How Long Does an Economic Impact Last? Tracking the Impact of a New Giant Panda Attraction at an Australian Zoo

Abstract

A concerning issue with Economic Impact Analysis (EIA) is that many EIAs give results for one year, without being explicit about how long impacts are expected to last. New tourism attractions should not be assumed to provide continuing positive impacts into the future. For instance, the Giant Pandas at Adelaide Zoo generated a positive economic impact in their first year of residence (22% of a sample of tourists visited Adelaide “due to pandas,” additional tourism expenditure in the region was $27.7 million, with $2.3 to $4.6 million captured by the zoo); however, increased numbers visiting to see the pandas lasted only two years. Investment decision makers expected larger, longer-term economic benefits than eventuated, and the zoo experienced financial difficulties. This study provides advice for predictive EIA of new tourism attractions and prompts a call for tourism EIA studies to be explicit about the time period for which results are relevant.

Keywords

economic impact analysis duration of impacts new tourism attraction Giant Pandas zoo revenue zoo attractions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics). 2013. Tourism Satellite Account: Australian National Accounts 2011-12 5249.0. Canberra: ABS.

Ballantyne

Packer

2013. “Ecotourism: Themes and Issues.” In International Handbook of Ecotourism, edited by Ballantyne

Packer

Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Barajas

Angel

Lago-Penas

Santiago

Sanchez

Patricio

. 2014. “On the Regional Economic Effects of the Pope’s Journeys: Evidence from the Visit to Santiago de Compostela in 2010.” Tourism Economics 20 (2): 279–99.

Beri

Tranent

Abelson

2010. “The Economic and Social Contribution of the Zoological Industry in Australia.” International Zoo Yearbook 44:192–200.

Caica

2011. “Ministerial Statement.” Hansard, House of Assembly, South Australia 21 June 2011. Adelaide: Government of South Australia.

Campbell

H. F.

Brown

R. P. C.

2003. Benefit Cost Analysis: Financial and Economic Appraisal Using Spreadsheets. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.

Carlsen

Wood

2004. Assessment of the Economic Value of Recreation and Tourism in Western Australia’s National Parks, Marine Parks and Forests. Gold Coast: Sustainable Tourism Cooperative Research Centre.

Cornelis

P. C. M.

2010. “Impact of New Attractions on Theme Park Attendance.” Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes 2 (3): 262–80.

Cornelis

P. C. M.

2011. “A Management Perspective on the Impact of New Attractions.” Journal of Vacation Marketing 17 (2): 151–62.

10.

Crompton

John

. 2006. “Economic Impact Studies: Instruments for Political Shenanigans?” Journal of Travel Research 45 (1): 47–82.

11.

Crompton

John L.

Jeong

Ji Youn

Dudensing

Rebekka M.

2015. “Sources of Variation in Economic Impact Multipliers.” Journal of Travel Research 1–14. doi: 10.1177/0047287515617298.

12.

Driml

Sally

Brown

Richard P. C.

Ballantyne

Roy

Pegg

Shane

Scott

Noel

. 2011. “Estimating the State-Wide Economic Significance of National Park Tourism: The Case of Queensland, Australia.” Tourism Analysis 16:243–57.

13.

Dwyer

Forsyth

Dwyer

2010. Tourism Economics and Policy. Bristol: Channel View.

14.

Dwyer

Larry

Forsyth

Peter

Spurr

Ray

. 2004. “Evaluating Tourism’s Economic Effects: New and Old Approaches.” Tourism Management 25 (3): 307–17.

15.

Dwyer

Larry

Jago

Leo

Forsyth

Peter

. 2015. “Economic Evaluation of Special Events: Reconciling Economic Impact and Cost–Benefit Analysis.” Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism 16 (2): 115–29.

16.

Faulkner

Bill

Raybould

Michael

. 1995. “Monitoring Visitor Expenditure Associated with Attendance at Sporting Events: An Experimental Assessment of the Diary and Recall Methods.” Festival Management and Event Tourism 3 (2): 73–81.

17.

Frost

2011. Zoos and Tourism—Conservation, Education, Entertainment? Bristol: Channel View.

18.

Grace

T. A.

Sawilowsky

S. S.

2009. “Data Error Prevention and Cleansing: A Comprehensive Guide for Instructors of Statistics and Their Students.” Model Assisted Statistics and Applications 4 (4): 303–12.

19.

Grajal

2013. “Zoos as Ecotourism Experiences.” In International Handbook on Ecotourism, edited by Ballantyne

Packer

, 504. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

20.

Gusset

Gerald

2011. “The Global Reach of Zoos and Aquariums in Visitor Numbers and Conservation Expenditures.” Zoo Biology 30 (5): 1098–2361.

21.

Grunwell

S. S.

2011. “The Economic Impact of a Heritage Tourism Attraction on a Rural Economy: The Great Smoky Mountains Railroad.” Tourism Analysis 16:629–36.

22.

Hjerpe

E. E.

Kim

Y.-S.

2007. “Regional Economic Impacts of Grand Canyon River Runners.” Journal of Environmental Management 85 (1): 137–49.

23.

Jeong

J. Y.

Crompton

J. L.

Dudensing

R. M.

2016. “The Potential Influence of Researchers’ ‘Hidden’ Procedure Decisions on Estimates of Visitor Spending and Economic Impact.” Journal of Travel Research 55(7): 874–888. doi:10.1177/0047287515605932.

24.

Kookana

Jai

Pham

Tien Duc

Quinn

Tim

. 2014. Tourism’s Contribution to the Australian Economy 1997-98 to 2012-13. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade.

25.

ShiNa

Blake

Adam

. 2009. “Estimating Olympic Related Investment and Expenditure.” International Journal of Tourism Research 11:337–56.

26.

ShiNa

Blake

Adam

Thomas

Rhodri

. 2013. “Modelling the Economic Impact of Sports Events: The Case of the Beijing Olympics.” Economic Modelling 30:235–44.

27.

Lynne

Warren

. 2006. “Panda, Inc.” National Geographic 210 (1): 42–59.

28.

Macfie

B. P.

Nufrio

P. M.

2006. Applied Statistics for Public Policy. New York: M.E. Sharpe.

29.

Madden

A. R.

2006. “Economic and Fiscal Impacts of Mega Sports Events: A General Equilibrium Assessment.” Public Finance and Management 6:346–94.

30.

Mason

Peter

. 2008. “Roles of the Modern Zoo: Conflicting or Complementary?” Tourism Review International 11:251–63.

31.

Smithsonian National Zoological Park. 2016. “Giant Pandas.” http://nationalzoo.si.edu/Animals/GiantPandas/PandaFacts/.

32.

Owen

Michael

. 2009. “Pandas Worth $630 Million to the State.” The Australian, December 14, 2009.

33.

Pandas International. 2016. “Captive Breeding Program.” https://www.pandasinternational.org/program-areas-2/captive-breeding-program/.

34.

Peddie

Clare

. 2010. “Pandas Will Leave Adelaide Zoo in Debt for a Decade.” news.com.au, December 27. http://www.news.com.au/national/wang-wang-leaves-giant-panda-debt-for-adelaide-zoo/story-e6frfkvr-1225976525886.

35.

Pham

Tien Duc

Kookana

Jai

. 2014. State Tourism Satellite Accounts 2012-13. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade.

36.

Saayman

2010. “Regional Development and National Parks in South Africa: Lessons Learned.” Tourism Economics 16 (4): 1037–64.

37.

Schultz-Byard

2011. “Adelaide Zoo $24m in Debt.” Australian Broadcasting Corporation. http://www.abc.net.au/local/stories/2011/06/21/3249843.html.

38.

Song

Haiyan

Dwyer

Larry

Gang

Cao

Zeng

. 2012. “Tourism Economics Research: A Review and Assessment.” Annals of Tourism Research 39 (3): 1653–82.

39.

Stoeckl

Birtles

Farr

Mangott

Curnock

Valentine

2010. “Live-Aboard Dive Boats in the Great Barrier Reef: Regional Economic Impact and the Relative Values of Their Target Marine Species.” Tourism Economics 16 (4): 995–1018.

40.

Stynes

D. J.

White

E. M.

2006. “Reflections on Measuring Recreation and Travel Spending.” Journal of Travel Research 45 (1): 8–16.

41.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2011. Regional Tourism Profiles 2010-11. Canberra: Tourism Research Australia.

42.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2015. Regional Expenditure Methodology. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://tra.gov.au/aboutus/regional-expenditure.html.

43.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2016a. Travel by Australians: Year Ended December 2015. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://tra.gov.au/research/latest-nvs-report.html.

44.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2016b. International Visitors in Australia: Year Ended December 2015. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://www.tra.gov.au/research/latest-ivs-report.html.

45.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2016c. Overnight Trips in Australia by Residents. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://www.tra.gov.au/research/domestic-travel-by-australians.html.

46.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2016d. NVS_3_Daytrips_YE_Dec_2015. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://www.tra.gov.au/documents/nvs/NVS_3_Daytrips_YE_Dec_2015.xlsx.

47.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2016e. NVS_2_Nights_YE_Dec_2015. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://www.tra.gov.au/research/domestic-travel-by-australians.html.

48.

TRA (Tourism Research Australia). 2016f. IVS_2_YE_Dec_2015. Canberra: Australian Government, Austrade. http://tra.gov.au/research/International-tourism-statistics.html.

49.

Tribe

John

. 2011. The Economics of Recreation, Leisure and Tourism. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.

50.

Tucker

Alyssa-Jane

. 2016. “Giant Panda Breeding Update.” http://www.adelaidezoo.com.au/giant-panda-breeding-update/.

51.

Turley

Sophie K.

1999. “Conservation and Tourism in the Traditional UK Zoo.” Journal of Tourism Studies 10 (2): 2–13.

52.

Vidal

John

. 2014. “Zoos Weigh Up the Cost of China’s ‘Pandanomics.’” The Guardian, September 13. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/sep/13/edinburgh-zoo-pandas-tian-tian-china-pandanomics-birth-cub.

53.

Wallace

Jeff

Orchik

Andrea

. 2004. “The Economic impact of Pandas at the Memphis Zoo.” Business Perspectives 16 (3): 30–37.

54.

Warnick

Rodney B.

Bojanic

David C.

Feng

. 2015. “Using a Trade Market Analysis Technique to Refine Measurements for Economic Impact Analysis of Special Events.” Journal of Travel Research 54:52–65.

55.

Wheater

C. P.

Cook

P. A.

2000. Using Statistics to Understand the Environment. London: Routledge.

56.

Zoos SA. 2009. 08/09 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.

57.

Zoos SA. 2010. 09/10 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.

58.

Zoos SA. 2011. 10/11 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.

59.

Zoos SA. 2012. 11/12 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.

60.

Zoos SA. 2013. 12/13 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.

61.

Zoos SA. 2014. 13/14 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.

62.

Zoos SA. 2015. 14/15 Zoos SA Annual Report. Adelaide: Zoos SA.