Much of the research documenting the size and importance of special interest (SI) tourism is based on secondary analysis of visitor survey data. Segments are defined by analyzing responses to activity questions, with the assumption being that activities are a valid proxy for motives to travel or trip purpose. The soundness of this approach is based on two suppositions that do not appear to have been questioned. The first is that visitor surveys are constructed in such a way that valid SI trip-purpose segments can be defined. The second is the existence of a direct correlation between actions and motivations. This article illustrates that both suppositions are unfounded, resulting in the production of figures that overstate the true importance of SI tourism as a trip generator by as much as 20 times. The authors call for the discontinuation of the method.
Acott, T. G., H. L. La Trobe, and S. H. Howard (1998). “An Evaluation of Deep Ecotourism and Shallow Ecotourism.”Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 6 (3): 238-253.
2.
Antolovic, J. (1999). “Immovable Cultural Monuments and Tourism.” In Cultural Tourism Session Notes XII Assembly ICOMOS. Mexico, pp. 103-118.
3.
Australian Tourist Commission (2004). Food and Wine Tourism Fact Sheet. Sydney: Australian Tourist Commission.
4.
Blamey, R. (1995). “Profiling the Ecotourism Market.” In Taking the Next Steps, edited by H. Richins, J. Richardson, and A. Crabtree. Brisbane: Ecotourism Association of Australia, pp. 1-9.
5.
Brown, L. (2002). The International Overnight Tourist in Vermont: Appendix A, International Visitor Survey. Montpelier: Vermont Tourism Data Center, University of Vermont.
6.
Cameron, C. (1997). “Cultural Tourism: Gold Mine or Land Mine.”Cultural Resource Management, 17 (3): 28-31.
7.
Canadian Tourism Commission (2001). “Rethinking Canada as a Cultural Destination.”Communiqué, (May): 3.
8.
Charters, S., and J. Ali-Knight (2001). “Who Is the Wine Tourist?”Tourism Management, 23 (3): 311-319.
9.
Chin, C., S. Moore, T. Wallington, and R. Dowling (2000). “Ecotourism in Bako National Park Borneo: Visitors’ Perspectives on Environmental Impacts and Their Management.”Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 8 (1): 20-35.
Crompton, J., and S. McKay (1997). “Motives for Visitors Attending Festivals.”Annals of Tourism Research, 24 (2): 425-439.
12.
Darcy, S. (2002). “Marginalized Participation: Physical Disability, High Support Needs and Tourism.”Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 9 (1): 61-72.
13.
Darcy, S. (2004). Disabling Journeys: The Social Relations of Tourism forPeople with Impairments in Australia: An Analysis of Government Tourism Authorities and Accommodation Sector Practices and Discourses. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Technology, Sydney.
14.
Department of Resource Recreation (1999). Idaho Travel: How Do We Stack Up?Moscow: Department of Resource Recreation and Tourism, University of Idaho.
15.
Economic Planning Group of Canada (1995). Packaging and Selling to the United States. Ottawa: Economic Planning Group of Canada for Tourism Canada.
16.
Ferguson, C. (2002). The Sports Tourist: Cultural Cringe or Cultural Tourist? Paper presented at the Museums Australia Conference, Adelaide, MarchÄ.
17.
Florida Division of Cultural Affairs (2001). Cultural Tourism. Tallahassee: Florida Division of Cultural Affairs.
18.
Fakeye, P. C., and L. Crompton (1991). “Image Differences between Prospective, First-Time, and Repeat Tourists to the Lower Rio Grande Valley.”Journal of Travel Research, 30 (2): 10-16.
19.
Gold Coast City Council (2002). Tourism Market Profile: Cultural Tourism. Gold Coast, Australia: Gold Coast City Council.
20.
Gitelson, R. J., and J. L. Crompton (1984). “Insights into the Repeat Vacation Phenomena.”Annals of Tourism Research, 11 (2): 199-218.
21.
Gallup McKinley County Chamber of Commerce (2004). Gallup Visitors Survey. Gallup McKinley County Chamber of Commerce. Retrieved August 5, 2004, from http://www.gallupchamber.com/survey.htm.
22.
Hall, C. M., and B. Weiler (1992). “Introduction: What’s So Special about Special Interest Tourism?” In Special Interest Tourism, edited by B. Weiler and C. M. Mall. London: Belhaven Press, pp. 1-14.
23.
Hong Kong Tourism Board (2004). Hong Kong Departing Visitor Survey: Air. Hong Kong: Hong Kong Tourism Board.
24.
Hui, L. L., and B. McKercher (2001). “The Omnibus Survey.”Pacific Tourism Review, 5 (1/2): 5-11.
25.
International Ecotourism Society (2000). Ecotourism Statistical Fact Sheet. Washington, DC: International Ecotourism Society.
26.
Keefe, C. (2002). Travelers Who Love History and Culture Spend More and Stay Longer than Average Tourists. Travel Industry Association of America. Retrieved December 31, 2003, from http://www.hotel-online.com/News/PR2002_1st/Jan02_HistoryTravelers.html.
27.
Keefe, C. (2003). History and Culture Significant and Growing Part of the US Travel Experience. Travel Industry Association of America. Retrieved April 6, 2004, from http://www.hotel-online.com/News/PR2003_2nd/Jun03_HistoryCulture.htm.
28.
KwaZulu-Natal Tourism Authority (2003). KwaZulu-Natal’s Nature Based Tourism Market. Tourism KwaZulu-Natal Occasional Paper no. 12. Durban, South Africa: KwaZulu-Natal Tourism Authority.
29.
Lau, L. S., and B. McKercher (2004). “Exploration versus Acquisition: A Comparison of First-Time and Repeat Visitors.”Journal of Travel Research, 42 (3): 279-285.
30.
Lew, Alan A. (1987). “A Framework of Tourist Attraction Research.”Annals of Tourism Research, 14 (4): 553-575.
31.
Litvin, S. (1996). “Ecotourism: A Study of Purchase Proclivity.”Journal of Vacation Marketing, 3 (1): 43-54.
32.
Loon, R. M., and D. Polakow (2001). “Ecotourism Ventures: Rags or Riches?”Annals of Tourism Research, 28 (4):892-907.
33.
MacKay, K., K. Andereck, and C. Vogt (2002). “Understanding Vacationing Motorist Niche Markets.”Journal of Travel Research, 40 (May): 356-363.
34.
Martin, B., and W. Valliere (2002). 2001 National Survey of the Vermont Visitor: The Cultural Heritage Sector. Montpelier: Vermont Department of Tourism and Marketing, Vermont Tourism Data Center and School of Natural Resources, University of Vermont.
35.
Matthews, D. (2001). Memorandum by Southwest Tourism (CEM 123). London: UJ Parliament.
36.
McKercher, B. (1996). “Insights into Ranking Attractions: Comparing Visitors Intentions with Their Actions.” In Tourism and Hospitality Research: Australian and International Perspectives, edited by G. Prosser. Canberra, Australia: Bureau of Tourism Research, pp. 561-568.
37.
McKercher, B. (2001). “A Comparison of Main Destination and Through Travelers at a Dual Purpose Destination.”Journal of Travel Research, 39 (4): 433-448.
38.
McKercher, B. (2002). “Towards a Classification of Cultural Tourists.”International Journal of Tourism Research, 4: 29-38.
39.
McKercher, B., and H. du Cros (2003). “Testing a Cultural Tourism Typology.”International Journal of Tourism Research, 5 (1): 45-58.
40.
McKercher, B., and B. Robbins (1998). “Business Development Issues Affecting Nature-Based Tourism Operators in Australia.”Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 6 (2), 173-188.
41.
Mill, R. C., and A. M. Morrison (1985). The Tourism System: An Introductory Text. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Ohio Division of Travel and Tourism (2002). Visitor Information Survey 1. Columbus: Ohio Division of Travel and Tourism. Retrieved February 2, 2004, from http://www.ohiotourism.com/industry/research/profiles/niche.html.
44.
Okanogan (2003). “Cultural Tourism and Cultural Industries.” In Okanogan Cultural Corridor. Kelowna. Retrieved December 31, 2003, from http://www.okanaganculturalcorridor.com/thecorridor/culturaltourism.htm.
45.
Office of National Statistics (2003). Travel Trends 2002: A Report on the International Travel Survey, Appendix A. Newport, UK: Office of National Statistics.
46.
Oppermann, M. (1995). “A Model of Travel Itineraries.”Journal of Travel Research, 33 (4): 57-61.
47.
Oppermann, M. (1997). “First-Time and Repeat Tourists to New Zealand.”Tourism Management, 18 (3): 177-181.
48.
Patterson, E. (2000). Nature-Based Tourism in Tasmania 1998-99 Update. Hobart: Tourism Tasmania.
49.
Pearce, D., and P. Wilson (1995). “Wild-Life Viewing Tourists in New Zealand.”Journal of Travel Research, 34 (4):19-26.
50.
Pizam, A. (1994). “Planning a Tourism Research Investigation.” In Travel, Tourism and Hospitality Research: A Handbook for Managers and Researchers, 2nd ed., edited by J. Ritchie, and C. Goeldner. Toronto: John Wiley, pp. 91-104.
51.
Prentice, R., and V. Andersen (2003). “Festivals as Creative Destinations.”Annals of Tourism Research, 30 (1): 7-30.
52.
Richards, Greg (1996a). “Production and Consumption of European Cultural Tourism.”Annals of Tourism Research, 23 (2): 261-283.
53.
Richards, Greg (1996b). “Introduction: Cultural Tourism in Europe.” In Cultural Tourism in Europe, edited by G. Richards. Oxon, UK: CAB International, pp. 3-18.
54.
Saunders, M., P. Lewis, and A. Thornhill (2000). Research Methods for Business Students, 2nd ed.Harlow, UK: FT Prentice Hall.
55.
Statistics Canada (2001). Government Travel Survey of Visitors to Canada. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
56.
Statistics Canada (2003). Canadian Travel Survey Questionnaire: Year 2003. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
57.
Stronge, W. (2000). The Economic Impact of the Florida Arts and Cultural Industry. West Palm Beach: Florida Cultural Alliance.
58.
Taubman Centers (1999). Shopping and Cultural/Heritage Tourism: A Special Study of Overseas Travelers to the United States. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce.
59.
Thurston, S. (2004). New Hampshire Visitor Survey Winter 2003-04. Plymouth: New Hampshire Division of Travel and Tourism Development, Institute for New Hampshire Studies.
60.
Tighe, A. (1985). “Cultural Tourism in the USA.”Tourism Management, 6 (4): 234-251.
61.
Tourism Queensland (2004). Cultural Tourism. Brisbane, Australia: Tourism Queensland.
62.
Travel Industry Association of America (2004). Domestic Research: Travel Market Segments. Retrieved July 12, 2004, from http://www.tia.org/Travel/TravelTrends.asp.
63.
Tourism Research Council New Zealand (2004). International Visitor Survey: Questionnaire. Tourism Research Council New Zealand. Retrieved March 3, 2004, from http://www.trcnz.govt.nz/Surveys/International+Visitor+Survey/Questionnaire.htm.
Virginia Tourism Corporation (1998). VTC Virginia Visitor Survey Virginia. Virginia Tourism Corporation. Retrieved March 8, 2004, from http://www.vatc.org/research/surveypopup.htm.
66.
U.S. Department of Transportation (1995). 1995 American Travel Survey, Appendix E. American Travel Survey Technical Documentation. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Transportation, Bureau of Transport Statistics.
67.
World Tourism Organization (2002). Tourism Market Trends: World Overview and Tourism Topics. Madrid: World Tourism Organization.
