Conversion studies are a standard technique by which marketers evaluate advertisement effectiveness. A review of the tourism literature finds that advertising conversion studies use a number of metrics that have evolved to include most aspects of visitor decisions; however, this literature also indicates that there are few comparative studies focusing on the variability of response. The overall goal of this study is to identify and compare estimates of impact on visitor expenditures using four different approaches ranging from traditional advertising models (i.e., gross conversion rate and net conversion rate) to a more comprehensive facets-based destination advertisement response (DAR) model. The various models result in a huge range of impact estimates and it is concluded that the DAR model offers, both theoretically and practically, a powerful framework for evaluating advertising response in that it incorporates the possibility that destination advertising affects decisions related to a range of trip-related activities.
AmblerT.2008. “Marketing Metrics.” Business Strategy Review11 (2): 414–27.
2.
AndereckK. L.2005. “Evaluation of a Tourist Brochure.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing18 (2): 1–13.
3.
AvrahamE.DaughertyD.2012. “‘Step into the Real Texas’: Associating and Claiming State Narrative in Advertising and Tourism Brochures.” Tourism Management33 (6): 1385–97.
4.
BallmanG.BurkeJ. F.BlankU.KorteD.1984. “Toward Higher Quality Conversion Studies: Refining the Numbers Game.” Journal of Travel Research22 (4): 28–33.
5.
BeckerG. S.1971. Economic Theory. New York, NY: Alfred Knopf.
6.
BojanicD. C.1991. “The Use of Advertising in Managing Destination Image.” Tourism Management12 (4): 352–55.
7.
BouldingW.LeeE.StaelinR.1994. “Mastering the Mix: Do Advertising, Promotion, and Sales Force Activities Lead to Differentiation?”Journal of Marketing Research31 (2): 159–72.
BurkeJ. F.GitelsonR. E.1990. “Conversion Studies: Assumptions, Applications, Accuracy and Abuse.” Journal of Travel Research28 (3): 46–51.
10.
ButterfieldD. W.DealK. R.KubursiA. A.1998. “Measuring the Returns to Tourism Advertising.” Journal of Travel Research37 (1): 12–20.
11.
ByunJ.JangS.2015. “Effective Destination Advertising: Matching Effect between Advertising Language and Destination Type.” Tourism Management50:31–40.
12.
CaiL. A.1998. “Effects of Destination Advertising on Financial Returns—A Comparative Analysis of Two Inquiring Methods.” Journal of Hospitality Financial Management6 (1): 61–73.
13.
Caldas-CoulthardC. R.2008. “Body Branded: Multimodal Identities in Tourism Advertising.” Journal of Language and Politics7 (3): 451–70.
14.
ChangJ. C.WallG.LaiC. Y.2005. “The Advertising Effectiveness of Aboriginal Endorsers: An Example from Taiwan.” Tourism Analysis10 (3): 247–56.
15.
ChangJ. C.WallG.TsaiC. T.2005. “Endorsement Advertising in Aboriginal Tourism: An Experiment in Taiwan.” International Journal of Tourism Research7 (6): 347–56.
16.
ChhabraD.AndereckK.YamanoiK.PlunkettD.2011. “Gender Equity and Social Marketing: An Analysis of Tourism Advertisements.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing28 (2): 111–28.
17.
ChiouW. B.WanC. S.LeeH. Y.2008. “Virtual Experience vs. Brochures in the Advertisement of Scenic Spots: How Cognitive Preferences and Order Effects Influence Advertising Effects on Consumers.” Tourism Management29 (1): 146–50.
ChoeY.StienmetzJ. L.FesenmaierD. R.2014b. “Travel Distance and Response to Destination Advertising.” Tourism Analysis19 (4): 531–39.
21.
ChoiS.LehtoX. Y.MorrisonA. M.JangS.2012. “Structure of Travel Planning Processes and Information Use Patterns.” Journal of Travel Research51 (1): 26–40.
22.
ChouH. Y.LienN. H.2012. “The Effects of Incentive Types and Appeal Regulatory Framing in Travel Advertising.” Service Industries Journal32 (6): 883–97.
23.
DecropA.2007. “The Influence of Message Format on the Effectiveness of Print Advertisements for Tourism Destinations.” International Journal of Advertising26 (4): 505–25.
24.
DeskinsJ.SeeversM. T.2011. “Are State Expenditures to Promote Tourism Effective?”Journal of Travel Research50 (2): 154–70.
25.
DivisekeraS.KulendranN.2006. “Economic Effects of Advertising on Tourism Demand: A Case Study.” Tourism Economics12 (2): 187–205.
26.
DolnicarS.LaesserC.MatusK.2009. “Online versus Paper Format Effects in Tourism Surveys.” Journal of Travel Research47 (3): 295–316.
27.
DorseyE. R.SteevesH. L.PorrasL. E.2004. “Advertising Ecotourism on the Internet: Commodifying Environment and Culture.” New Media & Society6 (6): 753–79.
28.
DossaK. B.WilliamsP.2002. “Assessing the Use of Internet Surveys in the Context of Advertisement Tracking Studies: A Case Study of Tourism Yukon’s Winter Promotion Campaign.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing11 (2/3): 39–62.
29.
DwyerL.PhamT.ForsythP.SpurrR.2014. “Destination Marketing of Australia Return on Investment.” Journal of Travel Research53 (3): 281–95.
30.
EllerbrockM. J.1981. “Improving Coupon Conversion Studies: A Comment.” Journal of Travel Research19 (4): 37–38.
31.
FullertonJ. A.KendrickA.2013. “Strategic Uses of Mediated Public Diplomacy: International Reaction to U.S. Tourism Advertising.” American Behavioral Scientist57 (9): 1332–49.
32.
FullertonJ. A.KendrickA.KerrG.2009. “Australian Student Reactions to US Tourism Advertising: A Test of Advertising as Public Diplomacy.” Place Branding and Public Diplomacy5 (2): 141–50.
33.
GoossensC. F.1995. “External Information Search.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing3 (3): 89–107.
34.
HemL. E.IversenN. M.GrenhaugK.2003. “Advertising Effects of Photos Used to Portray Nature-Based Tourism Attractions.” Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism3 (1): 48–70.
35.
HennesseyS. M.YunD.MacDonaldR.MacEachernM.2010. “The Effects of Advertising Awareness and Media Form on Travel Intentions.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management19 (3): 217–43.
36.
HuntJ. D.DaltonM. J.1983. “Comparing Mail and Telephone for Conducting Coupon Conversion Studies.” Journal of Travel Research21 (3): 16–18.
37.
HwangY. H.FesenmaierD. R.2004. “Coverage Error Embedded in Self-Selected Internet-Based Samples: A Case Study of Northern Indiana.” Journal of Travel Research42 (3): 297–304.
JengJ.FesenmaierD. R.2002. “Conceptualizing the Travel Decision-Making Hierarchy: A Review of Recent Developments.” Tourism Analysis7 (1): 15–32.
40.
JohnsonR. R.MessmerD. J.1997. “The Relationship between Inquiry and Visitation: What Is (or Should Be) Conversion?” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing6 (2): 101–9.
KimS. B.KimD. Y.BollsP.2014. “Tourist Mental-Imagery Processing: Attention and Arousal.” Annals of Tourism Research45:63–76.
44.
KlenoskyD. B.GitelsonR. E.1997. “Characteristics of Effective Tourism Promotion Slogans.” Annals of Tourism Research24 (1): 235–38.
45.
KulendranN.DwyerL.2008. “Measuring the Return from Australian Tourism Marketing Expenditure.” Journal of Travel Research47 (3): 275–84.
46.
LancasterK.1971. Consumer Demand: A New Approach. New York: Columbia University Press.
47.
LaskeyH. A.SeatonB.NichollsJ.A.F.1994. “Effects of Strategy and Pictures in Travel Agency Advertising.” Journal of Travel Research32 (4): 13–19.
48.
LavidgeR. J.SteinerG. A.1961. “A Model for Predictive Measurements of Advertising Effectiveness.” Journal of Marketing25 (6): 59–62.
49.
LitvinS. W.MouriN.2009. “A Comparative Study of the Use of Iconic versus Generic Advertising Images for Destination Marketing.” Journal of Travel Research48 (2): 152–61.
50.
LodaM. D.NormanW.BackmanK. F.2007. “Advertising and Publicity: Suggested New Applications for Tourism Marketers.” Journal of Travel Research45 (3): 259–65.
51.
MacinnisD. J.JaworskiB. J.1989. “Information from Processing toward Advertisements: An Framework Integrative.” Journal of Marketing53 (4): 1–23.
McLemoreC.MitchellN.2001. “An Internet Conversion Study of www.arkansas.com—A State Tourism Website.” Journal of Vacation Marketing7 (3): 268–74.
54.
McWilliamsE. G.CromptonJ. L.1997. “An Expanded Framework for Measuring the Effectiveness of Destination Advertising.” Tourism Management18 (3): 127–37.
55.
MehtaA.1994. “How Advertising Response Modeling (ARM) Can Increase Ad Effectiveness.” Journal of Advertising Research34 (3): 62–74.
56.
MessmerD. J.JohnsonR. R.1993. “Inquiry Conversion and Travel Advertising Effectiveness.” Journal of Travel Research31 (4): 14–21.
57.
MillsJ. E.LeeJ. K.DouglasA. C.2007. “Exploring Perceptions of US State Tourism Organizations’ Web Advertising Effectiveness.” Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research12 (3): 245–66.
58.
MinK. S.MartinD.JungJ. M.2013. “Designing Advertising Campaigns for Destinations with Mixed Images: Using Visitor Campaign Goal Messages to Motivate Visitors.” Journal of Business Research66 (6): 759–64.
59.
MokH. M. K.1990. “A Quasi-Experimental Measure of the Effectiveness of Destinational Advertising: Some Evidence from Hawaii.” Journal of Travel Research29 (1): 30–34.
60.
MorganN.HastingsE.PritchardA.2012. “Developing a New DMO Marketing Evaluation Framework: The Case of Visit Wales.” Journal of Vacation Marketing18 (1): 73–89.
61.
MorosanC.2008. “DMO Websites and the Role of Complementary Media in Tourism Advertising.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management17 (1): 216–36.
62.
MorosanC.2014. “The Influence of DMO Advertising on Specific Destination Visitation Behaviors.” Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management24 (1): 47–75.
63.
PanB.2010. “Online Travel Surveys and Response Patterns.” Journal of Travel Research49 (1): 121–35.
64.
PanS.2011. “The Role of TV Commercial Visuals in Forming Memorable and Impressive Destination Images.” Journal of Travel Research50 (2): 171–85.
65.
ParkS.FesenmaierD. R.2012. “Non-response Bias in Internet-Based Advertising Conversion Studies.” International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research6 (4): 340–55.
66.
ParkS.NicolauJ. L.2015. “Differentiated Effect of Advertising: Joint vs. Separate Consumption.” Tourism Management47:107–14.
67.
ParkS.NicolauJ. L.FesenmaierD. R.2013. “Assessing Advertising in a Hierarchical Decision Model.” Annals of Tourism Research40:260–82.
68.
PerdueR. R.BotkinM. R.1988. “Visitor Survey versus Conversion Study.” Annals of Tourism Research15 (1): 76–87.
69.
PerdueR. R.GustkeL. D.1992. “The Influence of Multiple Trips on Inquiry Conversion Research Results.” Journal of Travel Research30 (4): 27–30.
70.
PerdueR. R.PitegoffB. E.1990. “Methods of Accountability Research for Destination Marketing.” Journal of Travel Research28 (4): 45–49.
71.
PlogS. C.AdamsA.1996. “The Respondent Specific Method.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing5 (3): 241–52.
72.
PrattS.McCabeS.Cortes-JimenezI.BlakeA.2010. “Measuring the Effectiveness of Destination Marketing Campaigns: Comparative Analysis of Conversion Studies.” Journal of Travel Research49 (2): 179–90.
73.
PritchardM. P.1998. “Responses to Destination Advertising: Differentiating Inquirers to a Short, Getaway Vacation Campaign.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing7 (2): 31–51.
74.
RosenbaumP. R.RubinD. B.1984. “Reducing Bias in Observational Studies Using Subclassification on the Propensity Score.” Journal of the American Statistical Association79 (387): 516–24.
75.
RustR. T.AmblerT.CarpenterG. S.KumarV.SrivastavaR. K.2004. “Measuring Marketing Productivity Current Knowledge and Future Directions.” Journal of Marketing68 (4): 76–89.
76.
ScottN.GreenC.FairleyS.2015. “Investigation of the Use of Eye Tracking to Examine Tourism Advertising Effectiveness.” Current Issues in Tourism, 1–9.
77.
SiegelW.Ziff-LevineW.1990. “Evaluating Tourism Advertising Campaigns Conversion vs. Advertising Tracking Studies.” Journal of Travel Research28 (3): 51–55.
78.
SilbermanJ.KlockM.1986. “An Alternative to Conversion Studies for Measuring the Impact of Travel Ads.” Journal of Travel Research24 (4): 12–16.
79.
SirakayaE.SonmezS.2000. “Gender Images in State Tourism Brochures: An Overlooked Area in Socially Responsible Tourism Marketing.” Journal of Travel Research39 (4): 353–62.
80.
SpencerD. M.2013. “Effectiveness of intra-destination television advertising of tourist attractions and facilities.” Journal of Destination Marketing & Management2 (3): 155–64.
81.
StergiouD.AireyD.2003. “Inquiry Conversion and Tourism Website Effectiveness: Assumptions, Problems and Potential.” Tourism and Hospitality Research4 (4): 355–66.
StienmetzJ. L.FesenmaierD. R.2014. “Effects of Channel, Timing, and Bundling on Destination Advertising Response.” Tourism Analysis19 (1): 97–104.
84.
van der VeenR.SongH.2010. “Exploratory Study of the Measurement Scales for the Perceived Image and Advertising Effectiveness of Celebrity Endorsers in a Tourism Context.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing27 (5): 460–73.
85.
WaltersG.SparksB.HeringtonC.2007. “The Effectiveness of Print Advertising Stimuli in Evoking Elaborate Consumption Visions for Potential Travelers.” Journal of Travel Research46 (1): 24–34.
86.
WangK. C.ChouS. H.SuC. J.TsaiH. Y.2007. “More Information, Stronger Effectiveness? Different Group Package Tour Advertising Components on Web Page.” Journal of Business Research60 (4): 382–87.
87.
WicksB. E.SchuettM. A.1991. “Examining the Role of Tourism Promotion through the Use of Brochures.” Tourism Management12 (4): 301–12.
88.
WilliamsD. A.SpencerA.2010. “Advertising and Tourist Arrivals: Evidence from Jamaica.” Tourism and Hospitality Research10 (4): 359–66.
89.
WoodsideA. G.1981. “Measuring the Conversion of Advertising Coupon Inquirers into Visitors.” Journal of Travel Research19 (4): 38–39.
90.
WoodsideA. G.1990. “Measuring Advertising Effectiveness in Destination Marketing Strategies.” Journal of Travel Research29 (2): 3–8.
91.
WoodsideA. G.2010. “Tourism Advertising and Marketing Performance Metrics.” In Tourism-Marketing Performance Metrics and Usefulness Auditing of Destination Websites, edited by WoodsideA. G., 1–14. Somerville, MA: Elsevier.
92.
WoodsideA. G.ReidD. M.1974. “Tourism Profiles versus Audience Profiles: Are Upscale Magazines Really Upscale?”Journal of Travel Research12 (4): 17–23.
93.
WoodsideA. G.ReidD. M.1976. “Choosing Competing Magazines for Tourism Advertising Programs Using a Net Revenue Approach.” Journal of Advertising5 (3): 25–28.
94.
WoodsideA. G.RonkainenI. A.1984. “How Serious Is Nonresponse Bias in Advertising Conversion Research?”Journal of Travel Research22 (4): 34–37.
95.
WoodsideA. G.SakaiM. Y.2001. “Meta-Evaluations of Performance Audits of Government Tourism-Marketing Programs.” Journal of Travel Research39 (4): 369–79.
96.
WuH. Q.LiuY. X.ZhuangD. L.ZhuW. D.2014. “A DEA-Based Measurement of Effectiveness of Provincial Image Advertisement for Local Tourism Destination: Evidence from China.” International Journal of Management and Decision Making13 (2): 192.
97.
WuS. I.WeiP. L.ChenJ. H.2008. “Influential Factors and Relational Structure of Internet Banner Advertising in the Tourism Industry.” Tourism Management29 (2): 221–36.
98.
WöberK. W.FesenmaierD. R.2004. “A Multi-criteria Approach to Destination Benchmarking.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing16 (2-3):1–18.
99.
ZhouZ.1997. “Destination Marketing: Measuring the Effectiveness of Brochures.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing6 (3-4): 143–58.
