This article develops and applies a method to estimate the revenues of beggars in Brussels. This is relevant for three reasons. First, in the literature on the informal economy, we lack reliable empirical knowledge of informal street-level activities like begging, substantiating the expectation that beggars’ income will be low. Secondly, popular representation of beggars often depicts them as criminal and wealthy. Finally, recent legislation builds on the idea of criminal organisations behind beggars. Building on an analysis of existing attempts to measure beggars’ income, we aim for a triangulation with data from three different sources: observation, self-reports and quasi-experimental observations. This triangulation allows for more reliable and valid conclusions. Hypotheses based upon popular images and the criminalisation of begging are dismissed. The evidence does support the hypothesis based upon the literature on informal activities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, M., Bromley, C. and Rosie, M. (2000) Begging as a challenge to the welfare state, in: R. Jowell, J. Curtice, A. Park et al. (Eds) British Social Attitudes: The 17th Report: Focussing on Diversity, pp. 209-237. London: Sage.
2.
Alderslade, J., Talmage, J. and Freeman, Y. ( 2006) Measuring the Informal Economy: One Neighborhood at a TimeWashington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
3.
Baker, D.J. ( 2009) A critical evaluation of the historical and contemporary justifications for criminalising begging, Journal of Criminal Law, 73(3), pp. 212-240.
4.
Blomley, N. ( 2007) How to turn a beggar into a bus stop: law, traffic and the ‘function of the place’, Urban Studies, 44(9), pp. 1697-1712.
5.
Boarini, R. and d’Ercole, M.M. ( 2006) Measures of Material Deprivation in OECD Countries, No. 37. Paris: OECD.
6.
Bose, R. and Hwang, S.W. ( 2002) Income and spending patterns among panhandlers, Canadian Medical Association Journal, 167(5), pp. 477-479.
7.
Butovskaya, M., Kemp, F., Diakonov, I. and Smirnov, A. ( 2004) Urban begging and ethnic nepotism in Russia: an ethological pilot study, in: F. Salter (Ed.) Welfare, Ethnicity and Altruism: New Findings and Evolutionary Theory, pp. 27-52. London: Frank Cass.
8.
Danczuk, S. ( 2000) Walk on By: Begging, Street Drinking and the Giving Age . London: Crisis.
9.
Dean, H. and Gale, K. ( 1999) Begging and the contradicitons of citizenship, in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions: Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure, pp. 13-26. Bristol : Policy Press.
10.
Depreeuw, W. ( 1988) Landloperij, bedelarij en thuisloosheid: Een socio-historische analyse van repressie, bijstand en instellingen. Antwerp : Kluwer Rechtswetenschappen.
11.
Donovan, M.G. ( 2008) Informal cities and the contestation of public space: the case of Bogota’s street vendors, 1988-2003, Urban Studies, 45(1), pp. 29-51.
12.
Eck, R. van and Kazemier, B. ( 1988) Features of the hidden economy in the Netherlands, Review of Income and Wealth, 34(3), pp. 251-273.
13.
Ellickson, R.C. ( 1996) Controlling chronic misconduct in city spaces: of panhandlers, skid rows, and public-space zoning, Yale Law Journal, 105, pp. 1165-1248.
14.
Erskine, A. and McIntosh, I. ( 1999) Why begging offends: historical perspectives and continuities , in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions: Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure , pp. 27-42. Bristol: Policy Press.
15.
Feige, E.L. ( 1990) Defining and estimating underground and informal economies: the new institutional economics approach, World Development , 18(7), pp. 989-1002.
16.
Festinger, L. ( 1943) An exact test of significance for means of samples drawn from populations with an exponential frequency distribution, Psychometrika, 8(3), pp. 153-160.
17.
Fieller, E.C. ( 1940) The biological standardization of insulin, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 8(1), pp. 1-64.
18.
Fierens, J. ( 2004) La répression de la mendicité en 2004, Journal des tribunaux, pp. 543-544.
19.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Jones, A. ( 2005) Pursuing social justice or social cohesion? Coercion in street homelessness policies in England, Journal of Social Policy, 34, pp. 389-406.
20.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Kennedy, C. ( 2000) Getting By: Begging, Rough Sleeping and The Big Issue in Glasgow and Edinburgh. Bristol: The Policy Press.
21.
Friedman, E., Johnson, S., Kaufmann, D. and Zoido-Lobaton, P. ( 2000) Dodging the grabbing hand: the determinants of unofficial activity in 69 countries, Journal of Public Economics, 76, pp. 459-493.
22.
Geremek, B. ( 1980) Truands et misérables dans l’Europe moderne (1350-1600). Paris: Gallimard.
23.
Hershkoff, H. and Cohen, A.S. ( 1991) Begging to differ: the First Amendment and the right to beg, Harvard Law Review, 104, pp. 896-916.
24.
Hopkins Burke, R. ( 2000) The regulation of begging and vagrancy: a critical discussion , Crime Prevention and Community Safety: An International Journal, 2, pp. 43-52.
25.
Jamar, N. and Herbots, P. ( 2006) Bedelarij en exploitatie, Nieuw Juridisch Weekblad, 135, pp. 98-109.
26.
Kennedy, C. and Fitzpatrick, S. ( 2001) Begging, rough sleeping and social exclusion: implications for social policy, Urban Studies, 38(11), pp. 2001-2016.
27.
Lankenau, S.E. ( 1999) Stronger than dirt: public humiliation and status enhancement among panhandlers, Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 28(3), pp. 288-318.
28.
Lu, H. ( 1999) Becoming urban: mendicancy and vagrants in modern Shanghai , Journal of Social History, 33(1), pp. 7-36.
29.
McIntosh, I. and Erskine, A. (1999) ‘Feel rotten. I do, I feel rotten’: exploring the begging encounter , in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions. Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure , pp. 183-202. Bristol: Policy Press.
30.
Melrose, M. ( 1999) Word from the street: the perils and pains of researching begging, in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions: Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure , pp. 143-160. Bristol: Policy Press.
31.
Mitchell, D. ( 2005) The S.U.V. model of citizenship: bubbles, buffer zones, and the ‘purely atomic’ individual, Political Geography, 24, pp. 77-100.
32.
Moffatt, P.G. and Peters, S.A. ( 2004) Pricing personal services: an empirical study of earnings in the UK prostitution industry, Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 51(5), pp. 675-690.
33.
Motulsky, H. ( 1995) Intuitive Biostatistics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
Murdoch, A. ( 1994) We Are Human Too: A Study of People Who Beg. London: Crisis.
35.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) (2004) Employment Outlook 2004. Paris: OECD.
36.
O’Flaherty, B. ( 1996) Making Room: The Economics of Homelessness. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
37.
OSCE (Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe) (2000) Report on the Situation of Roma and Sinti in the OSCE area. The Hague: OSCE.
38.
Pahl, R.E. ( 1987) Does jobless mean workless? Unemployment and informal work, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 493, pp. 36-46.
39.
Portes, A. and Haller, W. ( 2005) The informal economy, in: N. J. Smelser and R. Swedberg (Eds) The Handbook of Economic Sociology, 2nd edn, pp. 403-425. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
40.
Portes, A., Castells, M. and Benton, L.A. ( 1989) Conclusion: the policy implications of informality, in: A. Portes, M. Castells and L. A. Benton (Eds) The Informal Economy: Studies in Advanced and Less Developed Countries, pp. 298-311. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
41.
Réa, A. ( 2001) La problematique des personnes sans-abri en Région de Bruxelles-Capitale. Bruxelles: ULB.
42.
Renooy, P.H., Ivarsson, S., Wusten-Gritsai, O. van der and Meijer, R. ( 2004) Undeclared Work in an Enlarged Union: An Analysis of Undeclared Work: An In-depth Study of Specific Items. Brussels: European Commission.
43.
Ringold, D., Orenstein, M.A. and Wilkens, E. ( 2003) Roma in an Expanding Europe: Breaking the Poverty Circle . Washington, DC: The World Bank .
44.
Rosser, J.B.J., Rosser, M.V. and Ahmed, E. ( 2000) Income inequality and the informal economy in transition economies, Journal of Comparative Economics, 28(1), pp. 156-171.
45.
Ruggeri Laderchi, C., Saith, R. and Stewart, F. ( 2003) Does it matter that we do not agree on the definition of poverty? A comparison of four approaches, Oxford Development Studies, 31(3), pp. 243-274.
46.
Schneider, F. ( 2007) Shadow Economies and Corruption All Over the World: New Estimates for 145 Countries. Linz: Johannes Kepler University.
47.
Sifaneck, S.J. and Neaigus, A. ( 2001) The ethnographic accessing, sampling and screening of hidden population: heroin sniffers in New York City, Addiction Research and Theory, 9(6), pp. 519-543.
48.
Slack, T. ( 2007) The contours and correlates of informal work in rural Pennsylvania, Rural Sociology, 72(1), pp. 69-89.
49.
Smith, P.K. ( 2005) The economics of anti-begging regulations, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 64(2), pp. 549-577.
50.
Thomas, J.J. ( 1990) Measuring the underground economy: a suitable case for interdisciplinary treatment?, American Behavioral Scientist , 33(5), pp. 621-637.
51.
Trejos Solorzano, J.D. and Del Cid, M. ( 2003) Decent work and the informal economy in Central America . International Labour Office, Geneva.
52.
UNDP (United Nations Development Programme) (2003) Avoiding the dependency trap: the Roma in central and eastern Europe. UNDP, Bratislava.
53.
Venkatesh, S.A. (2006) Off the Books: The Underground Economy of the Urban Poor. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
54.
Wardhaugh, J. and Jones, J. (1999) Begging in time and space: ‘shadow work’ and the rural context , in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions: Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure , pp. 101-119. Bristol: Policy Press.
55.
Williams, C.C. ( 2004) Tackling undeclared work in advanced economies: towards an evidence-based public policy approach, Policy Studies, 25(4), pp. 243-258.
56.
Williams, C.C. and Windebank, J. ( 2002) The uneven geographies of informal economic activities: a case study of twoBritish cities, Work, Employment & Society, 16(2), pp. 231-250.
57.
Williams, M. and Cheal, B. ( 2002) Can we measure homelessness? A critical evaluation of the method of ‘capture-recapture’, Social Research Methodology, 5(4), pp. 315-331.
58.
Wold, S. ( 1974) Confidence limits on the product of two uncertain numbers , Analytical Chemistry, 46(11), p. 1614.
59.
Woodbridge, L. ( 2002) Impostors, monsters, and spies: what rogue literature can tell us about early modern subjectivity, Early Modern Literature Studies, 9(4), pp. 1-11.
