The study of contextual effects on political behavior has expanded dramatically in the last two decades. In this article we review the recent progress of the field in an attempt to develop a coherent framework for categorizing and analyzing contextual effects. We note that some types of effects have been understudied and that the processes by which context affects individuals have not received sufficient attention. Taking an information approach, we argue that context works through individual perceptions of contextual phenomena and that many sources of and reactions to information condition contextual effects. Finally, we suggest profitable future research efforts based on previous research and our preferred approach to the field.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALLARDT, E.
(1968) “The merger of American and European traditions of sociological research: contextual analysis.”Social Sci. Information7 (February): 151-168.
2.
BARTON, A.
(1968) “Bringing society back in: survey research and macro-methodology.”Amer. Behavioral Scientist12 (November-December): 1-9.
3.
BERELSON, B.
, P. LAZARSFELD, and W. McPHEE (1954) Voting.Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press
4.
BIEBLY, W.
(1981) “Neighborhood effects: a LISREL model for clustered samples.”Socio. Methods and Research10 (August): 82-111.
5.
BIERNACK, P.
and D. WALDORF (1981) “Snowball sampling: problems and techniques of chain referral sampling.”Socio. Methods and Research10 (November): 141-164.
6.
BLAU, P.
(1960) “Structural effects.”Amer. Socio. Rev.25 (April): 178-193.
7.
BODMAN, A.
(1983) “The neighborhood effect: a test of the Butler-Stokes model.”British J. of Pol. Sci.3 (April): 243-249.
8.
BOOKS, J.
(1977) “Social context and voting behavior in West Germany: a note on contextual analysis.”Social Sci. Q.58: 481-488.
9.
BOYD, L.
and G. IVERSON (1979) Contextual Analysis.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth
10.
BROWN, T.
(1981) “Contextual change and partisan attributes.”British J. of Pol. Sci.11 (October): 427-447.
11.
BUTLER, D.
and D. STOKES (1969) Political Change in Britain.New York: St. Martin's
12.
CAMPBELL, E.
and C. N. ALEXANDER (1965) “Structural effects and interpersonal relationships.”Amer. J. of Sociology71 (November): 284-289.
13.
COX, K.
(1969) “The special structuring of information flow and partisan attitudes,” in M. Dogan and S. Rokkan (eds.) Quantitative Ecological Analysis in the Social Sciences.Cambridge: MIT Press
14.
COX, K.
(1970) “Residential relocation and political behavior.”Acta Sociologica13: 40-53.
15.
CRENSON, M.
(1978) “Social networks and political processes in urban neighborhoods.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.22 (August): 578-594.
16.
CROTTY, W.
(1971) “Party effort and its impact on the vote.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.65 (June): 439-450.
17.
CUTRIGHT, P.
(1963) “Measuring the impact of local party activity on the general election vote.”Public Opinion Q.27 (Fall): 372-386.
18.
CUTRIGHT, P.
(1958) “Grass roots politicians and the vote.”Amer. Socio. Rev.23 (April): 171-179.
19.
DAVIS, J.
, J. SPAETH, and C. HUDSON (1961) “A technique for analyzing the effects of group composition.”Amer. Socio. Rev.26 (April): 215-225.
20.
DURAND, R.
and D. ECKART (1973) “Social rank, residential effects, and community satisfaction.”Social Forces52 (September): 74-85.
21.
DURAND, R.
and D. ECKART (1976) “Contextual models of party identification: a critical examination.”Socio. Q.17 (Summer): 291-302.
22.
ECKART, D.
and R. DURAND (1975) “The effect of context in measuring anomia.”Public Opinion Q.39 (Summer): 199-206.
23.
ENNIS, P.
(1962) “The contextual dimension in voting,” in W. McPhee and W. Glaser (eds.) Public Opinion and Congressional Elections.New York: Free Press
24.
ERBRING, L.
and A. YOUNG (1979) “Individuals and social structure: contextual effects as endogenous feedback.”Socio. Methods and Research7 (May): 396-430.
25.
FARKAS, G.
(1974) “Specification, residuals, and contextual effects.”Socio. Methods and Research2 (February): 333-363.
26.
FESTINGER, L.
(1957) A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance.Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press
27.
FINIFTER, A.
(1974) “The friendship group as protective environment for political deviants.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.68 (June): 607-625.
28.
FINIFTER, A.
and P. ABRAMSON (1975) “City size and feelings of political competence.”Public Opinion Q.39 (Summer): 189-198.
29.
FIREBAUGH, G.
(1979) “Assessing group effects: a comparison of two methods.”Socio. Methods and Research7 (May): 384-395.
30.
FITTON, M.
(1973) “Neighbourhood and voting: a sociometric examination.”British J. of Pol. Sci.3 (October): 445-472.
31.
FOLADARE, I.
(1968) “The effect of neighborhood on voting behavior.”Pol. Sci. Q.83 (December): 516-529.
32.
GILES, M.
and M. DANTICO (1982) “Political participation and neighborhood context revisited.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.26 (February): 144-150.
33.
GILES, M.
and A. EVANS (1985) “External threat, perceived threat, and group identity.”Social Sci. Q.66 (March): 50-66.
34.
GILES, M.
and D. GATLIN (1980) “Mass level compliance with public policy: the case of school desegregation.”J. of Politics42 (August): 722-746.
35.
GILES, M.
, G. WRIGHT, and M. DANTICO (1981) “Social status and political behavior: the impact of residential context.”Social Sci. Q.62 (September): 453-460.
36.
GOLDBERG, E.
and M. TRAUGOTT (1980) “Congressional campaign effects on candidate recognition and evaluation.”Political Behavior2: 61-90.
37.
GREEN, B.
(1971) “Social area analysis and structural effects.”Sociology1 (January): 1-19.
38.
GREENSTEIN, F.
and R. WOLFINGER (1958) “The suburbs and shifting party loyalty.”Public Opinion Q.22 (Winter): 473-483.
39.
HAUSER, R.
(1970) “Context and consex: a cautionary tale.”Amer. J. of Sociology75 (January): 645-664.
40.
HAUSER, R.
(1974) “Contextual analysis revisited.”Socio. Methods and Research2 (February): 365-375.
41.
HEILIG, P.
and R. MUNDT (1981) “Do districts make a difference?”Urban Interest3 (Spring): 62-75.
42.
HOVLAND, C.
, I. JANIS, and H. KELLEY (1953) Communication and Persuasion.New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press
43.
HUCKFELDT, R. R.
(1979) “Political participation and the neighborhood social context.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.23 (August): 579-592.
44.
HUCKFELDT, R. R.
(1980) “Variable responses to neighborhood social contexts: assimilation, conflict, and tipping points.”Pol. Behavior2: 231-258.
45.
HUCKFELDT, R. R.
(1983a) “The social context of ethnic loyalties.”Amer. Politics Q.11 (January): 91-124.
46.
HUCKFELDT, R. R.
(1983b) “Social contexts, social networks, and urban neighborhoods: environmental constraints of friendship choice.”Amer. J. of Sociology89: 651-669.
47.
HUCKFELDT, R. R.
(1983c) “The social context of political change: durability, volatility, and social influence.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.77 (December): 929-944.
48.
HUCKFELDT, R. R.
(1984) “Political loyalties and social class ties: the mechanisms of contextual influence.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.28 (May): 399-417.
49.
JAEHNIG, W.
, D. WEAVER, and F. FICO (1981) “Reporting crime and fearing crime in three communities.”J. of Communication31 (Winter): 88-96.
50.
KARNIG, A.
and B. O. WALTER (1983) “Decline in municipal turnout: a function of changing structure?”Amer. Politics Q.11 (October): 491-506.
51.
KATZ, D.
and S. ELDERSVELD (1961) “The impact of local party activity upon the electorate.”Public Opinion Q.25 (Spring): 1-24.
52.
KEECH, W.
(1968) The Impact of Negro Voting.Chicago: Rand McNally
53.
KELLEY, S.
, R. AYRES, and W. BOWEN (1967) “Registration and voting: putting first things first.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.61 (June): 359-379.
54.
KELLEY, J.
and I. McALLISTER (1985) “Social context and electoral behavior in Britain.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.29 (August): 564-586.
55.
KIM, J.
, J. PETROCIK, and S. ENOKSON (1975) “Voter turnout among the American states: systemic and individual components.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.69 (March): 107-123.
56.
KRAMER, G.
(1970) “The effects of precinct-level canvassing on voter behavior.”Public Opinion Q.34: 560-572.
57.
LANGTON, K.
and R. RAPOPORT (1975) “Social structure, social context, and partisan mobilization.”Comparative Pol. Studies8 (October): 318-344.
58.
LAZARSFELD, P.
and H. MENZEL (1961) “On the relation between individual and collective properties,” in A. Etzioni (ed.) Complex Organizations.New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston
59.
LINZ, J.
(1969) “Ecological analysis and survey research,” in M. Dogan and S. Rokkan (eds.) Quantitative Ecological Analysis in the Social Sciences.Cambridge: MIT Press
60.
MANIS, J.
and L. STINE (1958) “Suburban residence and political behavior.”Public Opinion Q.22 (Winter): 483-489.
61.
MATTHEWS, D.
and J. PROTHRO (1966) Negroes and the New Southern Politics.New York: Harcourt, Brace & World
62.
McPHEE, W.
, R. SMITH, and J. FERGUSON (1963) “A theory of informal social influence,” in W. McPhee, Formal Theories of Mass Behavior.Glencoe, IL: Free Press
63.
MELTZER, L.
(1963) “Comparing relationships of individual and average variables to individual responses.”Amer. Socio. Rev.28: 117-122.
64.
MILLER, W.
(1956) “One party politics and the voter.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.50 (September): 707-725.
65.
O'LOUGHLIN, J.
(1981) “The neighbourhood effect in urban voting surfaces: a crossnational analysis,” in A. Burnett and P. Taylor (eds.) Political Studies from Spacial Perspectives.New York: John Wiley
66.
ORBELL,J.
(1970a) “An information-flow theory of community influence.”J. of Politics32 (May): 322-338.
67.
ORBELL, J.
(1970b) “The impact of metropolitan residence on social and political orientations.”Social Sci. Q.51: 634-648.
68.
ORBELL, J.
and K. SHERRILL (1969) “Racial attitudes and the metropolitan context: a structural analysis.”Public Opinion Q.33 (Spring): 46-54.
69.
PATTERSON, T.
(1980) The Mass Media Election.New York: Praeger
70.
PRYSBY, C.
(1975) “Neighborhood class composition and individual partisan choice: a test with Chilean data.”Social Sci. Q.56 (September): 225-238.
71.
PRYSBY, C.
(1976) “Community partisanship and individual voting behavior: methodological problems of contextual analysis.”Pol. Methodology3: 183-198.
72.
PRZEWORSKI, A.
(1974) “Contextual models of political behavior.”Pol. Methodology1 (Winter): 27-61.
73.
PRZEWORSKI, A.
and B. SOARES (1971) “Theories in search of a curve: a contextual interpretation of left vote.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.65 (March): 51-68.
74.
PUTNAM, R.
(1966) “Political attitudes and the local community.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.60 (September): 640-654.
75.
ROSENSTONE, S.
and R. WOLFINGER (1978) “The effect of registration laws on voter turnout.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.72 (March): 22-45.
76.
SCHEUCH, E.
(1969) “Social context and individual behavior,” in M. Dogan and S. Rokkan (eds.) Quantitative Ecological Analysis in the Social Sciences.Cambridge: MIT Press
77.
SEGAL, D.
and M. MEYER (1969) “The social context of political partisanship,” in M. Dogan and S. Rokkan (eds.) Quantitative Ecological Analysis in the Social Sciences.Cambridge: MIT Press
78.
SEGAL, D.
and S. WILDSTROM (1970) “Community effects on political attitudes: partisanship and efficacy.”Socio. Q.11 (Winter): 67-86.
79.
SILLS, D.
(1961) “Three climate of opinion studies.”Public Opinion Q.25 (Winter): 571-573.
80.
SPRAGUE, J.
(1976) “Estimating a Boudon type contextual model: some practical and theoretical problems of measurement.”Pol. Methodology3: 333-353.
81.
SPRAGUE, J.
(1982) “Is there a micro theory consistent with contextual analysis?” in E. Ostrom (ed.) Strategies of Political Inquiry.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
82.
STIPAK, B.
and C. HENSLER (1982) “Statistical inference in contextual analysis.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.26 (February): 151-175.
83.
TANNENBAUM, A.
and J. BACHMAN (1964) “Structural versus individual effects.”Amer. J. of Sociology69 (May): 585-595.
84.
TATE, C. N.
(1974) “Individual and contextual variables in British voting behavior: an exploratory note.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.68 (December): 1656-1662.
85.
TAYLOR, P.
and R. JOHNSTON (1979) Geography of Elections.New York: Homes & Meier
86.
TINGSTEN, H.
(1937) Political Behavior: Studies in Election Statistics.London: P.S. King
87.
VALKONEN, T.
(1969) “Individual and structural effects in ecological research,” in M. Dogan and S. Rokkan (eds.) Quantitative Ecological Analysis in the Social Sciences.Cambridge: MIT Press
88.
WEATHERFORD, M. S.
(1980) “The politics of school busing: contextual effects and community polarization.”J. of Politics42 (August): 747-765.
89.
WEATHERFORD, M. S.
(1982a) “Measurement problems in contextual analysis: on statistical assumptions and social processes.”Pol. Methodology8: 61-90.
90.
WEATHERFORD, M. S.
(1982b) “Interpersonal networks and political behavior.”Amer. J. of Pol. Sci.26 (February): 117-143.
91.
WEATHERFORD,M. S.
(1983) “Evaluating economic policy: a contextual model of the opinion formation process.”J. of Politics45 (November): 866-888.
92.
WOLFINGER, R.
(1963) “The influence of precinct work on voting behavior.”Public Opinion Q.27 (Fall): 387-398.
93.
WRIGHT, G.
(1976) “Community structure and voting in the South.”Public Opinion Q.40 (Summer): 201-215.
94.
WRIGHT, G.
(1977) “Contextual models of electoral behavior: the southern Wallace vote.”Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev.71 (June): 497-508.
