The outsourcing of control: Alcohol law enforcement,private-sector governance and the evening and night-time economy

Abstract

England and Wales have experienced a decade of transformation concerning the legislative governance of urban public drinking spaces, yet the Evening and Night-time Economy (ENTE) retains its position at the top of ‘community safety’ agendas. This article reflects upon our research on alcohol law enforcement. We explore how some alcohol laws are ill-fit-for-purpose, whilst others are considered too difficult, or costly, to pursue. Subtle negotiations of compliance in which regulator and regulated form ‘partnerships’ are, at best, increasing trust and the flow of intelligence, and at worst, breeding complacency, inaction and regulatory capture. Gaps between headline statutory objectives and their delivery through policy implementation are being filled by corporate actors mobilising resources in line with central government predilections towards the outsourcing of control. In particular, the alcohol and hospitality industries promote ‘voluntary alternatives’ to the statutory roles and enforcement powers of city authorities and police. Replacing traditional law enforcement activity with self-regulation by alco-centric commercial interests is unlikely to assist attempts by public bodies, NGOs and other business sectors to engineer more diversified and inclusive urban nightscapes.

Keywords

alcohol community safety law enforcement night-time economy public policy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Association of Town Centre Management (2013) Newry to Receive Purple Flag. Press Release. ACTM: London. Available at: https://www.atcm.org/news/view?id=21&x%5B0%5D=/list (accessed 14 May 2014).

Ayres

Braithwaite

(1992) Responsive Regulation: Transcending the Deregulation Debate. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Babor

Caetano

Casswell

. (2010) Alcohol: No Ordinary Commodity – Research and Public Policy. 2nd edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Best Bar None (2010) The History of BBN. Available at: http://www.bbnuk.com/what-is-best-bar-none/history-of-best-bar-none (accessed 22 January 2014).

Civic Trust (2006) Nightvision: Town Centres for All. London: The Civic Trust.

Davies

(2010) Better Town Centres at Night: Raising the Standard and Broadening the Appeal. London: British Council of Shopping Centres.

Department of Culture, Media, Sport (2008) Evaluation of the Impact of the Licensing Act 2003. London: DCMS.

Diageo (2011) Nine New UK Towns and Cities Awarded the Purple Standard. 12 October. Press Release. Diageo: London. Available at: http://www.diageo.com/en-row/newsmedia/pages/resource.aspx?resourceid=1083 (accessed 14 May 2014).

Forsyth

Cloonan

Barr

(2005) Factors Associated with Alcohol-related Problems within Licensed Premises. Glasgow: Greater Glasgow NHS Board.

10.

Garland

(1996) The limits of the sovereign state: Strategies of crime control in contemporary society. British Journal of Criminology 36(4): 445–471.

11.

Graham

(2000) Training Manual for the Observers on the Safer Bars Study. Toronto: Centre for Addiction and Mental Health.

12.

Hadfield

(2006) Bar Wars: Contesting the Night in Contemporary British Cities. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

13.

Hadfield

(2008) From threat to promise: Nightclub ‘security’, governance and consumer elites. British Journal of Criminology 48: 429–447.

14.

Hadfield

(2014) The night-time city. Four modes of exclusion: Reflections on the Urban Studies special collection. Urban Studies. DOI: 10.1177/0042098014552934.

15.

Hadfield

Measham

(2009) England and Wales. In: Hadfield

(ed.) Nightlife and Crime: Social Order and Governance in International Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 19–50.

16.

Hadfield

Measham

(2011) Lost Orders? Alcohol and Law Enforcement in England and Wales: Final Report to the Portman Group. Available at: http://www.docstoc.com/docs/148444747/Law-Enforcement-and-Alcohol-in-England-and----Portman-Group (accessed 25 June 2014).

17.

Hadfield

Lister

Traynor

(2009a) This town’s a different town today: Policing and regulating the night-time economy. Criminology and Criminal Justice 9(4): 465–485.

18.

Hadfield

Lister

Traynor

(2009b) Alcohol Insights: The Orientation and Integration of Local and National Alcohol Policy. London: Alcohol Education Research Council.

19.

Hardy

(2014) The National Policy Context. Presentation at Section 141: Selling to Drunks? Supply, Enforcement and Policy conference, Guildhall, London, 16 June 2014.

20.

Hawkins

Holden

McCambridge

(2012) Alcohol industry influence on UK alcohol policy: A new research agenda for public health. Critical Public Health 22(3): 297–305.

21.

Home Office (2010) Rebalancing the Licensing Act – A Consultation on Empowering Individuals, Families and Local Communities to Shape and Determine Local Licensing. London: Home Office.

22.

Home Office (2012) Amended Guidance on the Late-Night Levy. London: Home Office.

23.

Home Office (2013a) Alcohol and Late-Night Refreshment Licensing England and Wales 31 March 2013 Tables. London: Home Office.

24.

Home Office (2013b) Penalty Notices for Disorder (PND) Guidance. London: Ministry of Justice.

25.

Home Office (2013c) Next Steps Following the Consultation on Delivering the Government’s Alcohol Strategy. London: Home Office.

26.

Home Office (2014) Revised Guidance Issued Under Section 182 of the Licensing Act 2003. London: Home Office.

27.

Home Office/Institute of Licensing (2012) A Stepped Approach to Gaining Compliance Factsheet. London: Home Office.

28.

Home Office/KPMG, LLP (2008) Review of the Social Responsibility Standards for the Production and Sale of Alcoholic Drinks. Birmingham: KPMG LLP.

29.

Hubbard

(2013) Carnage! Coming to a town near you? Nightlife, uncivilized behaviour and the carnivalesque body. Leisure Studies 32(3): 265–282.

30.

Hughes

Bellis

Leckenby

. (2014) Does legislation to prevent alcohol sales to drunk individuals work? Measuring the propensity for night-time sales to drunks in a UK city. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. DOI: 10.1136/jech-2013–203287.

31.

Humphreys

Eisner

(2010) Evaluating a natural experiment in alcohol policy: The Licensing Act (2003) and the requirement for attention to implementation. Criminology & Public Policy 9(1): 41–67.

32.

Humphreys

Eisner

(2014) Do flexible alcohol trading hours reduce violence? A theory-based natural experiment in alcohol policy. Journal of Social Science and Medicine 102: 1–9.

33.

Kenyon

(2012) Introduction to the Best Bar None Scheme and Its Benefits. BBN and Leeds Metropolitan University.

34.

Light

(2010) Alcohol licensing, crime and disorder. In: Herzog-Evans

(ed.) Transnational Criminology Manual. Nijmegen: Wolf Legal Publishing, pp. 297–314.

35.

Measham

Brain

(2005) ‘Binge’ drinking, British alcohol policy and the new culture of intoxication. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal 1(3): 263–284.

36.

Measham

Moore

Østergaard

(2011) Emerging Drug Trends in Lancashire: Night Time Economy Surveys. Phase One Report, Lancaster: Lancaster University and Lancashire Drug and Alcohol Action Team, pp. 1–62.

37.

Millar

. (2012) Dealing with Alcohol-Related Harm and the Night-time Economy (DANTE) Final Report. Monograph Series No. 43. Canberra: National Drug Law Enforcement Research Fund.

38.

Ministry of Justice (2012) Criminal Justice Stats – June 2012. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/criminal-justice-statistics-in-england-and-wales-earlier-editions-in-the-series.

39.

Newton

Hirschfield

Armitage

. (2008) Evaluation of the Licensing Act: Measuring Crime and Disorder in and around Licensed Premises. Research Study SRG/05/007 Final Report for the Home Office. University of Huddersfield.

40.

Office for National Statistics (2013a) Focus On: Violent Crime and Sexual Offences, 2011/12. London: ONS.

41.

Office for National Statistics (2013b) Drinking Habits Amongst Adults, 2012. London: ONS.

42.

Perham

Moore

Shepherd

. (2007) Identifying drunkenness in the night-time economy. Addiction 102(3): 377–380.

43.

Poppleston Allen (2012) Late-night Licensing Survey 2012. Nottingham: Poppleston Allen.

44.

Shepherd

(2007) The Cardiff Model/Effective NHS Contributions to Violence Prevention. Cardiff: Cardiff University.

45.

Slade

(2007) Sales to Drunks Enforcement and Responsible Alcohol Sales Campaign: Additional Information for Participating BCUs. London: Home Office, Police and Partnership Standards Unit.

46.

Wine and Spirit Trade Association (2008) White Paper on Enforcement. London: WSTA.

47.

Wine and Spirit Trade Association, et al. (2005) Social Responsibility Standards for the Production and Sale of Alcoholic Drinks in the UK. London: WSTA.