The paper debates the role of planning in `Operation Murambatsvina/Restore Order', Zimbabwe's 2005 controversial urban clean-up campaign. The discussion critically assesses two perspectives regarding the purported contribution and complicity of planning in what critics perceive to be the machinations of a regime that is internationally viewed as nefarious. This is done, first, by interrogating the role and contribution of planners and planning to the instigation and design of the operation before it was launched and, secondly, by determining the extent to which planners and planning served as the handmaiden of state repression during the operation. After weighing relevant empirical evidence on the culpability of planning, the discussion concludes that, while planning may escape the first charge, it certainly has a case to answer on the second.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agnew, J. (1997) The dramaturgy of horizons: geographical scale in the `reconstruction of Italy' by the new Italian political parties, 1992-1995 , Political Geography, 16(2), pp. 99-121.
2.
Allen, J. (2004) The whereabouts of power: politics, government and space, Geografiska Annaler, Series B, 86(1), pp. 19-32.
3.
Amin, A. and Thrift, N. (2002) Cities: Reimagining the Urban. Cambridge: Polity Press.
4.
Ankomah, B. (2005) Zimbabwe: a land of many surprises, New African, October, pp. 52-55.
5.
Audefroy, J. (1994) Eviction trends worldwide and the role of local authorities in implementing the righttohousing,Environmentand Urbanization, 6(1), pp. 8-24.
6.
Beauregard, R. (1989) Between modernity and post-modernity: the ambiguous position of US planning, Environment and Planning D, 7(3), pp. 381-395.
7.
Blattner, W.D. (1995) Decontextualization, standardization and Deweyan science, Man and World, 28(2), pp. 321-339.
8.
Bond, P. and Manyanya, M. (2002) Zimbabwe's Plunge: Exhausted Nationalism, Neoliberalism and the Search for Social Justice. London: Merlin Press .
9.
Brenner, N. (2004) New State Spaces: Urban Governance and the Rescaling of Statehood. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.
CBS News (2005) 200,000 homes bulldozed in Zimbabwe , 10 June (http://www.cbc.ca/storyview/-MSN/world/national/2005/06/10/zimbabwebulldozers050610.html ).
11.
City of Harare (2005a) Speech by the Chairperson of the Harare Commission on the occasion of the official launch of `Operation Murambatsvina'. Harare, 19 May.
12.
City of Harare (2005b) Enforcement Order Section 32. Harare, 26 May.
13.
Clark, G.L. (1984) A theory of local autonomy, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 74(2), pp. 195-200.
14.
Clark, G.L. (1985) Judges and the Cities: Interpreting Local Autonomy . Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
15.
Clark, G.L. and Dear, M.J. (1984) State Apparatus: Structures and Language of Legitimacy . Boston, MA: Allen & Unwin .
16.
COHRE (Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions) ( 2003) Global survey on forced evictions: violations of Human Rights 9. COHRE, Geneva.
17.
Cox, K.R. (2002) `Globalization', the `regulation approach', and the politics of scale, in: A. Herod and M. W. Wright (Eds) Geographies of Power: Placing Scale, pp. 85-114. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
18.
Cross, E. (2005) The destruction of the informal sector (http://zimbabwesituation.com/jun3_2005.html#link9).
19.
The Daily Mirror (Harare) (2005) Police barred from speaking on clean-up, 23 June.
20.
Dear, M.J. (1986) Planning and post modernism, Environment and Planning D, 4(3), pp. 367-384.
21.
Dear, M. and Clark, G.L. (1981) Dimensions of local state automony, Environment and Planning A, 13(10), pp. 1277-1294.
Everett, M. (2001) Evictions and human rights: land disputes in Bogotá , Colombia, Habitat International, 25(4), pp. 453-471.
24.
Fainstein, S.S. (2000) New directions in planning theory, Urban Affairs Review, 35(4), pp. 451-478.
25.
The Financial Gazette (Harare) (2005) Political backlash or genuine clean-up?, 9-15 June.
26.
Flyvbjerg, B. (1996) The dark side of planning: rationality and `realrationalität' , in: S. J. Mandelbaum, L. Mazza and R. W. Burchell (Eds) Explorations in Planning Theory, pp. 383-394. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.
27.
Flyvbjerg, B. (1998) Rationality and Power: Democracy in Practice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
28.
Flyvbjerg, B. (2001) Making Social Science Matter: Why Social Inquiry Fails and How It Can Succeed Again, tranl. S. Sampson. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
Flyvbjerg, B. and Richardson, T. (2002) Planning and Foucault: in search of the dark side of planning theory, in: P. Allmendinger and M. Tewdwr-Jones (Eds) Planning Futures: New Directions for Planning Theory, pp. 44-62. London : Routledge.
30.
Foglesong, R.E. (1986) Planning the Capitalist City: The Colonial Era to the 1920s. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
31.
Forester, J. (1993) Critical Theory, Public Policy, and Planning Practice: Toward a Critical Pragmatism. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
32.
Friedmann, J. and Douglass, M. (1998) Editors' introduction, in: M. Douglass and J. Friedmann (Eds) Cities for Citizens: Planning and the Rise of Civil Society in a Global Age, pp. 1-17. Chichester: John Wiley.
33.
Goldsmith, M. (1995) Autonomy and city limits, in: D. Judge, G. Stoker and H. Wolman (Eds) Theories of Urban Politics, pp. 228-252. London: Sage.
34.
Gono, G. (2005a) 2005 third quarter monetary policy statement. Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, Harare.
35.
Gono, G. (2005b) The 2005 post-election and drought mitigation monetary policy framework. Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, Harare.
36.
Government of Zimbabwe (1995) Urban Councils Act. Harare: Government Printer.
37.
Government of Zimbabwe (1996) The Regional, Town and Country Planning Act. Harare: Government Printer.
38.
Government of Zimbabwe (2005) Response by Government of Zimbabwe to the Report by the UN Special Envoy on Operation Murambatsvina/ Restore Order. Harare: Government Printer.
39.
Hammar, A. and Raftopoulos, B. (2003) Zimbabwe's unfinished business: rethinking land, state and nation, in: A. Hammar, B. Raftopoulos and S. Jensen (Eds) Zimbabwe's Unfinished Business: Rethinking Land, State and Nation in the Context of Crisis, pp. 1-47. Harare: Weaver.
40.
Hardt, M. and Negri, A. (2000) Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
41.
Harrison, P. (2003) Fragmentation and globalisation as the new meta-narrative , in: P. Harrison, M. Huchzemeyer and M. Mayekiso (Eds) Confronting Fragmentation: Housing and Urban Development in a Democratising Society, pp. 13-25. Cape Town: University of Cape Town Press.
42.
Harvey, D. (1997) The new urbanism and the communitarian trap, Harvard Design Magazine, Winter/Spring (http://www.gsd.harvard.edu/research/publications/hdm/back/1harvey.html).
43.
Healey, P. (1997) Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies. London: Macmillan.
44.
The Herald (Harare) (2005) Rural voters hailed, 11 April.
45.
The Herald (Harare) (2005) Government not punishing people, 16 June.
46.
The Herald (Harare) (2005) Urban planners call for proper urban planning policies, 27 June.
47.
The Herald (Harare) (2005) Operation to leave informal sector more focussed, 30 June.
48.
The Herald (Harare) (2005) Zim a steadfast country, 4 October.
49.
Herod, A. and Wright, M.W. (2002) Introduction: placing scale, in: A. Herod and M. W. Wright (Eds) Geographies of Power: Placing Scale, pp. 1-14. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
50.
Hillier, J. (2002) Shadows of Power: An Allegory of Prudence in Land-use Planning. New York: Routledge.
51.
Holliday, I. (2000) Is the British state hollowing out?, The Political Quarterly, 71(2), pp. 167-176.
52.
HRW (Human Rights Watch) (2005) Clear the filth: mass evictions and demolitions in Zimbabwe. HRW, New York.
53.
IDMC (Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre) ( 2006) Zimbabwe: government obstructs humanitarian access to displaced as new evictions loom: a profile of the internal displacement situation . IDMC, Geneva.
54.
IMF (International Monetary Fund) (2005) Staff report for the 2005 Article IV consultation. IMF , Washington, DC.
55.
Izeogu, C.V. (1993) Public policy and affordable housing for the urban poor in Nigeria: a study of squatter redevelopment in Port Harcourt, Habitat International, 17(2), pp. 21-38.
56.
Jessop, B. (2002) Liberalism, neoliberalism, and urban governance: a state-theoretical perspective, Antipode, 34(3), pp. 452-472.
57.
Jessop, B. (2004) Hollowing out the `nation-state' and multilevel governance, in: P. Kennett (Ed.) A Handbook of Comparative Social Policy, pp. 11-25. Northampton, MA : Edward Elgar.
58.
Kamete, A.Y. (1998) Continuity with change: a review of Zimbabwe's public sector urban low-income housing production system, Development Southern Africa, 15(1), pp. 13-28.
59.
Kamete,A.Y. (2002) Governance for sustainability? Balancing social and environmental concerns in Harare. Christian Michelsen Institute, Bergen.
60.
Kamete,A.Y. (2003) In defence of national sovereignty? Urban governance and democracy in Zimbabwe, Journal of Contemporary African Studies, 21(2), pp. 193-212.
61.
Kamete, A.Y. (2004a) Repositioning the urban environment question in Zimbabwe: a review of the context, conditions and processes, Development Southern Africa, 21(4), pp. 663-686.
62.
Kamete, A.Y. (2004b) Governing rebel outposts: centre-local relations in Harare. Paper presented at the AEGIS Thematic Conference, `From Violent Conflicts to Civil Governance', The Nordic Africa Institute, Uppsala, May.
63.
Kamete, A.Y. (2006a) More than urban local governance? Warring over Zimbabwe's fading cities, African Renaissance, 3(2), pp. 34-46.
64.
Kamete, A.Y. (2006b) Revisiting the urban housing crisis in Zimbabwe: some forgotten dimensions?, Habitat International, 30(4), pp. 981-995.
65.
Kamete, A.Y. (2006c) The return of the jettisoned: ZANU-PF's crack at re-urbanising in Harare, Journal of Southern African Studies , 32(2), pp. 256-271.
66.
Kamete,A.Y. (2007) Cold-hearted, negligent and spineless? Planning, planners and the (r)ejection of `filth' in urban Zimbabwe, International Planning Studies, 12(2), pp. 153-171.
67.
Keeble, L. (1952) Principles and Practice of Town and Country Planning. London: The Estates Gazette.
68.
Kirby, A. (1993) Power/Resistance: Local Politics and the Chaotic State. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
69.
Mabin, A. and Smit, D. (1997) Reconstructing South Africa's cities? The making of urban planning 1900-2000, Planning Perspectives, 12(2), pp. 193-223.
70.
Marris, P. (1998) Planning and civil society in the twenty-first century: an introduction, in: M. Douglass and J. Friedmann (Eds) Cities for Citizens: Planning and the Rise of Civil Society in a Global Age , pp. 9-17. Chichester: John Wiley.
71.
Miller, B. (1994) Political empowerment, local- central state relations and geographically shifting political opportunity structures: strategies of the Cambridge, Massachusetts peace movement, Political Geography , 13(5), pp. 393-406.
72.
Mubvami, T. and Hall, N. (2000) City consultations on urban poverty in Harare. Municipal Development Programme, Harare.
73.
NGO Forum (Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum) ( 2005) Order out of chaos, or chaos out of order? A preliminary report on Operation `Murambatsvina'. Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum, Harare.
74.
Plessis, J. du (2005) The growing problem of forced evictions and the crucial importance of community-based, locally appropriate alternatives, Environment and Urbanization, 17(1), pp. 123-134.
75.
Potts, D. (2006) `Restoring order'? Operation Murambatsvina and the urban crisis in Zimbabwe, Journal of Southern African Studies, 32(2), pp. 273-291.
76.
Potts, D. (2007) City life in Zimbabwe at a time of fear and loathing: urban planning, urban poverty and Operation Murambatsvina, in: G. Myers and M. Murray (Eds) Cities in Contemporary Africa, pp. 265-288. New York: Palgrave.
77.
Raftopoulos, B. (2005) The battle for the cities ( http://www.zimbabwesituation.com/jun4a_2005.html#link17).
78.
Rahman, M.M. (2001) Bastee eviction and housing rights: a case of Dhaka , Bangladesh, Habitat International, 25(1), pp. 49-67.
79.
Reader, J. (2004) Cities. New York: Atlantic Monthly Press.
80.
Sachikonye, L.M. (2006) The impact of Operation Murambatsvina/clean-up on the working people in Zimbabwe. Labour and Economic Development Research Institute of Zimbabwe, Harare .
81.
Sandercock, L. (2003) Cosmopolis II: Mongrel Cities in the 21st Century . London: Continuum.
82.
Sassen, S. (1996) Losing Control? Sovereignty in an Age of Globalization . New York: Columbia University Press.
83.
Sassen, S. (2002) Locating cities in global circuits, in: S. Sassen (Ed.) Global Networks, Linked Cities , pp. 1-36. New York: Routledge.
84.
Scott, J.C. (1998) Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
85.
Setšabi, S. (2006) Contest and conflict: governance and street livelihoods in Maseru, Lesotho, in: A. Brown (Ed.) Contested Spaces: Street Trading, Public Space and Livelihoods in Developing Countries, pp. 131-152. Rugby: ITDG Publishing.
86.
Short, J.R. (1996) The Urban Order: An Introduction to Cities, Culture, and Power. Malden, MA: Blackwell .
87.
SPT (Solidarity Peace Trust) (2005) Discarding the filth: operation Murambatsvina. SPT, Bulawayo and Durban.
88.
Stren, R.E. (2003) Introduction: towards the comparative study of urban governance, in: R. Stren and P. L. McCarney (Eds) Governance on the Ground: Innovations and Discontinuities in Cities of the Developing World, pp. 1-30. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
89.
The Sunday Mail (Harare) (2005) Clean-up exercise bears fruit, 26 June.
90.
Swilling, M., Simone, A.M. and Khan, F. (2002) `My soul I can see': the limits of governing Africa cities in a context of globalisation and complexity, in: S. Parnell, E. Pieterse, M. Swilling and D. Wooldridge (Eds) Democratising Local Government: The South African Experiment, pp. 305-327. Cape Town: University of Cape Town Press.
91.
Swyngedouw, E. (1996) Reconstructing citizenship, rescaling of the state and the new authoritarianism: closing the Belgian mines, Urban Studies, 33(8), pp. 1499-1521.
92.
Swyngedouw, E. (2000) Authoritarian governance, power and the politics of rescaling, Environment and Planning D, 18(1), pp. 63-76.
93.
Tannerfeldt, G. and Ljung, P. (2006) More Urban, Less Poor: An Introduction to Urban Development and Management . London: Earthscan.
94.
Taylor, N. (1998) Urban Planning Theory since 1945. Oxford: Sage.
95.
Tibaijuka, A.K. (2005) Report of the fact-finding mission to Zimbabwe to assess the scope and impact of Operation Murambatsvina by the UN Special Envoy on Human Settlements Issues in Zimbabwe. United Nations, New York.
96.
Tipple, A.G. (2000) Extending Themselves: User-initiated Transformations of Government-built Housing in Developing Countries. Liverpool : Liverpool University Press.
97.
Tordoff, W. (1994) Decentralisation: comparative experiences inCommonwealthAfrica , Journal of Modern African Studies, 32(4), pp. 555-580.
98.
United Nations (1996) Forced evictions and human rights. Fact Sheet No. 25, United Nations, Geneva.
99.
Watson, V. (2002) Change and Continuity in Spatial Planning: Metropolitan Planning in Cape Town under Political Transition. London : Routledge.
100.
Wekwete, K.H. (1988) Development of urban planning in Zimbabwe: an overview , Cities, 5(1), pp. 57-71.
101.
Wekwete, K.H. (1994) Urbanisation, urban development and management in Zimbabwe, in: K. H. Wekwete and C. O. Rambanapasi (Eds) Planning Urban Economies in Eastern and Southern Africa, pp. 31-54. Aldershot : Avebury.
102.
Wildavsky, A.B. (1987) Speaking Truth to Power: The Art and Craft of Policy Analysis. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.
103.
Wines, M. (2005) Zimbabwe launches attack on its citizens, The New York Times, 2 June.
104.
Wole, O. and Tungwarara, O. (Eds) (2005) An analysis of the demolitions in Zimbabwe. ActionAid International, Johannesburg.
105.
Yiftachel, O. (1993) Power disparities in the planning of a mixed region: Arabs and Jews in the Galilee, Israel, Urban Studies, 30(1), pp. 157-182.
106.
Yiftachel, O. (1998) Planning and social control: exploring the `dark side', Journal of Planning Literature, 12(4), pp. 395-406.
107.
Yiftachel, O. (2002) The dark side of modernism: planning as control of an ethnic minority, in: G. Bridge and S. Watson (Eds) The Blackwell City Reader, pp. 535-541. Malden, MA: Blackwell .
108.
Yiftachel, O. and Huxley, M. (2000) Debating dominance and relevance: notes on the `communicative turn' in planning theory, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 24(4), pp. 907-913.
109.
The Zimbabwe Independent (Harare) (2005) The battle for the cities, 3 June.
