448–71.
7.
BerezinaKaterinaBilgihanAnilCobanogluCihanOkumusFevzi. 2016. “Understanding Satisfied and Dissatisfied Hotel Customers: Text Mining of Online Hotel Reviews.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management25 (1): 1–24.
8.
BroadwayMichael J.1993. “Montreal’s Changing Tourist Landscape.” Canadian Journal of Urban Research2 (1): 30–48.
9.
BullAdrian O.1994. “Pricing a Motel’s Location.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management6 (6): 10–15.
10.
BurtenshawD.BatemanM.AshworthG. J.1991. The European City: A Western Perspective. London: Fulton.
11.
CaninaLindaEnzCathy A.HarrisonJeffrey S.2005. “Agglomeration Effects and Strategic Orientations: Evidence from the U.S. Lodging Industry.” Academy of Management Journal48 (4): 565–81.
12.
CarneiroMaria JoãoCostaCarlos2000. “The Influence of Service Quality on the Positioning of Five Star Hotels—The Case of the Lisbon Area.” Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism1 (4): 1–19.
13.
ChanEric S. W.WongSimon C. K.2006. “Hotel Selection: When Price Is Not the Issue.” Journal of Vacation Marketing12 (2): 142–59.
14.
ChavesMarcirio SilveiraGomesRodrigoPedronCristiane. 2012. “Analysing Reviews in the Web 2.0: Small and Medium Hotels in Portugal.” Tourism Management33 (5):1286–87.
15.
ChouTsung-YuHsuChia-LunChenMei-Chyi. 2008. “A Fuzzy Multi-criteria Decision Model for International Tourist Hotels Location Selection.” International Journal of Hospitality Management27 (2): 293–301.
16.
CooperC. P.1981. “Spatial and Temporal Patterns of Tourist Behaviour.” Regional Studies15 (5): 359–71.
17.
CrecenteJuan M.SantéInésDíazCarlosCrecenteRafael. 2012. “A Multicriteria Approach to Support the Location of Thalassotherapy (Seawater Therapy) Resorts: Application to Galicia Region, NW Spain.” Landscape and Urban Planning104 (1): 135–47.
18.
DolnicarSaraOtterTh. 2003. “Which Hotel Attributes Matter? A Review of Previous and a Framework for Future Research.” Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 9th Annual Conference of the Asia Pacific Tourism Association (APTA), at University of Technology Sydney.
19.
DredgeDianne. 1999. “Destination Place Planning and Design.” Annals of Tourism Research26 (4): 772–91.
20.
EganDavid J.NieldKevin. 2000. “Towards a Theory of Intraurban Hotel Location.” Urban Studies37 (3): 611–21.
21.
ErtEyalFleischerAliza. 2016. “Mere Position Effect in Booking Hotels Online.” Journal of Travel Research55 (3): 311–21.
22.
ESRI. 2015. Methodology Statement: 2015 ESRI US Business Locations and Business Summary Data. Redlands, CA: ESRI.
23.
FeickRobert D.HallG. Brent. 2000. “The Application of a Spatial Decision Support System to Tourism-Based Land Management in Small Island States.” Journal of Travel Research39 (2): 163–71.
24.
FerreiraSanette LaceaBoshoffAdriaan. 2014. “Post-2010 FIFA Soccer World Cup: Oversupply and Location of Luxury Hotel Rooms in Cape Town.” Current Issues in Tourism17 (2): 180–98.
25.
FleischerAliza. 2012. “A Room with a View—A Valuation of the Mediterranean Sea View.” Tourism Management33 (3): 598–602.
26.
GrayW. S.LiguoriS. C.1998. Hotel and Motel Management and Operations, 3rd ed.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
27.
GuHuiminRyanChris. 2008. “Chinese Clientele at Chinese Hotels—Preferences and Satisfaction.” International Journal of Hospitality Management27 (3): 337–45.
28.
GujaratiD. N.PorterD. C.2010. Essentials of Econometrics. New York: McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
29.
Hatton MacDonaldDarlaCrossmanNeville D.MahmoudiParvinTaylorLaura O.SummersDavid M.BoxallPeter C.2010. “The Value of Public and Private Green Spaces under Water Restrictions.” Landscape and Urban Planning95 (4): 192–200.
30.
HsiehLing-FengLinLi-HungLinYi-Yin. 2008. “A Service Quality Measurement Architecture for Hot Spring Hotels in Taiwan.” Tourism Management29 (3): 429–38.
31.
HuaNanYangYang. 2017. “Systematic Effects of Crime on Hotel Operating Performance.” Tourism Management60:257–69.
32.
KalninsArtursChungWilbur. 2004. “Resource-Seeking Agglomeration: A Study of Market Entry in the Lodging Industry.” Strategic Management Journal25 (7): 689–99.
33.
KimesSheryl E.FitzsimmonsJames A.1990. “Selecting Profitable Hotel Sites at La Quinta Motor Inns.” Interfaces20 (2): 12–20.
34.
LeeKwang-WooKimHong-bummKimHak-SeonLeeDong-Soo. 2010. “The Determinants of Factors in FIT Guests’ Perception of Hotel Location.” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management17 (1): 167–74.
35.
LeeSeul KiJangSooCheong. 2011. “Room Rates of U.S. Airport Hotels: Examining the Dual Effects of Proximities.” Journal of Travel Research50 (2): 186–97.
36.
LeeSeul KiJangSooCheong. 2017. “Early Mover or Late Mover Advantage for Hotels?”Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research41 (1): 23-40.
37.
LiGangLawRobVuHuy QuanRongJiaZhaoXinyuan. 2015. “Identifying Emerging Hotel Preferences Using Emerging Pattern Mining Technique.” Tourism Management46:311–21.
38.
LiHuiyingYeQiangLawRob. 2013. “Determinants of Customer Satisfaction in the Hotel Industry: An Application of Online Review Analysis.” Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research18 (7): 784–802.
39.
LockyerTim. 2005. “Understanding the Dynamics of the Hotel Accommodation Purchase Decision.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management17 (6): 481–92.
LuWeilinStepchenkovaSvetlana. 2015. “User-Generated Content as a Research Mode in Tourism and Hospitality Applications: Topics, Methods, and Software.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management24 (2): 119–54.
42.
MagniniVincent P.CrottsJohn C.ZehrerAnita. 2011. “Understanding Customer Delight: An Application of Travel Blog Analysis.” Journal of Travel Research50 (5): 535–45.
43.
Marine-RoigEstelaAnton ClavéSalvador. 2015. “Tourism Analytics with Massive User-Generated Content: A Case Study of Barcelona.” Journal of Destination Marketing & Management4 (3): 162–72.
44.
MasieroLorenzoHeoCindy YoonjoungPanBing. 2015. “Determining Guests’ Willingness to Pay for Hotel Room Attributes with a Discrete Choice Model.” International Journal of Hospitality Management49:117–24.
45.
McKercherBobLewAlan A.2004. “Tourist Flows and the Spatial Distribution of Tourists.” In A Companion to Tourism, edited by LewA. A.HallC. M.WilliamsA. M., 36–48. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
46.
MedlikS.1966. “Market Feasibility Approach to Hotel Location.” Tourism Review21 (4): 141–48.
47.
MurphyHilary CatherineChenMeng-Mei. 2016. “Online Information Sources Used in Hotel Bookings Examining Relevance and Recall.” Journal of Travel Research55 (4): 523–36.
48.
OwenSusan HesseDaskinMark S.1998. “Strategic Facility Location: A Review.” European Journal of Operational Research111 (3): 423–47.
49.
PaytonSethLindseyGregWilsonJeffOttensmannJohn R.ManJoyce. 2008. “Valuing the Benefits of the Urban Forest: A Spatial Hedonic Approach.” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management51 (6): 717–36.
50.
PesonenJuhoKomppulaRaijaRiihinenAnnina. 2015. “Senior Travellers as Users of Online Travel Services: A Qualitative Enquiry.” In Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2015: Proceedings of the International Conference in Lugano, Switzerland, February 3 – 6, 2015, edited by TussyadiahI.InversiniA.Cham, Switzerland: Springer International.
51.
PoonWai-ChingLowKevin Lock-Teng. 2005. “Are Travellers Satisfied with Malaysian Hotels?” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management17 (3): 217–27.
52.
RenL.QiuH.WangP.LinP. M. (2016). “Exploring Customer Experience with Budget Hotels: Dimensionality and Satisfaction.” International Journal of Hospitality Management52, 13-23.
53.
RheeHosung TimothyYangSung-Byung. 2015. “How Does Hotel Attribute Importance Vary among Different Travelers? An Exploratory Case Study Based on a Conjoint Analysis.” Electronic Markets25 (3): 211–26.
54.
Rigall-I-TorrentRicardFluviàModest. 2007. “Public Goods in Tourism Municipalities: Formal Analysis, Empirical Evidence and Implications for Sustainable Development.” Tourism Economics13 (3): 361–78.
55.
SalehFaroukRyanChris. 1992. “Client Perceptions of Hotels: A Multi-attribute Approach.” Tourism Management13 (2): 163–68.
56.
SchuckertMarkusLiuXianweiLawRob. 2015. “Hospitality and Tourism Online Reviews: Recent Trends and Future Directions.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing32 (5): 608–21.
57.
ShovalNoamMcKercherBobNgEricaBirenboimAmit. 2011. “Hotel Location and Tourist Activity in Cities.” Annals of Tourism Research38 (4): 1594–612.
58.
SoSiu-IanLehtoXinran Y.2007. “The Situational Influence of Travel Group Composition.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing20 (3/4): 79–91.
59.
TanfordSarahBalogluSeyhmusErdemMehmet. 2012. “Travel Packaging on the Internet—The Impact of Pricing Information and Perceived Value on Consumer Choice.” Journal of Travel Research51 (1): 68–80.
60.
TanfordSarahRaabCarolaKimYen-Soon. 2012. “Determinants of Customer Loyalty and Purchasing Behavior for Full-Service and Limited-Service Hotels.” International Journal of Hospitality Management31 (2): 319–28.
61.
Travel Daily News. 2012. Half of TripAdvisor Users Will Not Book a Hotel That Has No Reviews.
62.
TsaiHenryYeungSylvesterYimPhoebe H. L.2011. “Hotel Selection Criteria Used by Mainland Chinese and Foreign Individual Travelers to Hong Kong.” International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration12 (3): 252–67.
63.
TsaurSheng-HshiungTzengGwo-Hshiung. 1996. “Multiattribute Decision Making Analysis for Customer Preference of Tourist Hotels.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing4 (4): 55–69.
64.
UrtasunAinhoaGutiérrezIsabel. 2006. “Tourism Agglomeration and Its Impact on Social Welfare: An Empirical Approach to the Spanish Case.” Tourism Management27 (5): 901–12.
65.
WallG.DudychaD.HutchinsonJ.1985. “Point Pattern Analyses of Accommodation in Toronto.” Annals of Tourism Research12 (4): 603–18.
66.
WeaverDavid B.1993. “Model of Urban Tourism for Small Caribbean Islands.” Geographical Review83 (2): 134–40.
67.
WerczbergerE.BerechmanJ.1988. “Incorporating Neighborhood Effects into Spatial Allocation Models.” Environment and Planning A20 (5): 595–607.
68.
XiangZhengKrawczykMatthew. 2016. “What Does Hotel Location Mean for the Online Consumer? Text Analytics Using Online Reviews.” In Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2016. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
69.
YacouelNiraFleischerAliza. 2012. “The Role of Cybermediaries in Reputation Building and Price Premiums in the Online Hotel Market.” Journal of Travel Research51 (2): 219–26.
70.
YangYangLuoHaoLawRob. 2014. “Theoretical, Empirical, and Operational Models in Hotel Location Research.” International Journal of Hospitality Management36:209–20.
71.
YangYangWongKevin K. F.WangTongkun. 2012. “How Do Hotels Choose Their Location? Evidence from Hotels in Beijing.” International Journal of Hospitality Management31 (3): 675–85.
72.
ZhangZiqiongZhangZiliYangYang. 2016. “The Power of Expert Identity: How Website-Recognized Expert Reviews Influence Travelers’ Online Rating Behavior.” Tourism Management55: 15–24.
73.
ZhouLingqiangYeShunPearcePhilip L.WuMao-Ying. 2014. “Refreshing Hotel Satisfaction Studies by Reconfiguring Customer Review Data.” International Journal of Hospitality Management38:1–10.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
