Is ‘gentrification’ an analytically useful concept for Vietnam? A case study of Hanoi

Abstract

Despite the rapid transformation in the urban landscape of Vietnam, a simple and uncritical application of the ‘gentrification’ concept out of the specific spatial and temporal context of the country is problematic. Not only does the phenomenon progress in a highly compressed temporal scale compared with similar processes in cities in the Global North, it is also embedded within a paradigmatic shift of the entire socio-economic system. This paper attempts to explore the process of urban redevelopment in Vietnam and critically examines whether this concept, with its origin from the Global North, is capable of offering a conceptually robust lens through which the processes and outcomes of redevelopment can be consistently analysed. This helps to shed light on our understanding of the usefulness of the concept of gentrification in Vietnam and in transitional economies in Asia in general.

Keywords

gentrification Hanoi transitional economy urban transformation Vietnam

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson

(2003) Introduction: Misunderstood saviour or vengeful wrecker? The many meanings and problems of gentrification. Urban Studies 40(12): 2343–2350.

AusAID (1995) Detailed Development Planning for the Ancient Quarter of Hanoi. Hanoi Planning and Development Control Project.

Baotintuc.vn (2012) Nguyen Cong Tru residents agreed to hand over the residence. 17 December. Available at: http://baotintuc.vn/xa-hoi/nguoi-dan-ktt-nguyen-cong-tru-dong-thuan-giao-mat-bang-20121217171358352.htm (accessed 18 December 2012).

Baotintuc.vn (2014) Planning for redevelopment of the old apartment buildings. 28 August. Available at: http://baotintuc.vn/xa-hoi/quy-hoach-cai-tao-cac-chung-cu-cu-20140828064326925.htm (accessed September 2014).

Beresford

(1997) Vietnam: The transition from central planning. In: Rodan

Hewison

Robison

(eds) The Political Economy of South East Asia. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, pp. 206–232.

Bridge

(2003) Time–space trajectories provincial gentrification. Urban Studies 40(12): 2545–2556.

Butler

(1997) Gentrification and the Middle Classes. Aldershot: Ashgate.

Caulfield

(1994) City Form and Everyday Life: Toronto Gentrification and Critical Social Practice. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Clark

(2005) The order and simplicity of gentrification, a political challenge. In: Atkinson

Bridge

(ed.) Gentrification in a Global Context: The New Urban Colonialism. London, New York: Routledge, pp. 261–269.

10.

Davidson

(2008) Spoiled mixture: Where does state led ‘positive’ gentrification end? Urban Studies 45: 2385–2406.

11.

Davidson

Lees

(2010) New-build gentrification: Its histories, trajectories, and critical geographies, population. Space & Place 16: 395–411.

12.

Duckett

(1998) The Entrepreneurial State in China: Real Estate and Commerce Departments in Reform Era Tianjin. London and New York: Routledge.

13.

Gainsborough

(2010) Present but not powerful: Neoliberalism, the state and development in Vietnam. Globalisation 7(4): 775–488.

14.

General Statistics Office of Vietnam (2010) Results of the Vietnam Household Living Standard Survey 2010. Statistics Publishing House.

15.

Glass

(1964) London: Aspects Of Change. London: Centre For Urban Studies.

16.

Gotham

(2005) Tourism gentrification: The case of New Orleans’ Vieux Carre (French Quarter). Urban Studies 42(7): 1099–1121.

17.

Government of Vietnam (2007) Resolution on Implementing Measures to Renovate and Rebuild Old Damaged and Downgraded Apartment Buildings. Resolution 34/2007/NQ-CP.

18.

Government of Vietnam (2011) Qui hoach chung xay dung thu do Ha noi den nam 2030 va tam nhin den 2050 (Master plan for the construction of Hanoi capital to the year 2030 and vision to 2050). Accessed at: http://www.hapi.gov.vn/quyet-donh-so-1259qdttg-ngay-2672011-cua-thu-tuong-chinh-phu-ve-viec-phe-duyet-quy-hoach-chung-xay-dung-thu-do-ha-noi-den-nam-2030-va-tam-nhin-den_a497c74t185.aspx.

19.

Hackworth

Smith

(2001) The changing state of gentrification. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie 92(4): 464–477.

20.

Han

(2008) Land acquisition in transitional Hanoi, Vietnam. Urban Studies 45: 1097–1117.

21.

Hanoi2010.org (2012) 51 Hang Bac: The first pilot project for rehabilitation of housing. Available at: http://www.hanoi2010.org/uk/pagesEditos.asp?id=FD3573AA&IDPAGE=80&sX_Menu_selectedID=FD3573AA. (accessed November 30 2012)

22.

Harms

(2012) Beauty as control in the new Saigon. American Ethnologist 39(4): 735–750.

23.

Harris

(2008) From London to Mumbai and back again: Gentrification and public policy in comparative perspective. Urban Studies 45(12): 2407–2428.

24.

(2005) Property-led redevelopment in post-reform China: A case study of Xintiandi redevelopment project in Shanghai. Journal of Urban Affairs 27(1): 1–23.

25.

(2009) Breaking the Deadlock of Demolition and Relocation. Available at: http://www.ehomeday.comhttp://www.ehomeday.com/interview/zt8/interview8_detail4b.html.

26.

Kerkvliet

BJT

(2001) An approach for analysing state–society relations in Vietnam. Sojourn 16(2): 238–278.

27.

khudothimoi.com (2009) Land and house price in the Ancient quarter is skyhigh. 5 June. Available at: http://khudothimoi.com/tintuc/thi-truong-nha-dat/345-gia-nha-dat-khu-pho-co-ha-noi-dat-khung-khiep.html (accessed 10 December 2013).

28.

Kienviet.net (2011) Renovation of Ta Hien street: Many lessons learned from 15 billions dong. 31 December. Available at: http://kienviet.net/2011/12/31/cai-tao-pho-co-ta-hien-15-ty-dong-cho-nhieu-bai-hoc/http://kienviet.net/2011/12/31/cai-tao-pho-co-ta-hien-15-ty-dong-cho-nhieu-bai-hoc/,/ (accessed 18 November 2012).

29.

Kim

(2008) Learning to be Capitalists: Entrepreneurs Vietnam’s Transitional Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

30.

Koh

(2006) Wards in Vietnam. Singapore: Institute of South East Asia Studies.

31.

Lambert

Boddy

(2002) Transforming the city: Post recession gentrification and re-urbanization. Conference Upward Neighbourhood Trajectories: Gentrification in the New Century. 26–27 September, University of Glasgow.

32.

Land.cafef.vn (2012) Rebuilding the old apartment buildings. 14 June. Available at: http://land.cafef.vn/chinh-sach-quy-hoach/xay-chung-cu-cu-doanh-nghiep-huc-dau-vao-da-20120614071447683ca44.chn, / (accessed 18 November 2012).

33.

Lees

(2000) A reappraisal of gentrification: Towards a ‘geography of gentrification’. Progress in Human Geography 24(3): 389–408.

34.

Lees

(2012) The geography of gentrification: Thinking through comparative urbanism. Progress in Human Geography 36(2): 155–171.

35.

Lees

Slater

Wyly

(2008) Gentrification. New York: Routledge.

36.

Ley

(1996) The New Middle Class and the Remaking of the Central City. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

37.

Ley

Teo

(2013) Gentrification in Hong Kong? Epistemology vs ontology. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 38(4): 1286–1303.

38.

Maloutas

(2011) Contextual diversity in gentrification research. Critical Sociology 38(1): 33–48.

39.

Migdal

(1988) Strong Societies and Weak States. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univeristy Press.

40.

Ong

(1999) Flexible Citizenship: The Cultural Logics of Transnationality. Duham NC: Duke University Press.

41.

People’s Committee of Hanoi (2008) Regulations for redevelopment of old degraded apartment buildings in Hanoi. Hanoi 28 July 2008. Available at: http://thuvienphapluat.vn/archive/Quyet-dinh-26-2005-QD-UB-boi-thuong-ho-tro-tai-dinh-cu-vb3591.aspx.

42.

People’s Committee of Hanoi (2013) Resolution on the measures to redevelop, rebuild old apartment buildings before 1954 in Hanoi city. Hanoi, 23 July 2013. Available at: http://thuvienphapluat.vn/archive/Nghi-quyet-17-2013-NQ-HDND-cal-tao-xay-dung-lai-khu-chung-cu-nha-cu-Ha-Noi-vb202874.aspx.

43.

Preteceille

(2007) Is gentrification a useful paradigm to analyse social changes in the Paris metropolis? Environment and Planning A 42: 2302–2308.

44.

Quehuongonline.vn (2012) An ancient space in the heart of Hanoi. 2 July. Available at: http://quehuongonline.vn/VietNam/Home/Dat-nuoc-Con-nguoi/1000-nam-Thang-Long-Ha-Noi/2012/07/47F1CA72/http://quehuongonline.vn/VietNam/Home/Dat-nuoc-Con-nguoi/1000-nam-Thang-Long-Ha-Noi/2012/07/47F1CA72/ (accessed 18 November 2012).

45.

Quinn

BJM

(2002) Legal reform and its context in Vietnam. Columbia Journal of Asian Law. Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=995599 (accessed 18 December 2012).

46.

Shanghai Municipal Statistics Bureau (2012) Shanghai Statistical Yearbook 2012. Shanghai: Shanghai Municipal Statistics Bureau.

47.

Shin

(2008) Driven to Swim With the Tide? Urban Redevelopment and Community Participation in China. CASE Paper No. 130, Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics.

48.

Shin

(2009a) Property-based redevelopment and gentrification: The case of Seoul, South Korea. Geoforum 40(5): 906–917.

49.

Shin

(2009b) Residential redevelopment and the entrepreneurial local state: The implications of Beijing’s shifting emphasis on urban redevelopment policies. Urban Studies 46(13): 2815–2839.

50.

SIDA Sweco (1995) Hanoi - 36 Streets of Hanoi. Pilot project on Renovation and Development. Stockholm: SIDA.

51.

SIDA Sweco (1996) 36 Old Street of Hanoi. Pilot Project on Renovation and Development. Project report.

52.

Smith

(1996) The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and The Revanchist City. London: Routledge.

53.

Tran

(1999) Another modernism? Form, content and meaning of the new housing architecture of Hanoi. Doctoral Dissertation, Thesis 9, Department of Architecture and Development Studies, LTH, Lund University.

54.

Transparency International (2012) Corruption Perception Index. Available at: http://cpi.transparency.org/http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2012/interactive/ (accessed 20 December 2012).

55.

Van Criekingen

Decroly

(2003) Revisiting the diversity of gentrification: Neighbourhood renewal processes in Brussels and Montreal. Urban Studies 40(12): 2451–2468.

56.

Vietbao.vn (2012) Increase of land conflicts. 7 November. Available at: http://vietbao.vn/Xa-hoi/Tranh-chap-dat-dai-tang-Ra-quyet-dinh-nhieu-thieu-sot/75356289/157/http://vietbao.vn/Xa-hoi/Tranh-chap-dat-dai-tang-Ra-quyet-dinh-nhieu-thieu-sot/75356289/157/ (accessed 18 November 2012).

57.

Yip

Tran

(2008) Urban housing reform and state capacity in Vietnam. The Pacific Review 21(2): 189–210.

58.

Zhang

(2001) Strangers in the City: Reconfigurations of Space, Power and Social Networks Within China’s Floating Population. Stanford, CT: Stanford University Press.