The decline of ‘advantageous disadvantage’ in gateway suburbs in Australia: The challenge of private housing market settlement for newly arrived migrants

Abstract

Chinese

The spatial concentration of recently arrived immigrants in gateway cities and suburbs is usually seen as undesirable by urban academics and policy makers. This paper presents a counter-argument that the concentration of disadvantaged new immigrants in the form of humanitarian refugees and their families can, and does, result in positive outcomes for those groups. In part, our argument is based on making a distinction between people-based disadvantage and place-based disadvantage. The paper examines the changing nature of place-based ‘advantage’ for immigrants in Australian gateway cities through a focus on two metropolitan locations, Auburn (Sydney) and Springvale (Melbourne), known as popular destination suburbs for recent immigrants. While these two cases validate the benefits of such gateway suburbs, they also demonstrate that the capacity of recent migrants to emulate concentrated settlement patterns is now significantly undermined by changes in the labour market and affordability problems in the housing market. The paper concludes with a discussion on the possible future of gateway suburbs and the implications of this shift for the wellbeing of particular groups of disadvantaged residents.

Keywords

cities disadvantage gateway suburbs housing migration

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anacker

(2013) Immigrating, assimilating, cashing in? Analyzing property values in suburbs of immigrant gateways. Housing Studies 28(5): 720–745.

Andersen

Van Kempen

(2003) New trends in urban policies in Europe: Evidence from the Netherlands and Denmark. Cities 20(2): 77–86.

Andersson

Bråmå

(2004) Selective migration in Swedish distressed neighbourhoods: Can area-based urban policies counteract segregation processes? Housing Studies 19(4): 517–539.

Andersson

Musterd

(2005) Area-based policies: A critical appraisal. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie 96(4): 377–389.

Arthurson

(2012) Social Mix and the City: Challenging the Mixed Communities Consensus in Housing and Urban Planning Policies. Canberra: CSIRO Publishing.

Auburn City Council (2011) Auburn City Community Strategic Plan 2011–2021. Sydney: Auburn City Council.

Auburn City Council (2013) Auburn City Community Strategic Plan 2013–2023. Auburn: Auburn City Council.

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (2011) ABS Community Profiles. Available at: www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/censushome.nsf/home/communityprofiles (accessed 16 June 2016).

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (2013) 3412.0: Migration, Australia 2012–13. Available at: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/Lookup/3412.0Chapter12011–12%20and%202012–13 (accessed 17 June 2016).

10.

Australian Government Department of Social Services (2015) Settlement Reports: Local Government Areas by Migration Stream. Available at: https://www.dss.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/05_2015/local_government_area_by_migration_stream_-_april_2010_to_march_2015.pdf (acessed 9 December 2016).

11.

Baum

Haynes

Van Gellecum

. (2006) Advantage and disadvantage across Australia’s extended metropolitan regions: A typology of socio-economic outcomes. Urban Studies 43(9): 1549–1579.

12.

Baum

O’Connor

Stimson

(2005) Fault Lines Exposed: Advantage and Disadvantage Across Australia’s Settlement System. Melbourne: Monash ePress.

13.

Beer

Foley

(2003) Housing Need and Provision for Recently Arrived Refugees in Australia. Final Report No. 43. Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

14.

Benton-Short

Price

Friedman

(2005) Globalization from below: The ranking of global immigrant cities. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 29(4): 945–959.

15.

Betts

(2015) Migration to Australia: An Overview of the Data, From 1860 to 2014–15. The Australian Population Research Institute Background Paper, Melbourne.

16.

Bolton

(1992) Place prosperity vs people prosperity revisited: An old issue with a new angle. Urban Studies 29(2): 185–203.

17.

Bradford

(2013) Neighbourhood revitalization in Canada: Towards place-based policy solutions. In: Manley

van Ham

Bailey

. (eds) Neighbourhood Effects or Neighbourhood Based Problems? Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 157–176.

18.

Burke

Hulse

(2015) Spatial Disadvantage: Why is Australia Different? Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

19.

Burke

Stone

Ralston

(2011) The Residual Income Method: A New Lens on Housing Affordability and Market Behaviour. Final Report No. 176. Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

20.

Cheshire

(2012) Are mixed communities policies evidence-based? A review of the research on neighbourhood effects. In: van Ham

Manley

Bailey

. (eds) Neighbourhood Effects Research: New Perspectives. Springer: Dordrecht, pp. 267–294.

21.

Darcy

(2010) De-concentration of disadvantage and mixed income housing: A critical discourse approach. Housing, Theory and Society 27(1): 1–22.

22.

Department of Immigration and Citizenship (2008) Review of the Adult Migrant English Program. Discussion Paper July, Canberra.

23.

Edgar

(2014) An intergenerational model of spatial assimilation in Sydney and Melbourne, Australia. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 40(3): 363–383.

24.

Flood

Baker

(2010) Housing Implications of Economic, Social, and Spatial Change. Final Report No. 150. Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

25.

Galbally

(1978) Migrant Services and Programs. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service, p. 4.

26.

Gregory

Hunter

(1995) The Macro Economy and the Growth of Ghettoes and Urban Poverty in Australia. Report. Canberra: Australian National University.

27.

Hamnett

Randolph

(1988) Labour and housing market change in London: A longitudinal analysis, 1971–1981. Urban Studies 25(5): 380–398.

28.

Hou

Bourne

(2006) The migration–immigration link in Canada’s gateway cities: A comparative study of Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver. Environment and Planning A 38(8): 1505–1525.

29.

Hugo

(2011) Changing patterns of immigrant settlement. In: Jupp

Clyne

(eds) Multiculturalism and Integration: A Harmonious Relationship. Canberra: Australian National University Press, pp. 1–40.

30.

Hulse

Pawson

Reynolds

. (2014) Disadvantaged Places in Urban Australia: Analysing Socio-Economic Diversity and Housing Market Performance. Final Report No. 225. Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

31.

Hunter

(2003) Trends in neighbourhood inequality of Australian, Canadian and United States of America cities since the 1970s. Australian Economic History Review 43(1): 22–44.

32.

Jargowski

(1997) Poverty and Place: Ghettos, Barrios and the American City. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

33.

Katz

Creighton

Amsterdam

. (2010) Immigration and the new metropolitan geography. Journal of Urban Affairs 32(5): 523–547.

34.

Klapdor

(2014) Changed indexation of pensions and tightened eligibility for all benefits. Available at: www.aph.gov.au/about_parliament/parliamentary_departments/parliamentary_library/pubs/rp/budgetreview201415/indexation (accessed 15 June 2016).

35.

Ley

(2007) Countervailing immigration and domestic migration in gateway cities: Australian and Canadian variations on an American theme. Economic Geography 83(3): 231–254.

36.

Ley

Murphy

(2001) Immigration in gateway cities: Sydney and Vancouver in comparative perspective. Progress in Planning 55(3): 119–194.

37.

Ley

Smith

(2000) Relations between deprivation and immigrant groups in large Canadian cities. Urban Studies 37(1): 37–62.

38.

Lupton

(2003) Neighbourhood effects: What are they and can we measure them? LSE STICERD Research Paper No. CASE Paper 073, Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion. London: London School of Economics.

39.

Maclennan

(2013) Neighbourhoods: Evolving ideas, evidence and changing policies. In: Manley

van Ham

Bailey

. (eds) Neighbourhood Effects or Neighbourhood Based Problems? Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 269–292.

40.

Manley

van Ham

Bailey

. (2013) Neighbourhood effects or neighbourhood based problems? A policy context. In: Manley

van Ham

Bailey

. (eds) Neighbourhood Effects or Neighbourhood Based Problems? Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 1–23.

41.

Martin

(2012) The painful truth about trying to live on $35 a day. The Sydney Morning Herald, 24 April. Available at: http://www.smh.com.au/national/the-painful-truth-about-trying-to-live-on-35-a-day-20120423–1xhee.html.

42.

Morris

(2015) The residualisation of public housing and its impact on older tenants in inner-city Sydney, Australia. Journal of Sociology 51(2): 154–169.

43.

Murie

Musterd

(2004) Social exclusion and opportunity structures in European cities and neighbourhoods. Urban Studies 41(8): 1441–1459.

44.

Murphy

Murray

Chalmers

. (2011) Half a Citizen: Life on Welfare in Australia. Sydney: Allen and Unwin.

45.

Murray

(1984) Losing Ground: American Social Policy 1950–1980. New York: Basic Books.

46.

Musterd

(2005) Social and ethnic segregation in Europe: Levels, causes, and effects. Journal of Urban Affairs 27(3): 331–348.

47.

Musterd

Deurloo

(2002) Unstable immigrant concentrations in Amsterdam: Spatial segregation and integration of newcomers. Housing Studies 17(3): 487–503.

48.

North

Syrett

(2008) Making the links: Economic deprivation, neighbourhood renewal and scales of governance. Regional Studies 42(1): 133–148.

49.

Painter

(2008) Leaving gateway metropolitan areas in the United States: Immigrants and the housing market. Urban Studies 45(5–6): 1163–1191.

50.

Pawson

Hulse

Cheshire

(2015) Addressing Concentrations of Disadvantage in Urban Australia. Final Report No. 247. Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

51.

Phillimore

Goodson

(2006) Problem or opportunity? Asylum seekers, refugees, employment and social exclusion in deprived urban areas. Urban Studies 43(0): 1715–1736.

52.

Price

Benton-Short

(2007) Immigrants and world cities: From the hyper-diverse to the bypassed. GeoJournal 68(2–3): 103–117.

53.

Price

Cheung

Friedman

. (2005) The world settles in: Washington, DC, as an immigrant gateway. Urban Geography 26(1): 61–83.

54.

Randolph

Holloway

(2005) The suburbanization of disadvantage in Sydney: New problems, new policies. Opolis 1(1): 49–65.

55.

Randolph

Tice

(2014) Suburbanising disadvantage in Australian cities: Sociospatial change in an era of neoliberalism. Journal of Urban Affairs 36(1): 384–399.

56.

Singer

(2012) Metropolitan Washington: A new immigrant gateway. Research in Race and Ethnic Relations 17: 3–24.

57.

Smith

Ley

(2008) Even in Canada? The multiscalar construction and experience of concentrated immigrant poverty in gateway cities. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 98(3): 686–713.

58.

Stone

Parkinson

Sharam

. (2016) Housing Assistance Need and Provision in Australia: A Household-Based Policy Analysis. Final Report No. 262. Melbourne: Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.

59.

Teixeira

(2014) Living on the ‘edge of the suburbs’ of Vancouver: A case study of the housing experiences and coping strategies of recent immigrants in Surrey and Richmond. The Canadian Geographer/Le Géographe Canadien 58(2): 168–187.

60.

United Nations (2013) International Migration Report 2013. New York: Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division, United Nations.

61.

Wacquant

(1993) Urban outcasts, stigma and division in the black American ghetto and the French urban periphery. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 17(3): 366–383.

62.

Walks

(2001) The social ecology of the post-Fordist/global city? Economic restructuring and socio-spatial polarisation in the Toronto urban region. Urban Studies 38(3): 407–447.

63.

Ward

(2015) Geographies of exclusion: Seaside towns and houses in multiple occupancy. Journal of Rural Studies 37: 96–107.

64.

Yates

(2000) Is Australia’s home-ownership rate really stable? An examination of change between 1975 and 1994. Urban Studies 37: 319–342.