The Long Arm of Early Exclusionary School Discipline? A Multi-Model Analysis

Abstract

In this analysis, we consider how a potentially important triggering event in the life course—exclusionary school discipline—may affect students’ high school outcomes. We extend the literature to focus on the long-term effects of exclusionary discipline that occurs in the early grades, when students are relatively young and when a significant share of exclusionary discipline first occurs. We further evaluate the potential, long-term effects of exclusionary discipline on different high school outcomes (non-completion, GED certification, high school diploma) in statistical models that account for observed and unobserved heterogeneity. Overall, we find robust and consistent evidence that very young children are not somehow more resilient or more protected from negative, long-term effects of suspension or expulsion in early elementary school. Moreover, previous research might underestimate the effects of (early) exclusionary discipline more generally by ignoring the independent effects on GED certification.

Keywords

education longitudinal design school dropout exclusionary discipline

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abadie

Imbens

G. W.

(2006). Large sample properties of matching estimators for average treatment effects. Econometrica, 74(1), 235–267.

Andrew

(2014). The scarring effects of primary-grade retention? A study of cumulative advantage in the educational career. Social Forces, 93(2), 653–685.

Anyon

Gregory

Stone

Farrar

Jenson

J. M.

McQueen

Downing

Greer

Simmons

(2016). Restorative interventions and school discipline sanctions in a large urban school district. American Educational Research Journal, 53(6), 1663–1697.

Augustine

C. H.

Engberg

Grimm

G. E.

Lee

Wang

E. L.

Christianson

Joseph . (2018). Can restorative practices improve school climate and curb suspensions? An evaluation of the impact of restorative practices in a mid-sized urban school district. RAND Corporation.

Balfanz

Fox

(2014). Sent home and put off-track: The antecedents, disproportionalities, and consequences of being suspended in the ninth grade. Journal of Applied Research on Children: Informing Policy for Children at Risk, 5(2), 13.

Barrett

McEachin

Mills

J. N.

Valant

(2021). Disparities and discrimination in student discipline by race and family income. Journal of Human Resources, 56, 711–748.

Blokland

A. A.

Nieuwbeerta

(2010). Life course criminology. International handbook of criminology (pp. 51–94). CRC Press.

Bowditch

(1993). Getting rid of troublemakers: High school disciplinary procedures and the production of dropouts. Social Problems, 40(4), 493–509.

Brown

T. M.

(2007). Lost and turned out: Academic, social, and emotional experiences of students excluded from school. Urban Education, 42(5), 432–455.

10.

Carter

P. L.

Skiba

Arredondo

M. I.

Pollock

(2017). You can’t fix what you don’t look at: Acknowledging race in addressing racial discipline disparities. Urban Education, 52(2), 207–235.

11.

Cook

T. D.

Shadish

W. R.

Wong

V. C.

(2008). Three conditions under which experiments and observational studies produce comparable causal estimates: New findings from within-study comparisons. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 27(4), 724–750.

12.

Costenbader

Markson

(1998). School suspension: A study with secondary school students. Journal of School Psychology, 36(1), 59–82.

13.

DiPrete

T. A.

Eirich

G. M.

(2006). Cumulative advantage as a mechanism for inequality: A review of theoretical and empirical developments. Annual Review of Sociology, 32(1), 271–297.

14.

Elder

G. H.

(1998). The life course and human development. In Damon

Lerner

R. M.

(Eds.), Handbook of child psychology: Theoretical models of human development (pp. 939–991). John Wiley & Sons Inc.

15.

Fabelo

Thompson, Plotkin

Carmichael

Marchbanks

M.P

III Booth

E.A.

(2011). Breaking schools’ rules: A statewide study on how school discipline relates to students’ success and juvenile justice involvement. Council of State Governments Justice Center. https://csgjusticecenter.org/publications/breaking-schools-rules/

16.

Finn

J. D.

(1989). Withdrawing from school. Review of Educational Research, 59(2), 117–142.

17.

Gregory

Bell

Pollock

(2016). How educators can eradicate disparities in school discipline. In Skiba

Mediratta

Rausch

(Eds.), Inequality in school discipline (pp. 39–58). Palgrave Macmillan.

18.

Heckman

J. J.

Humphries

J. E.

Mader

N. S.

(2011). The GED. In Hanushek

E. A.

Machin

Woessmann

(Eds.), Handbook of the economics of education (pp. 423–483). Elsevier.

19.

Hemphill

S. A.

Toumbourou

J. W.

Herrenkohl

T. I.

McMorris

B. J.

Catalano

R. F.

(2006). The effect of school suspensions and arrests on subsequent adolescent antisocial behavior in Australia and the United States. Journal of Adolescent Health, 39(5), 736–744.

20.

Hirschfield

P. J.

(2018). Schools and crime. Annual Review of Criminology, 1, 149–169.

21.

Hwang

(2018). Suspensions and achievement: Varying links by type, frequency, and subgroup. Educational Researcher, 47(6), 363–374.

22.

Imbens

G. W.

(2004). Nonparametric estimation of average treatment effects under exogeneity: A review. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(1), 4–29.

23.

Jarvis

S. N.

Okonofua

J. A.

(2020). School deferred: When bias affects school leaders. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 11(4), 492–498.

24.

Johnson

M. K.

Crosnoe

Elder

G. H.

(2001). Students’ attachment and academic engagement: The role of race and ethnicity. Sociology of Education, 74, 318–340.

25.

Kelly

Carbonaro

(2012). Curriculum tracking and teacher expectations: Evidence from discrepant course taking models. Social Psychology of Education, 15(3), 271–294.

26.

Kerckhoff

A. C.

(1995). Institutional arrangements and stratification processes in industrial societies. Annual Review of Sociology, 21(1), 323–347.

27.

Kotok

Ikoma

Bodovski

(2016). School climate and dropping out of school in the era of accountability. American Journal of Education, 122(4), 569–599.

28.

Lacoe

Steinberg

M. P.

(2019). Do suspensions affect student outcomes? Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 41(1), 34–62.

29.

Losen

Hodson

C. E. J.

Martinez

(2014). Disturbing inequities: Exploring the relationship between racial disparities in special education identification and discipline. Journal of Applied Research on Children, 5(2), 15.

30.

Morris

E. W.

Perry

B. L.

(2017). Girls behaving badly? Race, gender, and subjective evaluation in the discipline of African American girls. Sociology of Education, 90, 127–148.

31.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2016, May 2016). Indicator 19: Serious disciplinary actions taken by public schools. http://nces.ed.gov/programs/crimeindicators/ind_19.asp

32.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2019, July 2019). Indicator 15: Retention, suspension, and expulsion. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/raceindicators/indicator_RDA.asp

33.

Nicholson-Crotty

Birchmeier

Valentine

(2009). Exploring the impact of school discipline on racial disproportion in the juvenile justice system. Social Science Quarterly, 90(4), 1003–1018.

34.

Okonofua

J. A.

Perez

A. D.

Darling-Hammond

(2020). When policy and psychology meet: Mitigating the consequences of bias in schools. Science Advances, 6(42), eaba9479.

35.

Owens

McLanahan

S. S.

(2020). Unpacking the drivers of racial disparities in school suspension and expulsion. Social Forces, 98(4), 1548–1577.

36.

Pearl

(2014). Comment: Understanding Simpson’s paradox. The American Statistician, 68(1), 8–13.

37.

Raffaele-Mendez

L. M.

Knoff

H. M.

Ferron

J. M.

(2002). School demographic variables and out-of-school suspension rates: A quantitative and qualitative analysis of a large, ethnically diverse school district. Psychology in the Schools, 39(3), 259–277.

38.

Rios

V. M.

(2011). Punished: Policing the lives of Black and Latino boys. NYU Press.

39.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

(2004). Observational studies (2nd ed.). Springer Series in Statistics Springer-Verlag.

40.

Sampson

R. J.

Laub

J. H.

(1992). Crime and deviance in the life course. Annual Review of Sociology, 18(1), 63–84.

41.

Schollenberger

T. L.

(2015). Racial disparities in school suspension and subsequent outcomes: Evidence from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. In Losen

D. J.

(Ed.), Closing the school discipline gap (pp. 31–43). Teachers College Press.

42.

Shifrer

(2013). Stigma of a label: Educational expectations for high school students labeled with learning disabilities. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 54(4), 462–480.

43.

Skiba

R. J.

Chung

C. G.

Trachok

Baker

T. L.

Sheya

Hughes

R. L.

(2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640–670.

44.

Suh

(2007). Risk factors and levels of risk for high school dropouts. Professional School Counseling, 10(3). 2156759X0701000312.

45.

Van Buuren

Boshuizen

H. C.

Knook

D. L

. (1999). Multiple imputation of missing blood pressure covariates in survival analysis. Statistics in Medicine, 18(6), 681–694.

46.

Wright

J. P.

Morgan

M. A.

Coyne

M. A.

Beaver

K. M.

Barnes

J. C.

(2014). Prior problem behavior accounts for the racial gap in school suspensions. Criminal Justice Journal, 42(3), 257–266.

47.

Yeager

D. S.

Purdie-Vaughns

Hooper

S. Y.

Cohen

G. L.

(2017). Loss of institutional trust among racial and ethnic minority adolescents: A consequence of procedural injustice and a cause of life-span outcomes. Child Development, 88(2), 658–676.